Decision
Reasons for decision
The Tribunal has considered the country information provided by the applicant and has also undertaken its own research. It notes that country information from DFAT indicates that women face a moderate risk of family and sexual violence, and this risk increases for members of vulnerable communities including those in rural areas, conservative religious groups, and in Syrian refugee communities.[7] The Tribunal also notes that gender discrimination remains rife in Lebanon, particularly in relation to divorce, citizenship, inheritance, property and child custody.[8] The Gender Working Group Gender Statistical Profile for Lebanon dated June 2023 confirms high percentages of women suffering domestic violence.[9] The Arab Centre Washington DC report called ‘The harrowing state of women’s rights in Lebanon’ states “There are four issues that affect Lebanese women: the existence of a religious personal code, a gendered nationality law, domestic violence, and child marriage”.[10] Women are not adequately protected from domestic violence under Lebanese law.[11] Husbands can put their wives’ names at relevant international travel points and thus prevent them from travelling without permission.[12] [7] 'DFAT Country Information Report: Lebanon' (DFAT Report), Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, 26 June 2023 at 3.62. [8] DFAT Report at 3.53; A Legal Guide to Being a Lebanese Woman, PeaceWomen (3 December 2010) [9] ‘Gender Statistical Profile Lebanon’ June 2023, Gender Working Group, pp 4 – 6 < [10] Rola El-Husseini, ‘The Harrowing State of Women’s Rights in Lebanon’, Arab Centre Washington DC (1 May 2023) <The Harrowing State of Women’s Rights in Lebanon (arabcenterdc.org)> [11] Unequal and Unprotected Women’s Rights Under Lebanese Personal Status Laws, Human Rights Watch (2015) p 102.[12] DFAT Report at 5.21; A Legal Guide to Being a Lebanese Woman, PeaceWomen (3 December 2010) <>The Tribunal has considered the absence of persuasive evidence that [Husband A] has any intention to harm, harass or even contact the applicant at all in Lebanon. Despite significant deficiencies in the State’s ability to prevent or protect women from domestic violence, considering the specific circumstances of the applicant’s case, and the speculative nature of the applicant’s evidence, the Tribunal does not find the applicant would face a real chance of serious harm from [Husband A] if she returned to Lebanon now or in the reasonably foreseeable future. The Tribunal does not accept [Husband A] has put the applicant on an international travel watchlist. While there are discriminatory laws of which [Husband A] has the ability to take advantage of under Lebanese law, there is no persuasive evidence that [Husband A] would take advantage of his position as a Lebanese male such that the applicant faces a real chance of serious harm from him. For the above reasons the Tribunal does not accept the applicant faces a real chance of serious harm from [Husband A]. The Tribunal finds the chance of harm is speculative only.Separated womanThe Tribunal has considered whether the applicant faces a real chance of serious harm from the Christian community or the wider community in Lebanon as a result of being a woman who has left her husband. While this claim was raised in the statutory declaration provided at time of lodging her protection visa application, the Tribunal notes the applicant did not raise a claim of social ostracism or discrimination due to her status as a separated woman or woman who has left their husband. Rather, during the hearing she stated that her fears related to harm from [Husband A].Country information indicates that separation and divorce in Lebanese society is no longer considered a stigma and, as at information published in 2022, 34% of marriages in Lebanon end in divorce.[13] Maronite women can and do leave their husbands, although some may wait until children are older to do so.[14] [13] Rise in breakups and divorce in Lebanon mirrors socio-economic changes across the Arab world, Arab News (10 September 2022) < [14] Interview: Women Unequal Under Lebanon’s Law, Human Rights Watch (19 January 2015) < Considering the country information, and the fact that the applicant did not raise this claim during the hearing, despite being specifically asked why she feared returning to Lebanon, the Tribunal finds there is no persuasive evidence the applicant faces a real chance of serious harm for reason of being a separated woman who has left her husband. As such, the Tribunal finds the applicant does not face a real chance of serious harm for this reason.The applicant has also claimed that she is unable to divorce in Lebanon, either due to [Husband A’s] refusal to divorce her, or because the law does not permit divorce for Maronite Christians. As stated above, there is no persuasive evidence that [Husband A] refuses to divorce the applicant. The applicant has never tried to find out if he would agree to a divorce. In any case, the Tribunal does not accept that the applicant’s inability to get divorced constitutes serious harm. Section 5J(4)(b) of the Act requires the Tribunal to consider whether the persecution involves serious harm. Section 5J(5) defines ‘serious harm’ for the purposes of s 5J(4)(b). It sets out a non-exhaustive list of types and levels of harm that will meet the serious harm threshold. For the purposes of s 5J(4), s 5J(5) provides that the following are instances of serious harm: (a) a threat to the person’s life or liberty; (b) significant physical harassment of the person; (c) significant physical ill-treatment of the person; (d) significant economic hardship that threatens the person’s capacity to subsist; (e) denial of access to basic services, where the denial threatens the person’s capacity to subsist; (f) denial of capacity to earn a livelihood of any kind, where the denial threatens the person’s capacity to subsist. The Tribunal has considered the applicant’s personal circumstances. It notes she is currently in a de facto relationship, and she has registered this relationship with the NSW authorities. It also notes that divorce is no longer considered a stigma in Lebanon. On the applicant’s oral evidence, her family have been supportive of her decision to leave [Husband A]. The applicant fled to her sister’s house after incidents of abuse from [Husband A]. While the Tribunal accepts that under Lebanese law the applicant may be unable to get divorced, the Tribunal is not satisfied that in the applicant’s circumstances this constitutes serious harm. Conflict and war in LebanonDuring the hearing the applicant reiterated her claim that the security situation in Lebanon is dire. She stated that the conflict extends to the whole of Lebanon and that it was impossible to travel to Lebanon at present. The Tribunal accepts that the security situation in Lebanon has been in constant and rapid decline and that Israel and Lebanon are at war. The Tribunal also notes information on the DFAT website which advises Australians not to travel to Lebanon due to the volatile security situation and the risk of the security situation deteriorating further.[15] The Tribunal notes that rocket and missile fire commenced in southern Lebanon, and has spread to other areas in Lebanon.[16] According to the Lebanese health ministry, the death toll in Lebanon from Israel’s bombing is more than 2,653, with thousands more injured and others missing.[17] The Tribunal also notes from the post-hearing submission dated 8 October 2024 that the applicant’s sister has been displaced from her home because of the war. Considering the significant escalation of hostilities with Israel in recent weeks resulting in the displacement of over 1 million people,[18] and DFAT’s assessment that Israeli military airstrikes in southern Beirut and other locations and Israeli military ground operations in southern Lebanon are likely to continue,[19] the Tribunal accepts there is a real chance the applicant will be a victim of the military action.[15] [16] Ibid. [17] Zena Chamas, ‘Lebanese Australians grieve family members killed in Israeli attacks on Beirut and southern Lebanon’, ABC News (28 October 2024) < [18] How is Lebanon’s cash-strapped government responding to war?, AlJazeera (17 October 2024) < [19] During the hearing the Tribunal put to the applicant that any harm arising from the war with Israel did not appear to be targeted towards her personally, nor did the harm appear to arise for a refugee reason. The applicant agreed that the deteriorating security situation could affect anyone in Lebanon; it was not specific to her. The Tribunal notes from the country information that certain groups in Lebanon are targeted by Israeli forces. The Tribunal notes that while airstrikes have taken place across many areas in Lebanon, the majority appear to be concentrated in southern Lebanon and Beirut.[20] The Tribunal notes a recent report regarding an apparent Israeli airstrike on a compound housing Lebanese journalists.[21] Furthermore, Israel has carried out airstrikes in the northern city of Tripoli, targeting Hamas members.[22] In terms of how the war and mass displacement has affected women in Lebanon, the Tribunal notes that maintaining decent health and hygiene is challenging for women and girls experiencing menstruation or pregnancy.[23] The applicant has not provided any evidence that she is pregnant. [20] Israeli attacks on Lebanon in maps and charts: Live tracker, AlJazeera (24 September 2024) < International organisations condemn Israel's fatal strike on journalists, ABC News (26 October 2024) < Israeli air strike on northern Lebanon kills Hamas commander and his family, AlJazeera (5 October 2024) < [23] Escalating hostilities in Lebanon have gendered impact on women and girls, Women’s, Children’s and Adolescents’ Health (27 September 2024) < Furthermore, the Tribunal has not located country information indicating that failed asylum seekers attract any particular stigma upon return to Lebanon. According to the latest DFAT Report, it is not a crime for Lebanese citizens to seek asylum abroad.[24] A failed asylum seeker would only come to the attention of authorities if they had an existing stop order against them.[25] As stated above, the Tribunal does not find there is a real chance [Husband A] has had a stop order imposed on the applicant.[24] DFAT Report at 5.26. [25] Ibid. Regarding whether the applicant faces a heightened profile in the context of the war for any reason, the Tribunal has considered the applicant’s personal circumstances. It notes she has a sister in Lebanon, with whom she has previously resided. On her oral evidence, her sister is still in Lebanon. The Tribunal was informed in the post-hearing submission dated 8 October 2024 that the applicant’s sister remains in Lebanon, albeit she has been internally displaced by the war. The Tribunal finds the applicant would not be alone in Lebanon, as she could reside with her sister and her sister’s family. The Tribunal acknowledges that this would be a less than ideal situation considering the family is displaced, however the Tribunal finds the applicant would have the protection of her family in Lebanon. She would not be a woman on her own. Furthermore, she would not be returning to Lebanon to work in a hospital or as a journalist. On the evidence, her status as a failed asylum seeker would not come to the attention of anyone.The Tribunal has considered the post-hearing submission dated 3 October 2024 which submits that the applicant falls into the particular social group of ‘women in Lebanon’ and is therefore at a greater risk of harm and significantly more vulnerable than the remainder of the residents in the country. The submission also states that the applicant fits into the particular social groups of ‘victim of domestic violence’, ‘women who are unable to obtain a divorce in Lebanon’, ‘women who are unable to depart Lebanon due to travel bans’ and ‘women returning to country during war after prolonged absence’. While the post-hearing submission makes these assertions, they do not provide any explanation as to why the applicant is at a greater risk of harm because of her membership of these groups. The submissions do not include or reference any country information. The Tribunal finds they are unsubstantiated assertions made by the applicant’s representative. The Tribunal also notes that while the representative stated in his post-hearing submission dated 3 October 2024 that the applicant was more vulnerable than the general population, no evidence from the applicant (for example a post-hearing written statement) has been provided to the Tribunal to substantiate the representative’s submission.The Tribunal has also considered the representative’s submission dated 8 October 2024 regarding the deteriorating situation in Lebanon and the human cost of war. The Tribunal does not doubt that the war with Israel has had a profound and multifaced impact on civilians. However, considering the applicant’s personal circumstances, the Tribunal does not accept she has a heightened profile over the general population. On the country information, and considering the lack of persuasive evidence, the Tribunal does not accept the representative’s submission that the applicant is at a greater risk of harm in conflict between Lebanon and Israel because of her membership of any particular social group. The Tribunal does not find that the generalised violence in Lebanon would impact the applicant differentially due to her sex, religion, nationality, or any other refugee protection reason in s 5J(1)(a) of the Act. For the above reasons, the Tribunal does not accept the applicant has a well-founded fear of persecution for any of the 5 refugee protection reasons in s 5J(1)(a) of the Act. Economic claimsDuring the hearing the applicant stated that if she returns to Lebanon she may not be able to find work considering she is now [age] years old and there is an economic crisis. She has been in Australia for 7 years and has lost work contacts in Lebanon. She said that it is hard for women to find work. In Australia she has been gainfully employed for many years. The deteriorating economic and labour market conditions in Lebanon, coupled with rising prices of essential goods and services, such as fuel and food, have made it extremely challenging for individuals to make ends meet. According to a 2021 Gallup poll 85% of Lebanese respondents reported struggling to meet their financial needs, with 62% characterising their financial situation as “very difficult”.[26] [26] Arab States Employment and Social Outlook – Trends 2024, International Labour Organization (2024) < The Tribunal put to the applicant that no legal restrictions limit women’s engagement in income-generating activities. The law does not distinguish between women and men in employment, and it provides for equal pay for women and men.[27] The depression of the Lebanese economy impacts everyone in Lebanon. The applicant responded that she would particularly be affected because of her age. According to the 2023 DFAT Report on Lebanon, international media reports estimate that about a third of the labour force is unemployed.[28] According to International Labour Organization (ILO) data, the youth unemployment rate (people aged 15 to 24 years old) was 25% in 2021, compared with 12.5% overall.[29] According to UNICEF, youth unemployment increased to 48% in 2022, almost twice the adult unemployment rate which was at 25.6% in 2022.[30] Many young Lebanese people study abroad but do not return to Lebanon because of more favourable employment prospects, higher wages and superior working conditions available to them in foreign countries.[31] The country information before the Tribunal indicates that, in fact, young people are disproportionately affected by the economic crisis in Lebanon. The Tribunal finds the applicant, who is [age] years old and has many years of work experience in Lebanon and Australia, would not face the same barriers to finding employment as young people in Lebanon.[27] DFAT Report at 3.54. [28] DFAT Report at 2.11.[29] DFAT Report at 2.11. [30] UNICEF Lebanon (2022) < [31] Arab States Employment and Social Outlook – Trends 2024, International Labour Organization (2024) < p 52. Furthermore, the Tribunal has considered whether the applicant faces a real chance of being denied the opportunity to work because of her sex. The Tribunal notes that while women face considerable societal obstacles to gaining employment,[32] these obstacles may arise as a result of men exercising control over female relatives.[33] As stated above, the Tribunal does not find [Husband A] poses a real chance of serious harm to the applicant and, for the same reasons, the Tribunal does not find that [Husband A] would prevent the applicant from finding work. [32] DFAT Report 3.54.[33] DFAT Report 3.54. According to the Global Gender Gap 2024 Insight Report, published in June 2024, gender parity in technical and professional roles is higher than 70% in 7 economies in the Middle East and North Africa, including in Lebanon.[34] As stated above, the applicant has worked in Lebanon in various positions for many years. There is no persuasive evidence before the Tribunal that there is a real chance she would be denied the opportunity to work, or would face economic hardship, for reason of her sex. [34] Global Gender Gap 2024 Insight Report World Economic Forum (June 2024) < p 24.On the country information before the Tribunal, it does not accept the applicant would be disproportionately affected by the economic crisis because of her age or sex. Rather, high levels of unemployment stem from the wider economic crisis which affects most people in Lebanon.[35] [35] DFAT Report at 2.12. As such, the Tribunal does not accept the applicant faces a real chance of serious harm, including significant economic hardship, denial of capacity to earn a livelihood of any kind, or denial of access to basic services, for the essential and significant reason of any of the 5 refugee protection reasons in s 5J(1)(a) of the Act. Requirement to apply for a partner visa offshoreThe Tribunal has considered the claim in the applicant’s statement dated 17 September 2024 that being forced to depart Australia and apply for a Partner visa from outside Australia would be tantamount to persecution. The Tribunal put to the applicant during the hearing that this did not appear to be persecution arising from the actions of the government, an individual, or anyone else in Lebanon, rather it appeared to be a consequence of Australian immigration laws. The applicant did not have any comment on the legal issue, rather she reiterated that she would apply for a partner visa offshore, but in Lebanon her partner wouldn’t be recognised as her lawful husband. Considering the applicant’s oral evidence that she has already applied for an onshore partner visa on the basis of her de facto relationship with her partner, the Tribunal does not consider their de facto status would prevent her from applying for a partner visa offshore. In any case, the Tribunal does not consider the applicant faces a real chance of persecution if obliged to apply for a Partner visa offshore considering there is no “persecutor” involved, and it is the consequences of Australian law, not Lebanese law, that would require the applicant to apply for a partner visa offshore. For the reasons given above, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant is a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under s 36(2)(a).Complementary protectionHaving concluded that the applicant does not meet the refugee criterion in s 36(2)(a), the Tribunal has considered the alternative criterion in s 36(2)(aa). Section 36(2)(aa) refers to a ‘real risk’ of an applicant suffering significant harm. In MIAC v SZQRB (2013) 210 FCR 505, the ‘real risk’ test was held to impose the same standard as the ‘real chance’ test applicable to the assessment of ‘well-founded fear’ in the Refugee Convention definition and that reasoning appears equally applicable to the refugee criterion in s 5J(1)(b) of the Act. On the basis of the findings above, and for the same reasons as referred to above, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant faces a real risk of significant harm from [Husband A] for reason of having left him, nor is the Tribunal satisfied the applicant faces a real risk of significant harm as a separated woman. In relation to the applicant’s claim that she will be unable to obtain a divorce in Lebanon, the Tribunal is not satisfied this constitutes significant harm as defined in s 36(2A). Considering the applicant’s personal circumstances, namely that she is currently in a de facto relationship, she has the support of her family in Lebanon, and the fact that separation is becoming more and more common in Lebanon, the Tribunal is not satisfied that any level of anxiety the applicant may feel as a woman in a de facto relationship (and not a legal marriage) would reach the necessary level of severity to constitute significant harm. In relation to the applicant’s claims regarding the economy, security situation and war in Lebanon, for the reasons set out above, the Tribunal considers that the real risk of being affected by the poor economy or war is one faced by the population generally and not by the applicant personally such that s 36(2B)(c) applies and there is taken not to be a real risk she will suffer significant harm in Lebanon for these reasons.In relation to the applicant’s claim that if she is removed from Australia she will be required to apply for a partner visa offshore, the Tribunal finds this does not constitute significant harm as there is no relevant act or omission, rather, the applicant’s decision to apply for a partner visa offshore would be a consequence of the act of being removed, and a consequence of Australia’s immigration laws.The Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant is a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under s 36(2)(aa).Member of the same family unit There is no suggestion that the applicant satisfies s 36(2) on the basis of being a member of the same family unit as a person who satisfies s 36(2)(a) or (aa) and who holds a protection visa. Accordingly, the applicant does not satisfy any of the criteria in s 36(2).Final commentThe Tribunal is sympathetic to the applicant’s situation. It notes she has been living and working in Australia for the past 7 years, and she has been in a relationship with an Australian citizen for approximately 4 years. The Tribunal notes the security situation in Lebanon has rapidly deteriorated, and that the Australian government is recommending Australian citizens to leave Lebanon as soon as possible. The Tribunal has considered referring this matter to the Minister for intervention under s 351 of the Act. However, the Tribunal notes that the Minister has considered that it is inappropriate to consider ministerial intervention requests from persons who may be eligible to apply for a partner visa. Considering the applicant has applied onshore for a partner visa, it is the Tribunal’s firm opinion that, in the circumstances, there are compelling reasons for the grant of an onshore partner visa to the applicant.DECISIONThe Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a protection visa.Date of hearing: 26 September 2024Representative for the Applicant: Mr Simar Hermis (MARN: 1464902)