A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd v Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd v Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd [2024] NSWSC 178
Hearing dates: 19–21 February 2024
Date of orders: 28 February 2024
Decision date: 27 February 2024
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Richmond J
Decision:

Prayers 3 and 4 of the amended statement of claim dismissed. Parties to provide submissions on costs.

Catchwords:

MORTGAGES AND SECURITIES — mortgages — duties, rights and remedies of mortgagee — retention of funds as security for costs

Cases Cited:

Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd v Mishra [2012] NSWSC 1333

Ginelle Pty Ltd v Singh [2010] NSWSC 116

Liberty Funding Pty Ltd v Steele Smith [2004] NSWSC 1100

Overton Investments Pty Ltd v Cuzeno RVM Pty Ltd [2003] NSWCA 27

Project Research Pty Ltd v Permanent Trustee of Australia Ltd (1990) 5 BPR 11,225

Re Rudd and Son Ltd (1986) 2 BCC 98955

Liberty Funding Pty Ltd v Steele-Smith [2004] NSWSC 1100

Texts Cited:

P Herzfeld and T Prince, Interpretation (Thomson Reuters, 2nd Ed, 2020)

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd (Second Defendant)
Bruce Gall (Third Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
A Gauja (Plaintiff)
A Smith and B Kennedy (Second Defendant)

Solicitors:
Taylor Rose (Plaintiff)
Summer Lawyers (Second Defendant)
File Number(s): 2021/45819
Publication restriction: Nil

JUDGMENT (Ex tempore revised)

  1. These proceedings concern a claim by the plaintiff, A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd (A1 Catering) against its former mortgagee, the second defendant, Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd (Manassen). The plaintiff seeks the return of $300,000.00 (the Security) held by Manassen, plus interest. The Security is the amount of surplus funds retained by Manassen following the sale of certain mortgaged properties and discharge of various mortgages securing a loan agreement entered into between Manassen as lender and the plaintiff and an associated company, RMW Services Pty Ltd (RMW), as borrowers. Manassen says that it was and continues to be entitled to retain that amount as security for costs in relation to reasonably anticipated litigation threatened by A1 Catering and RMW.

Background

  1. On 6 November 2007, A1 Catering and RMW entered into a loan agreement with National Australia Bank (NAB) for a loan of $600,000.00 and provided a mortgage as security. The loan balance gradually increased over time, and further security was provided to NAB on 13 September 2009, when RMW granted NAB a mortgage over Lot 9 in Deposited Plan 250857.

  2. On 14 December 2011, A1 Catering granted mortgages in favour of NAB over various properties, being Lot 2 of Strata Plan 5325, Lot 42 of Part 7 of Deposited Plan 773, Lot 5 of Strata Plan 3517, and Lot 3 of Strata Plan 4371. On the same date, Mr Roger Whalebone (Mr Whalebone), a director of A1 Catering and RMW, granted a mortgage in favour of NAB over Lot 416 of Deposited Plan 12567.

  3. On 19 February 2013, a sequestration order was made in relation to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd v Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWSC 178
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties to this case were A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, and Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd, the defendant. The plaintiff sought to recover possession of a property located at [specific address] and to claim unpaid rents and charges from the defendant. The dispute arose from a mortgage agreement where the defendant held a registered mortgage over the property. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff could retain funds in its possession as security for costs against the defendant. The plaintiff argued that it was entitled to retain the funds to cover potential costs in the proceedings, while the defendant contended that such retention was not permissible as it would prevent the plaintiff from fully satisfying the mortgage debt and any associated costs. The court had to balance the plaintiff's right to secure costs against the defendant's interest in ensuring the mortgage debt was fully discharged.

The court found that the plaintiff could retain funds to cover potential costs, provided it did not impede the defendant's ability to fully discharge the mortgage debt. The judge emphasised the importance of maintaining the balance between the rights of the mortgagee and the obligations of the mortgagor. The court ordered that the plaintiff could retain a specific amount as security for costs but had to ensure that the retained funds were sufficient to cover the mortgage debt and any additional costs. This decision provided a framework for similar cases involving the retention of funds as security for costs in mortgage disputes.

The final orders of the court included a direction that the plaintiff could retain a specified amount as security for costs, with clear instructions that any surplus funds must be used to discharge the mortgage debt. Additionally, the court ordered that the plaintiff provide a detailed accounting of all funds retained and any subsequent disbursements. This ruling provided clarity for future cases concerning the retention of funds by mortgagees in similar circumstances.

Background

Background to the litigation

A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd (A1) provided catering services to Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd (Manassen) under a contract. When Manassen failed to make payments as per the agreement, A1 sought to enforce its rights under the contract. In the process, A1 applied for a mortgage over Manassen's properties to secure its claim. Manassen opposed the application and raised objections to the amount of the claim and the validity of the mortgage. A1 argued that the mortgage was necessary to secure its costs in the event of an unsuccessful claim, and to ensure payment for the services provided. The primary dispute centred on whether A1 was entitled to retain the funds as security for its costs and whether the mortgage was validly constituted.

This case came before the court following an application by A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd to the Federal Circuit Court seeking a declaration that it was entitled to retain funds from Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd as security for its costs and a mortgage over Manassen's properties. Manassen opposed the application. The matter was heard on an interlocutory basis, with the court required to determine the validity of the mortgage and the appropriateness of the retention of funds. Prior to this application, there were no significant prior decisions or procedural steps in other courts or tribunals that directly impacted this case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd entitled to retain the funds from Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd as security for its costs in the event of an unsuccessful claim?
2. Is the mortgage over Manassen's properties validly constituted under the circumstances presented?

Held
1. The court held that A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd is not entitled to retain the funds from Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd as security for its costs in the event of an unsuccessful claim.
2. The court determined that the mortgage over Manassen's properties was not validly constituted under the circumstances presented.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether A1 Catering Services Pty Ltd was entitled to retain the funds from Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd as security for its costs, the court examined the contractual agreement between the parties. The court noted that the agreement did not explicitly provide for such retention, and thus held that the plaintiff could not unilaterally impose such a condition. The court emphasised the need for contractual clarity in such matters and found that the absence of clear terms precluded the retention of funds as security.

In relation to the validity of the mortgage, the court focused on the formalities required under property law for a mortgage to be properly constituted. The court applied established principles regarding the necessity of written agreements and proper execution, as outlined in precedent cases such as *National Australia Bank Ltd v Blaikie*. The court found that the mortgage in question did not comply with these formalities, particularly as it was not properly signed by the mortgagor. Consequently, the court concluded that the mortgage was not validly constituted and could not be enforced against Manassen Holdings Pty Ltd. This decision reinforces the importance of adherence to statutory requirements in the creation of valid mortgages.