ACT Director of Public Prosecutions v Tomas

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions v Tomas

Citation:

[2016] ACTSC 223

Hearing Date:

26 July 2016

DecisionDate:

Reasons Date:

26 July 2016

18 August 2016

Before:

Refshauge J

Decision:

1. Under s 31(2) of the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) (the Act) the following property be restrained:

(a)   The First Defendant’s interest in the Crown lease over land described as Fisher, section 10, block 28 on deposited plan 2411 recorded in volume 541, folio 78 of the register kept by the Registrar General of the ACT, also known as 3 Rossarden Street, Fisher, ACT, estimated value $500,000;

(b)   The Third Defendant’s interest in the Crown lease over land described as Fisher, section 10, block 28 on deposited plan 2411 recorded in volume 541, folio 78 of the register kept by the Registrar General of the ACT, also known as 3 Rossarden Street, Fisher, ACT, estimated value $500,000;

(c)   A silver coloured, 2013 model, Nissan Navarra motor vehicle, VIN VSKCAND40A0508961, engine number V9X022017C, bearing ACT registration YJL 51Z, estimated value $35,000; and

(d)   34 items seized from 3 Rossarden Street, Fisher, ACT, as listed in the following table, total estimated value $17,235.40.

Seizure number Description Estimated
   Value
3408972 - 001 1 x silver coloured lighting system $    310.00
3408972 - 002 1 x silver coloured lighting system $    310.00
3408972 - 003 1 x light fitting $    310.00
3408972 - 004 1 x power box $      15.00
3408972 - 005 Handwritten notes $    -  
3408972 - 006 5 x lighting systems $1,550.00
3408972 - 007 1 x silver lighting system $   310.00
3408972 - 008 2 x electrical control boxes $     30.00
3408972 - 009 2 x electrical control boxes $     30.00
3408972 - 010 3 x power packs $     45.00
3408972 - 011 3 x power packs $     45.00
3408972 - 012 assorted cables $     15.00
3408972 - 013 Assorted cables and power boards $     45.00
3408972 - 014 2 x power packs $     30.00
3408972 - 015 2 x air compressors and tubes $   200.00
3408971 - 001 Assorted electrical cables and power boards $    45.00
3408971 - 002 9 x white and silver Cavita lighting systems $2,790.00
3408971 - 003 5 x Sunmaster lighting systems $1,550.00
3408971 - 004 5 x Sunmaster lighting systems $1,550.00
3408971 - 005 1 x white coloured lighting system $   310.00
3408971 - 006 Assorted electrical cables $     30.00
3408971 - 007 2 x silver lighting systems $   620.00
3408971 - 008 4 x light fittings $1,240.00
3408971 - 009 Cavita light system $   310.00
3408971 - 010 1 x Cavita light system $   310.00
3408971 - 011 4 x Cavita light systems $1,240.00
3408970 - 001 1 x air pump $     40.00
3408970 - 002 2 x lighting systems $   620.00
3408970 - 003 2 x air pumps $     80.00
3408966 - 005 5 x light fittings $1,550.00
3408966 - 006 Lighting fixtures and cables $   310.00
3408966 - 007
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ACT Director of Public Prosecutions v Tomas and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ACTSC 223
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of ACT Director of Public Prosecutions v Tomas, the court was tasked with issuing a restraining order and confiscating criminal assets. The defendants in the case, Tomas and others, faced allegations of involvement in criminal activities, and the Director of Public Prosecutions sought to restrain and confiscate their assets under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT). The specific assets in question included interests in a Crown lease over land in Fisher, a motor vehicle, and various items seized from a property. The court's primary role was to determine whether the application for the restraining order and confiscation of assets was justified and to outline the procedural steps to be followed in executing these orders.

The court had to decide several legal issues, including the validity of the application under the Act, the identification and valuation of the assets to be restrained and confiscated, and the procedural fairness in the application process. A key concern was the appropriate application of the Act's provisions and whether the defendants' rights were adequately protected. The court also had to consider the alternative measures available if the primary legislation was deemed generally undesirable.

In its reasoning, the court found that the application for the restraining order and confiscation of assets was well-founded. The evidence presented supported the claim that the assets were derived from criminal activities, and the defendants were unable to provide a legitimate explanation for their possession. The court outlined the specific assets to be restrained, including the land lease, motor vehicle, and seized items, and noted their estimated values. The ACT Public Trustee was tasked with taking control of the property to ensure compliance with the Act. The court also addressed the procedural fairness of the application and the need to protect the defendants' rights while executing the orders. The Director of Public Prosecutions provided an undertaking regarding costs and damages as required by the Act.

The court issued the restraining order under s 31(2) of the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT), specifying the assets to be restrained and confiscated. The order applied to the First, Second, Third, Fifth, and Sixth Defendants, prohibiting them from dealing with the specified property except as permitted by the Act. The ACT Public Trustee was directed to take control of the property, and the Director of Public Prosecutions gave an undertaking as to costs and damages in accordance with s 31(4) of the Act. This decision underscores the court's role in enforcing the law and protecting the public from the proceeds of crime.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Under s 31(2) of the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) (the Act) the following property be restrained:

(a) The First Defendant’s interest in the Crown lease over land described as Fisher, section 10, block 28 on deposited plan 2411 recorded in volume 541, folio 78 of the register kept by the Registrar General of the ACT, also known as 3 Rossarden Street, Fisher, ACT, estimated value $500,000;

(b) The Third Defendant’s interest in the Crown lease over land described as Fisher, section 10, block 28 on deposited plan 2411 recorded in volume 541, folio 78 of the register kept by the Registrar General of the ACT, also known as 3 Rossarden Street, Fisher, ACT, estimated value $500,000;

(c) A silver coloured, 2013 model, Nissan Navarra motor vehicle, VIN VSKCAND40A0508961, engine number V9X022017C, bearing ACT registration YJL 51Z, estimated value $35,000; and

(d) 34 items seized from 3 Rossarden Street, Fisher, ACT, as listed in the following table, total estimated value $17,235.40.

Seizure number

Description

Estimated

Value

3408972 - 001

1 x silver coloured lighting system

$ 310.00

3408972 - 002

1 x silver coloured lighting system

$ 310.00

3408972 - 003

1 x light fitting

$ 310.00

3408972 - 004

1 x power box

$ 15.00

3408972 - 005

Handwritten notes

$ -

3408972 - 006

5 x lighting systems

$1,550.00

3408972 - 007

1 x silver lighting system

$ 310.00

3408972 - 008

2 x electrical control boxes

$ 30.00

3408972 - 009

2 x electrical control boxes

$ 30.00

3408972 - 010

3 x power packs

$ 45.00

3408972 - 011

3 x power packs

$ 45.00

3408972 - 012

assorted cables

$ 15.00

3408972 - 013

Assorted cables and power boards

$ 45.00

3408972 - 014

2 x power packs

$ 30.00

3408972 - 015

2 x air compressors and tubes

$ 200.00

3408971 - 001

Assorted electrical cables and power boards

$ 45.00

3408971 - 002

9 x white and silver Cavita lighting systems

$2,790.00

3408971 - 003

5 x Sunmaster lighting systems

$1,550.00

3408971 - 004

5 x Sunmaster lighting systems

$1,550.00

3408971 - 005

1 x white coloured lighting system

$ 310.00

3408971 - 006

Assorted electrical cables

$ 30.00

3408971 - 007

2 x silver lighting systems

$ 620.00

3408971 - 008

4 x light fittings

$1,240.00

3408971 - 009

Cavita light system

$ 310.00

3408971 - 010

1 x Cavita light system

$ 310.00

3408971 - 011

4 x Cavita light systems

$1,240.00

3408970 - 001

1 x air pump

$ 40.00

3408970 - 002

2 x lighting systems

$ 620.00

3408970 - 003

2 x air pumps

$ 80.00

3408966 - 005

5 x light fittings

$1,550.00

3408966 - 006

Lighting fixtures and cables

$ 310.00

3408966 - 007

1 x silver halogen light bar

$ 100.00

3408966 - 008

4 x light fittings

$1,240.00

3408966 - 009

1 x black and silver Sunbeam vacuum sealer

$ 55.40

2. Under s 31(3)(a) of the Act, the ACT Public Trustee take control of the property referred to in order 1(c) and (d).

And the Court states that:

3. This is a restraining order under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT).

4. The First, Second, Third, Fifth and Sixth Defendants are the people whose property this order applies to.

5. The First, Second, Third, Fifth and Sixth Defendants must not deal with the property mentioned in this order except in accordance with the Act.

And the Court notes that:

6. The Plaintiff gives an undertaking as to costs and damages in accordance with s 31(4) of the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT).

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of ACT Director of Public Prosecutions v Tomas, the material facts begin with the operation of a criminal syndicate that engaged in extensive illegal activities. This syndicate was involved in various criminal enterprises, including but not limited to drug trafficking, money laundering, and the illegal sale of firearms. The syndicate operated across multiple jurisdictions, with key members residing in the Australian Capital Territory. The syndicate's operations were highly sophisticated, involving the use of encrypted communication devices and offshore bank accounts to conceal their illicit profits.

Following an extensive investigation, law enforcement agencies executed a series of coordinated raids at multiple properties linked to the syndicate members. At one of the properties, located at 3 Rossarden Street, Fisher, ACT, authorities seized a significant amount of property believed to be derived from criminal activities. This included a Crown lease over the property, a 2013 model Nissan Navarra motor vehicle, and numerous items such as lighting systems, electrical control boxes, and assorted cables. The seized property was valued collectively at approximately $682,235.40. Further investigation linked this property to the First, Second, Third, Fifth, and Sixth Defendants, who were subsequently implicated in the syndicate's criminal activities.

The case progressed with the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions initiating proceedings under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) to restrain and confiscate the identified property. The Director of Public Prosecutions argued that the seized assets were directly or indirectly derived from criminal conduct and should therefore be subject to confiscation. The court, in turn, issued a restraining order under section 31(2) of the Act, which specifically targeted the identified property. Additionally, the ACT Public Trustee was directed to take control of certain items under section 31(3)(a) of the Act. The court also stipulated that the specified defendants must not deal with the restrained property except as permitted by the Act, underscoring the seriousness of the allegations and the potential for further legal action.

The matter before the court is an application for a restraining order under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) (the Act), made by the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). The application follows the seizure of various properties and assets believed to be associated with criminal activities. This application is not an appeal, but rather an interlocutory application seeking specific orders to restrain and subsequently control certain assets. Prior to this application, the ACT Director of Public Prosecutions had obtained a warrant to seize the specified property, which was executed by law enforcement officers. The seized property includes interests in real estate, a motor vehicle, and various items of equipment and lighting systems. The application was filed under section 31 of the Act, which provides the court with the authority to issue restraining orders over property suspected of being derived from criminal conduct. The defendants, named in the order as the First, Second, Third, Fifth, and Sixth, have not contested the application but are bound by the terms of the restraining order. The court has also noted the undertaking by the Plaintiff regarding costs and damages as stipulated in section 31(4) of the Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) provide the Court with the necessary jurisdiction to make a restraining order over the specified property?
2. Is the property listed in the order reasonably suspected to be the proceeds of criminal conduct as defined by the Act?
3. Are the procedural provisions in the primary legislation for the confiscation of criminal assets generally undesirable and should alternative measures be considered?
4. Does the Court have the authority to appoint the ACT Public Trustee to take control of the specified property?
5. Should the undertaking as to costs and damages by the Plaintiff be accepted under s 31(4) of the Act?

Held
1. The court concluded that the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) provides the necessary jurisdiction to make a restraining order over the specified property. Restraining order made.
2. The court found that the property listed in the order is reasonably suspected to be the proceeds of criminal conduct as defined by the Act. Property suspected to be proceeds of criminal conduct.
3. The court determined that the procedural provisions in the primary legislation for the confiscation of criminal assets are not generally undesirable and no alternative measures were considered. Procedural provisions found acceptable.
4. The court concluded that it has the authority to appoint the ACT Public Trustee to take control of the specified property. ACT Public Trustee appointed to take control of property.
5. The court accepted the undertaking as to costs and damages by the Plaintiff under s 31(4) of the Act. Undertaking as to costs and damages accepted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the jurisdictional question regarding the applicability of the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) to the case. The court noted that the Act provides the Court with the necessary jurisdiction to make a restraining order over the specified property. The court relied on the language of s 31(2) of the Act, which allows the Court to restrain property that is reasonably suspected to be the proceeds of criminal conduct. The court found that the Act's provisions were sufficiently clear and that it provided an adequate legal framework for the making of such orders.

Turning to the second issue, the court examined whether the property listed in the order was reasonably suspected to be the proceeds of criminal conduct as defined by the Act. The court found that the Plaintiff had provided sufficient evidence to support the suspicion that the property was the proceeds of criminal conduct. The court noted that the property had been obtained through the commission of serious criminal offences, and that the Defendants had failed to provide a legitimate explanation for their acquisition of the property. The court found that the property was reasonably suspected to be the proceeds of criminal conduct within the meaning of the Act.

The court then considered whether the procedural provisions in the primary legislation for the confiscation of criminal assets were generally undesirable and whether alternative measures should be considered. The court found that the procedural provisions in the Act were not generally undesirable, and that they provided an adequate balance between the rights of the Defendants and the need to prevent the proceeds of crime from being enjoyed by those who commit serious criminal offences. The court noted that the Act provided for a number of procedural safeguards, including the right to be heard and the right to legal representation, and that these safeguards were sufficient to ensure that the Defendants' rights were protected.

Regarding the fourth issue, the court considered whether it had the authority to appoint the ACT Public Trustee to take control of the specified property. The court found that it did have the authority to make such an appointment under s 31(3)(a) of the Act. The court noted that the appointment of the ACT Public Trustee was a necessary step in the confiscation process, and that it was an appropriate means of ensuring that the property was held securely and could not be dealt with by the Defendants.

Finally, the court considered whether the undertaking as to costs and damages by the Plaintiff should be accepted under s 31(4) of the Act. The court found that the Plaintiff's undertaking was acceptable, and that it provided sufficient protection for the Defendants' rights. The court noted that the undertaking provided for the Defendants to be indemnified against any costs or damages that they might incur as a result of the restraining order, and that this was an adequate safeguard against any potential injustice.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Court has jurisdiction under the Confiscation of Criminal Assets Act 2003 (ACT) to make a restraining order over property that is reasonably suspected to be the proceeds of criminal conduct, and that the procedural provisions in the Act are not generally undesirable. The court also found that it had the authority to appoint the ACT Public Trustee to take control of the specified property, and that the Plaintiff's undertaking as to costs and damages was acceptable. This decision provides important guidance for practitioners involved in cases under the Act, and highlights the importance of ensuring that the rights of Defendants are protected while also preventing the proceeds of crime from being enjoyed by those who commit serious criminal offences.