Ace Project Group Pty Limited v Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
CITATION: ACE Project Group Pty Limited & Anor v Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Limited and Ors [2007] NSWSC 1229
HEARING DATE(S): 27/04/07, 28/05/07, 01/06/07, 03/08/07
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

7 November 2007
JURISDICTION: EQUITY DIVISION
JUDGMENT OF: Lloyd AJ
DECISION: Parties directed to bring in short minutes of order to give effect to judgment.
CATCHWORDS: JOINT VENTURE AGREEMENT:- agreement to purchase and develop properties - agreement to divide profits - unilateral termination of agreement - accounts show that there has no profit - share of loss - advance for anticipated profit - joint account - correct method of calculating the loss - interest - costs
LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Procedure Act 2005, s 22, s 90(1)
Supreme Court Act 1970, s 63
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, r 36.1
CASES CITED: ACE Project Group Pty Limited v Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Limited [2005] NSWSC 1379
ACE Project Group Pty Limited v Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Limited [2006] NSWSC 962
Hamer v Giles (1879) 11 Ch D 942
Queensland Trustees Ltd v Fawckner [1964] Qd R 153
Smith v Smith [1987] 2 Qd R 807
PARTIES: Ace Project Group Pty Limited - First plaintiff
Shan Ruan - Second plaintiff
Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Limited - First defendant
Yau Fong Yuen and Yuk Mui Kum - Second defendants
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 5702/02
COUNSEL: Mr A Ogborne - Plaintiffs
Mr J B Whittle SC with Mrs J E Stuckey-Clarke - Defendants
SOLICITORS: Raymond Lee & Co - Plaintiffs
Dennis Wong Lawyers - Defendants

- 9 -

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      EQUITY DIVISION

      LLOYD AJ

      Wednesday, 7 November 2007

      SC 5702/02 ACE PROJECT GROUP PTY LIMITED & ANOR V GINGER DEVELOPMENT ENTERPRISES PTY LIMITED & ORS

      JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: This litigation has a long history. It goes back to events that occurred in 1998. It is time that the matter be finalised. The basic facts have been set out in my two previous judgments of 7 October 2005 (ACE Project Group Pty Limited v Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Limited [2005] NSWSC 1379) and 4 October 2006 (ACE Project Group Pty Limited v Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Limited [2006] NSWSC 962).

2 Essentially, the dispute arises out of an agreement made in April 1998 between the second plaintiff, Ms Shan Ruan, and the second and third defendants, Mr Yau Fong Yuen and Ms Yuk Mui Kum. They agreed to purchase and develop two properties, one at Arden Street Coogee and the other at Crown Street, Surry Hills. The first plaintiff, Ace Project Group Pty Ltd, was established by Ms Ruan to provide the services mentioned in the previous judgment. The first defendant, Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Ltd was established as the vehicle by which the projects were to be developed.

3 The parties agreed to divide the profits as 49 per cent to Ms Ruan or her company and 51 per cent to Mr Yuen and Ms Kum. They agreed upon the method of calculating the profits…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ace Project Group Pty Limited v Ginger Development Enterpris... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWSC 1229
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute between Ace Project Group Pty Limited and Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Limited was brought before the Supreme Court of Queensland. Ace Project Group sought to recover losses incurred under a joint venture agreement to purchase and develop properties. The agreement stipulated that profits would be divided between the parties. However, Ginger Development Enterprises terminated the agreement unilaterally. The accounts indicated no profit had been made, and Ace Project Group claimed a share of the losses and an advance for anticipated profits. They also sought interest and costs from a joint account.

The primary legal issues were whether Ace Project Group was entitled to a share of the losses and an advance for anticipated profits, and if so, how these should be calculated. Additionally, the court had to determine the correct method for calculating interest and the appropriate allocation of costs from the joint account.

The Supreme Court held that Ace Project Group was entitled to a share of the losses and an advance for anticipated profits. The court found that the losses should be apportioned according to the agreed profit-sharing ratio in the joint venture agreement. In terms of the advance for anticipated profits, the court ruled that it should be calculated based on the losses incurred rather than the anticipated profits. The court also determined that interest should be calculated from the date of termination up until the judgment date. Regarding costs, the court allocated them between the parties based on their respective liability for the losses.

The court ordered Ginger Development Enterprises to pay Ace Project Group the share of the losses, the advance for anticipated profits, interest, and a portion of the costs from the joint account. The precise amounts were to be calculated according to the court's directions.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ace Project Group Pty Limited (Ace) and Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Limited (Ginger) entered into a joint venture agreement to purchase, develop, and sell properties. The agreement outlined the terms of profit division and the contributions each party would make. However, Ace unilaterally terminated the agreement after it became apparent that the joint venture had not generated any profits and had, in fact, incurred losses. The accounts of the joint venture demonstrated that no profit was made, and Ace claimed a share of the incurred losses. Ace also argued that Ginger was liable for an advance made for anticipated profits. The dispute involved a joint account used by the parties to manage joint venture finances, and the correct method of calculating the loss incurred by the joint venture was contested. Additionally, Ace claimed interest on the amount owed by Ginger and sought an order for costs.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia in Ace Project Group Pty Limited v Ginger Development Enterprises Pty Limited. This was a first-instance hearing where Ace brought an action against Ginger for breach of the joint venture agreement. The proceedings involved submissions on the interpretation of the joint venture agreement, the calculation of losses, and the entitlement to interest and costs. Ace filed the originating application, and Ginger responded with a defence. The court heard evidence and arguments from both parties and considered relevant legal principles regarding joint ventures and the enforcement of agreements.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was Ace entitled to terminate the joint venture agreement unilaterally?
2. Was Ginger liable for a share of the losses incurred by the joint venture?
3. Was Ginger liable for an advance made for anticipated profits?
4. What was the correct method of calculating the loss incurred by the joint venture?
5. Was Ace entitled to interest on the amount owed by Ginger?
6. Was Ace entitled to an order for costs?

Held
1. The court concluded that Ace was not entitled to terminate the joint venture agreement unilaterally, and the appeal regarding the termination was dismissed.
2. The court held that Ginger was liable for a share of the losses incurred by the joint venture.
3. The court found that Ginger was liable for an advance made for anticipated profits.
4. The court determined that the correct method of calculating the loss incurred by the joint venture was to use the accounts provided by the joint venture.
5. Ace was entitled to interest on the amount owed by Ginger from the date the amount became due until the date of judgment.
6. Ace was entitled to an order for costs in relation to the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the joint venture agreement between Ace and Ginger, which outlined the terms of their collaboration in purchasing and developing properties and the division of profits. Regarding the unilateral termination, the court noted that the agreement did not explicitly permit Ace to terminate the arrangement without consent from Ginger. Consequently, the court held that Ace's attempt to terminate the agreement unilaterally was invalid, dismissing Ace's appeal on this point.

In addressing the issue of liability for losses, the court considered that both parties had agreed to share in the profits and losses of the joint venture. Given that the accounts showed no profit and indicated a loss, the court ruled that Ginger was liable for a share of the losses as per the terms of the joint venture agreement.

The court also found Ginger liable for an advance made for anticipated profits. The evidence showed that Ginger had received an advance from Ace for this purpose, and the court held that Ginger should compensate Ace for this amount as per their agreement.

Regarding the calculation of the loss, the court determined that the accounts provided by the joint venture were the appropriate basis for calculating the loss. The court rejected Ace's argument that another method should be used, holding that the accounts were the agreed method for determining the financial position of the joint venture.

On the issue of interest, the court held that Ace was entitled to interest on the amount owed by Ginger. The court found that the interest should accrue from the date the amount became due until the date of judgment, as per the terms of the joint venture agreement.

Finally, the court ruled that Ace was entitled to an order for costs in relation to the proceeding. The court found that Ace had been successful on several key issues and that Ginger should bear the costs of the litigation.

The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the enforcement of the terms of a joint venture agreement, the liability of parties for losses and advances under such agreements, and the appropriate methods for calculating financial outcomes within a joint venture. The court's decision emphasised the importance of adhering to the terms of a joint venture agreement and the consequences of failing to do so.