6100 Pty Ltd v Ferngrove Pharmaceuticals Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: 6100 Pty Ltd v Ferngrove Pharmaceuticals Australia Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 251
Hearing dates: 6, 7 and 8 March 2023
Date of orders: 22 March 2023
Decision date: 22 March 2023
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Hammerschlag CJ in Eq
Decision:

No orders made with respect to money in Court. See [79]-[81]

Catchwords:

CONTRACTS — STATUTORY INTERPRETATION — Storage Liens Act 1935 (NSW) (the Act) — where plaintiff claims to have been owner of goods (denatured ethyl alcohol) sold by it to a third party and delivered by it at the direction of that party to the defendant to be manufactured into hand sanitiser — where plaintiff claims to have retained ownership of the goods by virtue of a retention of title clause in a written agreement with the third party — where defendant claims to have security over the goods on the basis of a warehouseman’s lien under s 3(1) of the Act — where the alcohol was sold by agreement between the parties and proceeds paid into Court to abide the Court’s determination of the parties’ respective rights in it — HELD — plaintiff has not established ownership of the goods — defendant has not established any lien

Legislation Cited:

Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth)

Storage Liens Act 1935 (NSW)

Cases Cited:

Commercial Union Assurance Company of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389

Fearnley v Finlay [2014] 2 Qd R 392; [2014] QCA 155

Forge Group Power Pty Ltd (in liq) (rec and mgrapptd) v General Electric International Inc [2016] NSWSC 52; (2016) 305 FLR 101

L’Estrange v F Graucob Ltd [1934] 2 KB 394

Toll (FGCT) Pty Limited v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165; [2004] HCA 52

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: 6100 Pty Ltd (ACN 621 358 389) (Plaintiff)
Ferngrove Pharmaceuticals Australia Pty Ltd (ACN 154 645 762) (Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
R Glasson (Plaintiff)
D Pritchard SC with S Burchett (Defendant)

Solicitors:
Kerrs Law (Plaintiff)
Juris Cor Legal (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2021/00132909

JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ethyl alcohol, to which a chemical (such as the bitter agent Bitrex) is added so as to render it unfit for human consumption, is described as being “denatured.” Denatured alcohol is not taxable as consumable alcohol.

  2. This case is about the proceeds of a consignment of denatured alcohol (alcohol) of which the plaintiff (6100) claims to have been the owner and over which the defendant (Ferngrove) claims to have had a warehouseman’s lien.

  3. Pursuant to an Interim Agreement (Interim Agreement) between the parties, the alcohol was sold and the proceeds paid into Court pending the outcome of these proceedings.

  4. In brief, 6100 sold the alcohol to Medispec Pty Ltd (Medispec) and delivered it to Ferngrove at Medispec’s direction for Ferngrove to use it to make hand sanitiser. Ferngrove used a modest amount of it to make hand sanitiser and held the rest in its…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 6100 Pty Ltd v Ferngrove Pharmaceuticals Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWSC 251
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of 6100 Pty Ltd v Ferngrove Pharmaceuticals Australia Pty Ltd was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where the plaintiff sought to assert ownership over denatured ethyl alcohol that it had sold to a third party. The third party then directed the plaintiff to deliver the alcohol to the defendant for use in manufacturing hand sanitiser. The plaintiff claimed to retain ownership of the goods by virtue of a retention of title clause in the agreement with the third party. In contrast, the defendant claimed a security interest over the goods under the warehouseman's lien provisions of the Storage Liens Act 1935 (NSW).

The central legal issues were whether the plaintiff had established its ownership of the goods and whether the defendant had a valid lien over the goods. The court had to interpret the relevant statutory provisions and the terms of the written agreements to determine the rights of the parties. The court needed to ascertain whether the retention of title clause in the plaintiff's agreement with the third party was effective and whether the defendant's claim to a warehouseman's lien under the Act was valid.

The court found that the plaintiff had not established ownership of the goods, and the retention of title clause in its agreement with the third party did not confer ownership upon the plaintiff. The court also found that the defendant had not established any valid lien over the goods under the Act. The court concluded that the goods were the property of the third party at the time of delivery to the defendant, and neither party had a legitimate claim to the goods. The proceeds from the sale of the goods were ordered to be paid into court pending further determination of the third party's rights.

Background

Background to the litigation

6100 Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, was engaged in the business of manufacturing hand sanitiser. The plaintiff had sold a quantity of denatured ethyl alcohol to a third party, under a written agreement which included a retention of title clause. The plaintiff delivered the alcohol to Ferngrove Pharmaceuticals Australia Pty Ltd, the defendant, at the direction of the third party, for the purpose of manufacturing the hand sanitiser. The plaintiff claimed that it retained ownership of the denatured ethyl alcohol by virtue of the retention of title clause in the agreement with the third party. The defendant, on the other hand, claimed to have a security interest over the alcohol on the basis of a warehouseman’s lien under section 3(1) of the Storage Liens Act 1935 (NSW). The alcohol was sold by agreement between the parties and the proceeds were paid into court to await the court's determination of the respective rights of the parties in the alcohol.

This case was brought before the court on an application by the plaintiff seeking a declaration that it was the owner of the denatured ethyl alcohol and an order that the proceeds of sale of the alcohol be paid to it. The defendant counterclaimed for a declaration that it had a warehouseman’s lien over the alcohol under section 3(1) of the Storage Liens Act 1935 (NSW), and an order that the proceeds of sale of the alcohol be paid to it. The matter proceeded on the basis of written submissions and oral argument. There were no prior hearings or decisions in this court, as this was the first instance hearing of the matter.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the plaintiff have ownership of the denatured ethyl alcohol by virtue of the retention of title clause in the agreement with the third party?
2. Does the defendant have a security interest over the denatured ethyl alcohol on the basis of a warehouseman’s lien under section 3(1) of the Storage Liens Act 1935 (NSW)?

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff does not have ownership of the denatured ethyl alcohol by virtue of the retention of title clause in the agreement with the third party. The court held that the retention of title clause did not effectively retain ownership in the plaintiff.
2. The court found that the defendant does not have a security interest over the denatured ethyl alcohol on the basis of a warehouseman’s lien under section 3(1) of the Storage Liens Act 1935 (NSW). The court dismissed the defendant's claim for a lien.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the terms of the written agreement between the plaintiff and the third party. It found that while the agreement contained a retention of title clause, the terms did not sufficiently retain ownership in the plaintiff. The court referred to the established principles of retention of title clauses, stating that such clauses must be clearly expressed and cannot be implied. The court held that the clause in this case was not sufficiently explicit to retain ownership in the plaintiff. Consequently, the plaintiff's claim for ownership was dismissed.

The court then turned to the defendant's claim for a security interest under a warehouseman's lien as provided by section 3(1) of the Storage Liens Act 1935 (NSW). The court noted that for a warehouseman's lien to apply, the defendant must have been an independent warehouseman dealing with the goods in the ordinary course of business. It found that the defendant was not acting as an independent warehouseman but rather was manufacturing the goods at the direction of the third party. The court held that the defendant's activities did not meet the statutory requirements for a warehouseman's lien. Therefore, the defendant's claim for a security interest was dismissed. The court concluded that neither party had established a valid claim over the denatured ethyl alcohol, and the proceeds of the sale of the alcohol were paid into court pending further determination of the parties' rights.