A Nelson & Co Ltd v Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd (Stay Application)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

A Nelson & Co Ltd v Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd (Stay Application) [2021] FCA 754  

File number: NSD 154 of 2021
Judgment of: PERRAM J
Date of judgment: 5 July 2021
Catchwords: PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW – application for permanent stay of claim for breach of contract and temporary stay of claim for damages for intellectual property infringements – where intellectual property infringements admitted – where exclusive jurisdiction clause in distribution agreement between First Applicant and First Respondent requires disputes to occur in England
– whether ‘strong reasons’ adduced against grant of stay – whether fragmentation of proceedings a strong reason – whether Applicants the authors of any fragmentation
Legislation: Foreign Judgments Act 1991 (Cth) s 3
Cases cited:

A Nelson & Co Ltd v Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 228

Akai Pty Ltd v People’s Insurance Co Ltd (1996) 188 CLR 418

Australian Health & Nutrition Association Ltd v Hive Marketing Group Pty Ltd [2019] NSWCA 61; 99 NSWLR 419

Blair v Curran (1939) 62 CLR 464

Cassegrain v Gerard Cassegrain & Co Pty Ltd [2013] NSWCA 454; 305 ALR 648

Global Partners Fund Ltd v Babcock & Brown Ltd (in liq) [2010] NSWCA 196

Gujarat NRE Coke Limited v Coeclerici Asia (Pte) Ltd [2013] FCAFC 109; 304 ALR 468

Huddart Parker Ltd v Ship ‘Mill Hill’ (1950) 81 CLR 502

Incitec Ltd v Alkimos Shipping Corporation [2004] FCA 698; 138 FCR 496

Incitec Ltd v Alkimos Shipping Corporation [2004] FCA 839

Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd v A Nelson & Co Ltd [2021] FCAFC 80

The Eleftheria [1970] P 94

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Trade Marks
Number of paragraphs: 32
Date of hearing: 1 July 2021
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr N Murray SC with Ms A Campbell
Solicitor for the Applicants: Gilbert + Tobin
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr P W Flynn SC with Mr S G Frauenfelder
Solicitor for the Respondents: Corrs Chambers Westgarth

ORDERS

NSD 154 of 2021
BETWEEN:

A NELSON & CO LTD

First Applicant

BACH FLOWER REMEDIES LIMITED

Second Applicant

AND:

MARTIN & PLEASANCE PTY LTD ACN 006 935 888

First Respondent

ALOE VERA INDUSTRIES PTY LTD ACN 063 710 832

Second Respondent

MARTIN & PLEASANCE WHOLESALE PTY LTD

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

PERRAM J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 JULY 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties bring in short minutes of order giving effect to these reasons within 7 days.

2.The matter be listed for a case management hearing at 9.30 am on 20 July 2021.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

PERRAM J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. The First Applicant (‘Nelsons’) sues the First Respondent (‘M&P’) for breach of contract.  Nelsons and its subsidiary, the Second Applicant (‘BFR’), also sue the three Respondents for infringing, in various ways, their intellectual property in the word ‘RESCUE’ (another product named ‘BACH’ is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A Nelson & Co Ltd v Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd (Stay Applica... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 754
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, A Nelson & Co Ltd (Applicant) and Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd (Respondent) were engaged in a dispute over a breach of contract and intellectual property infringements. The Applicants sought to enforce a distribution agreement against the Respondents, which included an exclusive jurisdiction clause mandating disputes to be resolved in England. The Respondents applied for a permanent stay of the Applicants' claims for breach of contract and a temporary stay of the claims for damages for intellectual property infringements. The central legal issues were whether there were strong reasons against granting the stay, and whether the risk of fragmented proceedings was a compelling factor.

The Court considered the Applicants' admissions of the intellectual property infringements and the existence of an exclusive jurisdiction clause in the distribution agreement. The Applicants argued that the risk of fragmented proceedings constituted a strong reason against granting the stay. The Respondents did not contest that fragmentation of proceedings could be a valid reason to deny a stay but argued that they were not responsible for any potential fragmentation. The Court found that the risk of fragmentation provided a strong reason against granting the stay. The Applicants had not contributed to the fragmentation, and the Court was mindful of the potential for contradictory outcomes in different jurisdictions.

The Court concluded that the application for a stay should be refused. The Respondents were ordered to bear the costs of the stay application. The Court also addressed the issue of the terms of the declarations and injunctions to be made regarding the Respondents' liability for the intellectual property infringements. The Court decided against including a proposed rider that the Respondents had suggested, finding it either otiose or ambiguous. The Court granted the Applicants the liberty to seek further costs in the proceedings if they succeeded in their additional damages claim.

ORDERS:
1. The parties are to prepare short minutes of order reflecting these reasons within 7 days.
2. The matter is to be listed for a case management hearing at 9.30 am on 20 July 2021.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties bring in short minutes of order giving effect to these reasons within 7 days.

2. The matter be listed for a case management hearing at 9.30 am on 20 July 2021.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves A Nelson & Co Ltd and Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd, with A Nelson & Co Ltd (the First Applicant) being a company involved in the distribution of various products, and Martin & Pleasance Pty Ltd (the First Respondent) being a supplier of certain products. The First Applicant had entered into a distribution agreement with the First Respondent, which included an exclusive jurisdiction clause requiring disputes to be resolved in England. The First Applicant instituted proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia, seeking damages for breach of contract and intellectual property infringements. The First Respondent applied for a permanent stay of the breach of contract claim and a temporary stay of the intellectual property infringement claims, arguing that the exclusive jurisdiction clause in the distribution agreement required the disputes to be heard in England.

The First Respondent admitted to the intellectual property infringements but argued that the exclusive jurisdiction clause mandated that any disputes should be heard in England. The First Applicant opposed the stay application, contending that there were strong reasons against granting the stay, including the risk of fragmentation of the proceedings and the possibility that the First Respondent was contributing to any potential fragmentation. The First Applicant also argued that the Respondents unduly delayed in bringing the stay application, which could be a factor against granting the stay.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application for a stay of proceedings. The First Respondent applied for a permanent stay of the claim for breach of contract and a temporary stay of the claims for damages for intellectual property infringements. The First Applicant opposed the stay application, arguing against the grant of the stay on several grounds, including the risk of fragmentation and the Respondents' potential contribution to any fragmentation. The court heard submissions from both parties and considered the arguments presented before making its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In those circumstances, I accept Mr Murray’s submission that the risk of fragmentation in this case provides a strong reason not to grant the stay sought by the Respondents. That being so I do not need to consider his submission that the Respondents unduly delayed in bringing the stay application.CONCLUSIONS AND ORDERS The application is refused. Mr Flynn submitted that if the stay was refused, I should not order the Respondents to pay the costs of the application. It is true in Incitec Allsop J said this at [67]:I am mindful that my conclusion is one which permits the owner to undertake a course contrary to its contract. In particular in the light of those circumstances, and the entirely legitimate and reasonable approach adopted by Mr Nell in argument on behalf of Hyundai, I will hear the parties on costs. His Honour subsequently ordered that the costs be costs in the proceedings: Incitec Ltd v Alkimos Shipping Corporation [2004] FCA 839. At [5] his Honour said this:There are sufficient circumstances here which warrant the order that I propose. Alkimos was not entirely successful in its opposition to Hyundai’s position. In particular, I rejected some of the important submissions put by Alkimos regarding the nature of the claim and whether or not it fell within the dispute resolution clause. Further, the judgment as to the exercise of discretion in these matters is often a difficult one to predict. I indicated that the balance was a “fine one”, see [66] of my earlier reasons. Further, Hyundai did not act unreasonably in seeking to enforce its contractual bargain. This case is not the same. I do not think that the case was finely balanced and the Respondents have not been in any way successful. They will need to bear the costs of the stay application. There remains an unrelated issue between the parties. Although the Respondents have accepted they are liable on the intellectual property case, the parties remain at loggerheads about the terms in which this Court should record that fact. The difference between them relates to whether the declarations and injunctions which they otherwise agree should be made should be prefaced with this rider, as the Respondents seek:Solely on the basis of the admissions made and matters pleaded in the Defence to the Further Amended Statement of Claim dated 25 May 2021 (Defence to FASOC) in the form shown at Annexure 1 to this order, the Court [declares/orders] that: I see no reason why these words should be added. As Mr Murray submitted, it is unclear what they do. They either have no effect on the meaning of the orders in which case they are otiose or they do have some effect but one which is unclear, in which case they are apt to create ambiguity in the orders. I apprehend that the point of the rider may have been to limit the effect of any estoppel in any English proceedings. Since there will be no English proceedings this purpose lacks utility. There was another debate as to whether an agreed order that the Respondents pay the Applicants’ costs in the intellectual property proceeding be prefaced by a rider permitting the Applicants to seek further costs in the proceedings. Presumably, the Applicants wish to reserve to themselves the right to seek indemnity costs if the hearing on the additional damages claim goes their way. In my view, they should have that liberty.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the application for a permanent stay of the claim for breach of contract and a temporary stay of the claim for damages for intellectual property infringements. The court considered the exclusive jurisdiction clause in the distribution agreement, which requires disputes to be resolved in England. The Respondents sought a stay of the proceedings due to the intellectual property infringements being admitted, but the Applicants argued that the exclusive jurisdiction clause should be enforced. The court noted that the Applicants had not unreasonably sought to enforce their contractual rights and that the Respondents had not been successful in their application for a stay. The risk of fragmentation was identified as a significant factor against granting the stay, as the parties were already at odds over the terms of the orders regarding the intellectual property case. The court rejected the Respondents' argument that the Applicants had contributed to the fragmentation of the proceedings. The ratio decidendi is that in cases involving an exclusive jurisdiction clause in a distribution agreement, where there is a risk of fragmentation in proceedings, this constitutes a strong reason against granting a stay sought by the Respondents.