1721573 (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

1721573 (Migration) [2018] AATA 509 (6 February 2018)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1721573

MEMBER:K. Chapman

DATE:6 February 2018

PLACE OF DECISION:  Brisbane

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 444 (Special Category) visa.

Statement made on 06 February 2018 at 2:41pm

  1. This is an application for review of a decision dated [in] August 2017 made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 444 (Special Category) visa under s.116 of the Migration Act 1958 (‘the Act’).

  2. The delegate cancelled the visa under s.116(1)(e)(i) on the basis that the applicant had a history of criminal offending and pending criminal charges, and therefore his presence in Australia ‘is or may be, or would or might be, a risk to the health, safety or good order of the Australian community or a segment of the Australian community.’ The issue in the present case is whether that ground for cancellation is made out, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled.

  3. [In] January 2018, the Tribunal issued a Summons to the Commissioner of the [State 1] [Police] seeking documents relating to the applicant’s criminal history. On 8 January 2018, the applicant’s representative advised the Tribunal that he had been transferred from criminal custody to immigration detention. On 11 January 2017, the Tribunal wrote to the applicant pursuant to sections 359A and 359(2) of the Act inviting him to respond to information contained in the delegate’s decision, and in [State 1] [Police] documentation returned by Summons, regarding his criminal history. For completeness, the Tribunal notes that it obtained permission from the [State 1] [Police] to release a full copy of the applicant’s ‘[State 1] Person History’ and on 22 January 2018 it reissued the invitation pursuant to sections 359A and 359(2) of the Act, enclosing that document. On 29 and 30 January 2018, the Tribunal received material from the applicant responding to the invitation including submissions, references, and supporting documentation. The aforementioned material has been duly considered by the Tribunal.

  4. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 30 January 2018, via video link from immigration detention, to give evidence and present arguments. He confirmed he was able to hear the proceedings and agreed at the end of the review hearing that he was afforded a fair opportunity to present his case. The Tribunal also received oral evidence in person from Mrs J (who is married to, but separated from, the applicant), Ms A (the ex-wife of the applicant), Mrs C (the applicant’s sister), and Mr P (the applicant’s brother-in-law). The Tribunal notes that the applicant decided not to have a fifth witness, his brother, give evidence. The applicant was represented in person by his registered migration agent, who is a solicitor. Following the review hearing, on 2 February 2018, the Tribunal received a submission on behalf of the applicant advising he had no further response to information raised with him pursuant to s.359AA of the Act, a copy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1721573 (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 509
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by a New Zealand national against the cancellation of his Subclass 444 (Special Category) visa. The applicant, who had resided in Australia since 1999, possessed a lengthy and varied criminal record spanning from 2001 to 2017, including convictions for drug possession, assaulting police, using a carriage service to menace, harass or cause offence, contravention of domestic violence orders, unlawful possession of weapons, and serious assault of a police officer. He had received multiple sentences of imprisonment, with his most recent period of incarceration being 12 months in 2017, after which he was taken into immigration detention.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant's visa cancellation was justified, specifically whether his presence in Australia posed a risk to the good order or the health and safety of the Australian community. The Tribunal was required to consider the evidence of the applicant's criminal history and any mitigating factors presented, including claims of emotional and financial hardship for himself and his family members. The Tribunal also had to determine whether to exercise its discretion to cancel the visa, having regard to relevant circumstances and legal principles regarding the attribution of weight to evidence.

The Tribunal reasoned that the applicant's extensive criminal history, particularly the convictions for serious assault of police officers and contraventions of domestic violence orders, indicated a risk to the safety of the Australian community, including domestic partners and their children. While acknowledging the emotional and financial hardship that cancellation might cause to the applicant's Australian family members, the Tribunal afforded this evidence less weight than the evidence supporting the grounds for cancellation. The Tribunal applied the principle that decision-makers have the authority to attribute weight to relevant information as they see fit, citing established High Court authority.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the decision to cancel the applicant's visa, concluding that, on balance, the evidence supported the cancellation and that the power to cancel the visa should be exercised.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be affirmed.BACKGROUND [The applicant], the applicant, is [an age] year old national of New Zealand. His most recent Subclass 444 visa, issued [in] July 2016, was cancelled by a Departmental delegate [in] August 2017. At that time he was held on remand at [a] Correctional Centre with multiple criminal charges pending. [The applicant] first arrived in Australia [in] February 1999 at the age of [age] years, having completed his secondary schooling in New Zealand. He came to Australia with his parents and siblings. [The applicant] has made [number] short return visits to New Zealand since his first arrival in Australia, in [specified years]. He has two Australian citizen sons and he is separated from his second wife, Mrs J, however they plan to resume their relationship. [The applicant] obtained multiple criminal convictions between the years of 2001 and 2017 for matters including possessing dangerous drugs, assaulting police, using a carriage service to menace harass or cause offence, contravention of domestic violence orders, unlawful possession of weapons, and serious assault of police officer whilst pretending or is armed with a weapon (his criminal history is outlined in more detail below). [The applicant] received several sentences of imprisonment in 2017, with a head sentence of 12 months, and was in custody at [a] Correctional Centre between May and December 2017. Following his incarceration, [the applicant] was taken into immigration detention where he remains at the time of this decision. Information obtained from the [Police] of [State 1] and [State 2] confirms the applicant has the following proven criminal history:-[In] 2001 – ([State 1]) Enter or in dwelling with intent to commit indictable offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 18 months (wholly suspended for a period of 2 years) and compensation of $[amount];-[In] 2003 – ([State 1]) Breach bail undertaking (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $150;-[In] 2003 – ([State 1]) Enter dwelling with intent to commit an indictable offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $1,500;-[In] 2004 – ([State 1]) Breach of suspended sentence imposed [in 2001]. Breach proven, no further penalty imposed;-[In] 2006 – ([State 1]) Possessing dangerous drugs (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $600;-[In] 2006 – ([State 1]) Commit public nuisance (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $600;-[In] 2006 – ([State 1]) Obstruct Police Officer (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $400;-[In] 2007 – ([State 1]) Assault Police Officer (on [date]). Conviction recorded, probation for 7 months;-[In] 2007 – ([State 1]) Obstruct Police Officer (on [date]). Conviction recorded, probation for 7 months;-[In] 2008 – ([State 1]) Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking (on [date]). No conviction recorded, fined $500;-[In] 2008 – ([State 1]) Obstruct Police Officer (on [date]). Conviction recorded, probation for 2 years;-[In] 2008 – ([State 1]) Commit public nuisance (on [date]). Conviction recorded, probation for 2 years;-[In] 2008 – ([State 1]) Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking (on [date]). Conviction recorded, probation for 2 years;-[In] 2008 – ([State 2]) Common assault (on [date]). Conviction recorded, S.9 Bond imposed (12 months comply with AVO);-[In] 2008 – ([State 2]) Drive with low range PCA (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $300, disqualified from driving for 6 months;-[In] 2008 – ([State 2]) Licence expired less than 2 years before, first offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, no other penalty;-[In] 2009 – ([State 1]) Breach of probation order imposed [in 2007]. Conviction recorded, fined $350;-[In] 2009 – ([State 1]) Breach of probation order imposed [in 2008]. Conviction recorded, fined $400. Order revoked and re-sentenced for original offences with convictions recorded and sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months (wholly suspended for a period of 18 months);-[In] 2010 – ([State 2]) Contravene Prohibition/Restriction in AVO (Domestic) (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $500;-[In] 2010 – ([State 2]) Contravene Prohibition/Restriction in AVO (Domestic) (on [date]). Conviction recorded, S.9 Bond imposed for 2 years;-[In] 2010 – ([State 2]) Contravene Prohibition/Restriction in AVO (Domestic) (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $500;-[In] 2014 – ([State 1]) Contravene direction or requirement (on [date]). No conviction recorded and not further punished; -[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Using a Carriage Service to Menace, Harass or Cause Offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 6 months with recognisance $3,000 and good behaviour period 2 years;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Contravention of Domestic Violence Order (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 6 months (concurrent);-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Using a Carriage Service to Menace, Harass or Cause Offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 12 months with recognisance $3,000 and good behaviour period 2 years;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Contravention of Domestic Violence Order (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 12 months concurrent;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Serious Assault Police Officer Whilst Pretending / Is Armed With a Weapon (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 12 months concurrent;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Possessing Dangerous Drugs (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 14 days concurrent;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Unlawful Possession of Weapons Category A, B or M (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 7 days concurrent;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Possessing Dangerous Drugs (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 7 days concurrent; -[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Possess Utensils or Pipes etc. That Had Been Used (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 7 days concurrent; -[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Using a Carriage Service to Menace, Harass or Cause Offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months with recognisance $3,000 and good behaviour period 2 years;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Contravention of Domestic Violence Order (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months concurrent;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Common Assault Domestic Violence Offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months concurrent; -[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Unlawful Use of Motor Vehicles, Aircraft or Vessels (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months concurrent; and-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Receiving Tainted Property (Between [two dates]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months concurrent.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Information obtained from the [Police] of [State 1] and [State 2] confirms the applicant has the following proven criminal history:-[In] 2001 – ([State 1]) Enter or in dwelling with intent to commit indictable offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 18 months (wholly suspended for a period of 2 years) and compensation of $[amount];-[In] 2003 – ([State 1]) Breach bail undertaking (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $150;-[In] 2003 – ([State 1]) Enter dwelling with intent to commit an indictable offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $1,500;-[In] 2004 – ([State 1]) Breach of suspended sentence imposed [in 2001]. Breach proven, no further penalty imposed;-[In] 2006 – ([State 1]) Possessing dangerous drugs (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $600;-[In] 2006 – ([State 1]) Commit public nuisance (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $600;-[In] 2006 – ([State 1]) Obstruct Police Officer (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $400;-[In] 2007 – ([State 1]) Assault Police Officer (on [date]). Conviction recorded, probation for 7 months;-[In] 2007 – ([State 1]) Obstruct Police Officer (on [date]). Conviction recorded, probation for 7 months;-[In] 2008 – ([State 1]) Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking (on [date]). No conviction recorded, fined $500;-[In] 2008 – ([State 1]) Obstruct Police Officer (on [date]). Conviction recorded, probation for 2 years;-[In] 2008 – ([State 1]) Commit public nuisance (on [date]). Conviction recorded, probation for 2 years;-[In] 2008 – ([State 1]) Failure to appear in accordance with undertaking (on [date]). Conviction recorded, probation for 2 years;-[In] 2008 – ([State 2]) Common assault (on [date]). Conviction recorded, S.9 Bond imposed (12 months comply with AVO);-[In] 2008 – ([State 2]) Drive with low range PCA (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $300, disqualified from driving for 6 months;-[In] 2008 – ([State 2]) Licence expired less than 2 years before, first offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, no other penalty;-[In] 2009 – ([State 1]) Breach of probation order imposed [in 2007]. Conviction recorded, fined $350;-[In] 2009 – ([State 1]) Breach of probation order imposed [in 2008]. Conviction recorded, fined $400. Order revoked and re-sentenced for original offences with convictions recorded and sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months (wholly suspended for a period of 18 months);-[In] 2010 – ([State 2]) Contravene Prohibition/Restriction in AVO (Domestic) (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $500;-[In] 2010 – ([State 2]) Contravene Prohibition/Restriction in AVO (Domestic) (on [date]). Conviction recorded, S.9 Bond imposed for 2 years;-[In] 2010 – ([State 2]) Contravene Prohibition/Restriction in AVO (Domestic) (on [date]). Conviction recorded, fined $500;-[In] 2014 – ([State 1]) Contravene direction or requirement (on [date]). No conviction recorded and not further punished; -[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Using a Carriage Service to Menace, Harass or Cause Offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 6 months with recognisance $3,000 and good behaviour period 2 years;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Contravention of Domestic Violence Order (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 6 months (concurrent);-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Using a Carriage Service to Menace, Harass or Cause Offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 12 months with recognisance $3,000 and good behaviour period 2 years;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Contravention of Domestic Violence Order (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 12 months concurrent;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Serious Assault Police Officer Whilst Pretending / Is Armed With a Weapon (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 12 months concurrent;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Possessing Dangerous Drugs (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 14 days concurrent;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Unlawful Possession of Weapons Category A, B or M (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 7 days concurrent;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Possessing Dangerous Drugs (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 7 days concurrent; -[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Possess Utensils or Pipes etc. That Had Been Used (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 7 days concurrent; -[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Using a Carriage Service to Menace, Harass or Cause Offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months with recognisance $3,000 and good behaviour period 2 years;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Contravention of Domestic Violence Order (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months concurrent;-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Common Assault Domestic Violence Offence (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months concurrent; -[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Unlawful Use of Motor Vehicles, Aircraft or Vessels (on [date]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months concurrent; and-[In] 2017 – ([State 1]) Receiving Tainted Property (Between [two dates]). Conviction recorded, sentenced to imprisonment for 3 months concurrent.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

Decision

Reasons for decision

Considering the circumstances as a whole, the Tribunal concludes that the visa should be cancelled.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 444 (Special Category) visa.K. ChapmanMember

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On balance, following careful consideration, the Tribunal affords more weight to the evidence outlined above which suggests the ground for visa cancellation exists, than it gives to evidence to the contrary. Accordingly, the Tribunal finds that the applicant’s presence in Australia might be a risk to the safety of the Australian community, or a segment of the Australian community (being domestic partners of the applicant and their children, for example Mrs J and her five children). The Tribunal is therefore satisfied that the ground for cancellation in s.116(1)(e)(i) exists. As that ground does not require mandatory cancellation under s.116(3), the Tribunal must proceed to consider whether the power to cancel the visa should be exercised.Consideration of discretion There are no matters specified in the Act or Regulations that are required to be considered in relation to the exercise of the discretion to cancel the visa. However, in considering whether to exercise its discretion to cancel the applicant’s visa, the Tribunal has had regard to the relevant circumstances including, but not limited to, matters identified in the Department’s Procedures Advice Manual PAM3 ‘General visa cancellation powers’. The Tribunal has also very carefully considered the attribution of weight to the evidence before it in assessing whether the applicant’s visa should be cancelled. In doing so, the Tribunal is mindful of the observations of Collier J in Botha v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 362 at [39]: There is ample authority at high level in this country that it is for a decision-maker to attribute such weight to relevant information as it sees fit: see for example Kirby J in Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 at [24]; Gummow and Hayne JJ in Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510 at [197]; the plurality in Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS (2010) 243 CLR 164 at [33]. The applicant’s background has been detailed above. He has resided in Australia since 1999 from the age of [age] years and arrived with his parents and siblings. He has his grandmother, siblings and over 100 family members from his father’s side that reside in Australia. His father and a selection of relatives live in [Country 1]. The Tribunal accepts the oral and documentary evidence (including statements from family members) that some emotional and financial hardship will be faced by these family members, and the applicant, should the visa be cancelled. The Tribunal affords some weight to the respective evidence concerning this matter and finds that the aforementioned family considerations weigh against cancellation of the visa. For completeness, the Tribunal notes that no professional medical or psychological evidence was before it to suggest that either the applicant, or any other person, will suffer psychological hardship if the visa is cancelled, and it does not accept inferences to the contrary from witnesses who are unqualified in these fields.