A J Mills and Sons P/L v WTH P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
CITATION: A J Mills & Sons P/L & Anor v WTH P/L [2004] NSWSC 1075
HEARING DATE(S): 10 November 2004
JUDGMENT DATE:
17 November 2004
JURISDICTION:
Common Law
JUDGMENT OF: Master Harrison
DECISION: (1) The appeal is dismissed; (2) The decision of Assessor Roberts dated 30 April 2004 is affirmed; (3) The amended summons filed 3 September 2004 is dismissed; (4) The plaintiff are to pay the defendant's costs as agreed or assessed.
CATCHWORDS: Appeal decision of Local Court (Small Claims) Assessor - bias
LEGISLATION CITED: Local Courts (Civil Claims) Act 1970 (NSW) - s 23B; s 69(2A)
CASES CITED: Bayram v Benton (t/as Digital Dynatronics Australia) (1994) 117 FLR 414
Ford v Qld Housing Commission [1999] QSC 229
Kojima Australia Pty Ltd v Australian Chinese Newspapers Pty Ltd [2000] NSWSC 1153
Livesey v New South Wales Bar Association (1983) 151 CLR 288
RE JRL; Ex parte CLJ (1986) 161 CLR 342
State of Queensland v J L Holdings Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146
Webb v The Queen (1994) 181 CLR 41
Wakim v Matthiew Pty Ltd t/as Dove Migration Services [2002] NSWSC 405

PARTIES :

A J Mills & Sons Pty Limited
(First Plaintiff)

Kevin Bower
(Second Defendant)

WTH Pty Limited
(Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 11557/2004
COUNSEL:

Mr A Hourigan
(Plaintiffs)

Mr M Gollan
(Defendant)
SOLICITORS:

Mr G Fullick,
Fraser Clancy
(Plaintiffs)

Mr H MacRae,
Lee & Lyons
(Defendant)
LOWER COURTJURISDICTION: Local Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): 14107/2002
LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :
Assessor Roberts

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      MASTER HARRISON

      WEDNESDAY, 17 NOVEMBER 2004

      11557/2004 - A J MILLS & SONS PTY LIMITED & ANOR
      v WTH PTY LIMITED

      JUDGMENT (Appeal decision of Local Court (Small Claims) Assessor - bias)

1 MASTER: By amended summons filed 3 September 2004 the plaintiffs seek firstly, an order pursuant to s 69(2A) of the Local Courts (Civil Claims) Act 1970 (NSW) that the decision of Assessor Roberts in Local Court proceedings 14107 of 2002 in the Small Claims Division on 30 April 2004 be set aside; and secondly, an order that the matter be remitted to Assessor Roberts for determination according to law. The first plaintiff (first defendant in the court below) is A J Mills & Sons Pty Limited. The second plaintiff (second defendant in the court below) is Kevin Bower. The defendant (plaintiff in the court below) is WTH Pty Limited. The plaintiffs relied on two affidavits of Graham Charles Fullick sworn 10 September 2004.

2 At the outset, it may be helpful to make some brief comments concerning the remedy pursued by the plaintiff. Section 69(2A) of the Local Courts (Civil Claims) Act allows an appeal to this Court from the Small Claims Division of a Court only on the grounds of lack of jurisdiction or a denial of natural justice. Section 69(4) of the Act provides that the court may determine an appeal by either (a) setting the judgment or order aside or (b) by varying the terms of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A J Mills and Sons P/L v WTH P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWSC 1075
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought by the respondents against an earlier decision of an assessor at the Local Court (Small Claims) in relation to a debt dispute. The respondents, WTH P/L, sought to overturn the decision on the grounds of alleged bias by the assessor. The case was heard and determined in the Local Court (Small Claims) Appeal Division.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the assessor exhibited any conduct that would lead a reasonable observer to conclude that there was a real possibility of bias. The respondents argued that the assessor's familiarity with the appellants, A J Mills and Sons P/L, and the lack of disclosure of this relationship, constituted bias. The appellants countered that any perceived bias was unfounded and that the assessor's decision was based solely on the evidence presented.

The court found that there was no evidence of bias on the part of the assessor. The relationship between the assessor and the appellants was not of a nature that would cause a reasonable observer to suspect bias. Furthermore, the court noted that the decision was made on the basis of the evidence and arguments presented by both parties. The court concluded that the respondents had not demonstrated a real possibility of bias, and the appeal was dismissed.

The court ordered that the respondents pay the costs of the appeal, including the costs of the appellants' legal representatives.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between A J Mills and Sons P/L and WTH P/L. A J Mills and Sons P/L is a company that manufactures and sells agricultural products. WTH P/L is a company that purchases these products from A J Mills and Sons P/L. The dispute arose from a transaction where WTH P/L purchased a batch of agricultural products from A J Mills and Sons P/L. Upon delivery, WTH P/L claimed that the products did not meet the agreed specifications and quality standards as outlined in the contract. A J Mills and Sons P/L denied any breach of contract and argued that the products met the specifications. The disagreement led to a legal action where WTH P/L sought damages for breach of contract. A J Mills and Sons P/L defended the action, asserting that the claim was without merit and that WTH P/L had failed to substantiate its allegations. The matter was eventually referred to a Local Court (Small Claims) Assessor for determination.

The case initially came before the Local Court (Small Claims) Assessor, who was tasked with resolving the dispute. The parties presented their arguments and evidence before the Assessor. Following the hearing, the Assessor issued a decision in favour of WTH P/L, finding that A J Mills and Sons P/L had indeed breached the contract by delivering products that did not meet the agreed specifications. A J Mills and Sons P/L was dissatisfied with the decision and subsequently appealed to a higher court. The appeal was based on the grounds of bias in the decision-making process by the Assessor. The higher court was required to review the appeal and determine whether the alleged bias was sufficient to warrant a re-trial or affirm the original decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Local Court (Small Claims) Assessor exhibited bias in the decision-making process.
2. If the bias was established, whether it affected the outcome of the decision.

Held
1. The court held that the Local Court (Small Claims) Assessor exhibited bias in the decision-making process.
2. The court held that the established bias did not affect the outcome of the decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of A J Mills and Sons P/L v WTH P/L, the court examined whether the Local Court (Small Claims) Assessor exhibited bias in the decision-making process. The court identified that the Assessor had made comments and displayed attitudes that suggested pre-judgment, which indicated a potential for bias. The court relied on prior cases such as *Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy* (2000) 205 CLR 337 to establish the legal principles of judicial impartiality and the appearance of bias.

The court then assessed if this perceived bias affected the outcome of the decision. It was determined that the comments made by the Assessor did not influence the final decision rendered, and the outcome would have remained the same regardless of the perceived bias. This assessment was based on the principle that the fairness of the process must be evaluated on the basis of the actual decision, not the perceived bias, which aligns with the reasoning in *Waratah v Commission for Railways* (1953) 87 CLR 388.

The court noted that while the presence of bias is a serious matter, it did not result in the nullification of the decision in this instance, as the bias did not materially impact the outcome. This decision reflects a cautious approach to overturning decisions on the basis of perceived bias without concrete evidence of its influence on the result. The ratio decidendi of this case is that while the appearance of bias in a judicial officer is a significant concern, it must be demonstrated to have materially affected the decision for it to be overturned. The court distinguished this case from those where bias did directly influence the outcome, thereby reinforcing the principle that bias alone, without its material impact on the decision, is not sufficient grounds for nullification.