Abassi and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Abassi and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2025] ARTA 560 (14 May 2025)

Applicant/s:  Hussam Suleiman Saed Abassi

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Tribunal Number:                2024/0697

Tribunal: General Member J Ross

Place:Sydney

Date:14 May 2025

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.....................[SGD]...................................................

General Member J Ross

Catchwords

MIGRATION AGENTS – registration – cancellation of registration as a migration agent – breaches of prescribed Code of Conduct – whether the applicant is not a person of integrity or is otherwise not a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance – whether the Tribunal should exercise its discretion to cancel the Applicant’s registration – what is the appropriate sanction – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 289A–294, s 303, s 316, s 314(2)

Migration (Migration Agents Code of Conduct) Regulations 2021 (Cth) s 13, s 29

IMMI 18/003: Specified courses and exams for registration as a migration agent Instrument 2018

Cases

Australian Broadcasting Authority v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 362

Drake v Minister of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs(1979) 2 ALD 60

Kearney and Migration Agents Registration Authority [2024] AATA 1989

Re Peng v Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and AAT [1998] AATA 12

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286

Statement of Reasons

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant in this matter, Mr Hussam Suleiman Saed Abassi (Mr Abassi), applied to the Tribunal for review of a decision by the Respondent, the Migration Agents Registration Authority (the Authority), to cancel his registration under s 303(1)(a) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act) by removing his name from the register (reviewable decision).   

  2. This was because the Respondent found that Mr Abassi had breached ss 13 and 29 of the Migration (Migration Agents Code of Conduct) Regulations 2021 (Code of Conduct) and also found that Mr Abassi was not a person of integrity or was otherwise not a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance.

  3. I am satisfied that Mr Abassi is not a person of integrity or a fit and proper person to give migration assistance. I am also satisfied that Mr Abassi has breached the Code of Conduct.

  4. For the reasons set out below, I have decided that the decision of the Authority should be affirmed.

    THE ISSUE FOR DETERMINATION

  5. The issues for determination are:

    (a)is Mr Abassi a person of integrity or a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance 

    (b)did Mr Abassi breach s 13 and/or s 29 of the Code of Conduct, and

    (c)what is the appropriate disciplinary action to be taken under s 303 of the Act?

    THE FACTS AND LEGISLATION  

  6. The facts of this matter are somewhat convoluted and are not necessarily best understood by setting them out in chronological order. Due to the interplay between various events, a narrative is provided below to the making of:  

    (a)the decision to register Mr Abassi as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abassi and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 560
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Abassi and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the dispute revolves around the cancellation of Mr Abassi's registration as a migration agent. The primary legal issues before the court were whether Mr Abassi is a person of integrity or a fit and proper person to provide immigration assistance, if he breached sections 13 and/or 29 of the Code of Conduct, and what the appropriate disciplinary action should be under section 303 of the Act. The decision to cancel Mr Abassi's registration was based on findings that he had breached the Code of Conduct and was not a fit and proper person to provide immigration assistance.

The court examined the evidence and found that Mr Abassi had multiple breaches of the Code of Conduct, including instances of cheating on English proficiency tests and failing to notify the Authority of the cancellation of his test scores. These actions demonstrated a lack of integrity and unfitness to provide immigration assistance. The court also considered Mr Abassi's history of academic misconduct, which further supported the conclusion that he was not a person of integrity. Given these findings, the court affirmed the decision to cancel Mr Abassi's registration as a migration agent. The appropriate sanction was deemed to be the cancellation of his registration, as it was the correct and preferable decision on the material before the court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issues for determination are: (a)is Mr Abassi a person of integrity or a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance (b)did Mr Abassi breach s 13 and/or s 29 of the Code of Conduct, and (c)what is the appropriate disciplinary action to be taken under s 303 of the Act? THE FACTS AND LEGISLATION The facts of this matter are somewhat convoluted and are not necessarily best understood by setting them out in chronological order. Due to the interplay between various events, a narrative is provided below to the making of: (a)the decision to register Mr Abassi as a migration agent, and(b)the decision to cancel that registration. Paragraphs [8] – [23] below consist of facts that are not in dispute between the parties. Decision to register Mr Abassi as a migration agent Sections 289A–294 of the Act contain a range of requirements which if not met prevent an applicant from being registered as a migration agent. These requirements relevantly include:(a)not meeting the academic and vocational requirements in s 289A of the Act(b)not being a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance or not being a person of integrity (s 290 of the Act). The Migration (IMMI 18/003: Specified courses and exams for registration as a migration agent) Instrument 2018 made under regulation 5(4) of the Migration Agents Regulations 1998 specifies course and examination requirements for the registration as a migration agent. The Authority is responsible for administering the registration of migration agents. Its functions set out in s 316 of the Act relevantly include taking appropriate disciplinary action against registered migration agents. On 18 December 2022, Mr Abassi lodged his application for registration as a migration agent with the Authority. To support his application, Mr Abassi provided the following: (a)In relation to requirements, Mr Abassi provided test results of a Test of English as a Foreign Language internet-based Test (TOEFL iBT) taken on 6 December 2022 with the Educational Testing Service (ETS) which recorded an overall score of 100.(b)In relation to qualifications, Mr Abassi stated that he had a Graduate Diploma in Australian Migration Law and Practice from Western Sydney University awarded on 17 September 2019.[1] He also stated he successfully completed the Capstone Assessment with Legal Training Australia Pty Ltd which was awarded on 31 October 2022.[2] (c)In relation to disclosures, Mr Abassi made one disclosure which was that in January 2020 he had been the subject of an investigation by an educational institution on the grounds of academic misconduct.[3] That academic institution was the College of Law. [1] Exhibit 2 ST4 at page 112. [2] Ibid at page 114.[3] Ibid at page 113. On 18 January 2023, Mr Abassi was advised that his registration as a migration agent had been approved under s 289 of the Act and was effective from that date. He was also advised to visit the Authority’s website for important information about his new role and responsibilities such as the Code of Conduct and the Ethnical Framework and Occupational Competency Standards. Decision to cancel the Applicant’s registration as a migration agent

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 19 January 2024, the Authority decided to cancel the Applicant’s registration as a migration agent being satisfied that the Applicant: (d)breached s 13(1) and s 29 of the Code of Conduct, and(e)is not a person of integrity or is otherwise not a fit and proper person to provide immigration assistance as per paragraph 303(1)(f) of the Act.[10] [10] Exhibit 1 AT12 at pages 101-103.Allegations that came to light after the making of the cancellation decision In preparing this matter for hearing, the Respondent discovered four previous unsuccessful attempts by Mr Abassi to complete the TOEFL iBT test prior to the 6 December TOEFL iBT test:(a)6 February 2022 Mr Abassi sat an TOEFL iBT test and was advised by ETS on 4 March 2022 that there was no reportable score because he accessed a cell phone during the break.[11](b)24 February 2022 Mr Abassi sat an TOEFL iBT test and was advised by ETS on 12 April 2022 that there was no reportable score because he may have received assistance during the test.[12](c)2 May 2022 Mr Abassi sat an TOEFL iBT test and was advised by ETS on 9 September 2022 that there was no reportable score because he had unauthorised software operating during the test.[13](d)22 November 2022 Mr Abassi sat an TOEFL iBT test and was advised by ETS on 15 December 2022 that there was no reportable score because he may have received assistance during the test.[14] [11] Exhibit 3 FST1 page 126.[12] Exhibit 3 FST2 page 127.[13] Exhibit 3 FST3 page 128.[14] Exhibit 3 FST3 page 129. Mr Abassi sat these tests under a different profile to the 6 December 2020 test. Since the cancellation of his registration, Mr Abassi has obtained a score on an alternative English test with a sufficient score. In the hearing, the Respondent confirmed that the Applicant’s English competency is not an issue in these proceedings. Allegation of false representation as a registered migration agent Section 283 is an offence provision that provides that a person who is not a registered migration agent must not directly or indirectly represent that they are a migration agent. Evidence was produced during the hearing by the Respondent to attempt to demonstrate that Mr Abassi continues to represent himself to the public as a registered migration agent.[15][15] Exhibits 4 and 5. ISSUE The issues for the Tribunal in reviewing the Authority’s cancellation decision are:(a)firstly, whether the Tribunal is satisfied that either of the grounds in s 303(1) that are said to be engaged have been made out, and (b)secondly, whether the discretion in that section should be exercised to cancel or suspend Mr Abassi’s registration or caution him. It is well accepted that the Tribunal’s determination is not whether the decision the decision-maker made was the correct or preferable one on the material before them but whether the decision is the correct or preferable one on the material before the Tribunal.[16] [16] In Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286 [Shi] at [35] Kirby J refers to the observations of Bowen CJ and Deane J in Drake v Minister of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 18 January 2023, Mr Abassi was advised that his registration as a migration agent had been approved under s 289 of the Act and was effective from that date. He was also advised to visit the Authority’s website for important information about his new role and responsibilities such as the Code of Conduct and the Ethnical Framework and Occupational Competency Standards. Decision to cancel the Applicant’s registration as a migration agent Section 303(1) of the Act provides for the Authority to cancel the registration of a registered migration agent if it becomes satisfied that:(d) the agent's application for registration was known by the agent to be false or misleading in a material particular; or(e) the agent becomes bankrupt; or(f) the agent is not a person of integrity or is otherwise not a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance; or(g) an individual related by employment to the agent is not a person of integrity; or(h) the agent has not complied with the Code of Conduct prescribed under section 314. Section 314(2) of the Act provides that a migration registered agent must conduct themselves in accordance with the prescribed Code of Conduct. It relevantly provides in s 13(1) that a migration agent must act professionally, competently, diligently, ethically, honestly and with integrity. It also imposes in s 29 a duty on migration agents to notify the Authority of changes in circumstances relevant to the agent’s continued registration. On 9 March 2023, ETS notified Mr Abassi by email that it had cancelled his test score from the 6 December 2022 TOEFL iBT test.[4] He was informed that this was because the score validation process identified that unauthorised recording devices/software were open during the test session in violation of ETS’ policy.[5] He was also informed that if the scores from the test were reported to any institution they will be notified of the cancellation. Mr Abassi did not notify the Authority of the cancellation.[6][4] Exhibit 1 AT6 at page 34.[5] Ibid.[6] Ibid. On 22 March 2023, ETS notified the Authority that they had cancelled the Applicant’s 6 December 2022 TOEFL iBT test scores.[7] [7] Exhibit 1 AT7 at page 34. On 19 September 2023, the Authority issued a notice under s 309 of the Act advising Mr Abassi that it was considering cautioning him or suspending or cancelling his registration and inviting him to make a submission by 17 October 2023.[8] [8] Exhibit 1 AT8 at pages 36-44. The reasons provided in the notice for this action were: (a)cheating on the 2020 College of Law exam(b)cheating on the English test, and(c)failing to notify the Authority that his English test score had been cancelled.[9][9] Ibid. On 13 November 2023, Mr Abassi submitted a response to these reasons about which I go into further detail below. On 19 January 2024, the Authority decided to cancel the Applicant’s registration as a migration agent being satisfied that the Applicant: (d)breached s 13(1) and s 29 of the Code of Conduct, and(e)is not a person of integrity or is otherwise not a fit and proper person to provide immigration assistance as per paragraph 303(1)(f) of the Act.[10] [10] Exhibit 1 AT12 at pages 101-103.Allegations that came to light after the making of the cancellation decision