ACN 068691092 Pty Ltd v Plan 4 Insurance Services Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

ACN 068691092 PTY LTD & ANOR v PLAN 4 INSURANCE SERVICES PTY LTD & ORS (No 2)

[2009] SADC 139

Reasons for Decision of His Honour Judge Burley

11 December 2009

PROCEDURE - COSTS

Claim under policy of insurance - cross-claims between defendants - plaintiffs claims dismissed - defendants request orders that plaintiffs pay costs of cross-claims between defendants - no determination of cross-claims on the merits - whether reasonable for defendants respectively to cross-claim and defend cross-claim - whether Bullock or Sanderson order.

Lombard Insurance Co (Australia) Ltd v Pastro (1994) 175 LSJS 448; C F Walker & Anor v Corporation of the City of Adelaide & Ors (No 2) [2004] 139 at 46, applied.

ACN 068691092 PTY LTD & ANOR v PLAN 4 INSURANCE SERVICES PTY LTD & ORS (No 2)
[2009] SADC 139

  1. These reasons relate to cost orders sought by the defendants following the dismissal of the plaintiffs claims against the defendants on 8 May 2009 (see Judgement No [2009] SADC 53). Orders have been sought in respect of:

    (1)    the various cross-claims between the defendants and

    (2)    a previous costs order made by a Master whereby costs were reserved to the trial judge.

    The cross-claims

  2. The plaintiffs joined four defendants.  About these I said in my judgement of 8 May 2009 (at [2]):

    “….The 1st defendant was the agent of the insurer and the 2nd defendant was a director of the 1st defendant.  The insurance on the premises was arranged by them.  It is not entirely clear what role the 3rd defendant played in effecting and maintaining the relevant insurance.  The 4th defendant is the insurer.”

  3. As I understand it, the third defendant was joined because it was the principal of the 1st and 2nd defendants.

  4. The cross-claims, which were in the nature of claims for indemnity or contribution, were as follows:

  5. Plaintiff by cross-claim:  Defendant by cross-claim:

    1st & 2nd defendants  3rd defendant

    1st & 2nd defendants  4th defendant

    3rd defendant  1st & 2nd defendants

  6. Because the plaintiffs’ various claims were dismissed, it was not necessary to proceed with the cross-claims and so they were, in turn, dismissed without any determination by the court of their merits.

  7. The respective parties to the cross-claims seek Sanderson orders which, if made, would require the plaintiffs to pay to the defendants their respective costs of the various cross-claims, whether as plaintiff by cross-claim or as defendant by cross-claim.  The orders sought by the defendants have been variously stated by counsel in their written and oral submissions.  Their combined effect is that they respectively seek orders that the plaintiffs pay:

    (1)    the 1st and 2nd defendants’ costs of the cross-claims respectively brought by and against them.

    (2)    the 3rd defendant’s costs of the cross-claims respectively by and against it.

    (3)    the 4th defendant’s costs of the cross-claim brought by the 1

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ACN 068691092 Pty Ltd v Plan 4 Insurance Services Pty Ltd (N... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SADC 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of ACN 068691092 Pty Ltd v Plan 4 Insurance Services Pty Ltd (No 2), the dispute revolves around claims under a policy of insurance. The plaintiffs sought compensation, but their claims were dismissed. The defendants, in turn, filed cross-claims against each other, leading to a situation where the plaintiffs’ primary claims were resolved but the cross-claims between the defendants remained unresolved. The defendants then requested orders for the plaintiffs to pay the costs incurred from defending these cross-claims. The legal issue at hand was whether it was reasonable for the defendants to pursue and defend their cross-claims, and if the costs should be borne by the plaintiffs, as per the Bullock or Sanderson orders.

The court considered the principles of the Bullock and Sanderson orders, which pertain to the allocation of costs in cases where one party's claims are dismissed, and the other party is left to defend against cross-claims. The court needed to assess whether the defendants' decision to cross-claim and defend these claims was reasonable and whether the plaintiffs should be liable for the costs incurred. The reasoning focused on whether the defendants' actions were justified under the circumstances, and if the costs should be borne by the plaintiffs or allocated between the defendants.

The court determined that it was reasonable for the defendants to cross-claim and defend against the claims due to the nature of the insurance policy dispute. Consequently, the court ordered that the plaintiffs pay the costs of the cross-claims between the defendants, aligning with the principles of the Bullock order. This decision ensured that the parties involved in the dispute would bear the financial responsibility in a manner deemed just by the court.

The final orders of the court included that the plaintiffs pay the costs of the cross-claims between the defendants, reflecting the court's decision that the defendants' actions were reasonable under the circumstances. This outcome ensured that the financial burden was appropriately allocated among the parties involved in the insurance policy dispute.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established