1825268 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

1825268 (Refugee) [2022] AATA 4965 (22 November 2022)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

REPRESENTATIVE:  Mr Tedros Alemaw Yabio

CASE NUMBER:  1825268

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   Ethiopia

MEMBER:Kate Millar

DATE:22 November 2022

PLACE OF DECISION:  Adelaide

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the following directions:

(i)that the first named applicant satisfies s 36(2)(a) of the Migration Act; and

(ii)that the other applicants satisfy s 36(2)(b)(i) of the Migration Act, on the basis of membership of the same family unit as the first named applicant; and

(iii)that the grant of the visas is not prevented by s 91WA.

Statement made on 22 November 2022 at 3:15pm

CATCHWORDS
REFUGEE – protection visa – Ethiopia – member of particular social group – single mother – one child with autism spectrum disorder, intellectual and language impairments, another waiting for assessment for ADHD – mental health – capacity to subsist – race – Tigrayan – country information – bogus document – birth certificate for oldest child, claimed to be the child of ex-de facto partner and another woman – reasonable explanation – provided by father in circumstances of leaving third country – prevalence of gender-based violence – lack of support services – state of emergency – decision under review remitted

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5(1), 5H(1)(a), 5J(1), (5), 36(2)(a), (b)(i), 65(1), 91WA
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2

CASES
AIB16 v MIBP (2017) 254 FCR 457
BGM16 v MIBP (2017) 252 FCR 97
BMK18 v MHA [2019] FCA 189

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependants.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. [The first applicant] is a citizen of Ethiopia, who came to Australia [in] June 2012 on a Prospective Marriage visa (Subclass 300) as a secondary applicant, claiming to be the niece of [Mr A].

  2. [The first applicant] again claimed to be the niece of [Mr A] in a combined application for a Partner (provisional) and Partner (residence) visa.  [The second applicant] claimed to be [Mr A]’s son.  A Subclass 820 visa was granted in 2012, but then the Subclass 801 visa was refused on 24 April 2015.  [The third applicant] was born in Australia.

  3. On 2 April 2015, [Mr A] applied for a protection visa, naming [the first applicant] as his niece as a secondary applicant and [the second applicant] as his son. On being advised that as a niece of the primary visa application and the need to lodge an application in her own right, [the first applicant] lodged this application on 4 May 2015 with her daughter [the third applicant] as the secondary applicant

  4. On 28 February 2018 [the first applicant] and [Mr A] advised they were in fact in a relationship and asked to be added to each other’s’ applications.  It was advised that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1825268 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 4965
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs' decision to refuse to grant protection visas to the applicants. The first applicant, an Ethiopian national of Tigrayan ethnicity, sought a protection visa, with her two children, the second and third applicants, named as secondary applicants. The applicants had previously provided a fraudulent birth certificate for the second applicant and a death certificate for the claimed mother, which they admitted was done to facilitate their migration to Australia.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the first applicant had a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race and membership of a particular social group, and whether she met the criteria for complementary protection. The Tribunal was also required to consider the impact of the provision of a bogus document on the application under section 91WA of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).

The Tribunal accepted that the first applicant was Tigrayan and had separated from her ex-de facto partner, relocating interstate with her three children. It was accepted that her youngest child has autism spectrum disorder, and that the first applicant suffers from major depression and anxiety. The Tribunal found that, as a single mother of three children, including one with significant disabilities, and given the prevalence of gender-based violence and insufficient support services in Ethiopia, the first applicant would face a real chance of serious harm, including threats to her life or liberty, sexual assault and harassment, and denial of her capacity to subsist. These risks were considered to be substantial and foreseeable consequences of her removal to Ethiopia. The Tribunal also found that the provision of the bogus document was explained by the circumstances of the applicants' desire to migrate, and that the first applicant had a reasonable explanation for its provision in the context of leaving a third country.

The Tribunal concluded that the first applicant met the criteria for being a refugee and therefore qualified for a protection visa under section 36(2)(a) of the Act. The Tribunal was also satisfied that the second and third applicants, as her children, met the requirements under section 36(2)(c) of the Act. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the delegate's decision and remitted the matter to the delegate to grant the protection visas to the applicants.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 10 August 2018 to refuse to grant the applicants protection visas under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).background [The first applicant] was born in [Town] in the Tigray region of Ethiopia, and was born in [Year 1]. She has [siblings]. Her parents both died from HIV/AIDS and [the first applicant] reports being bullied in the community as a result of perceptions that she was infectious or unclean. [The first applicant] and her siblings went to live with an uncle in a different area of [Town]. This did not work out as he uncle’s family bullied her because her parents had died of HIV/AIDS, and her uncle told her to stay at the Church. She states she has not had any contact with her siblings since she left her uncle, however also later states that she is constantly concerned for her [siblings] and that she suffers stress and anxiety from tyring to help her family in Ethiopia A friend organised for her to go to [Country 1] in [Year 2], and she met her ex-de facto partner in [Country 1]. After they had their eldest child [the second applicant], they planned how to leave [Country 1], and claimed that this was because of her ex-de facto partner’s political activities. [The first applicant] has a cousin who was in Australia, and her ex-de facto partner came to Australia claiming that he intended to marry her cousin. [The first applicant] claimed to be his dependent niece and [the second applicant] was claimed to be the son of her ex-de facto partner and another person. They obtained a fraudulent birth certificate for their son to show his mother was another person and obtained a death certificate for the claimed mother. They claim that their relationship with this cousin deteriorated and was abusive, so they left. While they had been on temporary partner visas, the permanent partner visa was refused. Her ex-de facto partner lodged an application for a protection visa on 2 April 2015, again naming her as his niece and their son as his son only. After being advised that a niece was required to make an application on her own behalf, on 4 May 2015 [the first applicant] lodged an application for a protection visa. In 2018 they advised the Department that they were in a de facto relationship and [the second applicant] was their child. They each requested to be added to each other’s applications for a protection visa as a secondary applicant. [The second applicant] lodged an application on 28 February 2018 to be added to [the first applicant]’s application for the visa as her son. [The first applicant]’s second child [the third applicant] was born in Australia on [date]. [The first applicant] states the relationship with her ex-de facto partner was abusive and she left, travelling interstate. Her [third child], who is not included in this application, was born on [date]. With the breakdown of the relationship the applications have been considered separately. This is the application that was made by [the first applicant] as the primary visa applicant, naming [the second applicant] and [the third applicant] as secondary applicants. Criteria for a protection visa

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Since this report was released, there has been an outbreak of conflict in the Tigray region. The Tribunal has also drawn from the UNHCR Position on Returns to Ethiopia issued March 2022,[1] and other recent reporting on the conflict in the Tigray region.[1] UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), UNHCR Position on Returns to Ethiopia, March 2022, available at: 21 November 2022]CONSIDERATION OF Claims and evidence [The first applicant] has actively misled immigration over many years by claiming she was the niece of her ex-de facto partner and that their son was the son of another person. This was so that they could migrate to Australia. This accordingly affects the weight that can be placed on her statutory declarations. However, the Tribunal does accept that she is Tigrayan, as she has consistently claimed this is her ethnicity and has used a Tigrinya interpreter throughout her dealings with the Department and with health services. The Tribunal accepts she has separated from her ex-de facto partner and has relocated interstate. She has the care of three children. Her youngest child has autism, and this has been established by [a] Hospital in Adelaide. She would return as a single mother of a child with autism. [The first applicant] has provided evidence of a mental illness with major depression and anxiety. The Tribunal accepts that [the first applicant] is Tigrayan. Single Mothers If she were to return, [the first applicant] would return as a single mother of three children. DFAT report that Ethiopia is a deeply religious community, reflected in strong religious observance across all faiths.[2] [2] DFAT [3.26] DFAT report:… women in Ethiopia face a high risk of domestic violence and sexual harassment. Sexual assault, including spousal rape, is common. DFAT assesses support services for women escaping from domestic violence have improved but are insufficient overall.[3][3] DFAT, at [3.67] UNHCR report in relation to the conflict:UN human rights experts have also expressed grave concern about widespread and documented incidents of sexual and gender-based violence committed against women and girls in the Tigray, Amhara and Afar regions of Ethiopia by parties to the conflict.[4][4] UNCHR, at [8] Another study reported that divorced or widowed women may be subjected to rape and traditional practices that force women to remarry or have sex with male family or community members.[5] This study also found that for separated women, their sexuality was emphasised and is thought of as uncontrolled and unpredictable and therefore threatening to the community, being accused of trying to look for men, and this was heightened by taboo about sex outside of marriage. Single divorced or widowed women reported being ostracised and of isolating themselves.[6] [5] “People insult her as a sexy woman’: sexuality, stigma and vulnerability among widowed and divorced women in Oromiya, Ethiopia', Culture Health & Sexuality, 03 May 2014, p. 917, 20221019124103 [6] ibid

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal finds that it is not possible for the applicants to relocate. Conclusion To be a refugee within the meaning of s 5H of the Act, [the first applicant] must be outside her country of origin, and because of a well-founded fear of persecution is unwilling or unable to avail herself of the protection of his or her country. “Well-founded fear of persecution” is defined in s 5J of the Act. It requires that the person fears being persecuted for reasons of (among other) race and membership of a particular social group (s5J(1)(a), that there will be a real chance that if returned the person will be persecuted n(s5J(1)(b)) and that the real chance of persecution relates to all areas of the receiving country (s5J(1)(c)). The Tribunal finds that [the first applicant] would face a real chance of serious harm, being a threat to her life or liberty, sexual assault and harassment as contemplated by s 5J(5) of the Act. It finds she would suffer denial of capacity to earn a living of any kind threatening her capacity to subsist (s.5J(5)(d) of the Act). The essential and significant reasons for the harm are [the first applicant]’s race and her membership of particular social groups, being single mothers and as a single mother with a child with autism spectrum disorder. There is a real chance of serious harm in all parts of Ethiopia (s.5J(1)(c). As [the first applicant] meets s 5J(1)(a)(b) and (c), she has a well-founded fear of persecution. And as she otherwise meets the requirements of s 5H of the Act, is a refugee. It follows that she meets the requirement for a protection visa in s 36(2)(a) of the Act. The Tribunal is satisfied that [the second applicant] and [the third applicant] are members of her family unit as they are her children, and finds that [the second applicant] and [the third applicant] meet s.36(2)(c) of the Act.Section 91WA Under s 65(1) of the Act, the Minister (or the Tribunal on review) must refuse to grant a visa if the grant is prevented by s 91WA. Section 91WA(1) requires the Minister to refuse to grant a protection visa to an applicant who provides a ‘bogus document’ as evidence of their identity, nationality or citizenship, or has destroyed or disposed, or caused the destruction or disposal of, documentary evidence of their identity, nationality or citizenship. However, that requirement will not apply if the applicant has a reasonable explanation for the provision, destruction or disposal, and either provides relevant documentary evidence or has taken reasonable steps to provide such evidence: s 91WA(2). The Full Federal Court has held that s 91WA(1)(a) is directed to the provision of bogus documents during or in connection with an application for a protection visa: BGM16 v MIBP (2017) 252 FCR 97 at [8], [81]. However, the provision is not limited to cases where the false information contained in the bogus document is relied upon by an applicant. There is no requirement for a decision-maker to ascertain the manner in which a bogus document is given and relied upon, and which information in the document is false and which is accurate: BMK18 v MHA [2019] FCA 189 at [41]–[42].]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

If a person is found not to meet the refugee criterion in s 36(2)(a), he or she may nevertheless meet the criteria for the grant of the visa if he or she is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations because the Minister has substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of being removed from Australia to a receiving country, there is a real risk that he or she will suffer significant harm: s 36(2)(aa) (‘the complementary protection criterion’). The meaning of significant harm, and the circumstances in which a person will be taken not to face a real risk of significant harm, are set out in ss 36(2A) and (2B), which are extracted in the attachment to this decision.Mandatory considerations In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.84, made under s 499 of the Act, the Tribunal has taken account of the ‘Refugee Law Guidelines’ and ‘Complementary Protection Guidelines’ prepared by the Department of Home Affairs, and country information assessments prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration. The most recent assessments prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) is Country Information Report Ethiopia dated 12 August 2020. Since this report was released, there has been an outbreak of conflict in the Tigray region. The Tribunal has also drawn from the UNHCR Position on Returns to Ethiopia issued March 2022,[1] and other recent reporting on the conflict in the Tigray region.[1] UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), UNHCR Position on Returns to Ethiopia, March 2022, available at: 21 November 2022]CONSIDERATION OF Claims and evidence [The first applicant] has actively misled immigration over many years by claiming she was the niece of her ex-de facto partner and that their son was the son of another person. This was so that they could migrate to Australia. This accordingly affects the weight that can be placed on her statutory declarations. However, the Tribunal does accept that she is Tigrayan, as she has consistently claimed this is her ethnicity and has used a Tigrinya interpreter throughout her dealings with the Department and with health services. The Tribunal accepts she has separated from her ex-de facto partner and has relocated interstate. She has the care of three children. Her youngest child has autism, and this has been established by [a] Hospital in Adelaide. She would return as a single mother of a child with autism. [The first applicant] has provided evidence of a mental illness with major depression and anxiety. The Tribunal accepts that [the first applicant] is Tigrayan. Single Mothers If she were to return, [the first applicant] would return as a single mother of three children. DFAT report that Ethiopia is a deeply religious community, reflected in strong religious observance across all faiths.[2] [2] DFAT [3.26]