1710637 (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

1710637 (Migration) [2020] AATA 3045 (10 June 2020)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1710637

MEMBER:Alison Murphy

DATE:10 June 2020

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision not to cancel the applicant’s Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa.

Statement made on 10 June 2020 at 12:06pm

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Return (Residence) (Class BB) visa – Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) – incorrect information in protection visa – previous residence and unsuccessful asylum application under another name in third country – use of incorrect information admitted – consistent and credible evidence – documentation confirming identity – exact date of birth unknown – Hazara ethnicity, Shia religion, imputed political opinion and work for foreign agency – country information – general conditions and specific attacks on Hazaras – non-refoulement – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 101(b), 107, 109(1)

CASES
DMH16 v MIBP [2017] FCA 448
MIAC v Khadgi (2010) 190 FCR 248
MIMA v Respondents S152/2003 (2004) 222 CLR 1

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 378 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration to cancel the applicant’s Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa under s.109(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The delegate cancelled the visa on the basis that she considered the applicant had given incorrect information in his protection visa application. The issue in the present case is whether that ground for cancellation is made out, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled.

  3. The applicant was represented in relation to the review by his registered migration agent.

  4. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be set aside.

    BACKGROUND

  5. The applicant is a young male arrived in Australia by boat [in] October 2009 and applied for a protection visa, identifying himself as a citizen of Afghanistan of Hazara ethnicity. On the basis of information provided in his protection visa application, he was granted a Class XA Subclass 866 protection visa on 16 December 2009 and a subclass 155 resident return visa on 13 November 2015.

  6. On 18 January 2017 a delegate of the Minister sent the applicant a Notification of Intention to Consider Cancellation under s.107 of the Act (the s.107 notice), advising him that she was considering the cancellation of his protection visa on the ground that she was not satisfied as to his identity. 

  7. Correspondence between the delegate and the applicant’s former representative identified that the notice dated 18 January 2017 contained a number of factual errors including information that did not appear to relate to the applicant.

  8. As a consequence a further s.107 notice was sent to the applicant by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1710637 (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 3045
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by an applicant against the cancellation of his Subclass 155 (Five Year Resident Return) visa. The applicant had arrived in Australia in 2009 and was granted a Subclass 866 (Protection) visa based on his claims of being an Afghan national of Hazara ethnicity, a Shia Muslim, with an imputed political opinion and having worked for a foreign agency. Subsequently, his Subclass 155 visa was granted in 2015. A delegate of the Minister issued a notice of intention to cancel the applicant's protection visa, alleging that the visa had been granted based on incorrect information regarding his identity, including his name, date of birth, previous countries of residence and travel, and migration history. This was discovered through a fingerprint match with an alias used in a previous asylum application in another country.

The court was required to determine whether the applicant had provided incorrect information in his visa applications, and if so, whether the decision to grant the protection visa was based wholly or partly on that incorrect information. Furthermore, the court needed to consider whether the circumstances of the non-compliance warranted the cancellation of the visa, exercising its discretion under section 109 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).

The court found that the applicant had indeed provided incorrect information regarding his previous residence and asylum application in another country, and that he had used an alias. However, the court was satisfied that the applicant's protection visa would have been granted even if this information had been disclosed. This was based on the original delegate's assessment of the applicant's credibility, the country information available at the time regarding the deteriorating situation for Hazaras in Afghanistan, and the high grant rate for protection visas for Afghan nationals during that period. The court accepted the applicant's explanation for providing incorrect information, noting his youth, difficult personal circumstances, and fear of being returned to Afghanistan. Consequently, the court determined that the decision to grant the visa was not based on the incorrect information.

The court concluded that while there had been non-compliance with section 101(b) of the Act due to the provision of incorrect information about his travel history and asylum application in another country, the discretionary power to cancel the visa under section 109 should not be exercised. The decision to cancel the applicant's visa was set aside.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be set aside. BACKGROUND The applicant is a young male arrived in Australia by boat [in] October 2009 and applied for a protection visa, identifying himself as a citizen of Afghanistan of Hazara ethnicity. On the basis of information provided in his protection visa application, he was granted a Class XA Subclass 866 protection visa on 16 December 2009 and a subclass 155 resident return visa on 13 November 2015. On 18 January 2017 a delegate of the Minister sent the applicant a Notification of Intention to Consider Cancellation under s.107 of the Act (the s.107 notice), advising him that she was considering the cancellation of his protection visa on the ground that she was not satisfied as to his identity. Correspondence between the delegate and the applicant’s former representative identified that the notice dated 18 January 2017 contained a number of factual errors including information that did not appear to relate to the applicant. As a consequence a further s.107 notice was sent to the applicant by email on 13 February 2017. In summary, the s.107 notice sets out the following:·In his protection visa application, he identified himself as [the applicant], born [Date 1, Year 1]. He stated he had not been known by any other names (questions 1, 3, 4 and 7);·In response to questions asking for details of countries in which he had travelled, resided or transited through before his arrival in Australia, he listed these countries as Afghanistan, [Country 1], [Country 2] and [Country 3] (questions 32, 33 and 34);·In response to questions asking whether he had ever applied for refugee status or applied to migrate to a country other than Australia, he answered no (questions 56 and 57);·On the basis of this information, he was granted a protection visa on 16 December 2009;·As part of his protection visa application process, the applicant provided biometric information including his fingerprints. On 10 October 2014 the Department of Immigration (the Department) became aware that his fingerprints had been matched to those of [Alias], born [Date, Year 2], who resided in [Country 4] between [April] 2002 and [October] 2006 before being removed from [Country 4] after his asylum application was refused and he had exhausted all appeal rights;·The biometric information indicated the applicant had given incorrect information in his protection visa application as to his name, date of birth, his countries of former residence and travel and his migration history;·On 13 November 2015, the applicant lodged an application for a Subclass 155 resident return visa, in which he provided personal information consistent with his protection visa application. The biometric information indicated he had also provided incorrect information in his resident return visa application as to his name, date of birth and whether he had been known by any other names. The s.107 notice invited the applicant to comment on the information contained in the notice.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant responded to the s.107 notice by way of documents and submissions provided to the delegate on 27 February 2017. In a statutory declaration dated 27 February 2017 the applicant acknowledged that he was in [Country 4] between [April] 2002 and [October] 2006 where he used the name [Alias]. He stated that this is not his real name, rather his real name is [the applicant]. He stated (in summary):·He is a Hazara Shia from [Town], Jaghuri and the details he provided about his family in his protection visa application are correct. Apart from his statements about attending school in Afghanistan after 2002, all the information in his statutory declaration made 13 November 2009 is correct;·He was very young when he went to [Country 4], about [Age 1] years old. The decision to send him to [Country 4] was made by his family for his safety. He travelled overland with a group, following the directions of an agent. He gave his real name [the applicant] when the group were first interviewed by government officials in [Country 5] and the group continued to travel through [Country 6] to [Country 4]. The agent and others in the group told him not to use his real name in [Country 4] or he would be sent back to the first country in which he had registered, being [Country 5]. When they arrived in [Country 4], he gave his name as [Alias]. When he was asked his age, he told the [Country 4] officials he was [Age 1] and they assigned him a date of birth;·He was granted a visa to remain in [Country 4] until he was [Age 2] and when this expired, he had to go to court and re-apply. His application was refused because [Country 4] said the situation in Afghanistan had improved, especially in big cities like Kabul, and it was safe for him to return. He went through the appeal processes available to him but in the end had no choice but to return to Afghanistan;·On return to Afghanistan, he went back to his family land in Jaghuri, but there was no work so he could not stay permanently. He found a job working in the [Agency] in Kabul (being an international aid agency discussed in the November 2009 statutory declaration accompanying his protection visa application) working first as [an Occupation 1] in a [facility] and later being promoted to [an Occupation 2]. [The] Agency were part of USAID and working for them was a risk, but he was desperate for work and there were no other jobs available;·He did not feel safe in Kabul, where he finished work late at night [and] had to travel back to his accommodation. He also travelled from Kabul back to Jaghuri to see his family and vehicles he travelled in were stopped three times by the Taliban on the road back to Jaghuri. There were attacks happening in the city often and on two occasions he was close to locations where suicide bombers attacked. His brother [Mr A] went missing in early 2009 and the applicant made the decision to leave Afghanistan again, fearing he would be at risk of kidnapping because he worked for a foreign agency;·Having already been returned from Afghanistan to [Country 4], he didn’t know if he was allowed to put in applications in more than one country and feared being sent back to Afghanistan again if he said he had already applied for asylum in [Country 4]. ·He is unsure of his exact age or date of birth as such things are not recorded in Afghan culture, but he worked out his year of birth from the taskera issued to him by the local government office in Jaghuri after his return to Afghanistan from [Country 4]. He chose [Date 1, Year 1] as his date of birth when he came to Australia in order to avoid being assigned the date 31 December or 1 January.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons I am satisfied the correct identity of the applicant is [the applicant]. While the exact date of his birth is not known to him and cannot otherwise be established, I accept that to the best of his knowledge he was born in the year [1]. For the purposes of this review I find that his date of birth is that which he provided to the Australian authorities, [Date 1, Year 1], acknowledging that the day and birth month are merely approximations.Conclusion on non-compliance For the reasons set out above, I have found that the applicant gave incorrect information in his protection visa application as to whether he was known by any other name, the countries in which he had travelled, resided or transited through before his arrival in Australia and whether he had ever applied for refugee status or applied to migrate to a country other than Australia (questions 4, 32, 33, 34, 56, 57). I have not accepted he gave incorrect information about his name and date of birth (questions 1 and 7). For these reasons, I find that there was non-compliance with s.101(b) by the applicant in the way described in the s.107 notice. Should the visa be cancelled? As the Tribunal has decided that there was non-compliance in the way described in the notice given to the applicant under s.107 of the Act, it is necessary to consider whether the visa should be cancelled pursuant to s.109(1). Cancellation in this context is discretionary, as there are no mandatory cancellation circumstances prescribed under s.109(2). In exercising this power, the Tribunal must consider the applicant’s response (if any) to the s.107 notice about the non-compliance and have regard to any prescribed circumstances: s.109(1)(b) and (c). The prescribed circumstances are set out in r.2.41 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). The correct information: I consider the correct information is that the applicant was resident in [Country 4] between 2002 and 2006, applying for asylum in that country before being removed from [Country 4] to Afghanistan in 2006. I consider he was known to the [Country 4] authorities as [Alias], an Afghan national born [Date, Year 2]. The content of the genuine document (if any): This prescribed circumstance is not relevant in the present case because the s.107 notice relied solely on s.101, not on s.103 of the Act (relating to bogus documents). Whether the decision to grant a visa or immigration clear the visa holder was based, wholly or partly, on incorrect information or a bogus document: The Department’s Protection Visa Decision Record (decision record) and Refugee Status Assessment Record (RSA record) need to be read together to assess the basis on which the applicant was granted a protection visa. While the decision record makes bare findings about the eligibility of the applicant for the protection visa, the RSA record contains the analysis and assessment of his claims and the country information considered. Both documents were authored by the same delegate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Whether the decision to grant a visa or immigration clear the visa holder was based, wholly or partly, on incorrect information or a bogus document: The Department’s Protection Visa Decision Record (decision record) and Refugee Status Assessment Record (RSA record) need to be read together to assess the basis on which the applicant was granted a protection visa. While the decision record makes bare findings about the eligibility of the applicant for the protection visa, the RSA record contains the analysis and assessment of his claims and the country information considered. Both documents were authored by the same delegate. On the basis of those documents, I am satisfied the applicant’s protection visa was granted because the delegate was satisfied he faced a real chance of persecution by the Taliban or other insurgents for the combined reasons of his Hazara ethnicity, his Shia religion and his imputed political opinion arising out of his employment for [the] Agency. The delegate records that he found the applicant a generally credible witness who answered the questions asked of him in a forthright manner, including questions relating to his employment as [an Occupation 1] and [Occupation 2] for the [Agency]. The applicant’s ethnicity and religion are not in dispute. His employment with the [Agency] occurred after he was returned to Afghanistan from [Country 4] in 2006. The situation for Hazaras in Afghanistan deteriorated between 2006 and 2009, with the delegate citing country information in his decision indicating that 2008 was the most violent year in Afghanistan since 2001 and January 2009 recorded 75% more security incidents than January 2008 as insurgents continued to expand their presence in previously stable areas of the country. For these reasons I am satisfied that the applicant would have been granted the protection visa by the delegate even had he disclosed his [Country 4] travel. This is particularly the case given the delegate who made the decision to cancel the protection visa recorded in her decision that 99.2% of protection visa applications lodged by citizens of Afghanistan in the 2009/10 financial year in Australia were granted. For these reasons I am not satisfied the decision to grant the visa was based in any part on the incorrect information. The circumstances in which the non-compliance occurred: The incorrect information was provided by the applicant in his 2009 protection visa application and again in his citizenship application in 2014. He states he gave the incorrect information because he was advised by the people in the detention centre that he should not mention his trip to [Country 4] and his efforts to seek asylum there and that he is deeply sorry for not disclosing this information. I accept he was still very young when he arrived in Australia and had experienced difficult personal circumstances, including travelling alone and undocumented to [Country 4] at a young age and being detained by both the [Country 5] and [Country 4] authorities before being deported back to Afghanistan and undertaking a dangerous boat journey to reach Australia.