1613377 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

1613377 (Refugee) [2017] AATA 383 (3 March 2017)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1613377

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                  India

MEMBER:Peter Vlahos

DATE:3 March 2017

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Protection visa.

Statement made on 03 March 2017 at 3:40pm

CATCHWORDS
Refugee – Protection visa – India – Particular social group – Inter-caste relationships – Love marriages – Threats from Khap Panchayat – Honour killings – State protection

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, ss 5, 36, 65, 91, 499
Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2

CASES
Guo v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1996) 64 FCR 151
MIMA v Rajalingam (1999) 93 FCR 220
Randhawa v MILGEA (1994) 52 FCR 437
Selvadurai v MIEA & Anor (1994) 34 ALD 347
Kopalapillai v MIMA(1998) 86 FCR 547

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration to refuse to grant the applicant a Protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The applicant, who claims to be a citizen of India, applied for the visa [in] February 2014 and the delegate refused to grant the visa [in] October 2014.

  3. On 25 January 2016, the Tribunal (differently constituted) affirmed the decision under review. [In] August 2016 the Federal Circuit Court ordered, by consent, that a Writ of Certiorari issue quashing the Tribunal’s decision and that a Writ of Mandamus issue directed to the Tribunal requiring it to determine the application made to it for review of the decision of the delegate to refuse the applicant’s application for a Protection visa according to law.

  4. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 15 November 2016 to give evidence and present arguments.

    RELEVANT LAW

  5. The criteria for a protection visa are set out in s.36 of the Act and Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). An applicant for the visa must meet one of the alternative criteria in s.36 (2)(a), (aa), (b), or (c). That is, the applicant is either a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under the ‘refugee’ criterion, or on other ‘complementary protection’ grounds, or is a member of the same family unit as such a person and that person holds a protection visa of the same class.

    Refugee criterion

  6. Section 36(2)(a) provides that a criterion for a protection visa is that the applicant for the visa is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations under the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1613377 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 383
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, an Indian national, sought a protection visa, claiming he feared persecution upon return to India due to an inter-caste relationship. The dispute concerned whether the applicant's fear of harm from a "khap panchayat" (a traditional village council) constituted a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of membership in a particular social group, and whether the Indian authorities could offer protection. The matter was before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.

The court was required to determine if the applicant's fear of harm from the khap panchayat, stemming from his relationship with a woman of a different caste, met the criteria for a protection visa. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the applicant belonged to a "particular social group" as defined by the Refugee Convention, and whether the threats he alleged were sufficiently serious and likely to be carried out by state or non-state actors that the Indian state was unable or unwilling to protect him. The court also had to assess the credibility of the applicant's claims in light of the evidence presented and relevant policy guidelines.

The court considered the applicant's claims in light of established principles for assessing refugee claims, including the importance of giving the benefit of the doubt to generally credible asylum seekers who may be unable to substantiate all claims. However, the court also noted that statements must be coherent, plausible, and not contrary to known facts, and that it was not required to accept allegations uncritically. The Tribunal had found the applicant's central claim regarding the inter-caste relationship not credible, noting inconsistencies in his account of when the relationship began and how it was discovered, and that his father had reacted negatively to the relationship. The Tribunal also noted the absence of requested telephone logs.

The court affirmed the Tribunal's decision, finding that the applicant had not established a well-founded fear of persecution. The Tribunal's adverse credibility finding regarding the inter-caste relationship was upheld, meaning the basis for the alleged fear of the khap panchayat was not accepted. Consequently, the applicant's application for a protection visa was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.56, made under s.499 of the Act, the Tribunal is required to take account of policy guidelines prepared by the Department of Immigration –PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Complementary Protection Guidelines and PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Refugee Law Guidelines – and any country information assessment prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEBackground The applicant claims to be born on [date] in [his hometown] in the Indian state of Rajasthan and claims to be a citizen of India. The applicant claims never to have been married or engaged; to belong to Hindu faith/tradition; and that he speaks and writes Hindi and English. The applicant’s father is [name], aged [age] and is a [retiree]; his mother is [name], aged about [age], and is a housekeeper. Both are retired, residing in [the hometown]. The applicant has one sibling [who] is married with no children and living in the same village as the applicant’s parents. The applicant claims his family as well as himself belong to the Jatt or Jagt caste and that he and his family belong to the Hindu faith/tradition. The applicant claims he went to school in [another town] in the Indian state of Haryana and attended [a named] University in the capital territory of Chandigarh. The applicant speaks, reads and writes in English and speaks Punjabi. The applicant arrived in Australia [in] September 2006 on a class TU [student] visa for tertiary studies. [In] June 2010, the applicant applied for a class TU subclass [visa] for [study] and was granted this visa [in] June 2010. [In] September 2011, the applicant applied for a subsequent [student] visa but was refused this visa [in] November 2011. The applicant sought merits review of this decision at the Tribunal, differently constituted. The Tribunal affirmed the primary decision not to grant the student visa. [In] August 2013, the applicant requested the Minister to personally intervene in granting the student visa. [In] January 2014, the Assistant Minister declined to employ her power in this case. [In] February 2014, the applicant applied for a XA subclass 866 visa. Written Claims for Protection The applicant provided limited in detail claims in his 866 Form. Below is a summary of those claims:§The applicant left his country because he was in a relationship with a girl from a different caste. The relationship brought shame and dishonour to the community. The applicant claims he was shunned by relatives and that the shame can only be erased ‘…through killing.’ §The applicant’s sister or girlfriend was threatened and even the applicant and his family were forced to move far away as he had brought shame to the community; §The applicant fears anything could happen if he was to return to India, including being killed or being forced to suicide; §The ‘khap’ will harm the applicant if he returns and even try to harm his family members; §The authorities in India will not be able to protect the applicant because due to the perpetrators’ belief that the victim has brought shame to his community and the authorities do not have proper arrangements to save the victim because many of them are khap members; §The applicant claims ‘…the law itself us under the shadow of honour…’ Honour killings in India are brushed aside as mere numbers in the newspaper reports, especially in northern India were the khap panchayats are proactive.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant provided no telephone logs of his discussions between himself and his girlfriend, [Ms A] as requested by the Tribunal in its letter to the applicant dated 16 November 2016.The Tribunal’s conclusions about the applicant’s claimsCredibility The Tribunal is aware of the importance of adopting a reasonable approach in finding of credibility. In Guo v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1996) 64 FCR 151, the Full Federal Court made comments on determining credibility. The Tribunal notes in particular the cautionary note sounded by Foster J at 194:“…care must be taken that an over-stringent approach does not result in an unjust exclusion from consideration of the totality of some evidence where a portion of it could reasonably have been accepted.” The Tribunal also accepts that “…if the applicant’s account appears credible, he should, unless there are good reasons to the contrary, be given the benefit of the doubt (see, The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees’ Handbook on Procedures and Criteria for Determining Refugee Status, Geneva, 1992 at paragraph 196). However, the Handbook states (at para 204): “The benefit of the doubt should, however, only be given when all available evidence has been obtained and checked and when the examiner is satisfied as to the applicant’s general credibility. The applicant’s statements must be coherent and plausible, and must not run counter to generally known facts.” When assessing claims made by applicants the Tribunal needs to make findings of fact in relation to those claims. This usually involves an assessment of the credibility of the applicants. When doing it is important to bear in mind the difficulties often faced by asylum seekers. The benefit of the doubt should be given to asylum seekers who are generally credible but unable to substantiate all of their claims. The Tribunal must bear in mind that if it makes an adverse finding in relation to a material claim made by the applicant but is unable to make that finding with confidence it must proceed to assess the claim on the basis that it might possibly be true (see MIMA v Rajalingam (1999) 93 FCR 220). However, the Tribunal is not required to accept uncritically any or all of the allegations made by an applicant. Further, the Tribunal is not required to have rebutting evidence available to it before it can find that a particular factual assertion by an applicant has not been made out. (see Randhawa v MILGEA (1994) 52 FCR 437 at 451 per Beaumount J; Selvadurai v MIEA & Anor (1994) 34 ALD 347 at 348 per Heerey J, and Kopalapillai v MIMA (1998) 86 FCR 547). First, the applicant claimed that he fears persecution in India at the hands of his village’s khap Panchayat because he had formed a ‘love-relationship’ with a local village girl from another caste which the khap disapproved. The Tribunal does not accept this claim as credible. According to the applicant’s evidence, his relationship with his girlfriend commenced in 2004 while both were attending university, in Chandigarh. After both tried to conceal their intimate relationship from friends and family, friends told the girl’s brother, who did not accept the relationship as proper and later the applicant’s father found out about it and expressed similar feelings and ‘slapped’ the applicant to show his displeasure.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established