1910122 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

1910122 (Refugee) [2021] AATA 780 (15 February 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1910122

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   Afghanistan

MEMBER:Christopher Smolicz

DATE:15 February 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Adelaide

DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision not to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 866 (Protection) visa.

Statement made on 15 February 2021 at 11:04 am

CATCHWORDS
REFUGEE – cancellation – Subclass 866 (Protection) visa – Afghanistan – incorrect information provided in protection application – false identity – not disclosing that he was known by another name – an ongoing land dispute with the village head – respected member of the Hazara community – best interests of Australian citizen children – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, ss 101, 107, 109
Migration Regulations 1994, r 2.41; Schedule 2

CASES
MIAC v Khadgi (2010) 190 FCR 248

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 866 (Protection) visa under s.109(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

    Background

  2. The applicant arrived in Australia [in] October 2010 as an Irregular Maritime Arrival (IMA). He identified himself as [Name 1], an Afghan national of Shia religion and Hazara ethnicity born on [Date 1]. He claimed to be born stateless in Afghanistan, have not been known by other names and have not previously applied for refugee status or a protection visa. He has seven children. Two of his children ([Child 1] and [Child 2]) were born to his second wife [Ms A] who died 14 years ago (in 1997) after giving birth to [Child 2]. He provided his past addresses, employment history and family composition. He also claimed he fled Afghanistan for Iran with his family in 2010 after being threatened due to ongoing land disputes, and feared harm in Afghanistan by the Taliban as a Hazara Shia and being perceived as co-operating with the government.

  3. On 26 October 2011 he was granted a Subclass 866 (Protection) visa. On 26 April 2019 he was granted a Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa.

  4. A forensic facial comparison conducted by the Department of Home Affairs (the Department) disclosed that the applicant had applied on 10 October 2005 for a Refugee and Offshore Humanitarian (Subclass 202) – Global Special Humanitarian visa (GSH visa) from Iran using the identity of [Name 2] (DOB [Date 2]). The application included his wife and five children and was sponsored by [Mr B] who was identified as the applicant’s cousin and an Australian citizen. It contained different family composition. The applicant also claimed he left Afghanistan for Iran in 1980 with his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1910122 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 780
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant sought review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to cancel his Subclass 866 (Protection) visa under s.109(1) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth). The applicant had arrived in Australia in 2010 and was granted a protection visa in 2011. The cancellation decision was based on information that the applicant had provided incorrect information in his protection visa application, specifically by using a false identity and failing to disclose he was known by another name, and by misrepresenting his family composition.

The primary legal issues before the court were to determine the applicant's correct identity and the reasons for the provision of incorrect information in his visa applications. The court was required to assess whether the applicant had complied with his obligations under the Act, particularly concerning the disclosure of accurate information about his identity and personal circumstances.

The court found that while the applicant had provided incorrect information in a 2005 Global Special Humanitarian visa application using a false identity, this was due to exploitation and misinformation by agents in Iran, a country where asylum seekers faced significant rights abuses and a complex, bureaucratic system for retaining refugee status. The court accepted the applicant's explanation that the incorrect details in the 2005 application were based on an "Amayesh card" issued in the assumed identity, and that he lacked English language skills and knowledge of the visa process at that time. However, the court found the applicant's evidence regarding his marital status and the inclusion of three children as dependents in his Subclass 866 protection visa application to be inconsistent and lacking credibility. Specifically, the court noted discrepancies in the applicant's account of his second marriage and the death of his wife, and that the applicant only disclosed these children were not his biological offspring after DNA testing was requested, subsequently withdrawing their applications.

The court set aside the decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 866 (Protection) visa under s.109(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).Background The applicant arrived in Australia [in] October 2010 as an Irregular Maritime Arrival (IMA). He identified himself as [Name 1], an Afghan national of Shia religion and Hazara ethnicity born on [Date 1]. He claimed to be born stateless in Afghanistan, have not been known by other names and have not previously applied for refugee status or a protection visa. He has seven children. Two of his children ([Child 1] and [Child 2]) were born to his second wife [Ms A] who died 14 years ago (in 1997) after giving birth to [Child 2]. He provided his past addresses, employment history and family composition. He also claimed he fled Afghanistan for Iran with his family in 2010 after being threatened due to ongoing land disputes, and feared harm in Afghanistan by the Taliban as a Hazara Shia and being perceived as co-operating with the government. On 26 October 2011 he was granted a Subclass 866 (Protection) visa. On 26 April 2019 he was granted a Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa. A forensic facial comparison conducted by the Department of Home Affairs (the Department) disclosed that the applicant had applied on 10 October 2005 for a Refugee and Offshore Humanitarian (Subclass 202) – Global Special Humanitarian visa (GSH visa) from Iran using the identity of [Name 2] (DOB [Date 2]). The application included his wife and five children and was sponsored by [Mr B] who was identified as the applicant’s cousin and an Australian citizen. It contained different family composition. The applicant also claimed he left Afghanistan for Iran in 1980 with his family to avoid enlistment and being forced to fight against Afghanistan during the USSR occupation of Afghanistan, and his children were born in Iran. This s202 application was refused on 26 October 2005. Further, the Department’s records indicated that the applicant’s wife applied for a Subclass 202 visa on 17 February 2012 with the applicant as the sponsor, six children were listed as dependents, and this application was refused on 6 November 2013. Moreover, the Department’s record indicated that the applicant’s wife and six children applied for a Partner Subclass 100 visa on 19 September 2012 sponsored by the applicant. On 10 March 2013 the Department requested DNA testing for the children. The applicant responded with a statement declaring that his second claimed marriage didn’t take place, and that [Child 2], [Child 1] and [Child 3] were not his biological children but were orphans that they had been caring for. Integrity checks by the Department confirmed that the applicant fabricated the existence of a deceased second wife and provided a fraudulent death certificate to include these three children as dependents. The applicant withdrew the three children’s applications, and on 13 October 2013 the applicant’s wife and three children ([Child 4], [Child 5], [Child 6]) were granted Subclass 100 visas.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For these reasons, the Tribunal finds that there was non-compliance with s.101(b) by the applicant in the way described in the s.107 notice. Consideration of evidence and claims The applicant has applied for two visas using different identities and providing different evidence in support of each application. The Tribunal must first determine the applicant’s correct identity and why the applicant has provided incorrect information. This makes for a difficult decision. The Tribunal was provided with detailed submissions and country information by the applicant’s migration agent. At the hearing the applicant largely repeated the evidence he provided to the Department in response to the s.107 notice. The Tribunal finds that the applicant provided a credible explanation about his persecution as a Hazara Shia in Afghanistan, his migration history, illegal status in Iran and the circumstances in which he applied for the GSH visa in 2005 in Iran using a false identity. The Tribunal finds this information was consistent with his Subclass 866 protection visa application. The Tribunal accepts the applicant provided correct information regarding his identity and reasons why he was seeking protection after he arrived in Australia in 2010 and applied for protection. The Tribunal finds that the incorrect information provided by the applicant relating to dates of birth and family composition contained in the 2005 GHS application were based on the Amayesh card which was issued to the applicant in the assumed identity of [Name 2] when he was living in Iran. The Tribunal was referred to the report published by Human Rights Watch (HRW) in 2013. The HRW report confirms that Iran is failing to provide newly arrived asylum seekers access to protection because a functioning asylum system does not exist in Iran and the authorities are subjecting many Afghans to a range of rights abuses including arbitrary arrests and detentions. The report confirms that it has become increasingly difficult for registered Afghan refugees in Iran to retain their refugee status. This has been particularly true since the introduction of periodic registration exercises in 2000 and the establishment of the Amayesh registration system in 2003. The report states that the vast majority of Afghans arriving in Iran since the registration exercise in 2003 have not been allowed to register for an Amayesh card. It is reported that in practice, Amayesh card holders face an increasingly complex and bureaucratic process with the Iranian authorities to retain their status, in which the smallest mistake can result in permanent loss of refugee status. It is reported that Amayesh card holders are regularly required to renew their cards. Since the original registration of several hundred thousand Afghans in 2003, there have been nine re-registration exercises with a different colour card provided each time. The cards, which refugees must pay for, are generally valid for one year. When a card expires the card holder is considered to be unlawfully present in Iran and may be deported. If a card holder fails to register for a new card as soon as the old one has expired, he or she becomes undocumented and is subject to deportation. It is reported that another problem is that Afghans being deported from Iran are given no opportunity to challenge their deportation, such as by explaining that they previously had refugee status but lost it through no fault of their own or that they were prevented from requesting asylum or protection.[2] [2] Human Rights Watch, Unwelcome Guests: Iran's Violation of Afghan Refugee and Migrant Rights, 20 November 2013, ISBN: 978-1-62313-0770, available at: The Tribunal has had regard to the country information and finds that it is consistent with the applicant’s explanation about why he purchased Amayesh cards in an assumed name.101. The Tribunal also found the evidence of Mr [B] and Mr [C] to be credible. Both witnesses were born in Afghanistan and lived near the applicant’s home area in Ghazni Province and have known the applicant before he arrived in Australia. They have only known the applicant by the name [Name 1]. They know his wife and were able to name his biological children.102. Mr [B] told the Tribunal that he has known the applicant since he was a young child and they both come from the same tribe. In 2005 he travelled to Iran to get married and the applicant attended his wedding. When he was in Iran he was asked by a number of Afghan families to help them come to Australia because he was an Australian citizen. He was told that all he needed to do was sign some forms. He knew nothing about the visa process and had limited understanding of the English language. He did not turn his mind to the information that was contained in the forms but acted out of loyalty and support for his community. He was aware that the situation for Hazaras was not safe in Iran and agreed to help about five to six Afghan families (including the applicant) and signed a number of forms. He brought the forms back to Australia and lodged them with the Department. He was subsequently contacted by the Department and told the visa applications were refused. He thought that he did what was asked of him and had nothing further to do with the applications. 103. The Tribunal has had regard to Mr [B]’s evidence and finds that it is consistent with the applicant’s explanation that many Afghan refugees were exploited and misled by agents in Iran about their ability to obtain a visa to Australia. The Tribunal accepts the applicant would have had no English language skills and no knowledge of the visa process when he was living in Iran. The Tribunal accepts the applicant would have been guided by the agents in Iran who told him to use the false identity and provided false information in the 2005 GSH application. The Tribunal accepts the agents would have completed visa application forms and the application had little prospects of success. 104. The Tribunal also questioned the applicant about his marriages and family composition. The Tribunal found aspects of his evidence lacking in credibility. 105. The Tribunal finds the applicant provided a family composition table in response to question 9 (Part B Form 866) indicating he had family unit members who were residing outside of Australia at the time of the Subclass 866 visa application. As for those who were included in the family composition, the applicant maintains all members were in fact part of his family unit, including [Ms A], [Child 2], [Child 1] and [Child 3]. 106. He claims [Ms A] was his deceased second wife. He married her in 1997 after her husband passed away as she was a widow with three children and needed support. He claims he had a Nikah with [Ms A] so he could take care of her and her children and married her out of compassion. He claims he supported [Child 2], [Child 1] and [Child 3] as if they were his own children. When [Ms A] died, the three children continued to live with [Ms D] and his biological children. They lived with them up until [Ms D] and his biological children were granted the Partner (Subclass 309) visa and migrated to Australia. 107. He claims he declared [Ms A], [Child 2], [Child 1] and [Child 3] as part of his family unit. It was submitted the children only came into his life after the 2005 GSH application was lodged, which is why they were only declared in the Subclass 866 visa application, 2012 GSH application and partner visa application. 108. The Tribunal does not accept the applicant’s evidence about his relationship with [Ms A] and why he included three orphan children in his Protection visa application. The Tribunal finds the applicant’s evidence inconsistent and lacking in credibility.109. First, the Tribunal notes the applicant claims he entered into a Nikah with [Ms A] in 1997 because she was a widow caring for three children ([Child 2], [Child 1] and [Child 3]). According to information provided by the applicant in support of his Protection visa application he claims [Ms A] died in 1997 after she gave birth to [Child 2]. When questioned at the hearing he claimed [Ms A] died in 2005 or 2006 about six months after they left Afghanistan. When the inconsistency was put to the applicant, he claims it must have been a translating error. The Tribunal notes that the applicant’s statement was prepared with the assistance of his migration agent and translated into English and the applicant has not previously sought to change his evidence. The Tribunal further notes, that according to information on the Department’s file [in] Form 47SP [Application for migration to Australia by a partner] at page 7, question 58 the applicant declared that he was previously married to [Ms A] and they had two children together from the relationship. He also provided a death certificate for [Ms A].110. Second, the Tribunal notes the applicant did not declare [Child 2], [Child 1] and [Child 3] in the offshore GSH visa application made in 2005. He claims this is because the children did not come into his life until after 2005 and that’s why he disclosed them in his Subclass 866 protection visa application. The Tribunal finds this inconsistent with the applicant’s evidence that he treated three children as his own after he entered into a Nikah with [Ms A] in 1997. The Tribunal also notes that according to his evidence his wife and children came to join him in Iran in 2001. 111. Third, the Tribunal notes that the applicant only declared that [Child 2], [Child 1] and [Child 3] were not his biological children after the Department requested DNA evidence. He did not volunteer this evidence. He subsequently withdrew the children from the applications the same day. On 12 March 2013 he provided a statement to the Department referring to the partner visa application. He wrote: I wish to state that some of the information provided in the previous document was not true or correct and I wish this document to set the record straight. I previously stated that I was the father of seven children, all of whom were included in my application… I wish to advise that three of the claimed seven children were not in fact my biological children but orgphas who my family cared for… [Child 2], [Child 1] and [Child 3]… I wish to advise these children are not intending to come to Australia and are no longer included in my application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established