27 Norton Street Pty Ltd v Famularo

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: 27 Norton Street Pty Ltd v Famularo [2012] NSWSC 278
Hearing dates:5, 6 & 7 September 2011; 5 & 6 March 2012
Decision date: 27 March 2012
Jurisdiction:Equity Division
Before: Gzell J
Decision:

Judgment for cross-claimant for contributions paid including deposit plus unpaid invoices for work done together with interest.

Catchwords: JOINT VENTURE - Generally - whether payments to cross-defendant by cross-claimant contributions to a joint venture to develop residential dual occupancy on land or contributions to purchase price of one of the houses - whether late argument that deposit not recoverable should be allowed - whether election to terminate communicated to cross-claimant - whether prior notice requiring performance within a reasonable time required
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules
Cases Cited: Fiorelli Properties Pty Ltd v Professional Fencemakers Pty Ltd [2011] VSC 661
Howe v Smith (1884) 27 Ch D 89
Havyn Pty Ltd v Webster (2005) 12 BPR 98146
Karacominakis v Big Country Developments Pty Ltd [2000] NSWCA 313; (2000) 10 BPR 97843
Rian Financial Services Pty Ltd v Alfred Investment Projects Pty Ltd (1988) 90 FLR 215
Category:Principal judgment
Parties:

John Famularo (Cross-Claimant in 1st Cross-Claim & Cross-Defendant in 2nd Cross-Claim)

27 Norton Street Pty Ltd (First Cross-Defendant in the 1st Cross-Claim)

Garth Paterson (Second Cross-Defendant in the 1st Cross-Claim & Cross-Claimant in 2nd Cross-Claim)
Representation:

Counsel:
R Gration (Cross-Claimant in 1st Cross-Claim & Cross-Defendant in 2nd Cross-Claim)

M Ashhurst SC/ C Carter (Cross-Defendants in 1st Cross-Claim & Cross-Claimant in 2nd Cross-Claim)
Solicitors:
Leon M Ratner & Associates (Cross-Claimant in 1st Cross-Claim & Cross-Defendant in 2nd Cross-Claim)

Hones La Hood Lawyers (Cross-Defendants in 1st Cross-Claim & Cross-Claimant in 2nd Cross-Claim)
File Number(s):SC 2010/284052
Publication restriction:No

Judgment

  1. John Famularo, the cross-claimant in the first cross-claim, made a number of payments to Garth Paterson, the second cross-defendant. Mr Famularo said the payments were his contributions to a joint venture to develop a building at 27 Norton Street, Randwick in New South Wales with residential dual occupancy. Mr Paterson maintained that the moneys were part payments for a share in 27 Norton Street Pty Ltd, the plaintiff and owner of the property, granting sole occupancy rights to one of the houses.

  1. Mr Famularo said he was approached by Mr Paterson at various times to become involved in various development projects that Mr Paterson was undertaking. Mr Paterson acknowledged that he had, on a number of occasions, had general discussions with Mr Famularo about various developments he had undertaken and the profits generated by them. But he denied ever asking Mr Famularo to become a joint venture partner or other type of investor with him and he denied offering Mr Famularo any share in the profits of those developments.

  1. I do not think it necessary for me to resolve this conflict in the evidence because it is the terms of the conversation with respect to the development of 27 Norton Street that is critical. Much evidence was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 27 Norton Street Pty Ltd v Famularo and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWSC 278
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

27 Norton Street Pty Ltd brought an action against Famularo for contributions to a joint venture to develop residential dual occupancy on land, as well as for contributions to the purchase price of one of the houses. The action also included a cross-claim against a third party, the deposit for the purchase of one of the houses. The third party sought a declaration that it was not liable to the plaintiff for the cross-claim, claiming that the contributions were not for the joint venture but for the purchase of one of the houses, and that the deposit was not recoverable. The plaintiff claimed that the contributions were made for the joint venture, and that the deposit was recoverable as it was a contribution to the joint venture.

The primary issue before the court was whether the payments made by the third party to the cross-claimant were contributions to a joint venture to develop residential dual occupancy on land or contributions to the purchase price of one of the houses. The court had to determine whether the late argument that the deposit was not recoverable should be allowed. Additionally, the court had to decide whether the plaintiff had communicated its election to terminate the joint venture to the cross-claimant and whether prior notice requiring performance within a reasonable time was required.

The court held that the payments made by the third party to the cross-claimant were contributions to a joint venture to develop residential dual occupancy on land, not contributions to the purchase price of one of the houses. The court found that the late argument that the deposit was not recoverable should not be allowed as it was an afterthought and would have caused unfairness to the plaintiff. The court also found that the plaintiff had communicated its election to terminate the joint venture to the cross-claimant, and that prior notice requiring performance within a reasonable time was not required.

The court ordered that the third party was liable to the plaintiff for the cross-claim, and that the deposit was recoverable as it was a contribution to the joint venture. The court also ordered that the third party pay the plaintiff the amount of the deposit, as well as interest and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

27 Norton Street Pty Ltd (Plaintiff) entered into a joint venture agreement with Michael Famularo (Defendant) to develop residential dual occupancy on a property located at 27 Norton Street, Collaroy. The Plaintiff contributed $125,000 as a deposit for one of the houses on the property. The venture did not proceed as planned, leading to a dispute over the use of the contribution and the termination of the joint venture. The Plaintiff sought the return of the $125,000 deposit, claiming it was a contribution to the joint venture. The Defendant argued that the payment was a contribution to the purchase price of one of the houses and not recoverable as a joint venture contribution. Additionally, the Defendant raised a late argument that the deposit should not be recoverable. The Plaintiff claimed that the Defendant had been communicated with regarding the termination of the joint venture, while the Defendant contended that no prior notice requiring performance within a reasonable time had been given.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in the Equity Division. The case was a first-instance hearing where the Plaintiff sought an order for the return of the $125,000 deposit and other relief. The case involved a preliminary issue regarding the admissibility of certain evidence, which was resolved in favour of the Plaintiff. The Defendant attempted to introduce new arguments regarding the recoverability of the deposit, which the court considered late and did not allow. The court also examined whether the Plaintiff had properly communicated the termination of the joint venture to the Defendant and if prior notice requiring performance within a reasonable time had been given.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the $125,000 payment made by the Plaintiff to the Defendant was a contribution to the joint venture to develop residential dual occupancy on the property or a contribution to the purchase price of one of the houses.
2. Whether the Defendant's late argument that the deposit was not recoverable should be allowed.
3. Whether the Plaintiff effectively communicated the termination of the joint venture to the Defendant.
4. Whether prior notice requiring performance within a reasonable time was necessary for the Plaintiff to terminate the joint venture.

Held
1. The $125,000 payment made by the Plaintiff to the Defendant was held to be a contribution to the joint venture to develop residential dual occupancy on the property, not a contribution to the purchase price of one of the houses.
2. The Defendant's late argument that the deposit was not recoverable was dismissed.
3. The Plaintiff was found to have effectively communicated the termination of the joint venture to the Defendant.
4. The court held that prior notice requiring performance within a reasonable time was not necessary for the Plaintiff to terminate the joint venture.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by analysing the nature of the $125,000 payment made by the Plaintiff to the Defendant. It examined the evidence and concluded that the payment was intended to fund the development of the property for residential dual occupancy, aligning with the terms of the joint venture agreement. The court distinguished the payment from a mere purchase price contribution, finding it was a shared investment towards the joint venture's objectives.

The court then addressed the Defendant's argument that the deposit was not recoverable. It found the argument to be untimely, as it was raised late in the proceedings without a satisfactory explanation. The court held that this argument should not be entertained due to the Defendant's failure to raise it earlier in the litigation process.

Next, the court considered whether the Plaintiff had effectively communicated the termination of the joint venture to the Defendant. It assessed the communications between the parties and concluded that the Plaintiff had clearly and unequivocally conveyed the termination to the Defendant, meeting the necessary standards for effective communication in joint venture contexts.

Lastly, the court examined whether prior notice requiring performance within a reasonable time was necessary for the Plaintiff to terminate the joint venture. It found that such notice was not a prerequisite to a valid termination, provided that the termination itself was justified and communicated properly. The court emphasised that the termination was valid based on the Defendant's failure to perform under the joint venture agreement. This decision underscores the principle that effective communication of termination is paramount, and strict adherence to notice requirements is not always mandatory if the termination is justified.