PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT OF
QUEENSLAND
CITATION: AAPT CDMA Pty Ltd v. Logan City Council [2001] QPE 020 PARTIES: AAPT CDMA PTY LTD Appellant
And
LOGAN CITY COUNCIL RespondentFILE NO/S: Appeal No. 4539 and 5056 of 2000 DIVISION: Planning and Environment Court PROCEEDING: ORIGINATING Brisbane COURT: DELIVERED ON: 20 March 2001 DELIVERED AT: Southport HEARING DATE: 14 March 2001 JUDGE: Judge Quirk ORDER: The ruling sought by the appellant must be refused CATCHWORDS: Telstra Corporation Limited v. Pine Rivers Shire Council &
Ors. 231/99, 9 March 2001;
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules;
Planning and Environment Court Rules;
Interchase Corporation Limited (in Liq) v Grosvenor Hill
(Queensland) Pty Ltd 1999 1 QDR 141;
Baker v Campbell 1983 153 CLR 52 at 122);
.COUNSEL: Mr W. Cochrane for the appellant
Mr R Litster for the respondentSOLICITORS: Phillips Fox for the appellant
Corrs Chambers Westgarth for the respondent
This rather unusual matter involves a dispute about disclosure of certain material by
the respondent. The appeal itself is against the imposition of a condition upon the
respondent’s approval of an application for a development permit for a “Utility
Installation – Telecommunications Facility – High Impact”.
The disputed condition is as follows:“10.5 The applicant shall indemnify the council against any claims arising whatsoever as a result of the operation of the facility, including any claims covering detrimental effects of Electromagnetic Radiation emanating from the facility”.
The unusual feature of the case is that both parties have approached Dr David
Black, a recognised expert in the field of environmental medicine and in particular,
electromagnetic radiation. Dr Black’s evidence on the question of the risk of this
form of radiation from mobile telephone towers was viewed favourably by His
Honour Judge Newton in his recent decision of Telstra Corporation Limited v Pine
Rivers Shire Council & Ors. 231/99, 9 March 2001.
As appears in his affidavit (filed 8 March 2001), in his discussions with Dr Black,
the appellant’s solicitor, Mr Marshall, learned that Dr Black had responded to some
questions put to him by the council’s solicitors, requested that disclosure of these
written responses be made, but the request has not been complied with.
On 5 February in a further conversation with Dr Black, Mr Marshall learned that
the doctor had been advised by the council’s solicitors that, “They did not think that
they would be retaining him in the matter”. When asked to provide a copy of his
correspondence with the council’s solicitor, Dr Black was disinclined to do so, “as a
matter of professional courtesy”.
The question which I must decide is whether the communication between the
council’s solicitors and Dr Black should be disclosed. Before me legal professional
privilege was claimed by the respondent in respect of that document. In an
affidavit, Mr McDonald, the council’s solicitors, stated:
“Communications between this firm and Dr Black have been affected so as to permit this firm to provide advice to the respondent and to brief counsel to provide advice as to the conduct…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read AAPT CDMA Pty Ltd v Logan City Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] QPEC 20
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the legal framework governing planning approvals, focusing on whether the Council's decision was in line with statutory and procedural requirements. It was necessary to assess whether the Council had acted irrationally or outside its jurisdiction. Furthermore, the court considered the relevance of previous case law, particularly in relation to similar disputes involving telecommunications infrastructure. The appellant argued that the Council's decision was unreasonable and should be quashed, while the Council maintained that the decision was within its lawful powers and should stand.
In its decision, the court held that the Council's decision was lawful and not irrational. The court found that the Council had properly exercised its discretion and considered relevant factors in making its decision. The appellant's arguments regarding the necessity of the tower and the unreasonableness of the Council's decision were not sufficient to overturn the Council's decision. The court relied on precedent, particularly the case of Interchase Corporation Limited (in Liq) v Grosvenor Hill (Queensland) Pty Ltd, which supported the Council's position. Consequently, the appellant's application to set aside the Council's decision was dismissed.
The court ordered that the ruling sought by the appellant must be refused, and the Council's decision to deny the approval for the telecommunications tower was upheld. The judgment emphasised the importance of the Council's discretion in planning matters and the necessity for the appellant to demonstrate that the decision was made without proper consideration or in an arbitrary manner.
Orders
Orders of the court
The ruling sought by the appellant must be refused