QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CITATION:
Acacia Ridge Presbyterian Church v Thomson [2018] QCAT 300
PARTIES:
ACACIA RIDGE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH
(applicant)v CATHERINE THOMSON
(respondent)
APPLICATION NO/S:
NDR208-17
MATTER TYPE:
Neighbourhood Dispute
DELIVERED ON:
3 September 2018
HEARING DATE:
On the papers
HEARD AT:
Brisbane
DECISION OF:
Member Traves
ORDERS:
1. Catherine Thomson must arrange for the removal of the coconut palm situated on 376 Mortimer Road, Acacia Ridge and which overhangs
372 Mortimer Road, Acacia Ridge.2. Catherine Thomson is responsible for the cost of the removal.
3. The removal must be completed within 45 days of the date of this order.
CATCHWORDS:
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – TREES, VEGETATION AND HABITAT PROTECTION – DISPUTES BETWEEN NEIGHBOURS – where land affected by a tree – where coconut palm overhangs neighbouring carpark – whether risk of serious injury – whether substantial, ongoing and unreasonable interference with the use and enjoyment of the neighbour’s land – whether appropriate to make an order for removal of the tree pursuant to s 66 – where no material filed by respondent despite Directions to do so – where non-attendance by respondent at compulsory conference – where Directions made that if no Response filed by extended date matter would be determined on the basis of material filed
Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 (Qld), s 46, s 48, s 50, s 57, s 59, s 66, s 70, s 71,
s 73, s 74Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 28, s 72
McHugh v Withers [2017] QCAT 346
Moreton Island Development Group v Smith Development Pty Ltd [2012] QCATA 15REPRESENTATION: Applicant: Self-represented Respondent:
Self-represented
APPEARANCES:
This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)
REASONS FOR DECISION
Introduction
This matter concerns a coconut palm, approximately 12-15 metres tall, which is on land owned by Catherine Thomson. The palm overhangs adjoining land which is owned by the Acacia Ridge Presbyterian Church (‘the Church’).
As the palm produces coconuts, the Church is concerned about the risk of injury to people and of damage to property, in particular to vehicles parked in the Church carpark. The Church claims that in 2014, a coconut fell and damaged the windscreen of a motor vehicle parked in the carpark. The Church has provided photographic evidence of a car with a coconut resting on a damaged windscreen. Ms Thomson did not accept the incident occurred and questioned why she had not heard from the Church at the time. The Church responded by saying that, at the time of the incident, two members of the Church had gone next door to see Ms Thomson about it, but, as her gates were locked, were unable to gain access to her premises. Since that incident, barricades have been erected in the Church grounds preventing access to the 3 or 4 carparks situated beneath the overhanging palm. I am satisfied on the evidence that the incident…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Acacia Ridge Presbyterian Church v Thomson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] QCAT 300
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal found that the threshold requirements were satisfied, as the tree was on or against the boundary, extended over the Church’s land, and there was a likelihood of serious injury or damage to people or property on the Church’s land. The Tribunal noted that the Church had barricaded the affected carparks due to the risk of harm or damage, and that the responsibility for averting the risk lay with Ms Thomson, as the tree-keeper. The Tribunal held that Part 4 of the Neighbourhood Disputes Act, which applies to branches 2.5 metres or less above the ground, did not apply as the tree was approximately 12 to 15 metres in height. The Tribunal then considered what order should be made, and held that an order for the removal of the tree was appropriate to prevent serious injury to a person or property, and to prevent unreasonable interference with the Church’s use and enjoyment of its land.
Pursuant to the order made by the Tribunal, Ms Thomson must arrange for the removal of the coconut palm tree within 45 days of the date of the order, and is responsible for the cost of the removal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Catherine Thomson must arrange for the removal of the coconut palm situated on 376 Mortimer Road, Acacia Ridge and which overhangs
372 Mortimer Road, Acacia Ridge.
2. Catherine Thomson is responsible for the cost of the removal.
3. The removal must be completed within 45 days of the date of this order.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In making an order to remove a tree I may also consider any steps taken to prevent the likelihood of injury or damage,[23] or any other matter I consider relevant.[24][23]NDA, s 74(1)(b).[24]NDA, s 74(2)(d).Consideration I am satisfied that the threshold requirements in s 59 have been satisfied. The Arboricultural Tree Appraisal states that the canopy of the tree is 4 metres. The tree is on or against the boundary and from photographs appears to extend over the Church’s land by 1 to 2 metres. This is sufficient to satisfy the requirement that the land be affected by a tree.[25] [25]NDA, s 46. I also find that the tree is likely within the next 12 months to cause serious injury to a person on the Church’s land or serious damage to its land or property. Coconut palm nuts have fallen from the tree and, in one case, fallen on a motor vehicle parked in the Church carpark, causing damage. The Church also complains of other debris falling from the tree, including palm fronds. The risk of harm to people or of further damage being caused to property has meant that the Church has barricaded the affected carparks so that the public can no longer use them. The barricades would not have been erected if the Church was not concerned about the risk and its duty of care as occupier. It is, in my view, no answer, to argue as Ms Thomson has done, that the barricades have ameliorated any risk or that there are other carparks which can be used. It is not the responsibility of the adjoining land owner, affected by the tree, to put in place measures to avert risk. This is, by s 52(2) of the NDA, clearly the responsibility of the tree-keeper, Ms Thomson.[26] In any event, the ‘solutions’ which involve maintaining barricades on the affected land or using other car parking spaces, are an unreasonable restriction on the use and enjoyment by the Church of its land.[27][26]See also NDA, s 41.[27]NDA, s 46(a)(ii)(C). I am also satisfied that this is not a dispute that can be resolved using Part 4. This is because Part 4 establishes a process for resolving disputes relating to branches 2.5 metres or less above the ground. This tree is approximately 12 to 15 metres in height and Part 4 therefore has no application. Having been satisfied the ‘gateway requirements’ in s 59 have been met, I turn now to consider what order should be made. Pursuant to s 66(2), the Tribunal may, relevantly, make an order it considers appropriate in relation to the relevant tree to:(a)prevent serious injury to any person; or (b)to remedy, restrain or prevent – (i) prevent serious damage to the neighbour’s land or any property on the neighbour’s land; or(ii) substantial, ongoing and unreasonable interference with the use and enjoyment of the neighbour’s land. In my view, both limbs of s 66(2) are relevant in this case. There is a clear risk of serious injury to a person or to property from nuts falling from a 12-15 metre height. The tree extends over the carpark and, as is evident from photographs and the Arborist Report, its weight bias is towards the Church’s carpark.[28] The crown is mature and spans approximately 4 metres bearing potentially 20 to 30 coconuts. The rate of fruit production would increase with age.[29][28]Arboricultural Tree Appraisal, dated 8 October 2017, 7.[29]Ibid.