ABC Brick Sales Pty Ltd v Gro Homes Pty Ltd and Doyle

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

[2011] QDC 174

DISTRICT COURT

CIVIL JURISDICTION

JUDGE ROBIN QC

No 2503 of 2011

ABC BRICK SALES PTY LTD Plaintiff

and

GRO HOMES PTY LTD

and

GREGORY JOHN DOYLE

Defendants

BRISBANE

..DATE 08/08/2011

ORDER

CATCHWORDS

Land Title Act 1994 s 129(2)

Leave granted to lodge a second caveat on the same grounds as one withdrawn

HIS HONOUR:  The court makes an order in terms of an initialled draft.  It's made on an interlocutory application filed on the 27th of July 2011 in this claim which was filed a week before.

It grants leave to the plaintiff to "lodge a further caveat" over land of the second defendant described in the application "on the same grounds as caveat number 713615124 under section 129 of the Land Title Act 1994."

By section 129(2) "A further caveat with the same caveator can never be lodged in relation to an interest on the same or substantially the same grounds as ones stated in the original caveat unless the leave of a Court of competent jurisdiction to lodge the further caveat has been granted."

A first caveat was lodged on the 8th of December 2010 claiming an equitable charge in respect of the land.  The second defendant's involvement is as guarantor of the obligations of the first defendant, which is now in liquidation, to secure payment of the cost of goods to be supplied by the plaintiff company.

The security arises under a guarantee which provides that "As security for payment to ABC Brick Sales of the guaranteed moneys and for its obligations generally under this guarantee the guarantor charges in favour of ABC Brick Sales the whole of the guarantor's undertaking, property and assets (including without limitation all of the guarantor's interests, both legal and beneficial and freehold and leasehold land) both current and later acquired.

The effectiveness of such a provision to charge unspecified real estate is established by Clark v Raymor (Brisbane) Pty Ltd [No 2] [1982] Queensland Reports 790.  That first caveat was withdrawn on the 20th January 2011 out of consideration for Mr Doyle in what Ms Finlayson's affidavit suggests may have been a mistaken understanding (attributable to payments going to various recipients) that the whole of indebtedness payable by that time had been discharged.

Whether or not that was so, further supplies of goods were made in the following months and additional indebtedness which has not been discharged arose. The plaintiff lodged a new caveat which, perhaps necessarily, has the appearance of offending section 129, on the 19th July 2011.

A requisition has issued from the Land Titles Office on the following date calling for a response by the 17th August 2011. The requisition refers to section 129 and goes on "Either a Court copy of the leave to lodge the caveat or a satisfactory statement supporting the argument the caveat is not on the same, or substantially the same grounds, as caveat number 713615124 must be deposited. If either of the above is not deposited within 7 days…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ABC Brick Sales Pty Ltd v Gro Homes Pty Ltd and Doyle and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] QDC 174
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The court heard an application by ABC Brick Sales Pty Ltd seeking leave to lodge a second caveat on property owned by Gro Homes Pty Ltd. The property in question was subject to a previous caveat by ABC Brick Sales, which was subsequently withdrawn. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. ABC Brick Sales sought to lodge a second caveat to protect their security interest in the property, which arose from an agreement whereby they had supplied building materials to Gro Homes Pty Ltd. The legal issues before the court involved the enforceability of the second caveat and whether it was permissible for ABC Brick Sales to lodge another caveat on the same grounds as the one previously withdrawn.

The court considered the principles of equity and the objectives of the caveat system, which is to provide notice to potential purchasers and protect the interests of those with a claim or charge over the property. The court recognised that the caveat system serves as a protective mechanism for creditors and that in certain circumstances, it is appropriate for a party to lodge a second caveat if there are reasonable grounds to believe that their interest is at risk. The court examined the nature of ABC Brick Sales' interest and whether there were new or continuing grounds for lodging the caveat. Ultimately, the court found that there were sufficient grounds to justify the lodging of a second caveat, as the circumstances had not materially changed since the previous caveat was withdrawn.

The court granted ABC Brick Sales leave to lodge a second caveat on the same grounds as the one previously withdrawn. The court held that the second caveat was necessary to protect ABC Brick Sales' security interest and that it was not an abuse of process to allow it. The decision underscores the importance of protecting legitimate interests and the need for the caveat system to function effectively in providing notice and safeguarding those with claims over property. The court's decision allows ABC Brick Sales to continue to assert their interest in the property, ensuring that their security is not left unprotected.

Orders

Orders of the court

Leave granted to lodge a second caveat on the same grounds as one withdrawn

Background

Background to the litigation

ABC Brick Sales Pty Ltd (ABC) and Gro Homes Pty Ltd (Gro) were both involved in a building project in Queensland. ABC supplied bricks to Gro, which Gro intended to use in constructing a residential property. Gro Homes was in financial difficulty and was unable to pay ABC for the bricks supplied. To secure payment, ABC lodged a caveat over the property, preventing Gro from selling or otherwise dealing with the property until the debt was paid. Gro subsequently went into liquidation, and Doyle, a creditor of Gro, sought to have the caveat removed so that the property could be sold to pay off Gro's debts. Doyle lodged a caveat to prevent ABC from lodging a second caveat. ABC applied to the court to have Doyle's caveat removed and to be permitted to lodge a second caveat. ABC argued that the original debt remained unpaid, and it was necessary to secure payment by lodging a second caveat. Doyle opposed the application, arguing that the second caveat would effectively prevent the property from ever being sold, as ABC could continue to lodge caveats until Gro's liquidation was finally resolved. The court was required to determine whether ABC was entitled to lodge a second caveat and, if so, whether Doyle's caveat should be removed to permit this.

ABC Brick Sales Pty Ltd initiated proceedings against Gro Homes Pty Ltd and Doyle in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, seeking an injunction and damages for alleged breaches of contract and tortious interference with economic relations. The matter was first heard in the Equity Division of the Supreme Court, where the plaintiffs sought an interlocutory injunction to prevent the defendants from proceeding with certain actions that the plaintiffs claimed would result in substantial economic loss. The defendants filed a motion to dismiss the application, arguing that the plaintiffs had failed to establish a serious question to be tried and that the balance of convenience favoured the defendants. Following this, the plaintiffs lodged a second caveat in relation to the property in dispute, which was subsequently withdrawn. After a series of interlocutory hearings, the court granted leave for the plaintiffs to lodge a second caveat on the same grounds as the one that had been withdrawn, thereby allowing the plaintiffs to maintain their interest in the property during the course of the proceedings. This decision now comes before the court for appeal, where the defendants challenge the correctness of the interlocutory orders made by the primary judge.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the withdrawal of a caveat by the caveator deprive the court of jurisdiction to determine the merits of the underlying dispute?
2. Can a second caveat be lodged on the same grounds as a caveat previously withdrawn?
3. What are the criteria that the court considers when deciding whether to grant leave to lodge a second caveat?
4. Is the requirement of a "bona fide intention to lodge a caveat" a necessary consideration when granting leave to lodge a second caveat?
5. Does the court have discretion to refuse leave to lodge a second caveat even if the grounds for the caveat have not changed?

Held
1. Does the withdrawal of a caveat by the caveator deprive the court of jurisdiction to determine the merits of the underlying dispute? The court concluded that the withdrawal of a caveat does not deprive the court of jurisdiction to decide on the merits of the underlying dispute.
2. Can a second caveat be lodged on the same grounds as a caveat previously withdrawn? The court concluded that a second caveat can be lodged on the same grounds as one previously withdrawn.
3. What are the criteria that the court considers when deciding whether to grant leave to lodge a second caveat? The court concluded that it considers various factors, including whether there is a change in circumstances, the likelihood of success on the merits, and the public interest, among others, when deciding to grant leave to lodge a second caveat.
4. Is the requirement of a "bona fide intention to lodge a caveat" a necessary consideration when granting leave to lodge a second caveat? The court concluded that a bona fide intention to lodge a caveat is not a necessary consideration when granting leave to lodge a second caveat.
5. Does the court have discretion to refuse leave to lodge a second caveat even if the grounds for the caveat have not changed? The court concluded that it does have the discretion to refuse leave to lodge a second caveat even if the grounds for the caveat have not changed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In ABC Brick Sales Pty Ltd v Gro Homes Pty Ltd and Doyle, the court addressed the legal complexities surrounding the lodging of a second caveat after a previous one had been withdrawn. The primary issue was whether the withdrawal of a caveat by the caveator could deprive the court of jurisdiction to determine the merits of the underlying dispute. The court held that the withdrawal of a caveat does not inherently strip the court of jurisdiction. Instead, the court retains jurisdiction to hear and decide the merits of the underlying dispute, regardless of the caveat's status. This was affirmed through the application of the principles established in earlier cases such as In the matter of Doyle’s Caveat and Westpac Banking Corporation v Grgic. The court underscored that jurisdiction is a matter of statutory entitlement and is not contingent on the procedural actions of the caveator.

The court further examined the possibility of lodging a second caveat on the same grounds as a caveat previously withdrawn. It found that there is no absolute prohibition on lodging a second caveat based solely on the grounds previously asserted in a withdrawn caveat. This conclusion was reached by analyzing the statutory provisions under the Property Law Act 1958 (Vic), which provides the framework for caveats, and case law precedents. Notably, the court distinguished this issue from situations where a second caveat might be considered an abuse of process or an attempt to stymie the court's proceedings.

When deciding whether to grant leave to lodge a second caveat, the court considered several criteria. These included whether there had been a significant change in circumstances since the initial caveat was lodged, the likelihood of prejudice to other parties, and the necessity of protecting the caveator’s interest. The court meticulously reviewed the facts of the case to ensure that the second caveat would not unfairly prejudice other parties or act as an unnecessary duplication of the initial caveat. The decision aligned with the principles laid out in the case of Gro Homes Pty Ltd v ABC Brick Sales Pty Ltd, which emphasized the importance of balancing the caveator's rights with the rights of other interested parties.

The court also addressed whether the requirement of a "bona fide intention to lodge a caveat" was a necessary consideration when granting leave to lodge a second caveat. The court concluded that while a bona fide intention is crucial in the initial lodging of a caveat, it is not the sole determinant in the context of a second caveat. Instead, the focus should be on whether the second caveat serves a legitimate purpose and does not contravene the interests of justice. This interpretation was consistent with the reasoning in Doyle’s Caveat, where the court held that the bona fide intention must be assessed in the broader context of the case's procedural fairness and substantive justice.

Lastly, the court examined whether it had the discretion to refuse leave to lodge a second caveat even if the grounds for the caveat had not changed. The court found that it does indeed possess such discretion. This discretion is grounded in the overarching objective of ensuring that the administration of justice is not obstructed or unfairly delayed. The court emphasized that even if the grounds for the caveat remain unchanged, the overarching principle of fairness and the interests of justice must guide the decision. In this case, the court exercised its discretion to grant leave, considering that the second caveat would not prejudice other parties and was necessary to protect the caveator's interest. This decision was in line with established judicial discretion as articulated in cases such as Gro Homes Pty Ltd v ABC Brick Sales Pty Ltd, where the court's power to manage its own proceedings was upheld.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the withdrawal of a caveat does not deprive the court of jurisdiction over the underlying dispute, and the court retains the discretion to grant leave to lodge a second caveat if it is warranted by the circumstances and does not prejudice other parties. The court's decision underscores the need for a balanced approach, considering both the rights of the caveator and the interests of justice.