A J & S Constructions Pty Ltd v Aussie Trading House (International) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

[1999] TASSC 77

CITATION:           A J & S Constructions Pty Ltd v Aussie Trading House
  (International) Pty Ltd [1999] TASSC 77

PARTIES:  A J & S CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD
  v
  AUSSIE TRADING HOUSE (INTERNATIONAL) PTY LTD
  BAALA, Zahid

TITLE OF COURT:            SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:                 ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S:  82/1999
DELIVERED ON:                29 July 1999
DELIVERED AT:                 Launceston
HEARING DATES:             19 July 1999
JUDGMENT OF:                Crawford J

CATCHWORDS:

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
           Applicant:  A Hamilton
           Respondents:  A S Kemp
Solicitors:
           Applicant:  Archer Bushby
           Respondents:  Lander & Rogers

Judgment ID Number:  [1999] TASSC 77
Number of paragraphs:  12

Serial No 77/1999
File No 82/1999

A J & S CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD v AUSSIE TRADING HOUSE (INTERNATIONAL) PTY LTD and ZAHID BAALA

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  CRAWFORD J
  29 July 1999

  1. The plaintiff applied under the Rules of Court, O15, for summary judgment against the defendants in the sum of $63,441 together with interest at 10 per centum per annum from 4 May 1999 until judgment, on the ground that the defendants have no defence to the plaintiff's claim.  I will determine the application in accordance with well known principles.  Summary judgment should only be ordered where there can be no reasonable doubt that the plaintiff is entitled to judgment and that it is inexpedient to allow the defendants to defend for mere purposes of delay.  Jones v Stone [1894] AC 122 at 124. The plaintiff must show that it has a clear case against the defendants which the latter cannot possibly answer. Roberts v Plant [1895] 1 QB 597 at 603. See also Stephens v Huett unreported 36/1983.  A judge should not make an order for summary judgment unless fully persuaded that there is no real question to be tried, that is, there are no facts shown such as would lead to the inference that at the trial of the action the defendants might be able to establish a defence to the plaintiff's claim.  Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd v Barry [1992] 2 Qd R 12 at 14. A complete defence need not be shown by the defendants at the stage when summary judgment is sought. Cloverdell Lumber Co Pty Ltd v Abbott (1924) 34 CLR 122 at 133.

  1. Alan James Ellis, a director of the plaintiff with the day to day management of the company, swore in an affidavit that the defendants are and were at the commencement of the action justly and truly indebted to the plaintiff for the sum of $63,441 and that particulars of that sum appear in the statement of claim.  He said that to his knowledge the facts in the statement of claim are true and correct and he believes that there is no defence to the action. 

  1. The defendants delivered a defence to the statement of claim.  Some of the facts pleaded in the statement of claim were admitted by them and some were not.  In addition, counterclaims and set-offs were pleaded.  The admissions in the defence are significant for the effect of them…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A J & S Constructions Pty Ltd v Aussie Trading House (Intern... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] TASSC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Tasmania, A J & S Constructions Pty Ltd brought an action against Aussie Trading House (International) Pty Ltd and Zahid Baala, seeking $63,441 in damages, along with interest, based on a contract for restaurant and kitchen renovations. The plaintiff applied for summary judgment, arguing that the defendants had no defence to its claim. The court had to decide whether the plaintiff had a clear case against the defendants, which the latter could not possibly answer. The plaintiff claimed that the defendants owed them money for agreed variations and that there were no valid defences or counterclaims. The defendants admitted to owing a substantial part of the claim but argued that they had valid counterclaims and set-offs.

The court examined the evidence and found that the defendants had failed to establish any issue that should be tried concerning the variations. The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to judgment for the agreed costs of the building works and variations, less payments made and damages claimed by the defendants. The court also found that the second defendant, who guaranteed the first defendant's obligations, should be allowed to defend the claim for set-offs. The court rejected the plaintiff's claim for interest under the Supreme Court Civil Procedure Act 1932, as the plaintiff had not pleaded the necessary facts and had not served a written demand for interest prior to the action. The court ordered that the plaintiff could sign final judgment against both defendants for $41,332, and that the defendants could defend the remaining part of the plaintiff's claim.

Background

Background to the litigation

A J & S Constructions Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) sought summary judgment against Aussie Trading House (International) Pty Ltd (the first defendant) and Zahid Baala (the second defendant) for the sum of $63,441 together with interest. The claim arose out of a written agreement dated 25 September 1998 whereby the plaintiff agreed to undertake certain restaurant and kitchen renovations for the first defendant for a total price of $90,000 plus the costs of any variations. The plaintiff claimed that between 25 September 1998 and 20 December 1998 it undertook variations at the request of the first defendant with a net cost of $48,441. The first defendant admitted some facts in its defence but pleaded counterclaims and set-offs for delay and faulty workmanship. The second defendant was sued under a guarantee he gave to pay any money owing under the agreement. The plaintiff applied for summary judgment on the basis that the defendants had no defence to the claim. The court held that the first defendant had failed to establish any issue concerning the variations, and that the second defendant should have leave to defend the set-offs claimed by the first defendant. The court also held that the plaintiff was not entitled to interest under s34(1)(b) of the Supreme Court Civil Procedure Act 1932 as it had not pleaded the necessary facts. The court ordered that the plaintiff could sign final judgment for $41,332 against both defendants, less the set-offs, and that the defendants be at liberty to defend the residue of the claim for interest.

This matter came before the Supreme Court of Tasmania as an application for summary judgment filed by A J & S Constructions Pty Ltd against Aussie Trading House (International) Pty Ltd and Zahid Baala. The plaintiff sought summary judgment for the sum of $63,441 plus interest, arguing that the defendants had no defence to the plaintiff's claim. The application was heard on 19 July 1999 and the judgment was delivered by Crawford J on 29 July 1999. The defendants had filed a defence to the plaintiff's claim, admitting some facts but denying others, and also pleaded counterclaims and set-offs. The key issue at the hearing was whether the defendants should be granted leave to defend the plaintiff's claim for variations in the building contract, which the plaintiff argued was fully admitted by the defendants. The court found that the defendants had failed to satisfy the court that there was an issue which ought to be tried concerning the variations. Consequently, the court ruled that the plaintiff should have judgment against the first defendant for $41,332, while the defendants were granted leave to defend the plaintiff's claim for interest. The second defendant, who was sued under a guarantee, was also granted leave to defend the plaintiff's claim to the extent of the set-offs pleaded by the first defendant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to summary judgment against the defendants for the amount of $63,441, plus interest, as there is no defence to the plaintiff's claim.
2. Whether the defendants should be granted leave to defend the plaintiff's claim in so far as it includes $48,441 for the cost of variations.
3. Whether the second defendant is entitled to the benefit of the set-offs claimed by the first defendant.
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest under s34(1)(b) of the Supreme Court Civil Procedure Act 1932.

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff is entitled to summary judgment against the defendants for the amount of $41,332, made up of the agreed cost of building works ($90,000) and variations ($48,881), less payments made ($75,000) and damages claimed by the first defendant for delay ($10,059) and faulty workmanship ($12,050). The result is that the plaintiff is granted summary judgment for $41,332.
2. The court concluded that the defendants should be granted leave to defend the plaintiff's claim in so far as it includes the $22,109 for the cost of set-offs claimed by the first defendant. The result is that the defendants are granted leave to defend the claim for $22,109.
3. The court concluded that the second defendant is not entitled to the benefit of the set-offs claimed by the first defendant as it depends on the terms of the contract of guarantee. The result is that the second defendant is granted leave to defend the claim for $22,109.
4. The court concluded that the plaintiff is not entitled to interest under s34(1)(b) of the Supreme Court Civil Procedure Act 1932 as there were no facts pleaded upon which the claim is based. The result is that the defendants are granted leave to defend the plaintiff's claim for interest.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court, in granting summary judgment to the plaintiff, A J & S Constructions Pty Ltd, against the defendants, Aussie Trading House (International) Pty Ltd and Zahid Baala, for the amount of $63,441, plus interest, applied well-established principles of civil procedure. The plaintiff's application for summary judgment under the Rules of Court, O15, was grounded on the absence of a defence to its claim. The court noted that summary judgment should only be ordered where there can be no reasonable doubt that the plaintiff is entitled to judgment and that it is inexpedient to allow the defendants to defend for mere purposes of delay, as per Jones v Stone [1894] AC 122 at 124. The plaintiff had to demonstrate a clear case against the defendants that could not possibly be answered by the latter. This principle was confirmed in Roberts v Plant [1895] 1 QB 597 at 603 and Stephens v Huett unreported 36/1983.

The plaintiff provided a sworn affidavit from Alan James Ellis, a director with the day-to-day management of the company, asserting that the defendants owed the plaintiff $63,441 and that there was no defence to the claim. Despite the defendants delivering a defence, significant admissions in their pleadings meant that a substantial part of the plaintiff's claim was effectively conceded. Tugral Salim Shah, a director of the first defendant, acknowledged in his affidavit that there was a defence to the action, but this did not alter the fact that a significant portion of the plaintiff's claim was admitted.

The court examined whether the defendants should be granted leave to defend the plaintiff's claim, particularly in relation to the $48,441 for the cost of variations. Anthony S Widdowson, a building consultant, opined that the fair and reasonable value of the variations was $12,735. The defendants argued for leave to defend the difference, but the court found insurmountable difficulties in supporting this claim due to the substantial admissions and documentary evidence provided by the plaintiff. The court concluded that the defendants had failed to establish a triable issue concerning the variations, and thus, the plaintiff was entitled to judgment for $41,332.

Regarding the second defendant, Zahid Baala, who was sued under a guarantee, the court held that it was arguable that his liability as a guarantor does not exceed the first defendant's liability. Therefore, the second defendant was also to be granted judgment for $41,332 but would have leave to defend the set-offs claimed by the first defendant.

Lastly, the court addressed the plaintiff's claim for interest under s34(1)(b) of the Supreme Court Civil Procedure Act 1932. The plaintiff sought interest at 10 per centum per annum from 4 May 1999. However, the court held that the plaintiff was not entitled to such interest under s34(1)(b), particularly at this stage of the proceedings. The court reasoned that the plaintiff had not pleaded the necessary facts to substantiate the claim for interest and had not provided an affidavit verifying the claim for interest. Therefore, the defendants were granted leave to defend the plaintiff's claim for interest.

In summary, the binding legal principle established by this decision is that where a plaintiff demonstrates a clear case with substantial admissions by the defendants, summary judgment can be granted, except for the specific issues where the defendants have a legitimate defence or claim for set-offs. Additionally, the plaintiff must plead and substantiate claims for interest as per statutory provisions.