1702194 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

1702194 (Refugee) [2021] AATA 2922 (30 June 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:1702194

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   India

MEMBER:James Silva

DATE:30 June 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the applicant satisfies s.36(2)(a) of the Migration Act.

Statement made on 30 June 2021 at 2:21pm

CATCHWORDS

REFUGEE – protection visa – India – particular social group – male homosexual – homosexual living with HIV – pressure to marry a woman – abuse by relatives – state protection – access to appropriate retroviral medication – employment – return visits to India – right to enter and reside in Nepal – decision under review remitted

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5(1), 5H, 5J – 5LA, 36, 65
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2

CASES

MIMAC v SZRHU [2013] FCAFC 91
SZTOX v MIBP [2015] FCAFC 77

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependants.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. The applicant is a man in his [age range] who claims to be an Indian citizen.

  2. The applicant most recently arrived in Australia [in] October 2011, as the holder of a [temporary] visa. He lodged an application for a protection (class XA) visa on 27 April 2016. On 3 February 2017, the delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (the delegate) refused the application pursuant to s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  3. This is an application for review of that decision.

  4. The applicant attended a Tribunal hearing on 7 August 2020.

  5. For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be remitted for reconsideration.

    CRITERIA FOR A PROTECTION VISA

  6. The issues in this case are: (1) whether the applicant meets the refugee criterion, as a person who has a well-founded fear of persecution in India for reason of his race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership of a political opinion (in particular, on the basis of his homosexuality and/or his HIV status) and if not, (2) whether he is eligible for complementary protection, on the basis of a real risk of significant harm if he returns to India. A summary of the relevant law is set out in Attachment A.

    CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

    Protection claims

  7. The applicant is a gay man living with HIV. He claims to have had a difficult life in India growing up gay, due to social stigma, sexual abuse and threats. He claims to fear discrimination and persecutory harm if he returns to India, at the hands of some [relatives], society at large and potentially the police. While there may be few occasions when his HIV status comes to light, he claims that he cannot be expected to conceal his sexuality or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1702194 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 2922
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the Refugee Tribunal. The applicant, a gay man living with HIV, sought a protection visa, claiming he feared persecution and discrimination if returned to India due to his sexuality and health status. He alleged he had experienced social stigma, sexual abuse, and threats in India, and faced pressure to marry a woman to conceal his identity. The applicant contended that he could not be expected to alter his identity to avoid a real chance of persecution.

The court was required to determine two primary issues: first, whether the applicant met the criteria for a refugee, specifically if he had a well-founded fear of persecution in India based on his race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership of a particular social group, including his homosexuality and HIV status; and second, if he did not qualify as a refugee, whether he was eligible for complementary protection due to a real risk of significant harm upon return to India.

The court considered the applicant's claims of past difficulties and future fears in India, including potential harm from relatives, society, and law enforcement. It also noted the applicant's HIV status and the challenges associated with accessing appropriate medication in India. The court found that the applicant had exaggerated the importance of his village of origin to bolster his protection claims, as evidenced by discrepancies with his passport and birth certificate. The court ultimately remitted the decision for reconsideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant is a gay man living with HIV. He claims to have had a difficult life in India growing up gay, due to social stigma, sexual abuse and threats. He claims to fear discrimination and persecutory harm if he returns to India, at the hands of some [relatives], society at large and potentially the police. While there may be few occasions when his HIV status comes to light, he claims that he cannot be expected to conceal his sexuality or alter it (by succumbing to pressure to marry a woman) so as to avoid a real chance of persecution in India.Background The applicant is [an age] year old man from Chennai. His languages are English, Tamil and Hindi. He identifies as a Hindu. The applicant was born and grew up in [Town 1], a residential area some [distance] from central Chennai. He lived there until he first left India for Australia, in 2007. The applicant attended school [between specified years]. He repeated [a specified year], and then went on to study at [a specified type] college in [District 1], some [distance] from his home. He continued living at home and commuted to the college campus. The applicant [worked] in call centres in Chennai; he said that, in practice, this meant answering calls from [overseas] customers. He worked in one call centre in [a named location in] Chennai, from August 2004 to April 2006; and later in another, in [another location] Chennai. The applicant claims that he was virtually forced to resign the latter job in February 2007. The applicant’s parents are from [Village 1], a village some [distance from] Chennai. He has [specified family members]. They all live in Tamil Nadu. He said that his father worked as [an occupation] in New Delhi and used to return to Tamil Nadu infrequently. He is now retired. The applicant said that he has occasional contact with his parents, perhaps once a month; he does not send money back to them. His contacts with his [siblings] are limited to birthday greetings and the like. He is not in contact with other family members. The applicant stated that although his family is now based in Chennai, they return to [Village 1] at least once a year and for major occasions (such as [family] weddings). At hearing, he also said that he was actually born therein [Village 1]. The Tribunal does not accept on the available evidence, including the applicant’s passport and birth certificate, that he was born there. It is concerned that he exaggerated the importance of this place, to bolster his protection claims. The applicant said that he has lost touch with friends, former colleagues and other people in India. The applicant currently holds an Indian passport issued in [Australia] in [2012], valid for ten years. As noted in the delegate’s decision record[1], he first arrived in Australia [in] February 2007, just after his [specified] birthday, as the holder of a [student] visa. He was subsequently granted a student [further stay] on 15 December 2009; and [another] temporary visa on 2 June 2011. He applied for a skilled [permanent] visa. The Department refused that application on 15 January 2015, on the grounds that he did not meet the health criterion, on the basis of his HIV status. The Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse the visa on 1 April 2016. [1] The applicant provided a copy of this with his application for review.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The issues in this case are: (1) whether the applicant meets the refugee criterion, as a person who has a well-founded fear of persecution in India for reason of his race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership of a political opinion (in particular, on the basis of his homosexuality and/or his HIV status) and if not, (2) whether he is eligible for complementary protection, on the basis of a real risk of significant harm if he returns to India. A summary of the relevant law is set out in Attachment A.CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEProtection claims The applicant is a gay man living with HIV. He claims to have had a difficult life in India growing up gay, due to social stigma, sexual abuse and threats. He claims to fear discrimination and persecutory harm if he returns to India, at the hands of some [relatives], society at large and potentially the police. While there may be few occasions when his HIV status comes to light, he claims that he cannot be expected to conceal his sexuality or alter it (by succumbing to pressure to marry a woman) so as to avoid a real chance of persecution in India.Background The applicant is [an age] year old man from Chennai. His languages are English, Tamil and Hindi. He identifies as a Hindu. The applicant was born and grew up in [Town 1], a residential area some [distance] from central Chennai. He lived there until he first left India for Australia, in 2007. The applicant attended school [between specified years]. He repeated [a specified year], and then went on to study at [a specified type] college in [District 1], some [distance] from his home. He continued living at home and commuted to the college campus. The applicant [worked] in call centres in Chennai; he said that, in practice, this meant answering calls from [overseas] customers. He worked in one call centre in [a named location in] Chennai, from August 2004 to April 2006; and later in another, in [another location] Chennai. The applicant claims that he was virtually forced to resign the latter job in February 2007. The applicant’s parents are from [Village 1], a village some [distance from] Chennai. He has [specified family members]. They all live in Tamil Nadu. He said that his father worked as [an occupation] in New Delhi and used to return to Tamil Nadu infrequently. He is now retired. The applicant said that he has occasional contact with his parents, perhaps once a month; he does not send money back to them. His contacts with his [siblings] are limited to birthday greetings and the like. He is not in contact with other family members. The applicant stated that although his family is now based in Chennai, they return to [Village 1] at least once a year and for major occasions (such as [family] weddings). At hearing, he also said that he was actually born therein [Village 1]. The Tribunal does not accept on the available evidence, including the applicant’s passport and birth certificate, that he was born there. It is concerned that he exaggerated the importance of this place, to bolster his protection claims.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established