1714169 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

1714169 (Refugee) [2022] AATA 5117 (14 December 2022)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

REPRESENTATIVE:  Mrs Anna Ryburn (MARN: 9905853)

CASE NUMBER:  1714169

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   Afghanistan

MEMBER:Christine Cody

DATE OF WRITTEN STATEMENT:         14 December 2022

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the applicant satisfies s 36(2)(a) of the Migration Act.

Statement made on 14 December 2022 at 7:34pm

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958, ss 5H, 36, 65, 91, 499

Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2

CASES

MIEA v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559
Nagalingam v MILGEA (1992) 38 FCR 191
Prasad v MIEA (1985) 6 FCR 155

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependants.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection on 6 June 2017 to refuse to grant the applicant a protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act). The applicant initially claimed to be a citizen of Iran, applied for the visa on 17 February 2016.

  2. The case was difficult to assess as it involved changing claims including changed ethnicity (from Khavari to Hazara) and nationality (from Iranian to Afghanistan), consideration as to whether the applicant held more than one nationality and would thus have been barred from making the current protection visa application without permission from the Minister (s.91P of the Act), and numerous untruths and concerns about documents. However, having regard to relevant country information and the applicant’s written and oral evidence, the Tribunal has considered that the core of her current claims is likely to be true, and it is satisfied that: she is a female Hazara, her nationality is that of Afghanistan, and in all the circumstances she meets s 36(2)(a). Arriving at this finding has involved considering a number of Departmental files, including her offshore prospective spouse visa file, her protection visa file, her (previous) prospective spouse’s protection visa file and her current husband’s protection visa files, as well as Departmental notes, inconsistencies arising from multiple written applications and her oral evidence, as well as submissions and numerous documents, including documents relating to asylum claims of her family members in [Country 1], and significant country information researched by the Tribunal.

    The Department

  3. The Departmental file contains documents including the applicant’s protection visa application forms, Form 80 (Personal Particulars), a copy of the identification page of the applicant’s Iranian passport, a statement made by the applicant, copies of education records, copies of her marriage and divorce certificates, and the delegate’s decision record.

  4. The applicant was represented by a registered migration agent who provided assistance with completing her forms, Palagiri Sanjay Singh.

  5. The Departmental file does not contain any non-disclosure certificate.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1714169 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 5117
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, an Iranian citizen of Afghan Hazara ethnicity and Shia Muslim faith, sought a protection visa. Her claims for protection were based on fears of persecution in Afghanistan due to her ethnicity, religion, and status as a divorced woman and a failed asylum seeker. The primary dispute concerned the applicant's true nationality and ethnicity, and whether these, combined with her personal circumstances, gave rise to a well-founded fear of persecution or a real risk of significant harm upon return to Afghanistan or Iran. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine if the applicant met the criteria for a protection visa under section 36(2)(a) (refugee criterion) or section 36(2)(aa) (complementary protection criterion) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth).

The Tribunal considered the applicant's initial claims of Iranian citizenship and her subsequent revised claims of Afghan nationality, supported by a statutory declaration and an application for an Afghan identity document. A key issue was the applicant's credibility, given the significant discrepancies and changes in her account regarding her citizenship, ethnicity, and personal history, including the use of fake Iranian identity documents. The Tribunal also had to assess whether the applicant's fear of persecution was well-founded, considering the specific grounds raised, such as her Hazara ethnicity, Shia faith, and her status as a divorced woman and a failed asylum seeker. The Tribunal was tasked with determining if Australia owed protection obligations to the applicant under either the refugee or complementary protection provisions, taking into account the available country information regarding the treatment of Hazaras and divorced women in Afghanistan and Iran.

The Tribunal found significant credibility concerns due to the applicant's numerous untruths and the substantial changes in her claims throughout the process. While acknowledging that fear of persecution could explain some inaccuracies, the Tribunal did not accept this as a complete explanation for the extent of the inconsistencies. The Tribunal noted that the applicant's revised claims, particularly regarding her Afghan nationality and the fabrication of her Iranian identity documents, were supported by documentary evidence such as the application for an Afghan Taskera and her statutory declaration. However, the Tribunal ultimately concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration, indicating that the initial decision did not adequately address all relevant aspects of the applicant's claims or the evidence presented.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Departmental file does not contain any non-disclosure certificate. Background and claims before the Department Written claims According to the application forms of 16 February 2016, the applicant’s background and claims are summarised below. The applicant states in her forms that her name is [Name 1], and that she was born in [Suburb 1], a suburb of Tehran, Iran, on [Date 1]. She has never been known by any other names. She is an Iranian citizen and has never been a national or citizen of any other country. She gained her Iranian citizenship through birth. Both her parents were Afghani citizens. The applicant belongs to the “Khavarhi Afghani” ethnic group and is a Shia Muslim. In her Form 80 she provides details of her parents: · [Mr A] born [date], born [in] Afghanistan, citizen of Afghanistan, and currently in Afghanistan. · [Ms B] born [date] in [Afghanistan], citizen of Afghanistan, currently in [Country 1]. Her Iranian birth certificate (Shenasnemeh) (birth certificate number [deleted]) issued [date] states that she was born in [Suburb 1], Iran on [Date 1] to:·[Mr A] ·[Ms B] In addition to her Iranian birth certificate, the other identity documents provided by the applicant were her national ID card (no issue date was provided, however there was an expiry date of [date] 2010) which recorded that her father is [Mr A], and some pages of her passport issued by the Iranian authorities [in] 2011 (expired [in] 2016, recording that her father is [Mr A]). In her Form 80 she provides details of her siblings as follows:· [DOB] sibling [Ms C] born in Tehran, an Iranian citizen, currently in Iran · [DOB] sibling [name] born in Tehran, an Iranian citizen, currently in Iran· [DOB] [Ms D] born in [Tehran], currently in [Country 1] Her elder sister [is] deceased. The applicant can read, speak and write Persian and English. The applicant completed high school [in] [year] in Iran and went on to complete the following degrees from [University 1] (the certificates record her ID reference as no. [and] that her father’s name is [Mr A]): · Bachelor [degree] in 2007 · Masters [degree] in 2009 · PHD in [2015] at [University 1], Iran; certificate provided dated 2 January 2016. In her protection visa application form she states that her occupation is lecturer. According to her Form 80 the applicant had worked in Iran from 2012 – 2014 at [University 2] as a teacher and from 2007 – 2010 at [a] [Company]. The applicant listed two previous addresses in Iran (from birth to August 2000 she resided in [Suburb 1], Tehran, and from August 2000 to December 2015/January 2016 she resided in Mashhad). The applicant states in her Form B that she is “married” to [Mr E] (born in [Afghanistan], who has Australian citizenship). Their relationship began on 20 June 2007 and the date and place of marriage was [October] 2014 in Masshad. They were not allowed to register their marriage in Iran because [Mr E] was a “foreigner”. So she applied for a prospective spouse visa and she left Iran legally using her Iranian passport, which is valid for return to Iran. She travelled to Australia with the intention of marrying [Mr E]. She arrived on [date] January 2016 holding a subclass 300 marriage visa.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal considered that a further hearing was not necessary as it was able to make a decision favourable to the applicant. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that matter should be remitted for reconsideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE, FINDINGS AND REASONS The issues in this case are described in the second paragraph and relate to the applicant’s nationality, ethnicity, whether she meets the definition of refugee or is entitled to complementary protection, and a provisions of the Migration Act which may indicate that she is prevented from being found to satisfy the relevant criteria. Credibility The Tribunal has significant concerns about the applicant’s credibility. While it acknowledges that there may be valid reasons for telling some untruths (for example fear of persecution), it does not accept that this can explain the many untruths in this case. It is appropriate to set out some background history about Hazaras from Afghanistan and their migration to Iran at this stage, before discussing the applicant’s evidence. The criteria for a protection visa are set out in s 36 of the Act and Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations). An applicant for the visa must meet one of the alternative criteria in s 36(2)(a), (aa), (b), or (c). That is, he or she is either a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under the ‘refugee’ criterion, or on other ‘complementary protection’ grounds, or is a member of the same family unit as such a person and that person holds a protection visa of the same class. Section 36(2)(a) provides that a criterion for a protection visa is that the applicant for the visa is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations because the person is a refugee. A person is a refugee if, in the case of a person who has a nationality, they are outside the country of their nationality and, owing to a well-founded fear of persecution, are unable or unwilling to avail themselves of the protection of that country: s 5H(1)(a). In the case of a person without a nationality, they are a refugee if they are outside the country of their former habitual residence and, owing to a well-founded fear of persecution, are unable or unwilling to return to that country: s 5H(1)(b). Under s 5J(1), a person has a well-founded fear of persecution if they fear being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, there is a real chance they would be persecuted for one or more of those reasons, and the real chance of persecution relates to all areas of the relevant country. Additional requirements relating to a ‘well-founded fear of persecution’ and circumstances in which a person will be taken not to have such a fear are set out in ss 5J(2)-(6) and ss 5K-LA, which are extracted below. If a person is found not to meet the refugee criterion in s 36(2)(a), he or she may nevertheless meet the criteria for the grant of the visa if he or she is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations because the Minister has substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of being removed from Australia to a receiving country, there is a real risk that he or she will suffer significant harm: s 36(2)(aa) (‘the complementary protection criterion’). The meaning of significant harm, and the circumstances in which a person will be taken not to face a real risk of significant harm, are set out in ss 36(2A) and (2B), which are extracted below.Mandatory considerations

Decision

Reasons for decision

She had many problems because of her background; she said that she is smart, but the teachers ignored her, she didn’t have a chance to show herself or her ability. She did not get real opportunities. She did the teaching job as others were not inclined to do this. The delegate put to her that in order to get that doctorate at a very good university, that indicates that she did get support. She suggested she got minimum support and it took her 6 years instead of 4 years to finish her PhD.The delegate’s decision record The application was refused by the Department on 06 June 2017. The delegate accepted that the applicant was an ethnic Khavari based on her testimony at interview, her marriage in Iran to an Afghani male and Department records in relation to her prospective marriage visa. Reference was made to a February 2013 joint fact-finding mission report of the Danish immigration Service (DiS), the Danish Refugee Council (DRC) and the Norwegian Country of Origin Information Centre (Landinfo) noting that ‘‘the word ‘khavar’ means ‘east’ and ‘Khavari’ means ‘person from the east’” and "the Khavaris are a group of people with Afghan Hazara or Barbari origins, mostly Shia Muslim”. There are about 2.5 million persons in Iran who are regarded as Khavaris and they are often victims of racially motivated discrimination based on their appearances which often hint to their Afghan Hazara origins. Khavaris with Iranian citizenship face some (though not systematic) discrimination and while they are entitled by law to the same rights as other Iranian citizens, they are treated as “second-class citizens” and are discriminated against both socially and economically, and they face prejudice. Their discrimination is similar to the discrimination faced by people from Afghanistan, irrespective of whether the Khavaris hold Iranian citizenship or live in Iran illegally. [2][2] (As cited in the delegate’s decision record) Austrian Centre for Country of Origin and Asylum Research and Documentation (ACCORD). "Iran: Freedom of Religion;Treatment of Religious and Ethnic Minorities COI Compilation September 2015", 01 September 2015, CISEC96CF13622 The delegate noted that the applicant claimed to fear that due to her divorce she will be ostracised by her family, friends and the Afghani community in Iran and she will have little opportunity to get remarried as she is a divorced women who is [age] years of age. She was asked why she considers she will be ostracised, and she responded that she has had little contact with her family in Iran. The delegate could not locate country information which supports the applicant’s claim she will be ostracised by the Afghani community due to her divorce. The delegate considered that although the applicant may experience social stigmatisation due to her divorce, it would not amount to persecution. The delegate found it speculative that the applicant would not remarry due to a previous divorce and her age.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By way of email dated 5 March 2021, the Tribunal was provided with an application to the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan for a Taskera[3] via the Afghan Embassy of Australia, dated [February] 2021 (with a translation). This application contained the following details:[3] Spelt a variety of ways including Taskira, Tazkira. According to the current DFAT report (August 2021-January 2022), the taskira is the primary form of identification for Afghan citizens. Taskiras act as the primary document necessary to obtain other forms of identification including passports. They are also required for employment and admission to schools and universities, to obtain approval to run a business, and to buy, rent and sell property.· The applicant’s name was [Name 2] born [Date 1] in [Suburb 1], Tehran, Iran, her father’s name was [name], grandfather’s name was [name] [this was the first time that these surnames were used].· Her principal relative was [Mr E] who is described as her paternal [cousin], and whose Taskera was issued [in] September 2013 [this was the first time that [Mr E], her former prospective spouse, was said to be her paternal cousin]. Statutory Declaration changing her claims By way of email dated 9 March 2021, a statutory declaration of the applicant, dated 8 March 2021, provided a significant change in her claims, which are as follows: · The applicant is not an Iranian citizen, she is an Afghan citizen, born in Iran into an Afghan refugee family. · The applicant did not put forward to the Department all the information to support a finding that she is of Afghan nationality. · When she entered Australia on a prospective partner visa she stated she was an Iranian citizen and that her ethnicity was Khavari.· She had not been able to obtain a Taskera because she understood that she had to go to Afghanistan to get one at that time. · In the course of the protection visa application the topic of citizenship was not canvassed or discussed in detail. · The applicant had not received legal advice regarding changing her position and while she thought about this, she was scared to raise the subject herself from fear for her siblings who remain in Iran with fake Iranian identities.· The applicant’s mother and father are both from Daikundi (then Uruzgan). They married young, when the mother was about [age] years old, the father was [a few] years older than the mother. Neither of the applicant’s parents had the opportunity to attend school, they had poor literacy and numeracy skills. · They fled Afghanistan in or about 1968 as refugees (prior to the birth of their children). · Both parents worked on a [farm] in Iran, but this farm was raided, and they were deported back to Afghanistan, the applicant’s mother estimates this happened around 1972. Their life in Afghanistan was dire. The applicant’s parents returned to Iran and the applicant’s father worked with poultry, and her mother worked as a [occupation] etc. When inspectors visited, the employer hid the applicant’s parents. This employer sorted out some fake Iranian documents for the applicants’ parents to allow them to live their lives, keep working, and avoid deportation. These documents were made prior to the birth of their children. · The applicant’s mother was about [age] years old when she gave birth to the applicant’s oldest [sister] (who was born in or about [year] and is about [age] years older than the applicant). · On or about 1979 the applicant’s mother left the farm and started working in [a] factory. · The applicant’s mother and father relocated to [Suburb 1] and the applicant’s father found farm work in [Suburb 1]. · The applicant’s older sister [Ms C] was born in [year], and her older brother [was] born in [year].· The applicant was born in [year]. · When the applicant was [age] years old [in about 1991 or 1992], the applicant’s mother “upgraded her Iranian ID successfully by paying an agent”. He had only however succeeded in “creating a non-genuine birth certificate for her”. · The applicant’s father was not able to “upgrade” his identification because there were too many questions, so he abandoned the process due to concerns he would be found out during the process”. · In [year] the applicant’s younger sister [Ms D] was born. She is [a few] years younger than the applicant, however she now lives in [Country 1] and her birthdate is now recorded as [year]. · In 1997 the applicant’s father underwent [surgery] and was off work for 3 years, the mother supported the family. · Due to the applicant and her siblings holding fake Iranian identities, they were able to enrol in government schooling in [Suburb 1]. The applicant attended [schools] in [Suburb 1], and then finished her high school [in] [year], having moved there to join her father in 2000.· The applicant’s father started manufacturing [products], whilst the family was based in Mashad. The mother retired from the factory in [Suburb 1] and she and the other siblings joined her and her [in] 2001. · In 2002 Iran upgraded national identity cards in order to weed out fake identities and her mother was not able to obtain a national identity card. From this time on she was not able to pass as an Iranian in Iran so could not even obtain medical care. · In September [year], the applicant began studying Bachelor [degree] at [University 1] · In 2004 the applicant’s father went to Afghanistan, called her mother and said he was heading to Kabul, they never heard from him again. Her mother tried to obtain an Afghan Temporary Residence Card, however she was refused for being single, and was told the card was for families. · In 2007 the applicant commenced Masters [degree] at [University 1].· In September 2009 the applicant commenced her [PhD]. · In November 2014 the applicant married [Mr E], her paternal cousin in a religious nikah ceremony. As he was not Iranian, they were unable to obtain a marriage certificate. They did not use an agent. They decided that she would use her (fake) Iranian documents to lodge prospective ex-partner application, sponsored by [Mr E], as she did not have any Afghan identity documents. · The applicant graduated PhD on [date] September 2015. · Her mother and sister [Ms D] travelled to [Country 1] 15 days prior to PhD graduation, and sought asylum there. They presented their Afghan identification documents (obtained through Afghan embassy in [Country 1]) to the [Country 1] authorities and have been found by the [Country 1] authorities to be Afghan citizens and they were granted temporary protection visas. · The applicant arrived in Australia on [date] January 2016. · Her sister [Ms C] married on [date] February 2016 and migrated to [Country 1], thereafter, using her fake Iranian ID as she had no Afghan identification document. The applicant’s relationship with [Mr E]· The applicant’s [sister], and her paternal cousin [Mr E]’s father passed away in 2014 and the applicant and [Mr E] met again at this time in Iran when both were in mourning. His sister asked the applicant to marry him. [Mr E] visited the applicant in Iran whilst waiting for visa on 3 or 4 occasions for a few days at a time; he was frequently travelling for work. Their relationship was fine, although they didn’t spend a lot of time together. · Just before coming to Australia, [Mr E] asked the applicant to write to the Australian Embassy and seek an extension to delay arrival, worried about genetic defects of children; the applicant asked for extension, but she was informed that if she did not use the visa she would lose it.· [Mr E] was not in Australia when she arrived on [date] January 2016. He had gone to [another country] and did not answer her calls. It became apparent to the applicant that the relationship was not going to eventuate. The applicant had paternal cousins in Perth, but they were overseas attending a family wedding at the time of her arrival in Australia. · She sought advice from an agent and was advised that without sponsor she would need to leave Australia unless she got another visa. The thought of leaving Australia on fake documents and with no family, as a divorcee, was frightening. She had never lived or been to Afghanistan and did not have identity documents. · In April or May 2016, the applicant and [Mr E] completed a religious divorce without seeing each other. · The applicant’s brother is still in Iran and relies on fake identification, she is fearful that any enquiries in Iran could jeopardise her brother. Current Circumstances ·The applicant met her current husband, [Mr G], when [working]. They are both Hazara Afghans. They married on [date] March 2017. Her husband holds Temporary Protection Visa (Subclass 785), applied for a Subsequent SFE Haven Enterprise Visa which is yet to be processed.·Their eldest child [Son A] born on [date], holds a bridging E visa, and their second [child], born [date], holds a Subclass 785 visa. ·Neither child has permanent residency in Australia, both are secondary applicants to their father’s application.Fake Iranian Identity Documents ·The applicant states that she travelled to Australia on her fake Iranian passport: the name on her passport was [Alias 1]. While her fake Iranian passport was a genuine document, it was obtained by relying upon her fake birth certificate and fake national ID card. Her fake Iranian ID card had an expiry of [date] September 2010, but was “current” when entering Australia. Her Bachelor, Masters and PhD are all in her alias name [Alias 1]. Afghan National Identity Document · The applicant says that she has obtained legal advice that she should apply for Afghan National Identity card. She has done so, and has used her real family name [rather] than [Alias 1 surname] (which is not her real family name). She is awaiting the issuance of her Afghan National Identity Document. · She has submitted her ex-partner’s Afghan National Identity Document in support as he is her paternal cousin ([Mr E]). · She does not have her father’s Afghan National Identity Document. Although her mother has obtained an Afghan National Identity Document in recent years, the applicant has not been able to submit this in support due to the patriarchal system in Afghan National Identity Documents.Citizenship and Ethnicity · The applicant says that her citizenship is Afghani and not Iranian, and that her ethnicity is Hazara and not Khavari. She says that Khavari is a term for a subset of Hazara of subsequent generations living in Masshad and other areas of Iran however it is not a recognised ethnicity, rather just a subset of Hazara.· She apologises for not giving full disclosure; she was fearful when applying for both applications. Fear Upon Forcible Return to Afghanistan · The applicant fears death or significant harm from Taliban or Daesh if returned to Afghanistan due to her Hazara ethnicity; her Shia Islam religion; her imputed political opinion as a Shia Hazara; as a member of a group of people with an Iranian accent; as a member of a group of people who have lived in Iran; as being part of a group of returned failed asylum-seeker from a western nation; for her imputed political opinion as a returned failed asylum-seeker from a western nation; part of a group of people with foreign connections living in western nations. She also fears that she will be killed or significantly harmed for being a member of a group of women alone in Afghanistan without a male supporter. · She fears that if she is removed to Iran, she will be deported to Afghanistan, and the above concerns will apply.· She is identifiable as a Hazara woman[4] by her appearance. She speaks Persian with an Iranian accent which identifies her as a Hazara Shia and/or Iranian Shia. She fears being killed, kidnapped for ransom, raped, or otherwise significantly harmed by the Taliban for being a returned asylum seeker from a western country. [4] Her statement says that she is identifiable as a Hazara man but she has never otherwise claimed to face being imputed to be a man, and the Tribunal considers this to be an error· This will apply in Kabul or anywhere in Afghanistan. She will not be protected.· She could not take her children with her to such a dangerous place so would have to leave them behind, and both her husband and her children would suffer if she was deported.