Acacia Sportswear P/L v Segenhoe Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Ctfi 99

JUDGMENT No. ....... a#a"nnn
pl THE FFDFRAL COURT OF AUS- 1
)
JWW SOUTH - W R E G I S W ) No G201 of 1991
)
m DIVISION )
BETWEEN ACACIA SPORE= LIMITED &
ms
blYP:  SEGFNHOE LI-

Fust Respondent

A M O N SECU-

Second Respondent

SEGENHOE STUD MANAGEMENT PTY

Third Respondent

NZ1 SECURITIES AUSTRALIA LIMITEQ

Fourth Respondent

SEGENHOE LIMITFD

Cross Clalmant

SLY & RUSSFLL

Flnt Cross Respondent

m:  Danes J
20 July 1994
W: 
SY""~Y  MINUTES OF ORDER

DAVlD KENDFLL

Second Cross Respondent

I. Answers be p w n to lnterrogatones 4(d), (e), (f) & (g). @)(l), (11) &
2. The motlon be o t h e w e dlsm~ued

2.   The first respondent pay 5090 of the costs of the second cross respondent in respect of the motion.

Km. Rules.
Settlement and entry of orders is dealt wth m Order 36 of the Federal Court
COURT OF AUSTRAJ .M 1

1

W W SOUTH WAT.FS DISTRICT REGISTRY ) No G201 of 1991
)
- 1
BETWEEN:  ACACIA SPORTSWEAR PTY

JJMITED & ORS

Appl~canu

-

Fmt Respondent

ON SECURITIES

Second Respondent

S E G E N H O E S T U D m A G E M E N T PTY LIMITED

Thlrd Respondent

NZ1 SECURITIES AUSTRALL.4

LIMITED

Fourth Respondent

SEGENHOE LIMITED

Cross Clamant

SLY & RUSSELI .

First Cross Respondent

DAVID KENDELL

Second Cross Respondent

!&Lam Dames J.
m:  20 July 1994
m:  Sydney

This motlon seeks orders that certaln lnterrogatones delwered by the first respondent, Segenhoe Limited ("Segenhoe"), to Messrs Sly & Russell Sohcitors, who are cross respondents, and also to Mr Davld Kendell, a partner m that firm, who is

individually a cross respondent, be answered. For the moment, the lnterrogatories as

against Sly & Russell have been deferred pendlng my rullng on the interrogatories

delivered to Mr Kendell.

In 1986, r.1 of Order 16 of the Rules of the Court was amended so as to

provide that the delivery of lnterrogatories requlred the leave of the Court. Leave 1s

rarely granted for the reason that the process 1s costly and time consummg, both for
the Court and for lltlgants, unless vely strlctly hmlted.

The usual practlce of the Court in Sydney 1s not to allow lnterrogatones unless the partles are agreed upon a draft or the Judge approves a draft. In the present case, a Judge gave leave to interrogate, havlng been ~nformed that there was an unusual clrcumstance, namely that Mr Kendell had been Chalrman of Directors of

The Judge, who dealt with the matter only because the Judge who had been handling Segenhoe and possessed knowledge whlch other officers of Segenhoe dld not have.

the interlocutory processes was not available, dld not ~nslst that a draft be agreed or settled by hlm. In the cucumstances, I thlnk that h s Honour dld not intend to give unrestricted leave to interrogate and that I should not order answers unless the

~nterrogator~es fulfil the crlterla requlred by the general…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Acacia Sportswear P/L v Segenhoe Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] FCA 469
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Acacia Sportswear P/L v Segenhoe Ltd is a case in which the plaintiff, Acacia Sportswear P/L, sought to compel the defendant, Segenhoe Ltd, to answer certain interrogatories. The interrogatories were part of a larger legal dispute involving multiple parties, including Sly & Russell, a law firm, and David Kendell, a partner at the firm. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, with Justice Danes presiding.

The central legal issue in this case was whether the interrogatories, which were requests for information from Segenhoe Ltd, were valid and necessary for the proceedings. Specifically, the interrogatories sought information about advice given to Segenhoe Ltd by Sly & Russell, the relationship between Sly & Russell and Segenhoe Ltd, and the preparation of certain documents related to a horse breeding venture. The court had to determine whether these interrogatories were appropriate under the rules of the Federal Court and whether they were necessary for the fair resolution of the case.

Justice Danes ruled that while some of the interrogatories were appropriate and should be answered, others were overly broad, ambiguous, or irrelevant to the case. The interrogatories that were deemed too broad or irrelevant were considered fishing expeditions, which the court strictly prohibits. The court allowed answers to certain interrogatories that were specific and relevant to the case, such as those inquiring about the instructions given for the preparation of legal documents and the use of word processors by Sly & Russell. However, the court dismissed interrogatories that were too general or sought information that was not pertinent to the case, such as those asking for detailed accounts of fees charged by Sly & Russell and Mr. Kendell.

The final orders of the court mandated that certain interrogatories be answered while dismissing the rest of the motion. Additionally, the court ordered Segenhoe Ltd to pay 50% of the costs incurred by Mr. Kendell in responding to the motion. This ruling highlights the court's role in ensuring that litigation processes are efficient and that parties do not engage in unnecessary or overly burdensome discovery practices.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established