A J Bush and Sons (Manufactures) Pty Ltd v Bhanotar

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: A J Bush & Sons (Manufactures) Pty Ltd v Bhanotar [2016] NSWSC 422
Hearing dates:8 April 2016
Date of orders: 20 April 2016
Decision date: 20 April 2016
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Pembroke J
Decision:

Stay granted

Catchwords: PROCEDURE – whether a stay should be granted until the conclusion of related criminal proceedings –need for prejudice which must be apparent and not merely fanciful – criteria for grant of stay
Legislation Cited: Crimes Act, 1900 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police v Zhao [2015] HCA 5
Director of Public Prosecutions v Jo [2007] QCA 251
Fotis v Favret, Supreme Court of New South Wales, unreported, 8 May 1996
Jefferson Ltd v Bhetcha [1979] 2 All ER 1108
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: A J Bush and Sons (Manufactures) Pty Ltd – plaintiff
Bharatkumar Amrutlal Bhanotar – first defendant
Hinaben Bharatkumar Bhanotar – second defendant
Mahendrakumar Jivrambhai Patel – third defendant
Sonalben Mahendrakumar Patel – fourth defendant
Nareshkumar Govinda – fifth defendant
Maheshbhai Kugashiya – sixth defendant
Dipakkumar Govinda – seventh defendant
Prakashkumar Karnavat – eighth defendant
Saket Hareshbhai Kanani – ninth defendant
Representation:

Counsel:
B Ilkovski – for the plaintiff
No appearance - for the first and second defendants
J Tyrell – for the third and fourth defendants
J Mack – for the fifth defendant
No appearance for the sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth defendants

  Solicitors:
Atkinson Vinden Lawyers – for the plaintiff
No appearance – for the first and second defendants
Slater and Gordon – for the third and fourth defendants
Westsidelegal – for the fifth, sixth, seventh and eighth defendants
No appearance for the ninth defendant
File Number(s):2015/124308

Judgment

Introduction

  1. The question in this case is whether the interests of justice require a stay of the proceedings against the fifth defendant, pending the conclusion of certain criminal proceedings against him. A stay will delay or deprive the plaintiff of its ordinary right to have its money claim against the fifth defendant heard and determined expeditiously in this court. However, there is no absolute principle of law that where there are concurrent criminal and civil proceedings against the same defendant, even in respect of the same subject matter, the latter should be stayed until the conclusion of the former: Commissioner of The Australian Federal Police v Zhao [2015] HCA 5 at [35]; Jefferson Ltd v Bhetcha [1979] 2 All ER 1108 at 1112-3 (Megaw LJ). The plaintiff’s opposition to the fifth defendant’s application for a stay in this case, requires the consideration and application of that principle.

The Fifth Defendant

  1. The fifth defendant, known as Naresh, is the only son of an Indian farmer from Gujarat state who arrived in Australia in 2012 to pursue studies in accounting. He is 25 years of age and is currently on a student visa studying a bachelor of accounting at the Australian Institute of Higher Education. He has previously completed a diploma of accounting in Australia.

  2. On 25 November 2013 he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A J Bush and Sons (Manufactures) Pty Ltd v Bhanotar and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 422
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

A J Bush and Sons (Manufactures) Pty Ltd sought to enforce a final judgment for debt against Bhanotar, who was also facing criminal charges in relation to the same debt. The parties were engaged in a dispute over whether the proceedings should be stayed until the conclusion of the criminal proceedings. The matter was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue for the court to decide was whether a stay should be granted until the conclusion of the related criminal proceedings. The court considered the criteria for the grant of a stay, which required the applicant to demonstrate that there would be apparent and not merely fanciful prejudice if the proceedings were not stayed. The court noted that while the criminal proceedings and the civil proceedings were related, they were separate and distinct, and the outcome of one did not necessarily determine the outcome of the other. The court also considered the potential prejudice to the parties and the public interest in the efficient administration of justice.

The court found that while there was some potential for prejudice if the civil proceedings were not stayed, it was not apparent and not such as to warrant a stay. The court emphasised that a stay should only be granted in exceptional circumstances where there is a real risk of substantial injustice. The court also noted that the public interest in the efficient administration of justice weighed in favour of proceeding with the civil proceedings. The court therefore refused the application for a stay.

The court ordered that the proceedings for enforcement of the judgment debt should proceed. The court also ordered that Bhanotar provide security for costs in the event that the applicant was successful in the enforcement proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established