2010910 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

2010910 (Refugee) [2025] ARTA 856 (20 March 2025)

DECISION AND  

REASONS FOR DECISION

Respondent:Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:  2010910

Tribunal:General Member G Sammon

Date:20 March 2025

Place:Sydney

Decision:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the application for a protection visa for reconsideration, in accordance with the order that the Applicant meets the following criteria:

·s 36(2)(a) of the Migration Act.

I, General Member G Sammon, certify that this is the Tribunal’s statement of decision and statement of reasons.
Statement made on 20 March 2025 at 9:06AM.

CATCHWORDS
REFUGEE – protection visa – Indonesia – economic conditions – new claims of disability and sexual orientation made in pre-hearing information form – homosexual man – application form completed by another person, with applicant uncomfortable with disclosing orientation – reasonable explanation and no adverse inference drawn – orientation hidden and no activities or relationships in home country, and some social activities and short-term relationships in Australia – no disclosure to family – country information – no national laws, but provincial and religious laws punishable by caning – moderate risk of societal and employment discrimination in all areas of country – cumulative effect of several kinds of discrimination – modification of behaviour not required – decision under review remitted

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5H(1)(a), 5J(1)(a), (2), (3)(a), (c)(vi), (4), (5), 5L, 5LA, 36(2)(a), 65, 367A(2)

Migration Regulation 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2

CASES

AKA24 v MIMA [2024] FedCFamC2G 1434

Scat v MIMIA [2003] FCAFC 80

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 369 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs[1] (the Delegate) on 30 June 2020 to refuse to grant the Applicant a protection visa under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Migration Act’ or ‘the Act’).

    [1] As was the then Minister’s then title.

  2. The Applicant who claims to be a national of Indonesia, applied for the visa on 5 April 2018. The Delegate refused to grant the visa on the basis that the Applicant was not a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations as outlined in s 36(2)(a) as a ‘refugee’ as that term is defined in the Act[2] or eligible for ‘complementary protection' under s 36(2)(aa) of the Act.

    [2] Section 5H.

  3. In summary, the basis for the Applicant’s application for a protection visa, as stated in his application made in April 2018, was that the:

    Currency in Indonesia is not in stable condition. It's make me feel hard to survive my life as I have to do more than one job to survive.

  4. In a pre-hearing information form signed by the Applicant on 7 December 2024, he raised new grounds for a protection visa not provided to the Department which administers the Act…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 2010910 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 856
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves an applicant from Indonesia who applied for a protection visa, citing new claims of disability and sexual orientation in a pre-hearing information form. The applicant's initial application for a protection visa, completed in April 2018, did not mention these claims, and was assisted by a co-worker due to the applicant's limited English proficiency and discomfort in disclosing his sexual orientation. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the applicant was a refugee under the Migration Act and if he qualified for complementary protection due to economic hardship. Additionally, the Tribunal had to consider whether the applicant had a reasonable explanation for not presenting his new claims to the delegate who initially refused his application for a protection visa.

The key legal issues included whether the new claims of disability and sexual orientation could be considered by the Tribunal, despite being presented several years after the delegate's decision, and if a reasonable explanation existed for this delay. Furthermore, the Tribunal had to assess whether the applicant's claims met the statutory definition of a refugee and if there was a real risk of significant harm in Indonesia that warranted complementary protection. The Tribunal also needed to evaluate the country information regarding the treatment of homosexuals and people with disabilities in Indonesia, including the risk of societal and employment discrimination.

The Tribunal found that the applicant had a reasonable explanation for not disclosing his sexual orientation and disability in his initial application, as he was assisted by a co-worker who was unaware of these personal details. The Tribunal noted that the applicant's English was not proficient at the time and he felt uncomfortable disclosing his sexual orientation. The Tribunal also considered the country information which indicated that while there were no national laws criminalising homosexuality, provincial and religious laws in Aceh province could result in punishment by caning. The Tribunal concluded that there was a moderate risk of societal and employment discrimination in Indonesia due to the cumulative effect of discrimination based on sexual orientation and disability. The Tribunal found that the applicant's claims met the definition of a refugee and there was a real risk of significant harm on return to Indonesia. Therefore, the Tribunal remitted the decision under review back to the delegate for reconsideration.

In light of the Tribunal's findings, the decision of the delegate to refuse the applicant a protection visa was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the delegate for reconsideration in light of the new evidence and claims presented by the applicant. The Tribunal did not make a final determination on the grant of a protection visa but directed the delegate to reassess the application based on the updated information.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant made his application to the then Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) on 30 June 2020, under the provisions of the Migration Act and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). The application may continue to be heard by the new Administrative Review Tribunal under transitional provisions in the Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No. 1) Act 2024 (Cth).BACKGROUND The Delegate accepted that the Applicant is a citizen of Indonesia, after providing his passport to the Department of Home Affairs (the Department) which administers the Act. I agree with this aspect of the Delegate’s decision. The Delegate accepted that the Applicant was born in Indonesia in [Year]. The Applicant expanded slightly on his grounds for seeking a protection visa in the relevant application form, by answering in the negative a question asking him if he experienced harm in Indonesia. He also answered in the negative a question asking him if he tried to move to another part of Indonesia, saying it would be the same if he moved everywhere in Indonesia. In answer to a question on the form about what the Applicant thought would happen to him if he returned to Indonesia he said:I will tension to survive because I do not have my rest enough because I need to do more job in a day. More than four years later, and after the Delegate had made a decision refusing to grant the Applicant a protection visa, in the Applicant’s response to a pre-hearing information form for the Tribunal signed 7 December 2024, the Applicant raised new grounds for protection, that he was a 'disability person with gay sexual orientation.’ The Applicant did not describe the disability he referred to. He said he needed protection from Australia so as not to experience discrimination such as to gain the same employment opportunities to improve his life. He said he was afraid to return to Indonesia as he was from Aceh province, which he said is one of the provinces in Indonesia where homosexuality is illegal under Islamic Sharia law and it is punishable by whipping or imprisonment. He also said that there were 'very thin' employment opportunities as a person with a disability.The Delegate’s decision The Delegate made the decision dated 30 June 2020 based on the claims for protection in the Applicant’s application for protection visa, but not, of course, contained in the Applicant’s response to the Tribunal’s pre-hearing information form, signed more than four years later. The Delegate first considered the Applicant's claims for a protection visa against the statutory definition of a 'refugee' contained in s 5J(1)(a) of the Act, that a person has a well- founded fear of persecution for the reasons in that provision as attached to this decision. The Delegate’s decision was that the Applicant's claims for a protection visa did not relate to any of those reasons and there was no other information before the Delegate to suggest that the Applicant would be subject to harm on return to Indonesia for one or more of those reasons. The Delegate was therefore not satisfied that the Applicant was a refugee and a person in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations as outlined in s 36(2)(a) of the Act.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant filed his application for review of the Delegate’s decision with the then AAT on the same day the decision was made, namely 30 June 2020.Evidence before the TribunalGrounds for a protection visa At the hearing, the Applicant reiterated the grounds for a protection visa he raised for the first time in his response to the pre-hearing information form signed 7 December 2024, that he was a gay person, and also had a disability, which [description of disability]. He said that because of that, people question his ability to work. For that reason, he maintained his claim for economic hardship if he returned to Indonesia. The Applicant said that he came from Aceh province in Indonesia where homosexuality is illegal. He said that he can get lashes or be subject to imprisonment for an offence of that kind. He said that once people realise he is gay, and due to his disability, he would not be able to get work in Indonesia. The Applicant said that he was born with the disability of [description of disability]. I observe for the sake of the record, that the [presence of the Applicant’s disability] was obvious at the hearing at which he appeared before me in person, including manifesting itself in [a specific result of that disability].Preparation of application for protection visa Given the discrepancy between the claims made for a protection visa in the Applicant’s application dated April 2018, and the grounds he relied upon at the hearing, I asked him who prepared his application for a protection visa. He said a co-worker at the [workplace] he worked at in [Town 1], Victoria helped him complete the form. The Applicant said his English was not good then. The Applicant could not remember the name of the person who helped him complete the form, and the Applicant did not pay the co-worker to assist the Applicant. The Applicant said that he did not tell the person who prepared the application form for the protection visa about his sexuality, because he did not feel comfortable in doing so. The Applicant said that he did not tell the person who completed the application form about his disability, but there was no reason why not. In contrast, the Applicant said that he prepared the response to the pre-hearing information form dated 7 December 2024 by himself. The Applicant explained that in Australia, he had made a friend who was not Indonesian, so he was forced to speak English. He said his English had improved since the date of the application for the protection visa (2018) and so was able to complete the 2024 form by himself and that he did not need assistance in doing so.Threshold issue - application of s 367A of the Migration Act The claims made by the applicant for a protection visa, of him being gay and having a disability were first raised on 7 December 2024, several years after the Delegate made the decision to refuse the Applicant’s application for a protection visa on 30 June 2020. On the face of it, that raises the application of s 367A of the Migration Act, of the new claims, and evidence for them not being presented to the Department's delegate. The operative effect of s 367A, contained in s 367A(2) is that the Tribunal is to draw an inference unfavourable to the credibility of the claim or evidence unless the Applicant has a reasonable explanation why the claim was not presented before the Delegate made the decision to refuse the protection visa.

Decision

Reasons for decision

He said he was afraid to return to Indonesia as he was from Aceh province, which he said is one of the provinces in Indonesia where homosexuality is illegal under Islamic Sharia law and it is punishable by whipping or imprisonment. He also said that there were 'very thin' employment opportunities as a person with a disability.The Delegate’s decision The Delegate made the decision dated 30 June 2020 based on the claims for protection in the Applicant’s application for protection visa, but not, of course, contained in the Applicant’s response to the Tribunal’s pre-hearing information form, signed more than four years later. The Delegate first considered the Applicant's claims for a protection visa against the statutory definition of a 'refugee' contained in s 5J(1)(a) of the Act, that a person has a well- founded fear of persecution for the reasons in that provision as attached to this decision. The Delegate’s decision was that the Applicant's claims for a protection visa did not relate to any of those reasons and there was no other information before the Delegate to suggest that the Applicant would be subject to harm on return to Indonesia for one or more of those reasons. The Delegate was therefore not satisfied that the Applicant was a refugee and a person in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations as outlined in s 36(2)(a) of the Act. The Delegate also considered application of the criteria for complementary protection under s 36(2)(aa) of the Act against the Applicant’s claim to fear economic hardship in Indonesia. The Delegate found that the claimed harm was not 'significant harm' within s 36(2A) of the Act and was not satisfied that there was a real risk the Applicant would suffer significant harm on return to Indonesia. The Delegate was therefore not satisfied that the Applicant was a person in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations as provided for in s 36(2)(aa) for complementary protection. The Delegate therefore refused to grant the Applicant a protection visa. The Applicant filed his application for review of the Delegate’s decision with the then AAT on the same day the decision was made, namely 30 June 2020.Evidence before the TribunalGrounds for a protection visa At the hearing, the Applicant reiterated the grounds for a protection visa he raised for the first time in his response to the pre-hearing information form signed 7 December 2024, that he was a gay person, and also had a disability, which [description of disability]. He said that because of that, people question his ability to work. For that reason, he maintained his claim for economic hardship if he returned to Indonesia. The Applicant said that he came from Aceh province in Indonesia where homosexuality is illegal. He said that he can get lashes or be subject to imprisonment for an offence of that kind. He said that once people realise he is gay, and due to his disability, he would not be able to get work in Indonesia. The Applicant said that he was born with the disability of [description of disability]. I observe for the sake of the record, that the [presence of the Applicant’s disability] was obvious at the hearing at which he appeared before me in person, including manifesting itself in [a specific result of that disability].Preparation of application for protection visa

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal began by considering whether the new claims of being a gay person with a disability were made in a reasonable time and whether a reasonable explanation exists for the delay in presenting these claims. The Tribunal noted that the Applicant had not raised these claims in his original application for a protection visa, which was completed with the help of a co-worker in 2018. The Applicant explained that he did not disclose his sexual orientation and disability to the co-worker due to discomfort and the absence of a need to do so. The Tribunal accepted the Applicant's explanation, finding that there was no reason to draw an inference unfavourable to the credibility of the new claims under s 367A of the Migration Act.

Next, the Tribunal assessed whether the Applicant has a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of his sexual orientation and disability if he returns to Indonesia. The Applicant testified that he is from Aceh province, where homosexuality is illegal under Islamic Sharia law and punishable by whipping or imprisonment. The Tribunal also considered evidence of the moderate risk of societal and employment discrimination against individuals with disabilities in Indonesia. The Tribunal was satisfied that the Applicant's fear of persecution based on his sexual orientation and disability was well-founded.

The Tribunal then examined whether the claimed harm from returning to Indonesia amounted to significant harm within the meaning of the Migration Act. The Applicant argued that he would face significant difficulties in finding employment due to his sexual orientation and disability. The Tribunal found that the cumulative effect of several kinds of discrimination would result in significant harm for the Applicant if he returned to Indonesia.

Finally, the Tribunal determined that the Applicant is a refugee or a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations. Given the findings of well-founded fear of persecution and significant harm, the Tribunal concluded that the Applicant met the criteria for a protection visa. The Tribunal remitted the decision under review for reconsideration by the Delegate, taking into account the new evidence and findings.