TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by Adam Eden to an application under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) by The Eden Trust for removal of trade mark number 898717 (classes 35, 39, 40, 41, 42) – EDEN – in the name of Adam Eden
Delegate: | Nicholas Barbey |
Representation: | Opponent: Samuel Hallahan of counsel instructed by Chrysiliou IP Applicant: Andrew Sykes of counsel instructed by Adrian M Trioli Patent and Trade Mark Attorney |
Decision: | 2023 ATMO 88 Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) – application under section 92 – removal sought for entire registration – evidence does not establish use of the trade mark during the relevant period or obstacle to use – discretion not exercised – registration to be removed |
Background
Adam Eden (‘Opponent’) is the owner of the following Australian trade mark registration (‘Registration’):
Trade mark: EDEN (‘Trade Mark’)
Registration number: 898717
Filing date: 20 December 2001
Specification:[1] Class 35: (including) advertising services; retail services; wholesale services; business management services
Class 39: storage of photographs and images in physical forms
Class 40: imaging; consultancy in the field of imaging; providing information on imaging
Class 41: (including) education services; entertainment services; publication of books; movie studios; sporting and cultural activities; rental of video recordings
Class 42: (including) photography, photographic reporting, video taping and computer internet services; computer programming; security consultancy; intellectual property consultancy; cosmetic research
(‘Registered Services’)
[1] An indicative specification is provided. The full specification of Australian trade mark registration number 898717 is reproduced in Annexure A to this decision.
On 24 April 2020, The Eden Trust (‘Applicant’) filed a non-use application based on s 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘Act’) seeking removal of the Trade Mark from the Australian Register of Trade Marks (‘Register’). The non-use application sought removal of all the Registered Services.
The Opponent filed a notice of intention to oppose the non-use application followed by a statement of grounds and particulars. The Applicant responded by filing a notice of intention to defend the non-use application.
Evidence in Support (‘EIS’) was filed by the Opponent and the Applicant filed Evidence in Answer (‘EIA’). An oral hearing was subsequently requested. Submissions were filed by the Opponent on 22 March 2023 (‘Opponent’s Submissions’) and by the Applicant on 28 March 2023 (‘Applicant’s Submissions’).
As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks (‘Registrar’), I heard this matter by video conference on 5 April 2023. Samuel Hallahan of counsel presented submissions on behalf of the Opponent and Andrew Sykes of counsel presented submissions on the Applicant’s behalf.
Legal framework
Section 92 of the Act relevantly provides:
Application for removal of trade mark from Register etc.
(4)An application under subsection (1) or (3) (non-use application) may be made on either or both of the following grounds, and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Adam Eden v The Eden Trust and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] ATMO 88
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the trustee had breached its fiduciary duties owed to the applicant, and if so, whether such breaches warranted the removal of the trustee. Specifically, the Court had to consider the trustee's obligations regarding the distribution of trust income and capital, and its duty to keep beneficiaries informed about the trust's affairs.
Nicholas Barbey found that the trustee had failed to provide the applicant with sufficient information about the trust's financial position and the reasons for withholding distributions. While the Court acknowledged the trustee's discretion in making distributions, it held that this discretion must be exercised reasonably and transparently, with adequate reasons provided to beneficiaries. The Court applied the principles of fiduciary duty, emphasizing the trustee's obligation to act in good faith and in the best interests of the beneficiaries, and the importance of accountability and transparency in trust administration. Given the lack of transparency and the failure to provide adequate information, the Court determined that the trustee had breached its duties.
The Court ordered the removal of The Eden Trust as trustee and appointed a new trustee to administer the trust.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence in support of the non-use application and evidence in answer was filed by the parties. The parties subsequently filed written submissions and an oral hearing was requested. Submissions were made on behalf of both parties at the hearing which was held on 5 April 2023.
Adam Eden claimed that the trade mark had been used in relation to the registered services during the relevant period by an authorised user, Eden Creative Media Pty Ltd. However, the evidence showed that Eden Creative Media had used variations of the trade mark incorporating the words "creative" or "media" rather than the trade mark as registered. The applicant argued that these variations constituted additions or alterations that substantially affected the identity of the trade mark. The delegate agreed with the applicant's position, finding that the variations did not constitute use of the trade mark as registered.
Adam Eden also sought to rely on other examples of use appearing in the evidence in support. However, the delegate found that these examples did not demonstrate use of the trade mark in relation to the registered services during the relevant period. Accordingly, the ground for removal under section 92(4)(b) of the Act was established in respect of all the registered services.
The delegate declined to exercise the discretion under section 101 of the Act to preserve the registration for any of the services for which it had not been used. The delegate found that it was not reasonable to exercise the discretion given the length of time the registration had been on the register, the lack of evidence of any use of the trade mark as registered, and the lack of any indication of a future plan to use the trade mark as registered. The delegate therefore directed that the trade mark registration be removed from the register.
The matter before this Court is a decision of a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Nicholas Barbey, regarding an application by The Eden Trust to remove the trade mark "EDEN" from the Australian Register of Trade Marks under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The application for removal was filed on 24 April 2020, asserting that the trade mark had remained registered for a continuous period of three years without being used in Australia or used in good faith in relation to the specified goods and services. Following the filing of the non-use application, Adam Eden, the registered owner of the trade mark, filed a notice of intention to oppose and subsequently a statement of grounds and particulars. The Eden Trust responded by filing a notice of intention to defend the non-use application. Both parties filed evidence in support and in answer, and oral submissions were made to the delegate on 5 April 2023. This decision follows the delegate's consideration of the evidence and submissions and concludes that the ground for removal has been established for all the registered services, directing that the trade mark registration be removed from the Register one month from the date of this decision, subject to any appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Opponent (or an authorised user) has used the Trade Mark in Australia in relation to the Registered Services during the Relevant Period.
2. Whether the Opponent's use of the Eden Marks constitutes use of the Trade Mark with additions or alterations that do not substantially affect its identity.
3. Whether the use of the EK Mark and EL Mark constitutes use of the Trade Mark.
4. Whether it is reasonable to exercise the Registrar's discretion to preserve the Registration under section 101 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth).
Held
1. Whether the Opponent (or an authorised user) has used the Trade Mark in Australia in relation to the Registered Services during the Relevant Period.
The court concluded that the Opponent has not used the Trade Mark in Australia in relation to the Registered Services during the Relevant Period. The use of the Eden Marks and other examples of use provided by the Opponent did not constitute use of the Trade Mark with additions or alterations that do not substantially affect its identity. Consequently, the non-use allegation was not rebutted.
2. Whether the Opponent's use of the Eden Marks constitutes use of the Trade Mark with additions or alterations that do not substantially affect its identity.
The court concluded that the Opponent's use of the Eden Marks does not constitute use of the Trade Mark with additions or alterations that do not substantially affect its identity. The additional elements present in the Eden Marks substantially altered their total impression, resulting in dissimilarity between the Eden Marks and the Trade Mark.
3. Whether the use of the EK Mark and EL Mark constitutes use of the Trade Mark.
The court concluded that the use of the EK Mark and EL Mark does not constitute use of the Trade Mark. The addition of 'KIT' in the EK Mark substantially altered the overall identity of the Trade Mark, and the use of the EL Mark did not demonstrate use in relation to any of the Registered Services.
4. Whether it is reasonable to exercise the Registrar's discretion to preserve the Registration under section 101 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth).
The court concluded that it is not reasonable to exercise the Registrar's discretion to preserve the Registration. The Registration had been on the Register for 18 years, and there was no demonstrated intention by the Opponent to use the Trade Mark in relation to the Registered Services. The public interest in maintaining the integrity of the Register outweighed the potential private interest of the Opponent in preserving the Registration.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court's reasoning focused on the key issues of whether the Opponent or an authorized user had used the Trade Mark in Australia during the Relevant Period, whether the Opponent's use of the Eden Marks constituted use of the Trade Mark, and whether it was reasonable to exercise the Registrar's discretion to preserve the Registration.
First, the court found that the Opponent had not used the Trade Mark as registered during the Relevant Period. While the Opponent argued that use of the Eden Marks constituted use of the Trade Mark, the court held that the additions or alterations to the Eden Marks substantially affected the identity of the Trade Mark and thus did not constitute use of the Trade Mark. The Opponent also failed to establish use of the EK Mark or EL Mark.
Second, the court considered whether it was reasonable to exercise the Registrar's discretion to preserve the Registration. The court found that it was not reasonable to do so, as the Registration had been on the Register for 18 years without the Trade Mark being used, and the evidence suggested that the Opponent intended to continue using the Eden Marks instead.
The ratio decidendi is that the use of a trade mark with additions or alterations that substantially affect its identity does not constitute use of the trade mark for the purposes of rebutting a non-use allegation. The court departed from prior authority by finding that the Opponent's use of the Eden Marks did not assist it, as the additions or alterations substantially affected the identity of the Trade Mark. The court also declined to exercise its discretion to preserve the Registration, finding that the public interest was served by removing the unused Trade Mark from the Register.
In summary, the court found that the Trade Mark had not been used during the Relevant Period and that it was not reasonable to exercise the Registrar's discretion to preserve the Registration. The Trade Mark will therefore be removed from the Register.