A and S Boesley Pty Ltd v Stoney

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION
PRACTICE COURT

S CI 2014 00649

A & S BOESLEY PTY LTD ACN 122 610 511 Plaintiff
v
ROBERT JOHN BIGO STONEY First Defendant
REGISTRAR OF TITLES Second Defendant

and

S CI 2014 02657

A & S BOESLEY PTY LTD ACN 122 610 511 Plaintiff
v
ROBERT JOHN BIGO STONEY First Defendant
PETER BRUCE FULLER Second Defendant
JUSTIN PAUL WHITFORD Third Defendant
SAMANTHA STONEY Fourth Defendant
REGISTRAR OF TITLES Fifth Defendant

---

JUDGE:

MACAULAY J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

26 June 2014, 2 July 2014

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

7 July 2014

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

A & S Boesley Pty Ltd v Stoney & Anor

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2014] VSC 323

---

REMOVAL OF CAVEAT — s 90(3) Transfer of Land Act1958 — Caveats protecting interest of purchaser/s under contract for sale of land — Whether contract of sale validly terminated by vendor — Whether serious question to be tried — Whether new contract of sale entered into — Application for summary judgment on claim and on counterclaim — ss 61, 62 and 63 Civil Procedure Act 2010 — r 23 Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules2005 — Whether proposed formulations of amended defence and counterclaim sufficient to justify maintenance of caveats — No real prospect of success on claim or counterclaim — Applications granted.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr R Greenberger Engel & Partners

For the First Defendant in proceeding S CI 2014 00649 and for the First and Fourth Defendants in proceeding S CI 2014 02657

Mr M Stirling James D Mapleston

HIS HONOUR:

Introduction

  1. These reasons for judgment concern two proceedings.  In each, A & S Boesley Pty Ltd (Boesley) is the plaintiff.  One proceeding (2014/00649) was commenced by writ (the writ proceeding).  Robert Stoney is the first defendant and the Registrar of Titles the second defendant.  In the writ proceeding, Boesley sought declarations that a contract of sale of land made in 2010 (2010 contract of sale), in which it was the vendor and Mr Stoney was the purchaser, was terminated in September or October 2013.  If that was so, Boesley sought the removal of a caveat lodged by Mr Stoney in 2010 (2010 caveat) while he was the purchaser but which is no longer maintainable due to the termination of the contract.  In addition, it claimed damages for trespass and for loss upon a later resale of the land.

  1. The second proceeding (2014/02657) was commenced by originating motion (the OM proceeding).  By the OM proceeding, Boesley sought the removal of a second caveat lodged in May 2014 by Mr Stoney and three others (2014 caveat) which, again, asserted an interest derived from the 2010 contract of sale.  Two of those caveators (the second and third defendants in the OM proceeding) have consented to the caveat’s removal.  Only Mr and Mrs Stoney, first and fourth defendants in the OM proceeding, contest its removal.

  1. In each…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A and S Boesley Pty Ltd v Stoney and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] VSC 323
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

A and S Boesley Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, filed a claim and a counterclaim against Robert Stoney, the first defendant, and others, the second to fourth defendants. The plaintiff sought the removal of caveats on land titles and the rescission of a contract of sale, along with damages for trespass and unlawful entry. The defendants responded with a counterclaim for damages. The case was heard by the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The court had to determine whether the contract of sale was validly terminated by the plaintiff, whether there was a serious question to be tried regarding the validity of the contract, and whether a new contract of sale was entered into. The court also had to consider whether the proposed formulations of the amended defence and counterclaim were sufficient to justify the maintenance of the caveats, and whether there was a real prospect of success on the claim or counterclaim.

The court found that the contract of sale was validly terminated by the plaintiff. There was no serious question to be tried regarding the validity of the contract, and no new contract of sale was entered into. The proposed formulations of the amended defence and counterclaim were not sufficient to justify the maintenance of the caveats. There was no real prospect of success on the claim or counterclaim.

The court granted the plaintiff’s application for summary judgment on the claim and on the counterclaim. The court ordered the removal of the caveats on the land titles and restrained the defendants from lodging any further caveats. The court also ordered the plaintiff to be awarded damages for trespass and unlawful entry, and dismissed the counterclaim by the first defendant. The court further ordered the first and fourth defendants to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding to date, including the costs of the plaintiff’s summons.

Orders

Orders of the court

In the writ proceeding:

1. The Court declares that the Contract of Sale of Real Estate made on 1 July 2010 between the plaintiff as vendor and the first defendant, using the name Robert Stoney, as purchaser, referred to in paragraph 4 of the Statement of Claim, was rescinded by the plaintiff on 10 September 2013.

2. The Court declares that the plaintiff is entitled to possession of, and became, entitled to possession of, the land situated at and known as -

(a) 1119 Buchan-Ensay Road, Reedy Flat in Victoria, being the whole of the land more particularly described in Certificate of Title Volume 10626 Folio 504, Certificate of Title Volume 10626 Folio 505, and Certificate of Title Volume 10626 Folio 507, and one part of the land in Certificate of Title Volume 10626 Folio 503;

(b) 992 Buchan-Ensay Road, Reedy Flat in Victoria, being the remaining part of the land more particularly described in Certificate of Title Volume10626 Folio 503; and

(c) 470 Hammonds Road, Reedy Flat in Victoria, being the whole of the land more particularly described in Certificate of Title Volume 8202 Folio 223 - being the land referred to in paragraph 3 of the Statement of Claim (collectively referred to as “the land”) on 10 September 2013.

3. The first defendant by himself, his servants or agents, or howsoever otherwise is required to vacate the land and to deliver up possession of the land to the plaintiff, and to refrain from again entering upon the land while the plaintiff remains the registered proprietor of the land, or from grazing cattle thereon, with a stay of 30 days on the operation of this order to permit the removal of cattle, household effects and plant & equipment belonging to the plaintiff.

4. The caveat dated 2 September 2010 lodged at the Land Registry by the first defendant, using the name Robert John Bigo Stoney, and recorded by the second defendant in dealing number AH484908J on 9 September 2010 (“the caveat”), and the memorandum thereof entered on Certificates of Title Volume 10626 Folio 503, Volume 10626 Folio 504, Volume 10626 Folio 505, Volume 10626 Folio 507, and Volume 8202 Folio 223 (“the certificates of title”) be removed by the Registrar of Titles, and the Registrar of Titles is directed to amend the Register accordingly so as to give effect to this Order.

5. The first defendant be restrained, until 1 October 2014 or further order of the court, whether by himself, his servants or agents, or howsoever otherwise, from lodging any further caveat on any of the certificates of title, in respect of the same interest as specified in the caveat.

6. The counterclaim by the first defendant be dismissed, and the plaintiff have judgment on the counterclaim by the first defendant.

7. The first defendant pay the costs of the plaintiff of the proceeding to date in respect of the claim and the counterclaim, and including the costs of the plaintiff’s summons.

8. The plaintiff’s claims for damages be dealt with at the Directions Hearing fixed for 21 July 2014 at 9.30am in the Associate Judges’ Court 4, Ground Floor, 436 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne.

9. Liberty to apply is reserved.

In the originating motion proceeding:

1. The caveat dated 21 March 2014 lodged by the first, second, third and fourth defendants in the Land Titles Office and recorded in dealing number AK987232M (“the caveat”), and the memoranda thereof entered on Certificates of Title Volume 10626 Folio 503, Volume 10626 Folio 504, Volume 10626 Folio 505, Volume 10626 Folio 507 and Volume 8202 Folio 223 (“the certificates of title”), be removed, and the Registrar of Titles is directed to remove the caveat and to amend the Register accordingly so as to give effect to this Order.

2. The first, second, third and fourth defendants are restrained, until 1 October 2014 or further order of the court, by themselves, their servants or agents, or howsoever otherwise, from lodging any further caveat on any of the certificates of title in respect of the same interest as specified in the caveat.

3. The first and fourth defendants pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding to date, including the costs of the plaintiff’s summons filed on 29 May 2014.

4. The further hearing of the plaintiff’s summons dealing with its claim for compensation against the first and fourth defendants is adjourned to 21 July 2014 at 9.30am in the Associate Judges’ Court 4, Ground Floor, 436 Lonsdale Street, Melbourne.

5. Liberty to apply is reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.