ABB Power T & D Company Inc v Electrowatt Technology Innovation Corp

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

OFFICIAL NOTICE

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Application  :          No.  689059  in the name of ABB POWER T&D COMPANY INC

Title:          Method and Apparatus for Electronic Meter Testing.

Action: Opposition under Section 59 of the Patents Act by ELECTROWATT TECHNOLOGY INNOVATION CORP.

Decision:          Issued            .

Abstract


Final determination. 

In a decision issued on 19 December 2000 all the claims of application 689059 were found to lack an inventive step in the light of a particular meter referred to in a company brochure.

The applicant subsequently proposed amendments to the claims to attempt to overcome this deficiency.

The amended claims have been found to still lack an inventive step.

It was also found that the descriptive part of the specification was absent of any matter that could be claimed to define patentable subject matter over that of the cited meter. 

The application is refused.

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent application 689059 by ABB POWER T&D COMPANY INC, and opposition under section 59 by ELECTROWATT TECHNOLOGY INNOVATION CORP.

BACKGROUND

On 19 December 2000 a Patent Office decision was issued on the opposition to patent application 689059. The hearing officer found all the claims of the application lacked an inventive step in the light of a particular meter ("the Nilsen meter") referred to in a company brochure. The brochure is titled EMS 2100 Electricity Consumption Analyser. The hearing officer also found a minor non-compliance with Section 40 of the Patents Act in that claims 3 and 5 were identical.

In the light of this decision ABB Power T&D Company Inc ("ABB") subsequently proposed amendments to the claims to attempt to overcome this deficiency.  The amendments essentially introduce or emphasise the feature of a processing system, within an electronic energy meter, being responsive to a data command received over an optical communications port for selecting one of various power measurements as the basis for meter testing.

Electrowatt Technology Innovation Corp ("Electrowatt") provided comments during the examination stages on the proposed amendments.  Electrowatt accepted the amendments appeared allowable under section 102 (matter in substance disclosed and proposed claims within the scope of the claims as accepted) but stated the amendments did not overcome the deficiency raised in the hearing officer's decision.  The patent examiner examining the proposed amendments made similar observations in his report.  In light of the criteria under section 102 being met, leave was granted to ABB to amend the specification as desired and the amendments were subsequently allowed unopposed.

When the parties were advised the matter was ready for final determination Electrowatt filed submissions expanding on reasons to support its position that the amendments did not overcome the deficiency noted above.  In the light of these submissions ABB requested a hearing.

The hearing was to be held in Canberra on 5 February 2002.  On that date ABB withdrew its request to be heard and did not appear nor file any written submissions.  The previous day Electrowatt…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ABB Power T & D Company Inc v Electrowatt Technology Innovat... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] APO 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

ABB Power T & D Company Inc sought to patent a method and apparatus for electronic meter testing, but faced opposition from Electrowatt Technology Innovation Corp. The dispute centred on whether the patent claims met the inventive step requirement under the Patents Act 1990. On 19 December 2000, the hearing officer found that all claims lacked an inventive step in light of a particular meter, known as the Nilsen meter. Subsequently, ABB proposed amendments to the claims in an attempt to overcome this deficiency. However, Electrowatt argued that the amendments did not alter the fundamental issue of lack of inventive step.

The court examined the amended claims and found that they did not overcome the issue of lack of inventive step. The new claims still incorporated features that were found to be obvious in light of the Nilsen meter. The court noted that the amendments did not introduce any new matter from the descriptive part of the specification that could potentially define patentable subject matter. Ultimately, the court concluded that all of the new claims lacked an inventive step and refused the patent application.

The court also found that the descriptive part of the specification was absent of any matter that could be claimed as patentable subject matter over that of the Nilsen meter. The Nilsen meter disclosed several embodiments that were cited in the specification. Therefore, the court refused the patent application and did not award any costs to either party.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established