ABN Amro Morgans Ltd v Davies

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

[2009] QSC 18

FRYBERG J

No 9951 of 2008

ABN AMRO MORGANS LIMITED Plaintiff

and

JUDITH MARGARET DAVIES Defendant

BRISBANE

..DATE 12/02/2009

ORDER

HIS HONOUR:  The plaintiff seeks summary judgment from the defendant in respect of money owing to the plaintiff for the purchase on the instructions of the defendant of a number of share warrants on the stock market.

The defendant denies liability alleging that any agreement between her and the plaintiff was void or voidable. 

It is desirable to recount something of the history of the defendant in order to appreciate the defence which she postulates.  The background involves the town of Mackay which is where the defendant lived and worked and, in particular, where she worked in a dress shop owned by a partnership of herself and her mother.  She worked in businesses with her mother from 1984. 

In 2002 she commenced investing on the stock exchange.  Her brother was a stockbroker employed by Ord Minnett and it was on his advice that she decided to embark on that course.  She was, it seems, successful between when she started in 2002 with an initial investment of about $31,000 and 2008 her net worth on the stock exchange grew from $31,000 to about $1.25 million, measured as at December 2007.

During 2008 the value of her holdings declined radically because of an investment in a firm called Opes Prime which went into receivership.  She deposes that she was left with about $25,000 worth of shares.

In June 2008 her brother or his assistant contacted an officer of the plaintiff with a request that an account for the defendant be opened with the plaintiff.  As a result that officer sent, addressed to the defendant, through the email account which had been given to the plaintiff, a Financial Services Guide, a Standard Terms and Conditions booklet and a risk profile attached to the account opening application form.  That material was sent by email.

Ms Davies signed the application form and it was returned to the plaintiff on the 4th of June.  She also signed a Sophisticated Investor Application which required a Sophisticated Investor Accountant's Certificate.  Such a certificate was attached to the application signed by her accountant.  It confirmed that she had aggregate net assets of over $2.5 million.  She does not depose to her precise net assets but it seems that this figure was not correct.

On the 12th of August the plaintiff emailed an Australian Stock Exchange Warrant Client Agreement form to the defendant at the nominated email address.  On the following day (the plaintiff's affidavit says 13 June but it is evidently a mistake for 13 August), the plaintiff received the warrant agreement form signed by the defendant.

Subsequently various officers of the plaintiff were instructed, apparently through the defendant's brother or the secretary, to purchase share warrants covered by that warrant agreement form.  They did so.  It is unnecessary to list the warrants purchased.  They were purchased in September and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ABN Amro Morgans Ltd v Davies and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QSC 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

ABN Amro Morgans Limited (Plaintiff) v Judith Margaret Davies (Defendant) was a case before the Supreme Court of Queensland, where the plaintiff sought summary judgment for the amount owed by the defendant for the purchase of share warrants on the stock market. The defendant denied liability, claiming that any agreement with the plaintiff was void or voidable. The defendant had worked in a dress shop in Mackay since 1984 and started investing in the stock exchange in 2002, achieving significant returns until her investments in Opes Prime went into receivership. In June 2008, the plaintiff opened an account for the defendant, and various share warrants were purchased following her confirmation. The defendant claimed she did not understand the documents she signed and that her brother was responsible for the transactions.
The legal issues the court had to decide were whether the contract was void for uncertainty or non est factum, and if voidability could be established on the basis of unconscionability. The court found that there was no uncertainty in the relevant documents, and the defence of non est factum was not applicable. Additionally, there was no evidence of unconscionability on the part of the plaintiff. The court concluded that the plaintiff had clearly established that the defendant had no real prospect of successfully defending the claim, and granted summary judgment in favour of the plaintiff.

The court ordered the defendant to pay the sum of $1,855,814.20, interest under the Supreme Court Act of 1995 of $71,690.36, and costs to be assessed. The court also varied the restraining order, deleting the words "until the trial of this proceeding or such earlier order" and inserting "until 5 p.m. on 13 February 2009." The application was adjourned to the 13th of February 2009.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established