| CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER | |
| CITATION: | AAI Limited t/as AAMI v Zahr [2024] NSWPIC 571 |
| CLAIMANT: | Hassan Zahr |
| INSURER: | AAI Limited t/as AAMI |
| SENIOR MEMBER: | Brett Williams |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 11 September 2024 |
CATCHWORDS: | MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; application by insurer for exemption under section 7.34(1)(b); opposed by claimant; whether claim suitable for assessment; liability denied; factual disputes about the circumstances in which the accident occurred; multiple lay witnesses; each party proposes to rely on evidence from an accident re-construction expert; experts (including medico-legal experts) likely to be required for cross examination; subsequent accident; Held – experts (and witnesses other than the claimant) cannot be compelled to give evidence in the Commission; the parties should be in a position to compel witnesses to attend the hearing; damages claimed are substantial; the assessment of damages will be complicated by a subsequent motor accident; proceedings arising from both accidents are likely to be heard together; hearing likely to take a number of days; claim not suitable for assessment; recommendation subsequently approved by the Division Head, as the President’s delegate. |
RECOMMENDATIONS – CLAIM NOT SUITABLE FOR ASSESSMENT
BACKGROUND
Hassan Zahr (claimant) was injured in a motor accident at Rockdale on 11 March 2022 (accident). He subsequently made a claim for damages under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act) on AAI Limited t/as AAMI (insurer). Liability for the claim was denied by the insurer on 5 January 2024. A further denial was issued on 5 April 2024.
The insurer referred the claim to the Commission for assessment under Div 7.6 of the MAI Act. It now seeks to have the claim exempted from assessment in accordance with s 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act. On 5 August 2024 I:
(a) dispensed with the requirement for the insurer to lodge an application for exemption and for the claimant to lodge a reply;
(b) directed the insurer to lodge and serve submissions in support of its application for exemption, and
(c) directed the claimant to lodge submissions in reply.
Neither party objected to the preliminary assessment of the claim, for the purposes of s 7.34(1)(b), being undertaken on the papers. Having considered both s 52 of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 (PIC Act) and Procedural Direction PIC2, I have concluded that a preliminary assessment of the claim can be conducted on the papers. I am satisfied that sufficient information is available to allow me to conduct the preliminary assessment without holding a formal hearing.
STATUTORY FRAMEWORK
The application for exemption is made under s 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act. Section 7.34 is relevantly in the following terms:
“7.34 Claims exempt from assessment
(1) A claim is exempt from assessment under this Division if—
(a) …, or
(b) the Commission has made a preliminary assessment of the claim and has determined (with the approval of the President) that the claim is not suitable for assessment under this Division.
(2) If a claim is exempt from assessment under this Division,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read AAI Limited t/as AAMI v Zahr and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWPIC 571
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The application was made under rule 99 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021. The Commission must consider the objects of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2016 and the circumstances of the claim. In determining whether the claim is not suitable for assessment, the Commission must consider whether the claim involves complex legal or factual issues, or complex issues in the assessment of the amount of the claim; whether the claim involves issues of liability; and whether the assessment of damages will be complicated by a subsequent motor accident. The Commission may also consider any other relevant matters. The Commission has considered the evidence before it and the objects of the Personal Injury Commission Act. The Commission is satisfied that the claim is not suitable for assessment.
The objects of the Personal Injury Commission Act include, relevantly, to enable the Commission to resolve the real issues in proceedings justly, quickly, cost effectively and with as little formality as possible. The guiding principle for the Personal Injury Commission Act and the Rules, in their application to proceedings in the Commission, is to facilitate the just, quick and cost effective resolution of the real issues in the proceedings. The Commission must seek to give effect to the guiding principle when it exercises any power given to it by the Personal Injury Commission Act or the Rules, or interprets any provision of the Motor Accident Injuries Act or the Rules: section 42(2). The Commission is satisfied that the claim is not suitable for assessment. The claim involves complex issues in the assessment of the amount of the claim. The assessment of damages will be complicated by a subsequent motor accident. The hearing is likely to take a number of days. The Commission is satisfied that the claim is not suitable for assessment.
The application is approved. The claim is exempt from assessment. The parties should be in a position to compel witnesses to attend the hearing. Experts (and witnesses other than the claimant) cannot be compelled to give evidence in the Commission. The parties should be in a position to compel witnesses to attend the hearing.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Rule 99 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 (Rules) applies to the application, and is in the following terms:“99 Consideration of discretionary exemption from claims assessment(1) A claimant or insurer may apply for an exemption from assessment under section 92(1)(b) of the MAC Act or section 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act by lodging an application.(2) In determining whether a claim is not suitable for assessment for the purposes of section 92(1)(b) of the MAC Act or section 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act, the Commission must consider the objects of the PIC Act and the circumstances of the claim.(3) Without limiting the matters that may be considered, the Commission may consider the following—(a) whether the claim involves complex legal or factual issues, or complex issues in the assessment of the amount of the claim,(b) whether the claim involves issues of liability, including contributory negligence, fault or causation,(c) whether a claimant or witness, considered by the Commission to be a material witness, resides outside the State,(d) whether a claimant or insurer seeks to proceed against one or more non-CTP parties,(e) whether the insurer alleges that a person has made a false or misleading statement in a material particular in relation to the injuries, loss or damage sustained by the claimant in the accident giving rise to the claim.” Procedural Direction MA5 applies to the application. I have dispensed with a number of requirements under the Procedural Direction. In determining whether the claim is not suitable for assessment I must consider the objects of the PIC Act. Those objects include, relevantly, to enable the Commission to resolve the real issues in proceedings justly, quickly, cost effectively and with as little formality as possible. The guiding principle for the PIC Act and the Rules, in their application to proceedings in the Commission, is to facilitate the just, quick and cost effective resolution of the real issues in the proceedings. The Commission must seek to give effect to the guiding principle when it exercises any power given to it by the PIC Act or the Rules, or interprets any provision of the MAI Act or the Rules: s 42(2). The evidence before the Commission is contained in the application lodged by the insurer. The only document attached to the reply filed by the claimant is written submissions dated 12 July 2024. The evidence discloses that liability for the claim was denied in a notice dated 5 January 2024. In that notice, the insurer asserted that the insured driver did not breach their duty of care, and was not at fault, because they had a green arrow light and the claimant failed to give way. An application for personal injury benefits dated 9 February 2024, completed by the claimant, records that he was involved in a motor accident at Rockdale on 24 January 2024. A report from NSW police dated 31 March 2022 records the date, location, and circumstances of the accident on 11 March 2022. In his statement of 21 March 2022, the claimant provided the following description of the accident:“About 7:45pm on Friday the 11th of March 2022, I was travelling on Bay St heading towards Rockdale from Brighton Le Sands. As I was approaching the intersection of Bay St and West Botany St, I came to a stop as the traffic light was red.After my light went green, I put my bike into gear and took off from the line. I was almost out of the intersection and a lady came from Bay St, turning right onto West Botany St. I believe she ran a red arrow and then she collided with me head on…”