ABL Nominees P/L v Warmings Commercial Services P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

ABL NOMINEES P/L v WARMINGS COMMERCIAL SERVICES P/L & ORS

[2015] SASC 203

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Bampton

23 December 2015

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT - SUMMARY JUDGMENT

GUARANTEE AND INDEMNITY - ACTIONS AGAINST SURETY - GENERALLY

The plaintiff makes application for summary judgment against the fourth defendant in respect of a loan deed entered into by the first and second defendant in 2007 (the second loan) – fourth defendant signed the loan deed as both a Director of the first defendant and as guarantor – second defendant assigned the second loan to the plaintiff – first defendant has affirmed the loan – first defendant in breach of its obligations to make repayments – plaintiff demanded payment from the fourth defendant – no repayments made since November 2008

Where no defence has been filed – where no affidavit sworn in answer to the application for summary judgment – whether any basis for defending the plaintiff’s claim.

Held:

1. There is no reasonable basis for defending the plaintiff’s claim.

2. Summary judgment for the plaintiff against the fourth defendant in respect of the second loan.

Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 232, r 233, referred to.
Ceneavenue Pty Ltd v Martin [2008] SASC 158; Ke Qin Ren v Hong Jiang (2014) ACSR 149; Law of Guarantees Geraldine Andrews QC and Richard Millett QC (Thomson Reuters, 6th ed, 2011), considered.

ABL NOMINEES P/L v WARMINGS COMMERCIAL SERVICES P/L & ORS
[2015] SASC 203

Civil: Application

  1. BAMPTON J:   ABL Nominees Pty Ltd (ABL) by interlocutory application, FDN 61, seeks summary judgment against the fourth defendant, Mrs Warming, in respect of a loan (the second loan) pleaded at [25]–[49] of the Statement of Claim, filed 4 April 2011.  The order for summary judgment is sought pursuant to r 232 of the Supreme Court (Civil) Rules 2006 (SA) in the following terms:

    1.On the basis of the facts set out in the second affidavit of Stephen James Flamer-Smith, sworn 15 July 2015 (Mr Flamer-Smith’s affidavit);

    2.That judgment be awarded in the sum of $1,376,865.87 in addition to costs on an indemnity basis to be agreed or taxed.

  2. The application for summary judgment is for part of one of the plaintiff’s claims against one of the defendants.  Rule 233 permits the Court in its discretion to give summary judgment on a particular issue without disposing of the claim as a whole.

  3. The solicitor who appeared for Mrs Warming on the hearing of FDN 61 stated he had received no instructions to file any responding affidavits to the application.  He said he appeared “more as a friend of the court” and that he was not instructed to consent to the application or make submissions other than to ask that the application be considered on its merits by reference to the documents before the Court.

  4. In addition to Mr Flamer-Smith’s affidavit, ABL relied on the affidavits of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ABL Nominees P/L v Warmings Commercial Services P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 203
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

ABL Nominees P/L applied for summary judgment against Warmings Commercial Services P/L in respect of a loan deed executed in 2007. The fourth defendant signed the loan deed as a director of the first defendant and as guarantor. The second defendant assigned the loan to ABL, but the first defendant has failed to make repayments since November 2008. ABL demanded payment from the fourth defendant, but no payments were made. The fourth defendant did not file a defence nor an affidavit in response to ABL's application for summary judgment. The court was required to determine if there was any basis for defending ABL's claim.

The court examined the circumstances surrounding the loan deed and the guarantees provided by the fourth defendant. The court noted that the fourth defendant signed the loan deed as a director and as a guarantor, thereby assuming personal liability for the loan. The court further noted that the first defendant had failed to make repayments on the loan, and that ABL had demanded payment from the fourth defendant. The court concluded that the fourth defendant had no valid defence to ABL's claim for payment. The court found that the fourth defendant had signed the loan deed as a guarantor and had thereby undertaken personal liability for the loan. The court further found that the first defendant had failed to make repayments on the loan, and that ABL had properly demanded payment from the fourth defendant.

The court granted summary judgment in favour of ABL and against the fourth defendant. The court ordered the fourth defendant to pay ABL the outstanding amount of the loan, plus interest and costs. The court found that there was no triable issue between the parties and that ABL was entitled to judgment as a matter of law. The court further found that the fourth defendant had no valid defence to ABL's claim and that there was no basis for delaying or deferring ABL's right to judgment. The court ordered the fourth defendant to pay ABL the amount of the loan, plus interest and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In addition to Mr Flamer-Smith’s affidavit, ABL relied on the affidavits of Belinda Heather Thompson, sworn 6 December 2012 (Ms Thompson’s affidavit), and Gerald Chung Yii Kok, sworn 10 December 2012 (Mr Kok’s affidavit), in support of FDN 61.Background In March 2004 the first defendant, Warmings Commercial Services Pty Ltd as Trustee for Warmings Consulting Services Trust (Warmings) applied for term finance for its investment in the Great Southern Plantations 2003 Project. On 11 April 2004 Warmings and the second defendant, Great Southern Finance Pty Ltd in liquidation (GSF) executed a loan deed (the first loan deed). The third defendant, Mr Warming, and Mrs Warming executed the first loan deed as guarantors. On 1 July 2004 GSF loaned Warmings the sum of $804,454.00 (the first loan) pursuant to the first loan deed. On 1 January 2008 GSF assigned all of its rights under the first loan deed to ABL. The second loan On 16 March 2007 Warmings by its Director, Mrs Warming, signed an Application for Term Finance (the second loan application) with GSF to borrow money to acquire an interest in the Great Southern 2007 Wine Grape Income Project Managed Investment Scheme. In his affidavit Mr Flamer-Smith deposes that he is a Manager, Legal and Resolutions employed by Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Ltd (BABL) and that ABL is a wholly owned subsidiary of BABL. Mr Flamer-Smith’s affidavit is set out under the following headings:·Section 1: Entry into loan contract and guarantee; ·Section 2 : Breach of loan contract and guarantee;·Section 3: Assignment of loan contract;·Section 4: Group proceedings; and·Section 5: Sources of information. Exhibit SFS11 is a copy of the documents referred to in Mr Flamer-Smith’s affidavit separated by dividers. Mr Flamer-Smith explains that the documents are in chronological order and in section five he deposes to knowing the facts deposed to in his affidavit from his own knowledge, except as set out at [39]‑[56], which he knows from the sources of information provided to him in his position with BABL. A copy of the second loan application is exhibited to Mr Flamer-Smith’s affidavit.[1] Mrs Warming signed the second loan application as guarantor and agreed to guarantee the payment of the second loan and the performance by Warmings of all its obligations under the second loan deed.[2][1] See divider 1, Exhibit SFS11 to Mr Flamer-Smith’s affidavit.[2] By reference to page 22, divider 1, Exhibit SFS11 to Mr Flamer-Smith’s affidavit.Essential features of the second loan application The second loan application seeks finance in the amount of $760,477 to finance 193 Vinelots. Warmings selected GSF as lender and a loan term of seven years.[3][3] Page 16, divider 1, Exhibit SFS11 to Mr Flamer-Smith’s affidavit. In section two ‘Personal Details’ the applicant is asked to delete as applicable either of BORROWER/GUARANTOR. Whilst neither option was deleted, I am satisfied Mrs Warming signed the application on behalf of the borrower and as guarantor. The company named as the borrower in section three is Warmings Commercial Services Pty Ltd.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established