2002465 (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

2002465 (Migration) [2022] AATA 4237 (27 September 2022)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

REPRESENTATIVE:  Mr Besmellah Rezaee

CASE NUMBER:  2002465

MEMBER:Alison Murphy

DATE:27 September 2022

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision not to cancel the applicant’s Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa.

Statement made on 27 September 2022 at 8:01am

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – cancellation– subclass 155 (Five Year Resident Return) visa–applicant had given incorrect information – Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant is a Pakistani national – an Australian citizen wife and child – severe hardship to the applicant, his wife and daughter in Australia – best interests of the applicant’s daughter– time that has elapsed since the non-compliance – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, ss 46A, 101, 107, 109, 189
Migration Regulations 1994, r 2.41, Schedule 2

CASES
MIAC v Khadgi (2010) 190 FCR 248

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 378 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information.

statement of decision and reasons

application for review

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to cancel the applicant’s Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa under s 109(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The delegate cancelled the visa on the basis that it was considered the applicant had given incorrect information in his earlier protection visa application. The issue in the present case is whether that ground for cancellation is made out, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled.

  3. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 16 September 2022 to give evidence and present arguments. The Tribunal also received oral evidence from the applicant’s wife Ms [A]. The Tribunal hearing was conducted with the assistance of an interpreter in the Hazaragi and English languages.

  4. The applicant was represented in relation to the review.

  5. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be set aside.

    BACKGROUND

  6. The applicant is a [age]-year-old male from Pakistan who arrived in Australia by boat and without a valid visa on [date] February 2012. He identified himself as [Alias 1] born [Date 1], an Afghan national of Hazara ethnicity who had living in Pakistan as refugee. The applicant subsequently lodged an application for a protection visa and on the basis of the information he provided he was granted that visa on 14 August 2012. On 7 February 2019 he was granted a Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa and it is the cancellation of the resident return visa that is the subject of the current review.

  7. In 2018, several years after the grant of the protection visa but prior to the grant of the resident return visa, the Department formed the view that the applicant was a Pakistani national named [Name 1]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 2002465 (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 4237
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a review by the Tribunal of a decision to cancel the applicant's Subclass 155 (Five Year Resident Return) visa. The applicant, a male from Pakistan, had initially arrived in Australia in 2012 without a valid visa and was granted a protection visa based on information provided that he was an Afghan national with a well-founded fear of persecution. Subsequently, in 2019, the Department formed the view that the applicant was a Pakistani national named [Name 1] born [Date 2]. This led to a notice of intention to cancel his resident return visa under s 116(1AA) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) due to concerns about his identity. The applicant provided Pakistani identity documents, which satisfied the delegate of his identity as [Name 1] born [Date 2] and a national of Pakistan. However, a subsequent notice of intention to cancel the visa was issued under s 109 of the Act, alleging non-compliance with s 101(b) due to incorrect information provided in his original protection visa application regarding his name, date and place of birth, citizenship, and circumstances in Pakistan.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant had failed to comply with the provisions of the Act as alleged in the notice, and if so, whether the cancellation of his visa was warranted. Specifically, the Tribunal considered whether the incorrect information provided in the protection visa application had a material bearing on the decision to grant that visa, the circumstances under which the non-compliance occurred, and the present circumstances of the visa holder, including his contributions to the community and the potential hardship to his Australian citizen wife and daughter. The Tribunal also had to assess the validity of the notice issued under s 107 of the Act and whether it adequately particularised the alleged non-compliance.

The Tribunal found that while the applicant had indeed provided incorrect information in his protection visa application, this information had little bearing on the decision to grant the visa, as the delegate had already noted the applicant had no personal recollections of Afghanistan and his Hazara race, Shia religion, and residence in Pakistan were not in dispute. The Tribunal accepted that the applicant, a young male at the time, was advised by people smugglers not to disclose his true identity to avoid issues with the Australian government, which led him to provide incorrect details to distance himself from his Pakistani identity documents. Despite this deliberate provision of incorrect information weighing in favour of cancellation, the Tribunal gave significant weight to the applicant's circumstances. He had resided in Australia for over ten years, was married to an Australian citizen, had an Australian citizen daughter, and his wife relied on him for significant practical, emotional, and financial support due to a serious car accident. The applicant was also a blood donor, a member of community organisations, and had consistently paid taxes.

Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant's visa should be set aside. The Tribunal was satisfied that the notice issued under s 107 complied with statutory requirements and that the applicant had failed to comply with s 101(b). However, when considering the discretionary factors, particularly the severe hardship to the applicant, his wife, and daughter, and the time that had elapsed since the non-compliance, the Tribunal determined that cancellation was not the appropriate course of action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be set aside.BACKGROUND The applicant is a [age]-year-old male from Pakistan who arrived in Australia by boat and without a valid visa on [date] February 2012. He identified himself as [Alias 1] born [Date 1], an Afghan national of Hazara ethnicity who had living in Pakistan as refugee. The applicant subsequently lodged an application for a protection visa and on the basis of the information he provided he was granted that visa on 14 August 2012. On 7 February 2019 he was granted a Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa and it is the cancellation of the resident return visa that is the subject of the current review. In 2018, several years after the grant of the protection visa but prior to the grant of the resident return visa, the Department formed the view that the applicant was a Pakistani national named [Name 1] born [Date 2].This led to the Department undertaking an identity assessment and seeking further information from the applicant as to his identity. On 12 August 2019, a delegate of the Minister issued the applicant with a Notice of Intention to Consider Cancellation of his resident return visa under s 116(1AA) of the Act (the first NOICC) on the basis that the delegate was not satisfied as to the applicant’s identity. In response to that notice, the applicant provided information indicating that he was the holder of Pakistani identity documents under the name of [Name 1] born [Date 2] as the Department suspected. Those documents included a Pakistani Computerised National Identity Card, a Pakistani birth certificate and a copy of his Pakistani secondary school certificate indicating he was born in Quetta, Pakistan on [Date 2] and attended school in that city. These documents satisfied the delegate that the applicant’s correct identity was [Name 1] born [Date 2] and that he was a national of Pakistan and the delegate did not proceed to cancel the visa under s 116(1AA). On 23 October 2019, a delegate of the Minister issued the applicant with a Notice of Intention to Consider Cancellation of his resident return visa under s 109 of the Act (the second NOICC) on the basis that he did not comply with s 101(b) of the Act because he gave incorrect information in his protection visa application in the following instances:·at question 1 (when he stated his name was [Name 2] instead of [Name 1]);·at question 4 (when he stated that he had not been known by any other name);·at question 8 (when he gave his date of birth as [Date 1] instead of [Date 2]);·at question 9 (when he stated he was born in [Afghanistan] instead of Quetta, Pakistan);·at question 20 (when he stated his citizenship at birth was Afghan);·at question 22 (when he stated that he did not hold any other citizenship);·at question 40 (when he stated that he was seeking protection so he did not have to return to Afghanistan);·at questions 43, 45, 46, 47, 48 (when he referred to an attached statement in which he described his experiences living in Pakistan as a Hazara and a Shia living illegally in that country).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant sought a review of the decision to cancel the visa from this Tribunal. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be set aside. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Section 109(1) of the Act allows the Minister to cancel a visa if the visa holder has failed to comply with ss 101, 102, 103, 104, 105 or 107(2) of the Act. Broadly speaking, these sections require non-citizens to provide correct information in their visa applications and passenger cards, not to provide bogus documents and to notify the Department of any incorrect information of which they become aware and of any relevant changes in circumstances. The exercise of the cancellation power under s 109 of the Act is conditional on the Minister issuing a valid notice to the visa holder under s 107 of the Act, providing particulars of the alleged non-compliance. Where a notice is issued that does not comply with the requirements in s 107, the power to cancel the visa does not arise. Extracts of the Act relevant to this case are attached to this decision. In the present matter, the Tribunal is satisfied that the delegate had reached the necessary state of mind to engage s 107 and that the notice issued under s 107 complied with the statutory requirements.Did the notice comply with the requirements in s 107? The notice sets out in some detail the information given by the applicant in his protection visa application that is now said to be incorrect, as well as the reasons the Department formed that view. It is not suggested by the applicant or his representative that the notice is deficient or invalid. I am satisfied that information is set out in enough detail to allow the applicant to understand and respond to the non-compliance allegation. I am satisfied that the delegate had reached the necessary state of mind to engage s 107 and that the notice issued under s 107 complied with the statutory requirements.Was there non-compliance as described in the s 107 notice? The issue before the Tribunal is whether there was non-compliance in the way described in the s 107 notice, being the manner particularised in the notice, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled. The non-compliance identified and particularised in the s 107 notice was non-compliance with s 101(b). The notice alleges that the following declarations made by the applicant in her protection visa were incomplete or incorrect in respect of questions 1, 4, 8, 9, 20, 22, 40, 43, 45, 46, 47 and 48. In his response to the NOICC, the applicant appeared to acknowledge that he gave incorrect information in each of the respects set out in the notice:·at question 1 (when he stated his name was [Name 2] instead of [Name 1]) the applicant acknowledges this was incorrect in that his Pakistani identity documents record his name as [Name 1] but states he was in fact known by his family as [Name 1] following a childhood illness which caused his parents to accept the advice of religious leaders to change his name;·at questions 43, 45, 46, 47, 48 (when he referred to an attached statement in which he described his experiences living in Pakistan as a Hazara and a Shia living illegally in that country). In essence the applicant acknowledged he was not living illegally in Pakistan as stated but maintains that his experiences as a Hazara Shia as described in that statement are correct.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 7 November 2019, the applicant provided a statutory declaration dated 4 November 2019 from [name deleted], said to be the applicant’s brother. In that declaration [his brother] states that when the applicant was young he was known as [Name 1], but that due to some health problems it was suggested by local religious leaders that his name should be changed to ward off further health issues. Their parents agreed and the applicant’s name was changed to [Name 2] but no official documents exist to prove this. The covering email from the applicant’s representative indicates that it was send in relation to second NOICC, but there do not otherwise appear to be any substantive submissions as to the applicant’s citizenship or the information set out in the second NOICC.The cancellation decision On 4 February 2020 a delegate decided to cancel the applicant’s visa on the basis that he had provided incorrect information in the manner set out in the s 107 notice. In doing so the delegate considered the discretionary factors contained in the Department’s Procedures Advice Manual (PAM3) ‘General visa cancellation powers’ but concluded the visa should be cancelled. In considering Australia’s international obligations, the delegate noted that an International Treaties Obligations Assessment would be completed to assess whether the applicant would be at risk of harm in Pakistan before he was removed to that country and therefore a decision to cancel his visa would not necessarily cause him to be returned to Pakistan in breach of Australia’s non-refoulement obligations. For this reason the delegate did not make their own assessment of those obligations. The applicant sought a review of the decision to cancel the visa from this Tribunal. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be set aside. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Section 109(1) of the Act allows the Minister to cancel a visa if the visa holder has failed to comply with ss 101, 102, 103, 104, 105 or 107(2) of the Act. Broadly speaking, these sections require non-citizens to provide correct information in their visa applications and passenger cards, not to provide bogus documents and to notify the Department of any incorrect information of which they become aware and of any relevant changes in circumstances. The exercise of the cancellation power under s 109 of the Act is conditional on the Minister issuing a valid notice to the visa holder under s 107 of the Act, providing particulars of the alleged non-compliance. Where a notice is issued that does not comply with the requirements in s 107, the power to cancel the visa does not arise. Extracts of the Act relevant to this case are attached to this decision. In the present matter, the Tribunal is satisfied that the delegate had reached the necessary state of mind to engage s 107 and that the notice issued under s 107 complied with the statutory requirements.Did the notice comply with the requirements in s 107?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Whether the decision to grant a visa or immigration clear the visa holder was based, wholly or partly, on incorrect information or a bogus document: The decision to grant the applicant was made after a delegate found the applicant to be a refugee on the basis that he was a [age]-year-old male born in [Afghanistan] who held a well-founded fear of persecution due to his Hazara race and his Shia religion rather than a [age]-year-old Afghan Hazara born in Quetta, Pakistan where his family did not hold citizenship. The applicant’s Hazara race, Shia religion and residence in Pakistan are not in dispute and the delegate noted in the decision record that the applicant had no personal recollections of Afghanistan. The Tribunal considers that had the correct information about the applicant’s name and date and place of birth been known, the applicant would still have been granted the protection visa. For these reasons the Tribunal considers the incorrect information had little if any bearing on the decision to grant the visa and this factor weighs against the cancellation of the visa. The circumstances in which the non-compliance occurred: At the time the incorrect information was provided in 2012, the applicant was a [age] male who had travelled to Australia by boat with the assistance of people smugglers. At hearing he gave evidence that he was told by the people smugglers not to tell the truth about his Pakistani identity documents otherwise he would be in trouble with the Australian government. I accept he was advised by the people smugglers not to disclose his correct identity details on the basis that would enable the Department to link him to his Pakistani identity documents and result in the visa being refused. Although that advice was wrong, it resulted in the applicant giving incorrect information about his identity to distance himself from his Pakistani identity documents. The applicant states he was also advised to make himself appear younger than he was in order to obtain more favourable treatment and I accept that to be the case. The Tribunal considers that the applicant’s deliberate provision of incorrect information about his identity weighs in favour of the cancellation of the visa. The present circumstances of the visa holder and his contribution to the community: The applicant has lived in Australia for more than ten years. He is married to an Australian citizen and they have a [daughter], [Miss B], also an Australian citizen. The applicant’s wife was involved in a serious car accident in 2014 and requires the applicant’s assistance to undertake household tasks and look after their child. The applicant is a blood donor as well as a member of [Organisation 1] and [a charity organisation]. ATO documents indicate that he has paid taxes and completed tax returns for all of the time he has been in Australia. Prior to the cancellation of his visa, he was also sending money back to Pakistan for the support of his family there. At hearing he impressed as being an honest and thoughtful witness who is committed to looking after his family and it was clear that his wife relies on his greatly for practical, emotional and financial support.