1716676 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

1716676 (Refugee) [2022] AATA 2361 (28 June 2022)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1716676

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   Pakistan

MEMBER:Simone Burford

DATE:28 June 2022

PLACE OF DECISION:  Perth

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicants protection visas.

Statement made on 28 June 2022 at 11:59am

CATCHWORDS
REFUGEE – protection visa – Pakistan – fear of harm from family members and religious groups because of love marriage between cousins once removed – applicant threatened and attacked by militant religious extremists and second applicant beaten by family – credibility – inconsistent and implausible claims and evidence – families’ knowledge of relationship, consent to marriage and participation in wedding – members of family unit – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5AAA, 5J, 36, 65, 424A
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2

CASES
Abebe v Commonwealth (1999) 197 CLR 510
BEH15 v MIBP [2019] FCAFC 184
CQG15 v MIBP [2016] FCAFC 146
DAO v MIBP [2018] FCAFC 2
FCS17 v MHA (2020) 276 FCR 644
Kopalapillai v MIMA (1998) 86 FCR 547
MIAC v SZQRB [2013] FCAFC 33
MIMA v Lay Lat (2006) 151 FCR 214
MIMA v Rajalingam (1999) 93 FCR 220
Prasad v MIEA (1985) 6 FCR 155
Randhawa v MILGEA (1994) 52 FCR 437
Re Ruddock; Ex parte Applicant S154/2002 [2003] HCA 60
Selvadurai v MIEA (1994) 34 ALD 347
SZATV v MIAC (2007) 233 CLR 18
SZBEL v MIMIA (2006) 228 CLR 152
SZFDV v MIAC (2007) 233 CLR 51
WAKK v MIMIA [2005] FCAFC 225

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection on 5 July 2017 to refuse to grant the applicants protection visas under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

    Background

  2. The first applicant is a [Age 1]-year-old Pakistani citizen who was born in Abbottabad, Pakistan.  He is married and has three children who were all born in Australia. His spouse (the second applicant) and two eldest children (the third and fourth applicants) are included in this review application.  The second applicant is a [Age 2]-year-old Pakistani citizen who was born in Abbottabad, Pakistan. The third and fourth applicants are [Age 3] and [Age 4] years old respectively.  A third child who is around [Age 5] years old is not included in the application.

  3. The first applicant first arrived in Australia in May 2007 as the holder of a student visa.  The second applicant first arrived in Australia [in] September 2012 as a dependant on the first applicant’s student visa.

  4. The applicants applied for the protection visas on 17 March 2015.

  5. At the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1716676 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 2361
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse to grant protection visas to the applicants, who were citizens of Pakistan. The applicants, a married couple and their two children, claimed they feared harm from family members and religious groups due to their "love marriage" which was considered unacceptable in their society. The first applicant also claimed to have been threatened by militant religious extremists, and the second applicant alleged she was beaten by her family.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicants had established a well-founded fear of persecution based on their membership in a particular social group, specifically "Pakistani Muslims who entered into a love marriage" or "Pakistanis who have been educated in a Western country," or if they qualified for complementary protection. A key consideration was whether it would be reasonable for the applicants to relocate to another area within Pakistan to avoid the feared harm, as provided for under section 36(2B)(a) of the Migration Act 1958. The Tribunal was required to assess the credibility of the applicants' claims in light of the evidence presented and relevant country information.

The Tribunal found that the applicants' claims were inconsistent and implausible, leading to adverse credibility findings. It noted that both sets of parents and siblings attended the wedding ceremony, and the second applicant's grandfather and uncles acted as witnesses. The Tribunal also considered that the applicants had lived with the first applicant's family after the marriage, which contradicted claims of severe and ongoing opposition from that side of the family. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the applicants had not demonstrated that relocation within Pakistan would be unreasonable, referencing High Court authority that reasonableness depends on the applicant's specific circumstances. The Tribunal concluded that the applicants had not satisfied the onus of proving a real risk of significant harm that would warrant the grant of protection visas.

The Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision to refuse the protection visas.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection on 5 July 2017 to refuse to grant the applicants protection visas under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).Background The first applicant is a [Age 1]-year-old Pakistani citizen who was born in Abbottabad, Pakistan. He is married and has three children who were all born in Australia. His spouse (the second applicant) and two eldest children (the third and fourth applicants) are included in this review application. The second applicant is a [Age 2]-year-old Pakistani citizen who was born in Abbottabad, Pakistan. The third and fourth applicants are [Age 3] and [Age 4] years old respectively. A third child who is around [Age 5] years old is not included in the application. The first applicant first arrived in Australia in May 2007 as the holder of a student visa. The second applicant first arrived in Australia [in] September 2012 as a dependant on the first applicant’s student visa. The applicants applied for the protection visas on 17 March 2015. At the hearing the applicants confirmed that this is the second application for a protection visa lodged by the first and second applicants. The first application for a protection visa was lodged on 9 December 2013. That application was withdrawn on 10 March 2014. On 5 July 2017 a delegate of the Minister refused the second protection visa application. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.Protection claims The applicants detailed their claims for protection in their applications for protection. The delegate’s decision, dated 5 July 2017, contains a summary of the claims made in the application and during the first and second applicants’ interviews with the Department. The applicants provided a copy of the delegate’s decision to the Tribunal. The second and third applicants did not make any claims of their own. Initial claims detailed by the first applicant in the protection visa application are:·They got married even though members of their family and in-laws were against the wedding.·They received lots of threats, opposition and pressure from religious parties and most of their relatives.·If they return to Pakistan they will be shot as their marriage is an unacceptable sin and a very big crime. The first applicant has disobeyed his family and for religious groups a “love marriage” means the applicant is not a Muslim.·The first applicant and his wife have suffered a significant amount of stress and mental anxiety. One religious group tried to kill him because love marriage is a big sin and crime for which the punishment is death. The applicant’s wife was beaten and hurt badly by her family members and was nearly dead in the name of honour killing.·The applicants tried to contact police but the authorities were unable to provide any assistance/security because of religious militants group who were involved.·If the applicants moved to another state or site in Pakistan those parties will/could chase and kill them. In Pakistan there is interstate conflict between the people in the name of language and religion.·If the first applicant and his wife return to Pakistan they will be treated like they did a big crime and a sin because love marriage is unacceptable. They fear that the second applicant’s relatives/family members, religious parties and militant groups can kill them in the name of honour killing. They didn’t like that the first applicant got a qualification from Australia.·In Pakistan, everybody, including authorities, are scared of militant groups and being killed every now and then, including school children, so the applicants do not think that they can protect their family, especially as the first applicant belongs to the Khyber Pakhtoon Khuwa state.·The applicants cannot relocate within Pakistan because of interstate conflict; many incidents of killing have been reported of people who try to live and survive in another state.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal finds that the applicants are citizens of Pakistan, which is also their receiving country for the purposes of the refugee and complementary protection assessments.EVIDENCE The issue in this case is whether the first and second applicants have a well-found fear of persecution due to their membership of a particular social group as ‘Pakistani Muslims who entered into a love marriage’, as ‘Pakistanis who have been educated in a Western country’ or for any other reason or if complementary protection provisions apply to them. At the interview with the Department the second applicant provided evidence, which is summarised as follows:·The first and second applicants grew up as neighbours. They are the same religion (Sunni) and ethnicity (Gujer).·She lived with her mother (House [1]) until she was married to the first applicant. She moved to his house and stayed there for six months, until coming to Australia.·Her father owns their house and her parents, sisters and her [Age 6] year-old brother continue to live there. She did not undertake paid work in Pakistan.·The first and second applicants are relatives; the first applicant is her mother’s cousin.·She was not sure when they first met but thought it was in 2007 or 2008.·Her family did not pay a dowry. It was a love marriage, not arranged, and both their families were against it and they tortured her.·They had a small wedding ceremony, included the cleric and not many other people:o Both sets of parents attended and siblings.o The Nikah was performed and there was no party afterwards.o When asked about the witnesses named on their marriage certificate, she said [Mr F] (a neighbour) and the first applicant’s brother were his witnesses. Her grandfather and two of her uncles were her witnesses.·Following the ceremony they lived together in his house [2] for about 4 months, and after the first applicant left for Australia she lived in Pakistan for a further 2 months. After her husband returned to Australia (July 2012) she remained living in [2] while waiting for her visa for Australia. This was between March and September 2012.·She sometimes talks to her parents but they don’t talk much because of the marriage. She has called them to say sorry but her father hates her after the marriage. She last contacted her sister three weeks ago and had last contacted the first applicant’s siblings 2 or 3 months ago.·She has family in Islamabad, Karachi and Lahore but does not know them or their names. She did not visit them often. She has a sister and maternal aunt living in [Country 1]. Her sister moved to [Country 1] before she was married. She got married and is living in [Country 1] permanently. She has no family in Australia.·After she was married, her father and brother beat her for being in a ‘love marriage’ as it was bad in Muslim society. She could not recall dates, but it was after her husband had left for Australia, during the period she was waiting for her visa. On one occasion her father put a gun to her head and other times he and her brother would beat her with their hands and a stick.·The first applicant’s family did not do anything to intervene and were also unhappy with the marriage. When asked why her family did not prevent them from marrying, she said ‘if you do something like that in front of family it is very bad’; that’s why her family waited until after the wedding and then tortured her. Relatives and neighbours were around and helped her get free.·Their families opposed the marriage because they are not ‘good’ with each other and a love marriage is not acceptable to them. She fears harm from her mother, father, brother and uncle. They were not happy with the marriage and she fears they would also harm her children.·It would be very expensive to live in another city like Islamabad.·The first applicant’s brother is also opposed to the marriage and has threatened their lives. When asked why the first applicant’s family allowed her to live with them if they also opposed the marriage, she said that when living at the first applicant’s family house she lived separately from them and had little to do with them.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the first and second applicant have a well-founded fear of persecution due to their membership of a particular social group as 'Pakistani Muslims who entered into a love marriage', as 'Pakistanis who have been educated in a Western country' or for any other reason?
2. Are the claims and evidence presented by the applicants credible and consistent?
3. Can the applicants relocate to a safe area within Pakistan where they would not be at risk of significant harm?
4. Do the complementary protection provisions apply to the applicants if they are not found to be refugees under the Convention?
5. Are the applicants members of a family unit for the purposes of the Migration Act?

Held
1. Does the first and second applicant have a well-founded fear of persecution due to their membership of a particular social group as 'Pakistani Muslims who entered into a love marriage', as 'Pakistanis who have been educated in a Western country' or for any other reason?
The court concluded that the applicants do not have a well-founded fear of persecution, and the decision under review was affirmed.

2. Are the claims and evidence presented by the applicants credible and consistent?
The court concluded that the claims and evidence presented by the applicants are not credible and consistent.

3. Can the applicants relocate to a safe area within Pakistan where they would not be at risk of significant harm?
The court concluded that it would be reasonable for the applicants to relocate to a safe area within Pakistan.

4. Do the complementary protection provisions apply to the applicants if they are not found to be refugees under the Convention?
The court concluded that the complementary protection provisions do not apply to the applicants.

5. Are the applicants members of a family unit for the purposes of the Migration Act?
The court did not provide a specific conclusion on this issue but included the applicants' family members in the review application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Under s 36(2B)(a) of the Act, there is taken not to be a real risk that an applicant will suffer significant harm in a country if the Tribunal is satisfied that it would be reasonable for the applicant to relocate to an area of the country where there would not be a real risk that the applicant will suffer significant harm. The Tribunal draws guidance from the judgments of the High Court in SZATV v MIAC and SZFDV v MIAC which held that whether relocation is reasonable, in the sense of ‘practicable’, must depend upon the particular circumstances of the applicant and the impact upon that person of relocation within his or her country: SZATV v MIAC (2007) 233 CLR 18 and SZFDV v MIAC (2007) 233 CLR 51, per Gummow, Hayne & Crennan JJ, Callinan J agreeing.Mandatory considerations In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.84, made under s 499 of the Act, the Tribunal has taken account of the ‘Refugee Law Guidelines’ and ‘Complementary Protection Guidelines’ prepared by the Department of Home Affairs, and country information assessments prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration. The Tribunal notes that at the time of the first hearing the current DFAT Country Information Report: Pakistan was dated 20 February 2019 (the 2019 DFAT Report). In January 2022, DFAT released an updated country information report for Pakistan – the Country Information Report: Pakistan dated 25 January 2022 (the 2022 DFAT Report). The Tribunal considered the content of that report with respect to the applicant’s claims. The Tribunal considers that the general content of the 2022 DFAT Report as it relates to the applicants’ claims is consistent with the 2019 DFAT Report and with other country information discussed at the hearing. Relevant country information is discussed further below.Credibility assessments The Tribunal’s task of fact-finding may involve an assessment of an applicant’s credibility.[1] The mere fact that a person claims to fear persecution for a particular reason does not establish either the genuineness of the asserted fear or that it is ‘well-founded’ or that it is for the reason claimed. Similarly, the fact that an applicant claims to face a real risk of significant harm does not establish that such a risk exists, or that the harm feared amounts to ‘significant harm’. It remains for the applicant to satisfy the Tribunal that all of the statutory elements are made out. [1] Summaries of the principles relating to credibility findings are provided by the Federal Court in the following decisions: BEH15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCAFC 184 at [32]–[34] per Rangiah, Perry and Bromwich JJ; CQG15 v MIBP [2016] FCAFC 146 at [36]–[38] per McKerracher, Griffiths and Rangiah JJ; DAO v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 2 at [30] per Kenny, Kerr and Perry JJ.