ACN 007 528 207 PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) V BIRD CAMERON AND ORS
[2002] SASC 144
JUDGE BURLEY. By application filed on 16 April 2002 (Document 88), the plaintiff has applied for an order that:
“2.The defendants produce for inspection and copying the documents referred to as:
2.1 Accounts rendered to the defendants since 13 July 2001, referred to in paragraph 3 of the affirmation of Anthony John Keane made 7 March 2002 (FDN 85).
2.2 The 29 pages of letters from 21 January 2002 to 5 March 2002 referred to at item 15 of the short form bill of costs being exhibit AZK2 to the affirmation of Anthony John Keane made 7 March 2002, excluding the correspondence between the solicitors for the plaintiff and the solicitors for the defendants.”
This application has been made in response to the defendants’ application (by Document 84) for an increase in security for costs ordered by Bleby J on 13 July 2001. On that occasion his Honour made an order that security be provided in the sum of $40,000.00. The defendants now seek an increase in the security for costs by way of an additional $100,000.00.
The plaintiff relies upon the affidavit of its solicitor, Mr Beissel, sworn on 15 April 2002. In that affidavit Mr Beissel has stated:
“7.The plaintiff seeks access to the documents of the defendants in order to consider their claim that they require $100,000.00 to be provided by way of further or additional security for costs, in circumstances where the defendants have issued a third party claim (for which the plaintiff says the defendants are not entitled for security for costs) and also in respect of which a similar claim against the defendants is being dealt with concurrently (matter number 1484 of 1999). Further the defendants have already been provided with $40,000.00 for security for costs for preparation up to and commencement of trial.”
The application for an increase in the amount of costs is supported by the affidavit of the defendants’ solicitor, Mr Keane, affirmed on 7 March 2002. In paragraph 3 of that affidavit he has said:
“3.I have examined the accounts rendered to the defendants since 13 July 2001 and estimate that the defendants incurred costs in relation to this action in excess of $40,000.00 on or before 20 January 2002.”
Later in his affidavit he refers to an estimate made by him, the details of which are set out in exhibit AZK2 to his affidavit. That exhibit is in the form of a short form bill of costs which sets out actual costs to 5 March 2002 and the anticipated costs from 5 March 2002. The total reached by this method is just in excess of $100,000.00.
The plaintiff wishes to ascertain the basis upon which the defendants have calculated actual costs to 5 March 2002. Paragraph 2.1 of the order sought deals with accounts rendered by the defendants’ solicitors to their clients since 13 July 2001, that being the date on which Bleby…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ACN 007 528 207 Pty Ltd (in liq) v Bird Cameron and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] SASC 144
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court needed to decide included whether South Australian Civil Rules (SCR) 59.02 applied to documents referred to in an exhibit to an affidavit, and if so, whether the plaintiff could obtain an order for production of the bills of costs where privilege had been waived. The plaintiff argued that SCR 59.02 and SCR 59.03 allowed them to override a claim for legal professional privilege or that privilege had been waived. The defendants, however, maintained that legal professional privilege applied to the documents and that there had been no waiver of this privilege.
The court found that SCR 59.02 did not apply to documents referred to in an exhibit to an affidavit. It was not authority for the proposition that where a party exhibits a document to an affidavit, any other documents referred to in that exhibit became subject to immediate and summary production. The court also found that SCR 59.03 did not allow the court to override a claim for legal professional privilege once it had been properly established. The only basis upon which the plaintiff could obtain an order for production of the bills of costs was if there had been a waiver of privilege. However, the court held that the statement made by the defendants' solicitor did not constitute conduct inconsistent with the maintenance of confidentiality, and therefore, there had been no waiver of privilege.
As a result, the application for an order for production of the documents was refused. The court would hear the parties as to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi