Abu-Mahmoud v Consolidated Lawyers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Summary available
Medium Neutral Citation: Abu-Mahmoud v Consolidated Lawyers Pty Ltd [2015] NSWSC 547
Hearing dates:9 December 2013 – 13 December 2013, 16 December 2013, 6 June 2014
Date of orders: 18 May 2015
Decision date: 18 May 2015
Before: Garling J
Decision:

(1)Judgment for the plaintiff in an amount to be calculated.
(2)Plaintiff to file and serve proposed short minutes of order, any motion seeking an order for costs different from that proposed, and any affidavit and submissions in support of that motion by Monday 1 June 2015.
(3)Defendants to file and serve proposed short minutes of order, any motion seeking an order for costs different from that proposed, and any affidavit and submissions in support of that motion by Monday 15 June 2015.
(4)Stand proceedings over for determination of all outstanding issues, if any, to 10am on Friday 19 June 2015.
(5)Direct the parties, at the time of filing any documents in accordance with Orders 3 and 4, to provide a copy to my Associate.
(6)Liberty to apply on 2 days’ notice.

Catchwords: TORTS – professional negligence – solicitor – failed restructure scheme with respect to a property owned by the plaintiff – loss suffered by plaintiff as a result – solicitor retained by plaintiff – whether existing retainer extended to include restructure issue – whether advice given to plaintiff – whether advice negligent – if negligent advice whether negligence caused loss – whether plaintiff contributed to loss suffered – no question of principle
Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2002
Retail Leases Act 1994
Taxation Administration Act 1953
Cases Cited: Not Applicable
Texts Cited: Not Applicable
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Mohamed Abu-Mahmoud (P)
Consolidated Lawyers Pty Ltd (D1)
Abdul Salem Kassem t/as S K Lawyers (D2)
Christopher Shaw (D3)
Ann Bowen (D4)
John Gerathy (D5)
Representation:

Counsel:
B McClintock SC / P Doyle-Gray (P)
G Curtin SC / D Lloyd (D1-5)

Solicitors:
Atkinson Vinden (P)
Meridian Lawyers (D1-5)
File Number(s):2010/417411
Publication restriction:Not Applicable

______________________________________________________________

Judgment

  1. It is the case for the plaintiff, Mr Abu-Mahmoud, that he was a reasonably successful structural engineer, builder and property developer, who had a record of successful development projects and, at the relevant time, had a number of development projects underway.

  2. He claims that Mr Abdul Salem Kassem (“Mr Kassem”), a lawyer whom he instructed, was negligent. He claims that Mr Kassem advised him to take a series of steps with respect to a property which he owned and intended to develop. This restructure scheme would have had the effect of enabling him to avoid a tax impost which he regarded as unfair. Mr Abu-Mahmoud claims that in reliance upon Mr Kassem’s advice, he entered into this restructure scheme with the consequence that his property empire crumbled, and he became liable in a significant sum to the St George Bank on a personal guarantee, and lost the equity which he owned in a series of properties.

  3. Mr Kassem denies giving any advice of the kind…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abu-Mahmoud v Consolidated Lawyers Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 547
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Abu-Mahmoud, brought an action against the defendant, Consolidated Lawyers Pty Ltd, alleging professional negligence in relation to a failed restructure scheme concerning a property owned by the plaintiff. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The plaintiff retained the defendant, a firm of solicitors, to advise on the restructure scheme. The plaintiff contended that the defendant negligently failed to advise on the restructure scheme, which resulted in significant financial loss. The defendant, on the other hand, argued that the retainer did not extend to include advice on the restructure scheme and that any advice given was not negligent. The court was required to determine whether the retainer encompassed the restructure scheme, whether the defendant provided advice on the scheme, whether the advice was negligent, whether the negligence caused the loss, and whether the plaintiff contributed to the loss suffered.

The court examined the terms of the retainer and found that it did not include advice on the restructure scheme. The court further found that the defendant did not provide any advice on the scheme and that any advice given was not negligent. The court held that the plaintiff's loss was not caused by any negligence on the part of the defendant, but rather by the plaintiff's own actions in proceeding with the restructure scheme without seeking independent legal advice. The court held that the plaintiff contributed to the loss suffered by failing to seek independent legal advice before proceeding with the restructure scheme.

The court dismissed the plaintiff's claim and awarded costs to the defendant. The court found that there was no question of principle in the case and that the outcome was consistent with the law on professional negligence in Australia. The court held that the plaintiff's claim was without merit and that the defendant was entitled to costs on an indemnity basis. The court further held that the defendant was entitled to costs for the preparation and filing of the defence and for the hearing of the plaintiff's claim. The court made no order as to costs for the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff, Mr Abu-Mahmoud, engaged Consolidated Lawyers Pty Ltd, represented by the defendant, to provide legal services in relation to a property he owned. The property was subject to a restructure scheme, which ultimately failed. As a result of this failure, the plaintiff suffered financial loss. The plaintiff had previously retained the defendant to provide general legal advice concerning the property, and the question arose as to whether this retainer was extended to include advice regarding the restructure. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant provided negligent advice concerning the restructure, which directly contributed to the loss he suffered. Additionally, the plaintiff's conduct in relation to the restructure was examined to determine if he contributed to the loss.

The case came before the court as a result of an action initiated by the plaintiff against the defendant for professional negligence. The matter proceeded through various stages, including the filing of originating process and the exchange of pleadings. The court heard arguments from both parties regarding the scope of the defendant's retainer, the quality of advice provided, and the causation of the plaintiff's loss. The case did not proceed to trial as the central issues were resolved through interlocutory motions and submissions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the existing retainer between the plaintiff and the defendant extended to include advice on the restructure of the property.
2. Whether the defendant provided advice to the plaintiff concerning the restructure.
3. If advice was provided, whether that advice was negligent.
4. If negligent advice was provided, whether such negligence caused the plaintiff's loss.
5. Whether the plaintiff contributed to the loss suffered as a result of the failed restructure.

Held
1. The court concluded that the existing retainer between the plaintiff and the defendant did not extend to include advice on the restructure of the property.
2. The court found that the defendant did not provide advice to the plaintiff concerning the restructure.
3. Since no advice was provided, the issue of whether that advice was negligent did not arise.
4. Consequently, the issue of whether any negligent advice caused the plaintiff's loss did not arise.
5. The court determined that the plaintiff did not contribute to the loss suffered as a result of the failed restructure.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the scope of the retainer between the plaintiff and the defendant. It found that the retainer was limited to specific legal matters and did not encompass advice on the restructuring of the property. The court relied on the terms of the retainer agreement and the circumstances under which it was entered into to conclude that the retainer did not extend to the restructure issue. As a result, the court determined that the defendant had no obligation to provide advice on the restructuring.

Next, the court considered whether the defendant had provided any advice to the plaintiff concerning the restructure. The evidence showed that no such advice was given, as the defendant had not engaged in any discussion or correspondence with the plaintiff regarding the restructure. The court found that the defendant's lack of engagement in this matter further supported the conclusion that the retainer did not extend to the restructure issue.

Given that no advice was provided, the court did not need to address the issues of whether any advice, if given, was negligent or whether such negligence caused the plaintiff's loss. However, the court briefly noted that even if advice had been provided, the plaintiff would not have been able to establish negligence or causation due to the lack of clarity and certainty in the advice that would have been necessary to hold the defendant liable.

Finally, the court examined whether the plaintiff contributed to the loss suffered as a result of the failed restructure. The court found that the plaintiff did not contribute to the loss, as the plaintiff had acted reasonably and in good faith throughout the process, relying on the defendant's expertise in legal matters unrelated to the restructure. The court held that the plaintiff's loss was a direct result of the defendant's failure to provide advice on the restructure, which was outside the scope of the retainer.