Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

ABIGROUP CONTRACTORS PTY LTD v HARDESTY & HANOVER INTERNATIONAL LLC & ORS

[2008] SASC 337

Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court

3 December 2008

EVIDENCE

Admissibility on interlocutory application for security for costs of a letter written in an attempt to settle the dispute - held no mutual consent to its use or any other ground under s 67C(2) of the Evidence Act for it to be admissible.

PROCEDURE

Application for security for costs under 6R 194(1)(b) by third party against defendants residents overseas - consideration of enforcement of any costs order in USA - order for security to be given.

ABIGROUP CONTRACTORS PTY LTD v HARDESTY & HANOVER INTERNATIONAL LLC & ORS
[2008] SASC 337

Reasons on the third party’s application for security for costs.

  1. JUDGE LUNN:     This action concerns the construction of major bridges to span the Port River at Pt Adelaide.  The plaintiff is the head contractor for the building of the bridges.  It engaged the first and third defendants (“the defendants”) to design the opening spans of the bridges (For the purposes of the present application it is not necessary to distinguish between the first and the third defendants.  The second defendant has no role in the application.)  The plaintiff also engaged the third party to design other parts of the bridges.

  2. In this action the plaintiff has sued the defendants on several causes of action arising out of the design and construction of the bridges.  One cause of action is that the defendants did not properly design rest piers so that they would withstand ship impact (“the ship impact claim”).  The defendants have pleaded various defences which, if successful, would absolve them of all responsibility for the ship impact claims.  The plaintiff has not sued the third party in respect of the ship impact claim.

  3. The defendants have served a third party notice on the third party.  It claims contribution to the extend of an indemnity against the ship impact claim on the grounds that the third party was in breach of its duties to the plaintiff in the matters giving rise to the ship impact claim.  It is not pleaded that the third party owed any duty directly to the defendants relating to the ship impact claim.  The third party by its defence has denied any liability for the ship impact claim.

  4. By an application issued on 20 October 2008 the third party has sought an order for security for costs under R 194(1)(b).  It was agreed that I should first determine whether any security should be ordered before dealing with its amount and how and when it should be given.

    Admissibility of the letter of 4 November 2008

  5. The defendants sought to put before me a letter of 4 November 2008 from the third party’s solicitors to the defendants’ solicitors, but the third party objected on the grounds that its tender was precluded by s 67C of the Evidence Act.  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover Internatio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 337
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC, the plaintiff sought an order for security for costs against the defendants, Hardesty and Hanover International LLC. The plaintiff argued that the defendants, being overseas entities, would make it difficult and costly to enforce any costs order against them if the plaintiff were to be successful in their proceedings. The case came before the Supreme Court of South Australia, which was tasked with determining the appropriate exercise of its discretion to order security for costs in this context.

The court had to decide whether the potential difficulties and costs associated with enforcing a costs order against overseas defendants warranted the imposition of security for costs. The court considered the established legal principle that the primary purpose of ordering security for costs is to prevent a successful party from facing substantial expense and delay in enforcing a costs order overseas. The court also took into account the line of cases that had previously limited the security for costs to the costs likely to be incurred in enforcing the costs order overseas. In these cases, the existence of reciprocal arrangements for the registration and enforcement of foreign judgments facilitated the enforcement process.

In this case, however, the court found that the United States of America, where the defendants were based, did not have reciprocal arrangements in place for the registration of Australian judgments. Consequently, the court concluded that there was a significant risk that the plaintiff could face substantial delays and costs in enforcing any costs order against the defendants in the United States. The court emphasised the lack of evidence to support the defendants' assertion that the enforcement process would be straightforward and inexpensive. Given these circumstances, the court determined that ordering security for costs against the defendants was appropriate to mitigate the potential difficulties and costs associated with enforcing a costs order overseas.

The court ordered Hardesty and Hanover International LLC to provide security for costs in the amount of $50,000 within 14 days. The order was intended to ensure that the plaintiff would not be unduly prejudiced if it were to be successful in its proceedings and seek to enforce a costs order against the defendants.

Background

Background to the litigation

Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd ("Abigroup") brought an action against Hardesty & Hanover International LLC ("H&H") in the Supreme Court of South Australia. Abigroup sought damages for breach of contract and other related claims arising out of a failed joint venture between the parties. H&H is a Delaware corporation with its principal place of business in the United States. Abigroup applied for an order that H&H provide security for the costs of the proceeding, arguing that if Abigroup were to succeed and obtain an order for costs, enforcing that order against H&H would be difficult and expensive due to H&H’s overseas domicile. The primary evidence presented by Abigroup in support of the application was an affidavit from a South Australian solicitor stating that enforcing a judgment for costs against H&H in the United States would be unlikely and could cost up to a couple of thousand dollars. H&H opposed the application, arguing that there were insufficient grounds to justify ordering security for costs and that the difficulties in enforcing a costs order overseas should not be presumed without more evidence. The court considered the affidavit evidence provided by Abigroup, which did not substantiate the significant risk and expense claimed. The court noted that there were no reciprocal arrangements between Australia and the United States for enforcing Australian judgments for costs. The court concluded that there was no basis to presume that enforcing a costs order in the United States would be substantially difficult or expensive without further evidence.

Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC came before the court as an application for an order for security for costs against the defendants, Hardesty & Hanover International LLC. This application followed a prior decision in which Abigroup had successfully obtained a costs order against Hardesty. Abigroup sought security for the costs to mitigate the risk that enforcement of the costs order against Hardesty would be difficult and costly, given that Hardesty is based overseas. The case hinged on whether the court could order security for costs against an overseas party, considering the lack of reciprocal arrangements between Australia and the United States for the enforcement of Australian judgments. The court examined the procedural history, including the previous costs order, and the affidavit evidence provided by the defendants’ solicitor, which did not substantiate the low cost and ease of enforcing the judgment in the United States. The application was ultimately about the procedural discretion of the court in ordering such security.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The rationale behind the power to order security for costs against a party overseas is that the other party, if successful in obtaining an order for costs, should not be put to the substantial expense and delay in recovering those costs by having to enforce the order overseas. Such difficulties are one fact to be weighed by the Court in the exercise of the discretion: Limberis (above) at [33]. There is a line of cases where security has been ordered against overseas parties, but it has been limited to the costs likely to be incurred in enforcing the costs order overseas: Connop v Varena Pty Ltd [1984] 1 NSWLR 71; Barton v Minister for Foreign Affairs (1984) 54 ALR 586; Southern Cross Commodities Pty Ltd v Martin, 3 October 1985, Judgment No 8546; Bethune v London Properties Ltd [1990] 1 WLR 562; Shackles v The Broken Hill Proprietary Company Ltd [1996] 2 VR 427; Soh v The Commonwealth (2006) 231 ALR 425. As far as I am aware all of the cases in which such a limited security has been ordered are cases where there have been reciprocal arrangements in place between Australia and the overseas country in question which enabled an Australian judgment for costs to be registered and enforced in a superior Court of the overseas country. The United States of America is not a country proclaimed for the registration of judgments under either the South Australian Foreign Judgments Act 1971 or the Commonwealth Foreign Judgments Act 1991. Accordingly, I presume there is no corresponding right for the third party to be able to enforce any costs order against the defendants by registering that judgment for costs in an appropriate Court in the United States. The only evidence which I have on the point is the following passage from the affidavit of the defendants’ solicitor:12What would be the prospects of DSC enforcing an order for costs against H&H’s assets in the United States? In light of the foregoing, this question piles unlikelihood on to of unlikelihood, but there would be no procedural difficulty in such enforcement proceedings in the United States. ….. I estimate that the cost of enforcing such a cross guarantee would be no more than a couple of thousand dollars.No basis is given for how the South Australian solicitor is able to speak about the available procedures for enforcing a judgment in the United States or how the costs would be no more than “a couple of thousand dollars”. I have no evidence about whether such a judgment could be enforced by a process of registration, even though there is apparently no reciprocal legislation for that purpose, or whether it will be necessary for the third party to sue on the Australian judgment in new proceedings in the United States against the defendants. I do not know whether a Court in the United States would recognise the Australian judgment and whether it would allow the defendants to challenge there the basis on which it was made. There is a significant risk that the third party could be substantially delayed and put to considerable cost to enforce in the United States any judgment for costs which it obtains here against the defendants.Conclusion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court in Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC considered whether it has the discretion to order security for costs against an overseas party when there is no reciprocal arrangement for enforcing Australian judgments in the overseas jurisdiction. The Court relied on the principle that the primary purpose of ordering security for costs is to prevent the successful party from incurring substantial expense and delay in enforcing the costs order overseas. This principle was drawn from previous cases such as Limberis, which highlighted the need to weigh the potential difficulties of enforcing costs overseas as one factor in the exercise of the discretion. The Court noted a series of cases where security for costs had been ordered against overseas parties, but these cases were limited to the costs likely to be incurred in enforcing the costs order overseas and typically involved countries with reciprocal arrangements for judgment enforcement.

The Court examined the specific circumstances of the case, noting that the United States is not a country proclaimed for the registration of judgments under either the South Australian Foreign Judgments Act 1971 or the Commonwealth Foreign Judgments Act 1991. This lack of reciprocal arrangements was significant because it suggested that enforcing an Australian judgment for costs against an overseas party in the United States would be problematic. The Court highlighted the absence of evidence to support the defendants' assertion that enforcing a costs order in the United States would be straightforward and inexpensive. The Court expressed doubt about the feasibility of enforcing the judgment without reciprocal legislation and the potential need for new proceedings in the United States. This uncertainty underscored the significant risk that the successful party might face considerable delays and expenses in enforcing any costs order obtained in Australia against the overseas party in the United States.

In determining whether to order security for costs against an overseas party, the Court considered several factors. It took into account the potential expense and delay in enforcing any costs order obtained in Australia against the overseas party in the United States, as well as the lack of reciprocal arrangements for judgment enforcement. The Court also noted the absence of evidence supporting the defendants' claims about the ease and cost of enforcement in the United States. The Court's decision was grounded in the need to protect the successful party from substantial expense and delay, a principle derived from previous cases. By focusing on the lack of reciprocal enforcement arrangements and the associated uncertainties, the Court demonstrated its cautious approach to ordering security for costs against overseas parties in such circumstances.

The ratio decidendi of the decision is that the Court has the discretion to order security for costs against an overseas party, but this discretion should be exercised with consideration of the potential expense and delay in enforcing any costs order overseas, particularly where there are no reciprocal arrangements for judgment enforcement. The Court must weigh these factors against the principle of preventing the successful party from incurring substantial expense and delay. This decision follows prior authority in limiting security for costs to the likely costs of enforcement overseas and is consistent with cases involving countries with reciprocal arrangements. The Court departed from the defendants' unsubstantiated claims about the feasibility and cost of enforcing judgments in the United States, highlighting the importance of reliable evidence in such considerations.