1732002 (Migration) [2018] AATA 5359 (11 December 2018)
DECISION RECORD
DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division
CASE NUMBER: 1732002
MEMBER:Michael Hawkins
DATE AND TIME OF
ORAL DECISION AND REASONS: 11 December 2018 at 11:54 am (QLD time)
DATE OF WRITTEN RECORD: 14 December 2018
PLACE OF DECISION: Brisbane
Statement made on 14 December 2018 at 5:40pm
CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – cancellation – Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) (Class TY) visa – criminal offences – committed in group environment – out of character – low risk of recidivism – no family support in New Zealand – best interest of younger siblings – decision under review set asideLEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, ss 116, 375A
CASES
Botha v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 362
Gong v MIBP [2016] FCCA 561
Gummow and Hayne JJ in Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS (2010) 243 CLR 164
Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259
Tien v MIMA (1998) 89 FCR 80
Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 378 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information.
APPLICATION FOR REVIEW
This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration on 11 December 2017 to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) (Class TY) visa under the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).
At the hearing on 11 December 2018 the Tribunal made an oral decision and gave an undertaking to provide a statement of decision and reasons within 14 days of the hearing date. The following is the written record of those reasons.
STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS
Under s.116 of the Act, the Minister may cancel a visa if he or she is satisfied that certain grounds specified in that provision are made out. Relevantly, to this case, these include the ground set out in s.116(1)(e)(ii). If satisfied that the ground for cancellation is made out, the decision maker must proceed to consider whether the visa should be cancelled, having regard to all the relevant circumstances, which may include matters of government policy.
Background
[The applicant] was born in Samoa on [date]. He is [age] years old.
He has lived in Australia since he was [a child] with the exception of a brief period when he lived in New Zealand in 2007.
[The applicant] resided with his family in Australia until he and his siblings were placed into foster care in around 2009. He remained in foster care until around 2012 when he was placed in independent living. He has no relationship with his father and limited and irregular contact with his mother who has no fixed address.
He has maintained a strong and supportive relationship with his brothers and sisters, including his eldest sister [Ms A], who has been a mother-type figure to her younger siblings. He intends to reside with his family…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read 1732002 (Migration) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] AATA 5359
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal was required to determine whether the ground for cancellation under section 116(1)(e)(ii) was established, and if so, whether the discretion to cancel the visa should be exercised, considering all relevant circumstances. This involved assessing the weight of evidence regarding the applicant's alleged offending against the mitigating factors presented, including his strong family ties in Australia, his completion of schooling, and his potential employment opportunities. The Tribunal also had to consider the significant hardship the applicant and his siblings would face if he were removed from Australia, particularly given his lack of established support networks in New Zealand or Samoa.
The Tribunal found that the ground for cancellation under section 116(1)(e)(ii) was satisfied, concluding that the applicant's presence in Australia might pose a risk to the community. However, in exercising its discretion regarding cancellation, the Tribunal gave considerable weight to the compelling circumstances presented by the applicant. These included his deep and supportive relationships with his siblings, who regard Australia as their home and rely on him for emotional support, and his lack of any established connections or prospects in New Zealand. The Tribunal noted that the applicant had no family support in New Zealand, his mother had no fixed address, and his father was absent from his life. Furthermore, the Tribunal considered the significant financial and emotional hardship his removal would cause his siblings, who are unable to relocate.
Ultimately, the Tribunal set aside the delegate's decision to cancel the applicant's visa. The Tribunal determined that the compelling reasons for the applicant to remain in Australia, particularly the strong familial bonds and the severe hardship his removal would inflict on himself and his siblings, weighed heavily against the exercise of the cancellation power. The decision acknowledged the applicant's potential for rehabilitation and reintegration into the community, supported by his family and potential employment.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
On balance, after careful consideration, the Tribunal gives more weight to the evidence which suggests the grounds for visa cancellation exists than it gives to the evidence to contrary. Accordingly, the Tribunal finds that the applicant’s presence in Australia might be a risk to the safety of the Australian community or a segment of Australian community. The Tribunal is therefore satisfied that the ground for cancellation in s. 116(1)(e)(ii) exists. As that ground does not require mandatory cancellation under s.116(3), the Tribunal must proceed to consider whether the power to cancel the visa should be exercised.Consideration of discretion There are no matters specified in the Act or Regulations that are required to be considered in relation to the exercise of the discretion to cancel the visa. However, is considering whether to exercise its discretion to cancel the applicant’s visa, the Tribunal has had regard to the relevant circumstances including, but not limited to, matters identified in the Department’s Procedures Advice Manual PAM3 ‘General visa cancellation powers’. The Tribunal has also very carefully considered the attribution of weight to the evidence before it in assessing whether the applicant’s visa should be cancelled. In doing so, the Tribunal is mindful of the observations of Collier J in Botha v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 362 at [39]:There is ample authority at high level in this country that it is for a decision-maker to attribute such weight to relevant information as it sees fit: see for example Kirby J in Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 at [24]; Gummow and Hayne JJ in Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510 at [197]; the plurality in Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS (2010) 243 CLR 164 at [33]. The Tribunal considered the representative’s submission as follows:[The applicant] travelled to Australia as the holder of a Special Category (subclass 444) visa. This visa was first granted to him in around 1999 when he was three or four years old. He remained in Australia until 2007 at which time he travelled with his family to New Zealand. He relocated with his siblings to Australia in July 2007 and he has remained here since this time. Had his visa not been cancelled, it would have continued to permit him to remain living in Australia indefinitely. [The applicant] completed nearly the entirety of his schooling in Australia, having completed grade 12 at [High] School in [year]. He also obtained casual and part-time employment in different roles. He has been offered employment with a [company] which he can start immediately if released to the community. While his father and mother were notably absent from his childhood and he remains alienated from them (in particular his father with whom he has had no contact for several years), he has a close and supportive relationship with his siblings. Their connection was sustained through the years of their separation in different foster care homes. They have also been in constant contact with him during his incarceration, including visiting him on a weekly basis and speaking on the phone 8 to 10 times per week. [The applicant]'s siblings, with the exception of [one] who lives nearby, currently live with his eldest sister [Ms A], her partner and their [children] at their [Suburb 1] residence. [The applicant] intends to live with his sister and family upon his release. By contrast, he has neither connections, supports, a place to live or employment prospects in New Zealand or Samoa. His purpose of remaining in Australia is evidently to reside, as he has for nearly 17 years, with his family. Accordingly, we submit there are compelling reasons for him to remain in Australia which weighs against cancellation.Both [the applicant] and his family will face considerable hardship if his Special Category visa remains cancelled. This hardship was expressly recognised by [the judge] in his sentence [in] December 2018.As a starting point, we wish to emphasise that he is incredibly close to his siblings. This is perhaps a closeness borne from their experiences in foster care and the absence of their parents. Their very close relationships despite their separation during this period is testament to their strong familial bond. They are the only family he has and have been in daily contact with him during his incarceration and visited him on a weekly basis. They have understandably been distressed by his time in custody and his likely deportation should his visa not be reinstated. He intends to live with his eldest sister [Ms A], her partner and children and his other [siblings] at their home in [Suburb 1]. Prior to his incarceration, [the applicant] helped look after his younger siblings from time to time, including taking them to school, babysitting and chipping in for groceries.If [the applicant]'s visa remains cancelled, he will be removed to New Zealand after the Tribunal proceedings. This will have a negative impact on both himself and his siblings. He will face considerable obstacles in the event of his removal to New Zealand. It is submitted these challenges are not merely limited to those associated with relocating to a country he has not lived in since he was a child and starting afresh. Rather, we hold serious concerns that he will not be able to sustain basic living standards due the hardship he will face in New Zealand. He has no known family support in New Zealand, having lived in Australia for the majority of his life. He instructs that his biological father may be residing in New Zealand but he does not know his whereabouts and no knowledge of whether he could support [the applicant]. In any event, he has no intention of contacting his father given [family reasons]. While he has been in irregular contact with his mother, she resides between Australia, New Zealand and Samoa and has no fixed address. Given her previous limited involvement in his life and upbringing, she cannot be considered a stable, positive support to him if he is removed to New Zealand. He does not know of any other relatives he could live with or who could support him. [The applicant]'s siblings are unable to relocate to New Zealand to live with him. They have resided permanently in Australia for many years and regard it as their home. His eldest sister [Ms A] is established in Australia through her partner and [children], who are Australian citizens. She is employed as an [occupation] at [workplaces]. She is the principal breadwinner in the family and has multiple dependents who live with her, including her own [children] and her [younger] siblings who are enrolled in local primary and high schools. Their relocation to New Zealand where [Ms A] has no employment prospects would place too much financial strain and pressure on the family. It would also be undesirable given the proximity to their father. Their continued residence in Australia will make the impact of cancellation and removal particularly harsh on [the applicant]. He additionally has other close personal supports, namely [Ms B] and her family. [Ms B] is an Australian citizen by birth and is employed as [an occupation] at [a workplace]. [Ms B] lives across the street from [the applicant]'s family and has been providing support and assistance to him since 2010. She has sustained a close connection with [the applicant] during his incarceration, including regular visits and talking with him on the phone 2 to 3 times a week. She has pledged to continue supporting him if his visa is reinstated. In view of the above, [the applicant]'s removal to New Zealand would completely isolate him from his immediate family and support network. He will likely not see them again for an extended period of time due to the prohibitions on his return to Australia and the prohibitive costs of overseas travel which his family cannot afford. It is submitted that his family and other personal supports are critical to his health and well-being. As he explains in his statutory declaration, they have been a huge part of sustaining his positivity and motivation while he has been in custody. In his words - "If they weren't here, I would have given up by now". While it is accepted that he could remain in contact with his family and supports by phone and email, these methods of contact are hardly a substitute for the day-to-day contact and support he can both receive and provide to them in Australia. These methods are hardly meaningful if they are to be sustained on an indefinite basis. Put simply, [the applicant] cannot be a supportive brother nor derive adequate support from his family when reliant solely on such channels to sustain their relationships. His isolation from his support network to a place where he has no equivalent or indeed any known and established familial supports is likely to hamper his reintegration to New Zealand. [The applicant] has negligible prospects of supporting himself financially should be removed. He has no employment prospects and a very limited employment history in Australia to recommend himself to employers. He has no income or savings. His family have limited financial means and cannot afford to contribute to the costs of his living expenses in New Zealand. Accordingly, he does not have any place to live and no savings at his disposal to help him re-build a new life. In these circumstances, it is likely that he would be entirely dependent on welfare and support services on an indefinite basis. In these circumstances, he is likely to face significant challenges in sustaining and establishing support networks, securing employment and accommodation, as well as the detrimental impact of his complete isolation from his family and networks in Australia. Further, [the applicant] has expressed concern on a number of occasions for the impact of his removal on his family, who rely on him for emotional support. He is acutely aware of the stress and anxiety they have endured as a result his incarceration and threat of deportation. It is anticipated that they will experience considerable suffering should his removal occur - in [Ms A]'s words in her statutory declaration dated 15 March 2018, "my siblings and I would miss him greatly and would always feel like there was a piece of missing". It follows that their suffering would be likely to exact a heavy toll on [the applicant] personally. Accordingly, we submit [the applicant] will not merely face adversity and financial distress as a result of being separated from his family and having to establish himself in New Zealand. Rather, it is reasonable to suggest that he may face such hardship as would prove insurmountable and his well-being could be placed in significant jeopardy. By contrast, if he remains in Australia he can live with his family, receive their day-to-day support and commence work immediately with a [company]. We consider this factor weighs significantly against the cancellation of his visa.