ACIS and Reel SA v Aluminium Pechiney and ECL

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

OFFICIAL NOTICE

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No. 61780/99 in the name of Reel SA and Acis

Title:          Method of managing the operation of a plant for the production of aluminium by igneous electrolysis and aluminium production plant for implementing this method.

Action:          Request for a determination under section 32 and application for a declaration under section 36 in relation to the entitlement to the invention, both by Aluminium Pechiney, Societe Anonyme and ECL (Electrification Charpente Levage), Societe Anonyme.

Decision:          Issued            .

Abstract

Aluminium Pechiney and ECL filed a request under section 32 and an application under section 36 alleging that they, and not the named applicants, were entitled to the invention described in the patent specification.

One of the principles of Acis, Serge Huon, was a former employee of ECL.  It was argued that Aluminium Pechiney had conceived a concept they called ‘organisation tournante’ (translated as ‘turnaround operation’) in 1986 and that this was communicated to Mr Huon in his role at ECL.

The legal burden of proof in matters such as this rests with the requestors.  However, the evidentiary burden may shift according to the state of the evidence from time to time.  This will depend on the circumstances of the case and the likelihood of the facts being within the knowledge of, or more readily available to, one side or the other.  The Commissioner is not bound by the rules of evidence but is entitled to act on any material that is “logically probative” of the issues under decision.  The standard of proof required is the normal standard of proof required in civil litigation, that is the balance of probability.

Decided that the requestors had not proven on the balance of probabilities that they had conceived the same or similar process to what is described.  No declaration made under section 36.  Determined under section 32 that the application continues to proceed in the names of Acis and Reel SA.

Costs awarded against the requestor.  As the matter was not an opposition, but proceedings under sections 32 and 36, many of the cost items in schedule 8 of the Patent Regulations do not apply.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No. 61780/99 by Reel SA and Acis; and a request for a determination under section 32 and an application for a declaration under section 36 in relation to the entitlement to the invention, both by Aluminium Pechiney, Societe Anonyme and ECL (Electrification Charpente Levage), Societe Anonyme

BACKGROUND

  1. Reel SA and Acis jointly filed patent application 61780/99 on 30 November 1999.

  2. On 16 May 2002, Aluminium Pechiney, Societe Anonyme (hereafter "Pechiney") and ECL (Electrification Charpente Levage), Societe Anonyme (hereafter "ECL") jointly filed both a request for determination of a dispute under section 32 and an application for a declaration of an eligible person under section 36.  Section 32 provides a mechanism for the Commissioner to determine whether, or in what manner, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ACIS and Reel SA v Aluminium Pechiney and ECL and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] APO 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Aluminium Pechiney and ECL filed a request under section 32 and an application under section 36 alleging that they, and not the named applicants, were entitled to the invention described in the patent specification. The invention relates to a method of managing the operation of a plant for the production of aluminium by igneous electrolysis. The legal burden of proof in matters such as this rests with the requestors, however the evidentiary burden may shift according to the state of the evidence from time to time. The Commissioner is not bound by the rules of evidence but is entitled to act on any material that is logically probative of the issues under decision. The standard of proof required is the normal standard of proof required in civil litigation, that is the balance of probability. The Commissioner found that the requestors had not proven on the balance of probabilities that they had conceived the same or similar process to what is described. No declaration was made under section 36. The determination under section 32 was that the application was to continue to proceed in the names of Acis and Reel SA. Costs were awarded against the requestor.

Background

Background to the litigation

Reel SA and ACIS jointly filed patent application 61780/99 on 30 November 1999, describing a method of managing the operation of a plant for the production of aluminium by igneous electrolysis. The invention involves operating handling machines in a continuous circular path across two parallel pot rooms, using specialised machines. Aluminium Pechiney and ECL filed a request for a determination under section 32 and an application for a declaration under section 36, alleging that they were entitled to the invention. Pechiney and ECL argued that the invention was conceived by Pechiney employees in 1986 and communicated to Mr Serge Huon, a former ECL employee and later founder of ACIS. Huon left ECL in 1998 and, together with Reel SA, filed the patent application. Pechiney and ECL contended that the invention was based on their concept of "turnaround operation" and that Huon, while at ECL, had access to this information.

Patent application 61780/99 was filed on 30 November 1999. On 16 May 2002, Aluminium Pechiney and ECL filed a request for determination under section 32 and an application for declaration under section 36, alleging entitlement to the invention. The matter was set for a hearing, with further evidence filed following identified deficiencies. The hearing took place on 24 February 2004 and was resumed on 5 July 2004 to consider the additional evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the requestors, Aluminium Pechiney and ECL, have established that the concept of "turnaround operation" was the same as the arrangement described and claimed in patent application 61780/99.
2. Whether information regarding the "turnaround operation" was communicated to Mr Huon during his employment with ECL.
3. Whether the patent applicants, Reel SA and ACIS, are entitled to proceed with the patent application.

Held
1. The requestors, Aluminium Pechiney and ECL, have not proven on the balance of probabilities that the concept they called the "turnaround operation" was the same as the arrangement described in the patent specification.
2. The requestors have established that some information relating to the concept referred to as "organisation tournante" (or "turnaround operation") was communicated to Mr Huon during his employment with ECL, but they have not proven that this information was the basis for the described invention.
3. The application will continue to proceed in the names of Reel SA and Acis, and no declaration will be made under section 36. Costs are awarded against the requestors.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the submissions and evidence provided by both the requestors, Aluminium Pechiney and ECL, and the applicants, Reel SA and Acis. The key issue was whether the requestors had established that the "turnaround operation" they conceptualised was the same as the arrangement described in the patent specification, and whether this information was communicated to Mr Huon during his employment with ECL.

The court found that the requestors had not established that the concept they referred to as the "turnaround operation" was the same as the arrangement described in the patent specification. Although there were documents copied to Mr Huon, the sketches and technical details provided by Pechiney were vague and inconsistent with the patent specification. The court also found that the requestors had not proven that Mr Huon had obtained the described invention from the information communicated to him. The court was concerned that the applicants had not provided documentary evidence of their independent development of the invention, but found that this did not disentitle them to the invention.

The court determined under section 32 of the Patents Act that the application should continue to proceed in the names of Reel SA and Acis, and that no declaration should be made under section 36. The court awarded costs against the requestors, Aluminium Pechiney and ECL.