Ackers (as joint foreign representative) v Saad Investments Company Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ackers (as joint foreign representative) v Saad Investments Company Limited; In the matter of Saad Investments Company Limited (in official liquidation) [2013] FCA 738

Citation: Ackers (as joint foreign representative) v Saad Investments Company Limited; In the matter of Saad Investments Company Limited (in official liquidation) [2013] FCA 738
Parties:

IN THE MATTER OF SAAD INVESTMENTS COMPANY LIMITED (IN OFFICIAL LIQUIDATION) (A COMPANY REGISTERED IN THE CAYMAN ISLANDS)

STEPHEN JOHN ACKERS AS A JOINT FOREIGN REPRESENTATIVE OF SAAD INVESTMENTS COMPANY LIMITED (IN OFFICIAL LIQUIDATION) (A COMPANY REGISTERED IN THE CAYMAN ISLANDS), HUGH DICKSON AS A JOINT FOREIGN REPRESENTATIVE OF SAAD INVESTMENTS COMPANY LIMITED (IN OFFICIAL LIQUIDATION) (A COMPANY REGISTERED IN THE CAYMAN ISLANDS) and MARK BYERS AS A JOINT FOREIGN REPRESENTATIVE OF SAAD INVESTMENTS COMPANY LIMITED (IN OFFICIAL LIQUIDATION) (A COMPANY REGISTERED IN THE CAYMAN ISLANDS) v SAAD INVESTMENTS COMPANY LIMITED (IN OFFICIAL LIQUIDATION) (A COMPANY REGISTERED IN THE CAYMAN ISLANDS) and DEPUTY COMMISSION OF TAXATION

File number: NSD 1168 of 2010
Judge: RARES J
Date of judgment: 30 July 2013
Addendum: 30 August 2013
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – private international law – UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency – Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) – where no jurisdiction to wind up insolvent foreign company in Australia – whether domestic tax debt or penalty can be collected in Australia before estate transferred to jurisdiction of foreign main proceedings as recognised under the Model Law – interlocutory undertaking preventing foreign representatives from remitting Australian proceeds of sale of estate to debtor’s centre of main interests in Cayman Islands, recognised as location of foreign main proceedings – where debtor’s liabilities for Australian tax and penalties not admissible to proof in Cayman Islands – where Commissioner entitled with all other unsecured creditors under Australian law to pari passu distribution of estate – where previous undertakings required both parties not to take action, including Commissioner issuing notices under Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), in relation to debtor’s Australian assets without giving notice to the other – application by Commissioner to modify previous orders to allow recovery of assets in Australia up to amount available were he entitled to be admitted to prove for tax debts and penalties in Cayman Islands

PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW – construction of UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency – Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties – whether principle of modified universalism should be applied – whether international creditors would expect distribution of assets to include payments of local tax obligations and penalties – where Model Law silent on how local forum’s taxation laws may operate to diminish debtor’s estate before local assets remitted to debtor’s centre of main interests – where if pari passu tax and penalty debts not retained in local jurisdiction before local assets remitted to debtor’s centre of main interests, all other unsecured creditors and insolvent debtor receive windfall gain – construction of Art 22(1) of the Model Law – whether Commissioner’s interests as creditor were adequately protected as required under…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ackers (as joint foreign representative) v Saad Investments... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 738
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ackers (as joint foreign representative) v Saad Investments Company Limited involved the Commissioner of Taxation seeking to recover tax debts and penalties from an insolvent company, Saad Investments, through assets located in Australia. The dispute centred on whether the Commissioner could recover these debts from Australian assets before the estate was transferred to the jurisdiction of the foreign main proceedings in the Cayman Islands. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining the applicability of the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency and the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) to this scenario. The court also had to consider whether the principle of modified universalism should apply, the protection of creditors' interests under the Model Law, and the potential estoppel stemming from the Commissioner's submission of a proof of debt to the liquidators.

The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency, particularly Articles 6 and 22, and the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. The court had to determine whether the Commissioner’s interests were adequately protected as required under Article 22(1) of the Model Law. Additionally, it was necessary to assess whether the principle of modified universalism, which suggests international creditors would expect distribution of assets to include payments of local tax obligations and penalties, should be applied. The court also had to consider whether the failure to modify the earlier orders would be manifestly contrary to Australian public policy under Article 20 of the Model Law. Finally, the court had to decide whether the Commissioner had elected to submit to the jurisdiction of the Grand Court of the Cayman Islands by submitting a proof of debt to the liquidators.

The court ruled that the Model Law did not prevent the local forum from making provision for the pari passu payment of local tax debts and penalties from the debtor’s local assets before the assets were remitted to the debtor’s centre of main interests. It found that the Commissioner’s interests were not adequately protected by the orders under Article 20 as required by Article 22(1) of the Model Law. Consequently, the court permitted the Commissioner to seek to prove for such rights as he may have to recover from Saad Investments’ assets in Australia up to the pari passu amount that he would be entitled to receive as a dividend were he able to prove for the tax debts and penalties as an unsecured creditor in the Cayman Islands liquidation. The court also determined that the Commissioner had not elected to submit to the jurisdiction of the Grand Court of the Cayman Islands by submitting a proof of debt to the liquidators.

The final orders of the court allowed the Commissioner to exercise, within a reasonable time, his rights to recover from Saad Investments’ assets in Australia up to the pari passu amount that he would be entitled to receive as a dividend in the Cayman Islands liquidation. The parties were directed to bring in short minutes of order to give effect to the reasons for judgment. Additionally, the court granted leave to appeal from any one or more of the orders, with the orders being stayed pending any appeal or taxation objection.

Orders

Orders of the court

11. To the extent that leave to appeal from these orders is required, each of the parties is granted leave to appeal from any one or more of orders 1 to 10 of these orders and any requirement to make such application orally is dispensed with.

12. Orders 1 to 10 of these orders be stayed until the later of:

(a) if a notice of an appeal from any of those orders is filed within the time prescribed under the Rules, until the Full Court finally determines any such appeal;

(b) the expiry of the time prescribed under the Rules for filing of a notice of appeal and no such notice is filed; or

(c) if the plaintiffs lodge a taxation objection under the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) within 28 days of these orders, then until any such objection is finally determined.

13. Any party has liberty to apply on 7 days’ notice.

I certify that the preceding thirteen (13) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Addendum to the Reasons for Judgment herein of the Honourable Justice Rares.

Associate:

Dated: 30 August 2013

1. On or before 6 August 2013, the parties bring in short minutes of orders to give effect to the reasons for judgment given today.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In other words, the Commissioner contends that the Court should modify the ordinary operation of the Act and the Model Law so as to put him in the same position as an unsecured creditor in a liquidation as he would be under Australian law in respect of the liabilities that Saad Investments incurred here under Australia’s taxation laws.Background The background facts leading up to the 2010 orders are set out in my earlier reasons: Ackers 190 FCR 285. The relevant facts for the present application are set out below. The Grand Court ordered that Saad Investments be wound up on 18 September 2009. On 9 November 2009, an officer of the Commissioner sent an email to the liquidators, in the Cayman Islands, advising that the Commissioner was a creditor of “SAAd Investments Limited” (sic). The email requested the liquidators to provide a claim form, a copy of any notice of meeting of creditors that had been convened, a list of known creditors or a director’s statement of affairs, any notice calling for proofs of debt and information that a creditor might require and that the foreign representatives, as liquidators, were reasonably able to provide. Hugh Dickson, one of the foreign representatives, replied to the Commissioner by email on 13 November 2009. Mr Dickson said that he and his fellow liquidators had been appointed to a number of companies in a group of over 40 entities and that it was not clear which company the Commissioner’s enquiry concerned. Mr Dickson said that if, as seemed likely, it were Saad Investments, he would send a proof of debt form, a copy of the liquidators’ reports for the relevant company and all statutory and public notices. However, he advised that due to Cayman Islands’ confidentiality laws, liquidators did not routinely issue lists of creditors. Mr Dickson also said that the Commissioner would be added to its list of creditors. He said that the liquidators had sought, but not received, a statement of affairs from the directors of any company to which they had been appointed. Next, as I have said above, the Commissioner issued the notices of assessment and penalty on 27 November 2009. The Commissioner wrote a letter to Mr Dickson on 3 December 2009 enclosing a proof of debt for AUD83,271,545.70 based on those notices, although the proof referred to them as having been issued on 1 December 2009. The letter sought information about whether Saad Investments had assets in Australia at the date of the liquidators’ appointment and, if so, whether the liquidators had appointed any agent to wind up the company’s affairs in Australia. It also enquired whether any Australian assets had been realised by any such agent and, if so, whether the proceeds had been remitted to the liquidators. On 2 February 2010, the Commissioner wrote to Mr Dickson explaining how the assessment came to be made. The letter said that Saad Investments had made a taxable capital gain from disposal of a large parcel of 67,083,682 shares in an Australian company, Sunshine Gas Limited, in consequence of its participation in a pre-bid arrangement and a later acceptance of a takeover offer. The letter asserted that on 20 August 2008 Saad Investments entered into a pre-bid acceptance deed with Queensland Gas Company Ltd (QGC) (the deed). The letter asserted that the deed provided that Saad Investments would accept QGC’s off market takeover [sic] for Sunshine shares in respect of the higher of 46,495,368 shares or 15% of Sunshine’s issued capital at the time of acceptance. The Commissioner claimed that the conditions of acceptance in the deed were satisfied so that Saad Investments disposed of 46,495,368 shares held by its nominee. The letter also asserted that Saad Investments accepted QGC’s scrip offer of five QGC shares for every eight Sunshine shares held and that, in consequence, Saad Investments received QGC shares in October 2008 as consideration for the disposal of its residual holding in Sunshine. The letter noted that the liquidators’ report to creditors dated 2 November 2009 had advised that Saad Investments then had $13 million in Australian equities held by various custodians. The Commissioner sought the names of those custodians.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Here, at the times relied on by the foreign representatives in 2009 and 2010, the Commissioner was unaware of what, if any, courses of action he had in Australia in respect of Saad Investments. He sought information from the liquidators so that he could be informed of whether, metaphorically, the bird had flown: i.e. whether there were any assets of Saad Investments still left in Australia against which he could seek to recover the whole or part of the debt owed by that company. The foreign representatives did not suggest how, in fairness to them or the creditors generally, the Commissioner could be said to have elected to give up his rights in Australia to seek recovery of the debts owed to him by Saad Investments by the anodyne steps of submitting the proofs of debt (that the liquidators could not admit to proof in the Cayman Islands anyway) seeking information and participating in a creditors meeting. The Commissioner did not have the information necessary for him to be confronted with a choice of pursuing his rights either in the Cayman Islands or Australia.Conclusion For these reasons, I am satisfied that the 2010 orders should be modified to permit the Commissioner to exercise, within a reasonable time, such rights as he may have to recover from Saad Investments’ assets in Australia up to the pari passu amount that he would be entitled to receive as a dividend were he entitled to be admitted to prove for the tax debts as an unsecured creditor in the Cayman Islands liquidation. The parties should bring in short minutes of order to give effect to these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established