ABW Design & Construction Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Services Authority, Naidoo

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read
CITATION: ABW Design & Construction Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Services Authority, Naidoo [2013] QCAT 352
PARTIES: ABW Design & Construction Pty Ltd
(Applicant)
v
Queensland Building Services Authority
Mr Seshagaran Naidoo
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: GAR155-12
MATTER TYPE: General administrative review matters
HEARING DATE: 10 April 2013
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Ann Fitzpatrick, Member
DELIVERED ON: 12 July, 2013
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    The decision of the Queensland Building Services Authority, dated 5 April, 2012 is affirmed with respect to Items 3 and 15 set out in the Direction to Rectify and/or Complete No.37459;

2.    Except as set out in Order 1, the decision of the Queensland Building Services Authority, dated 5 April, 2012 is set aside.

CATCHWORDS:

REVIEW - Review of decision to direct rectification work – whether builder at fault or defective work attributable to builder – whether it would be unfair in the circumstances to direct builder rectify work.

Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 s 72.

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

APPLICANT: ABW Design & Construction Pty Ltd represented by Mr Utz Wellner of Wellner Lawyers
RESPONDENT: Queensland Building Services Authority and Mr Seshagaran Naidoo represented by Mr Simon Formby, Employee of the Queensland Building Services Authority.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The applicant, ABW Design & Construction Pty Ltd ACN 101 130 509 (ABW) seeks to review the decision of the Queensland Building Services Authority (BSA), dated 5 April, 2012 directing it to rectify certain items of building work at a property owned by the respondent Mr Naidoo.

  2. At the hearing evidence was given by Mr Richard Wangelin, Director and Nominee of ABW.

  3. ABW was engaged by Mr Naidoo to carry out renovation and extension work to a dwelling at 31 Kitchener Road, Ascot.

  4. Following lodgement of a complaint by Mr Naidoo a BSA Inspector, Mr Chris Coombs, carried out an inspection and prepared an initial inspection report dated 30 March 2012.  Relevantly the BSA also engaged an engineer Mr Peter Wright of Hughes, Beal and Wright Pty Ltd to attend the site and prepare a report. The report is dated 29 March, 2012.

  5. The BSA concluded that ABW had carried out defective building work and required it to be rectified.

Questions for the Tribunal

  1. The Tribunal has all the functions of the decision maker and must hear and decide the matter by way of a fresh hearing on the merits. In reviewing the BSA’s decision, I have to consider:

    (a)   whether  ABW is in some way at fault, so that defective building work can be attributed to it; and

    (b)   whether it would be unfair in all the circumstances to require it to rectify the defective work.[1]

    [1]Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 ss 72 and 86(1); Stephenson v Queensland building Services Authority [2005] CCT Q056-04.

  2. In undertaking this consideration I have had regard to the material filed by the parties and the evidence given at the hearing.

Items of Work

  1. At the commencement of the hearing Mr Formby for the BSA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ABW Design & Construction Pty Ltd v Queensland Building Serv... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QCAT 352
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves a dispute between ABW Design & Construction Pty Ltd and the Queensland Building Services Authority, with Mr. Naidoo as a party. The crux of the matter is a challenge to a decision directing ABW to undertake rectification work on two properties, specifically concerning issues with tile grouting and a driveway. The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) was tasked with determining whether the builder was at fault for the defects or if the defective work could be attributed to other factors, and whether it would be unfair to direct the builder to rectify the work.

The legal issues before the court were whether ABW was responsible for the unsatisfactory tiling and driveway, and if it would be unfair to compel ABW to rectify these issues. The court had to consider the evidence presented regarding the causes of the defects and whether ABW had made reasonable efforts to address the problems. Additionally, the tribunal assessed whether directing ABW to complete the rectification work would be a fair outcome given the circumstances.

In examining the evidence, the tribunal found that while ABW had made attempts to rectify the tile grouting issues, the work remained unsatisfactory. The evidence showed that the discolouration and uneven finish in the tile grout were due to water leakage from cracked toilets, which was not ABW's responsibility. Despite this, the tribunal concluded that ABW should still undertake the rectification work as it was not unfair to do so, given the builder's previous attempts and the unsatisfactory nature of the work. Regarding the driveway, the tribunal found that although the driveway did not strictly adhere to the contractual drawings, it was reshaped by ABW to address alleged design flaws. The tribunal determined that ABW should rectify the driveway to ensure it meets the required standards.

The tribunal affirmed the decision of the Queensland Building Services Authority in respect to Items 3 and 15 of the Direction to Rectify and/or Complete No.37459. However, it set aside the decision except for those specific items, directing ABW to complete the necessary rectification work.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of the Queensland Building Services Authority, dated 5 April, 2012 is affirmed with respect to Items 3 and 15 set out in the Direction to Rectify and/or Complete No.37459;

2. Except as set out in Order 1, the decision of the Queensland Building Services Authority, dated 5 April, 2012 is set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Discolouration and uneven joint finish is evident within the tile grout to the wet area tiling of both lower and upper floors creating an unsightly finish. Mr Wangelin gave evidence that in his opinion the cause of the discolouration was as a result of water leaking from cracked toilets which were not his responsibility. He said that in an effort to overcome the problem with the tiles, he had engaged a tiler to replace the tiles at ABW’s own cost on two occasions. Mr Naidoo gave evidence that even after the leaking toilets had been rectified, the tile grout discoloured in freshly laid tiles. The BSA submitted that it could not say why the tile grout was discoloured but a competent builder would not accept the work and the attempts at rectification had not been satisfactory. The evidence as to when the tiles were replaced relative to rectification of the leaking toilets was unclear. Although I accept Mr Wangelin’s evidence that he made attempts at rectification, I accept the evidence of Mr Coombs and find that the work is unsatisfactory and direct that the tile grouting be replaced. On balance, I do not consider it is unfair for ABW to be required to undertake this work. In essence the problem with the driveway is that the Owner’s sedan motor vehicle cannot drive down the driveway to the garage without bottoming out. As a result it is parked on the street. The driveway constructed by ABW is not entirely in accordance with the contractual drawing for the driveway, WD08, but rather has been reshaped by ABW to overcome what are alleged to be problems with the original design which led to bottoming out and lack of access to the garage. The driveway can be utilized by 4wheel drive vehicles but not the majority of ordinary sedans which still bottom out. Mr Wangelin’s evidence in this regard was supported by Zoran Utjeseoic, who was engaged as a carpenter on the project and who observed attempts to drive a vehicle down the driveway into the garage and who drove his own 4 wheel drive vehicle into the garage after modifications were made to the driveway. Mr Wangelin said that he met with the Owner Mr Naidoo and the architect Steve Manson of Mayhill Planning Architecture to discuss the driveway’s problems. Mr Wangelin said that the outcome of the meeting was that Mr Naidoo directed him to ensure his 4 wheel drive vehicle could access the garage. In evidence Mr Manson recalled that outcome, but could not recall any discussion of a need to reshape the driveway to ensure vehicles did not bottom out. He recalled the conversation to be about the size of the opening to the garage, rather than the driveway. Neither Mr Wangelin nor Mr Manson recalled any discussion about whether a normal sedan could drive down the driveway. Mr Naidoo did not recall any discussion of difficulties with the slope of the originally designed driveway which necessitated changes to the plan. His only recollection was in relation to a concern over clearance in accessing the garage, which was resolved by the builder lifting the roller door.