Acconci v Alpha Technologies Corporation Limited (In Liquidation)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Acconci v Alpha Technologies Corporation Limited (In Liquidation)

[2010] FCA 970

Citation: Acconci v Alpha Technologies Corporation Limited (In Liquidation) [2010] FCA 970
Parties: PAOLO ACCONCI, CHRISTIANO TALPO and FKM HOLDINGS LTD v ALPHA TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 006 613 636, KENNETH STEWART SELLERS IN HIS CAPACITY AS JOINT AND SEVERAL LIQUIDATOR OF ALPHA TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) and MATHEW CAMPBELL MULDOON IN HIS CAPACITY AS JOINT AND SEVERAL LIQUIDATOR OF ALPHA TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
File number: VID 580 of 2010
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 3 September 2010
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – winding up –application for termination of winding up – whether solvency established or sufficiently assured – adequacy of evidence – proposal to postpone but not subordinate related party debt – proposed loan from related party – availability of funds from wholly owned subsidiary – failure to notify contributories and creditors of application – interests of existing and future creditors and contributories – other relevant considerations
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 482, 563B.
Cases cited: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Plymin (No 1) (2003) 46 ACSR 126
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Lencal Excavations Pty Ltd (In liq) [2004] NSWSC 783
Double Bay Newspapers Pty Ltd v Fitness Lounge Pty Ltd (2006) 57 ACSR 131
Gematech Pty Ltd v Bardi Investments Pty Ltd [2008] NSWSC 196
Krextile Holdings Pty Ltd v Widdows; Re Brush Fabrics Pty Ltd [1974] VR 689
Mercy & Sons Pty Ltd v Wanari Pty Ltd (subject to deed of company arrangement) (in liq) (2000) 35 ACSR 70
Metledge v Bambakit Pty Ltd (in liq) [2005] NSWSC 160
Re Calgary and Edmonton Land Co Ltd (in liq) [1975] 1 WLR 355
Re E-Fahkri, in the matter of Elfah Pty Ltd (in liq) [2002] FCA 1469
Re King & I Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 2085
Von Risefer v Mainfreight International Pty Ltd (2009) 73 ACSR 427
Date of hearing: 20 August 2010
Date of last submissions: 20 August 2010
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 137
Counsel for the Plaintiffs: Mr M Wyles SC with Mr C Brown
Solicitor for the Plaintiffs: Foster Nicholson Legal
Counsel for the Defendants: Mr P Crutchfield SC with Mr L Merrick
Solicitor for the Defendants: Middletons

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 580 of 2010

BETWEEN:

PAOLO ACCONCI
First Plaintiff

CHRISTIANO TALPO
Second Plaintiff

FKM HOLDINGS LTD
Third Plaintiff

AND:

ALPHA TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 006 613 636
First Defendant

KENNETH STEWART SELLERS IN HIS CAPACITY AS JOINT AND SEVERAL LIQUIDATOR OF ALPHA TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
Second Defendant

MATHEW CAMPBELL MULDOON IN HIS CAPACITY AS JOINT AND SEVERAL LIQUIDATOR OF ALPHA TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
Third Defendant

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

3 SEPTEMBER 2010

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application made by originating process dated 16 July 2010 be refused.

2.The plaintiffs pay the defendants’ costs of the application.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Acconci v Alpha Technologies Corporation Limited (In Liquida... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 970
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Acconci v Alpha Technologies Corporation Limited (In Liquidation), the court was tasked with determining whether the winding up of Alpha Technologies Corporation Limited (Alpha) should be terminated. The case involved a dispute over the solvency of the company and whether the interests of its creditors and contributories were adequately protected. The primary legal issues centered on whether the plaintiffs had established the solvency of Alpha or sufficiently assured the position of creditors and contributories, and whether the proposed terms for termination would operate effectively without creating uncertainty.

The court considered various affidavits and expert reports, including those from the liquidators, shareholders, and creditors. Key points of contention included the valuation of Alpha's assets, particularly its shareholding in Alpha Sensors USA, and the potential impact on this subsidiary if a significant sum were to be transferred. The plaintiffs, represented by an expert report from Mr Wallace-Smith, argued that Alpha was solvent and that there was likely to be a full return to creditors. However, the defendants, supported by evidence from Mr O’Brien, contended that any significant cash transfer would detrimentally affect Alpha’s ability to meet its own financial requirements and maintain working capital.

The court concluded that the plaintiffs had not established that Alpha was solvent or that the interests of creditors and contributories were sufficiently assured. The evidence indicated that Alpha's solvency was uncertain, and the proposed terms for termination did not adequately address the interests of all parties involved. The court also noted the discord among shareholders and the potential for future disputes, which further supported the decision to deny the application for termination of the winding up. Consequently, the court refused the application and ordered the plaintiffs to pay the defendants’ costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application made by originating process dated 16 July 2010 be refused.

2. The plaintiffs pay the defendants’ costs of the application.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The following affidavits were filed in opposition:1.Affidavit of Christopher David Morris sworn 13 August 20102.Affidavit of Richard Harold Rubin affirmed 13 August 20103.Affidavit of Daniel O'Brien sworn 16 August 20104.Affidavit of Kenneth Stewart Sellers sworn 16 August 20105.Affidavit of Gavan Paul Stewart sworn 17 August 2010BACKGROUND AND EVIDENCEDefendants’ evidence As appears from Mr Sellers’ affidavit and the exhibits thereto, Alpha is a public company listed on the ASX. It has, it seems, about 800 shareholders. Alpha was placed in liquidation on 2 July 2010 pursuant to a resolution of creditors at a reconvened second meeting of creditors under s 439A of the Act, and Messrs Sellers and Muldoon were appointed liquidators. On 2 September 2009, Messrs Sellers and Muldoon were appointed voluntary administrators of Alpha pursuant to s 346A of the Act by a resolution of its directors. Alpha’s directors are Zac Anthony, Tony Bickerton and Robert Perdue. Its six largest shareholders as at 8 September 2009 were: Many of Alpha’s creditors were or are directors and, or alternatively, shareholders. The creditors’ claims against Alpha admitted for voting purposes at the second meeting of creditors total $3,291,159.89. The unsecured creditors admitted to vote at the second meeting of creditors on 2 July 2010 were as follows: Of the above creditors, the following filed deeds of assignment of debt with the administrators on 1 July 2010. Following the commencement of voluntary administration, the voluntary administrators made a number of applications to extend the convening period for the second meeting of creditors under s 439A of the Act. Mr Sellers deposed that the extensions were sought in order to investigate selling Alpha’s shareholding in ATA and Alpha’s main asset, its shareholding in its American subsidiary Alpha Sensors USA (“ASI”). The investigations included obtaining an indication of the value of the shareholding in ASI to assist in determining whether to vote for a deed of company arrangement (“DOCA”). The administrators engaged an American marketing firm, “CBIZ”, to make discreet inquiries about marketing ASI. The voluntary administrators’ investigation revealed that the value of assets of the business significantly exceeded creditors’ claims. They prepared a DOCA options paper. Between September 2009 and March 2010, the voluntary administrators had approximately a dozen discussions or meetings with Gavan Stewart, a director of E‑Fulfilment.com Pty Ltd (“E-Fulfilment”), Alpha’s largest shareholder (and a creditor for over $1 million), and E‑Fulfilment’s solicitor, Mr Nicholson, about E‑Fulfilment’s DOCA proposal. E‑Fulfilment’s DOCA proposal involved a six month deferral of related party creditors and apparently contemplated the non‑payment of the claims of Panache (a creditor for $451,000 and a 17.2% shareholder of Alpha) and its controller, Mr Rubin. Mr Sellers deposed that although the voluntary administrators requested the proponent to pay $954,000 to a Deed Fund to facilitate the payment of related party creditors (except for FKM), the final version did not provide for any up‑front payment. The voluntary administrators were also concerned at the possibility that certain creditors would not be paid.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr O’Brien deposed that if Alpha borrowed $1.5 million, it would leave ASI with problems, and unable to follow up business and growth opportunities. If ASI had to make a cash transfer of $1.5 million to its parent, whether as a dividend or loan, it would have a significant detrimental effect on ASI’s ability to fund new business opportunities and to maintain its working capital. In short, ASI could not both remit $1.5 million to Alpha and meets its own reasonable requirements.The plaintiffs’ evidenceMr Wallace‑Smith Mr Wallace‑Smith, a chartered accountant and partner of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu, prepared an expert report on behalf of the plaintiffs. In the section of his report entitled “Background of Appointment of Liquidators”, Mr Wallace‑Smith noted that the second report to creditors of Alpha stated “a best case” for the sale proceeds of ASI of $18 million and a lowest cash sale proceeds of $8 million. In Mr Wallace‑Smith’s view, even on the lowest case, there was likely to be a 100% return to creditors and a surplus available for distribution to shareholders. Mr Wallace‑Smith stated, in that context:In my experience of having acted as an Administrator, this case appears to have had a number of potential outcomes that would provide for the continuation of the business and a full return to creditors. It does not appear to be a company that is hopelessly insolvent and in need of immediate closure with potentially little or no return to creditors. Mr Wallace-Smith stated that the most recent audited balance sheet for Alpha as at 30 June 2009 showed:Current assets – $166,000Non‑current assets - $3,566,000Total assets - $3,726,000Current liabilities - $2,559,000Non-current liabilities - $0.00Total liabilities - $$2,559,000Net assets - $1,167,000 The consolidated accounts as at 31 December 2009 showed net assets of $4,786,000. The second creditors’ report revealed a surplus of $1,845,089 (book value) and $801,187 (ERV). Mr Wallace-Smith reconstructed Alpha’s balance sheet based on information in the second creditors’ report (including the summary RATA as at 2 September 2009, information presented to at the second creditors’ meeting and “other information”). He noted that “the reconstructed balance sheet has not been prepared pursuant to accounting standards and is not an audited or fully reconciled balance sheet at a single balance date, however, it provides a guide as to what the balance sheet for Alpha may currently approximate”. The reconstructed balance sheet assumed that the $1,144,506 debt to FKM was not due for 12 months and that a $500,000 facility (from an unidentified source) would be available to Alpha, repayable after 12 months. The reconstructed balance sheet showed net assets of $1,588,197, current liabilities of $2,289,714 (less FKM’s debt) and current assets (cash at bank) of $1,211,573. Mr Wallace-Smith acknowledged that the positive net asset position in the reconstructed balance sheet was primarily due to Alpha’s investment in ASI and ATA. The November 2009 KPMG report valued the Alpha Technics business in the range of $12.6 million to $15.4 million.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Such considerations, while not in themselves decisive, fortified the effect of more significant factors of insolvency and the interests of creditors and contributories which, in my view, precluded the termination of winding up in this case.CONCLUSION In my opinion, the application made by originating process dated 16 July 2010 should be refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the present case, as in Von Risefer, relief was sought only pursuant to s 482, as the plaintiffs did not pursue claims under s 600A and s 447A of the Act or the application to amend. The plaintiffs did not, in my view, establish any basis on which the resolutions to appoint voluntary administrations or to wind the company up should be set aside. However, had they done so, the termination of the winding up under s 482 would not be warranted in circumstances where the solvency of the company is not established, and the position of contributories and creditors is not satisfactorily addressed. Other considerations While no contraventions of law or duty by Alpha’s previous officers were alleged, the evidence established a degree of discord between shareholders and not insignificant related litigation. In contrast to Krextile, in the present case, there is no assurance that discord would not recur, were the winding up terminated. Rather, the evidence suggested the contrary. Further, as the defendants submitted, the terms of the orders sought did not assure their effective operation and raised potential uncertainty. Such considerations, while not in themselves decisive, fortified the effect of more significant factors of insolvency and the interests of creditors and contributories which, in my view, precluded the termination of winding up in this case.CONCLUSION In my opinion, the application made by originating process dated 16 July 2010 should be refused.