1600050 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

1600050 (Refugee) [2018] AATA 3888 (4 October 2018)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1600050

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                  Indonesia

MEMBER:Frances Simmons

DATE:4 October 2018

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicants protection visas.

Statement made on 04 October 2018 at 4:57pm

CATCHWORDS

REFUGEE – protection visa – Indonesia – social group – religious tour operator – threats and assaults from disgruntled customers – subject of legal action in Indonesia – delay in applying for protection credibility issues – inconsistencies between protection visa application and evidence at the Tribunal – no protection claims for the second and third named applicants – decision under review affirmed  

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5, 5H, 5J, 5K-LA, 36, 65, 438, 499
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2

CASES
MZAFZ v MIBP [2016] FCA 1081

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration on 7 December 2015 to refuse to grant the applicants protection visas under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act). The primary applicant arrived in Australia on 28 March 2015 holding a [temporary] visa.

  2. The applicants, who the Tribunal accepts are citizens of Indonesia, applied for the visas on 21 September 2015. The primary applicant attended an interview with the delegate. His wife and son did not make their own claims for protection. The delegate refused to grant the visas on the basis that the applicant’s claims were not credible.

  3. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.

    CRITERIA FOR A PROTECTION VISA

  4. The criteria for a protection visa are set out in s.36 of the Act and Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). An applicant for the visa must meet one of the alternative criteria in s.36(2)(a), (aa), (b) or (c). That is, he or she is either a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under the ‘refugee’ criterion, or on other ‘complementary protection’ grounds, or is a member of the same family unit as such a person and that person holds a protection visa of the same class.

  5. Section 36(2)(a) provides that a criterion for a protection visa is that the applicant for the visa is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations because the person is a refugee.

  6. A person is a refugee if, in the case of a person who has a nationality, they are outside the country of their nationality and, owing to a well-founded fear of persecution, are unable or unwilling to avail themselves of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1600050 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 3888
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for a protection visa by the applicant, with the second and third named applicants also seeking protection. The applicant claimed to be at risk of harm in Indonesia due to disputes arising from his involvement with a religious tour operator, including allegations of embezzlement, threats from disgruntled customers and debt collectors, and adverse attention from the Indonesian police. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant and his family members met the criteria for a protection visa, considering the evidence presented and relevant policy guidelines.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were the credibility of the applicant's claims and whether he, and by extension the other applicants, faced a real risk of significant harm amounting to persecution in Indonesia. This involved assessing inconsistencies in the applicant's account, the validity of a s.438 certificate, and the weight to be given to various pieces of evidence, including a police summons. The Tribunal also considered the complementary protection criterion under s.36(2)(aa) of the Act, which allows for the grant of a visa if a person faces a real risk of significant harm as a consequence of removal from Australia.

The Tribunal found the s.438 certificate invalid, as it did not sufficiently articulate the public interest grounds for non-disclosure, referencing established case law on public interest immunity. Upon reviewing the applicant's evidence, including a police summons, the Tribunal concluded that the applicant's claims were not credible. It found no satisfactory evidence that the applicant was of adverse interest to any individuals or groups in Indonesia, nor that he or his family members faced threats from debt collectors, disgruntled pilgrims, or the police. The Tribunal determined that the applicant had manufactured his claimed dispute and that the police investigation mentioned in the summons was not demonstrably linked to his asserted persecution claims.

Consequently, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the applicant or the second and third named applicants faced a real chance of serious harm amounting to persecution in Indonesia. The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, finding that the applicants' profile in Indonesia was that of ordinary citizens and that their claims lacked credibility.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.56, made under s.499 of the Act, the Tribunal has taken account of policy guidelines prepared by the Department of Immigration – PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Complementary Protection Guidelines and PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Refugee Law Guidelines – and relevant country information assessments prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The Tribunal has considered the evidence before the Department and the evidence before the Tribunal. Invalid s.438 certificate A certificate purportedly issued pursuant to s.438(1)(a) of the Act has been placed on folios 96–104 of the departmental file restricting the disclosure of the information contained therein.[1] If a certificate is issued because the disclosure of information or documents would be contrary to the public interest, it is necessary for the certificate to specify the reasons why. For s.438 certificates, this is any reason specified in the certificate that could form the basis for a claim by the Crown in right of the Commonwealth in a judicial proceeding.[2] [1] Department file, folio 118. [2] S.438(1)(a)(i). In the Tribunal’s judgment the certificate placed on folios 96–104 of the departmental file is invalid as the description of the reasons for restriction does not properly identify a basis for public interest immunity. The certificate states that the disclosure of the information would be contrary to the public interest because it would reveal internal working documents and business affairs. In MZAFZ v MIBP[3] the Federal Court held that the Tribunal had erred in treating a non-disclosure certificate as valid where the only reasons cited in the certificate as contrary to the public interest were ‘internal working documents’ as this had never been a sufficient basis for public interest immunity whether at common law or under statute and did not identify the harm that could be done to an agency by the disclosure of the documents. At best, the words ‘internal working documents’ disclosed a reason that could form part of the basis for a claim, but not the basis of the claim itself.[4][3] MZAFZ v MIBP [2016] FCA 1081 (Beach J, 7 September 2016).[4] MZAFZ v MIBP [2016] FCA 1081 (Beach J, 7 September 2016) at [37]. See also BXD15 v MIBP [2017] FCA 1209 (Flick J, 12 October 2017) at [46]–[48]. The Tribunal advised the applicant of its view that the s.438 certificate was invalid. Having determined the certificate is invalid, the Tribunal has proceeded to treat the information contained in folios 96–104 in the usual way. As discussed with the applicant, folios 96–104 contain departmental notes relating to his visitor visa application and his son’s visitor visa application. To the extent that this information is relevant to the review, it is set out in the decision of the delegate, a copy of which was provided to the Tribunal by the applicant. Background

Decision

Reasons for decision

With respect to the police summons submitted after the hearing, the Tribunal does not accept that the applicant has provided a reasonable explanation as to why this document was not provided before the primary decision. In any event, if the Tribunal were to accept the summons is a copy of a genuine document, it does not assist the applicant’s claims. Even if the summons were to be accepted on face value all it establishes is the applicant was summoned by the police in 2013 as a witness in relation to a police investigation in deception. It does not suggest that the applicant himself is of any adverse interest to the police; it does not refer to Mr B or Company A; and it does not corroborate the applicant’s claims that he reported the actions of Mr B to the police, either in 2014 or at any other time. Conclusions on the credibility of the applicant’s claims For all the reasons set out above, the Tribunal does not accept that the applicant’s claims are credible and finds that he is not a witness of truth. While it is possible that the applicant was a director and/or shareholder of Company A, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant is now, or was in the past, of adverse interest to anyone in Indonesia because of his association with Company A and/or because he has been falsely accused of embezzling money owed to pilgrims and/or because Company A owes money to pilgrims. The Tribunal does not accept that Mr B had a dispute with the applicant in relation to matters of religious opinion, or that he was pressured by Mr B to impose religious views on prospective pilgrims or that the applicant had a dispute with Mr B for any of the other reasons claimed. Even if it were to be accepted that Mr B was a shareholder in Company A in the past, the Tribunal rejects in their entirety the claims that there was a dispute between the applicant and Mr B, that Mr B falsely accused the applicant of stealing money owed to pilgrims, and that pilgrims then engaged debt collectors to take action against the applicant. The Tribunal finds the applicant has manufactured his claimed dispute with Mr B. The Tribunal does not accept that Mr B embezzled money from pilgrims and then sought to blame the applicant for these actions. Even if it were to be accepted that the applicant was summoned to give evidence to the police in 2013, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the investigation was related to Mr B and/or Company A. On the evidence before it, the Tribunal does not accept that the applicant is of adverse interest to anyone in Indonesia as a consequence of the actions of Mr B or for any other reason. The Tribunal rejects, in their entirety, the applicant’s claims that he has attracted the adverse interest of disgruntled pilgrims and/or debt collectors and/or the Indonesian police. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant is of any adverse interest to the police or to any other persons or groups in Indonesia. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant has outstanding debts in Indonesia to pilgrims or that he is of adverse interest to disgruntled pilgrims, debt collectors, the police, Mr B or any other individuals or groups. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant and/or his family members have been threatened by debt collectors or any other person or group in Indonesia. The Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant’s family members, including the second named applicant and the third named applicant, have been threatened or otherwise harmed by debt collectors/disgruntled pilgrims or any other individuals or groups. The Tribunal finds that the only profile the applicants have in Indonesia is that of ordinary Indonesian citizens. In light of its assessment that the applicant’s claims are not credible, the Tribunal finds that in Indonesia the applicant does not face a real chance of serious harm amounting to persecution now and in the reasonably foreseeable future, for the reasons he claims.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

If a person is found not to meet the refugee criterion in s.36(2)(a) of the Act, he or she may nevertheless meet the criteria for the grant of the visa if he or she is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations because the Minister has substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of being removed from Australia to a receiving country, there is a real risk that he or she will suffer significant harm: s.36(2)(aa) (‘the complementary protection criterion’). The meaning of significant harm, and the circumstances in which a person will be taken not to face a real risk of significant harm, are set out in s.36(2A) and (2B), which are extracted in the attachment to this decision. Mandatory considerations In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.56, made under s.499 of the Act, the Tribunal has taken account of policy guidelines prepared by the Department of Immigration – PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Complementary Protection Guidelines and PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Refugee Law Guidelines – and relevant country information assessments prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The Tribunal has considered the evidence before the Department and the evidence before the Tribunal. Invalid s.438 certificate A certificate purportedly issued pursuant to s.438(1)(a) of the Act has been placed on folios 96–104 of the departmental file restricting the disclosure of the information contained therein.[1] If a certificate is issued because the disclosure of information or documents would be contrary to the public interest, it is necessary for the certificate to specify the reasons why. For s.438 certificates, this is any reason specified in the certificate that could form the basis for a claim by the Crown in right of the Commonwealth in a judicial proceeding.[2] [1] Department file, folio 118. [2] S.438(1)(a)(i). In the Tribunal’s judgment the certificate placed on folios 96–104 of the departmental file is invalid as the description of the reasons for restriction does not properly identify a basis for public interest immunity. The certificate states that the disclosure of the information would be contrary to the public interest because it would reveal internal working documents and business affairs. In MZAFZ v MIBP[3] the Federal Court held that the Tribunal had erred in treating a non-disclosure certificate as valid where the only reasons cited in the certificate as contrary to the public interest were ‘internal working documents’ as this had never been a sufficient basis for public interest immunity whether at common law or under statute and did not identify the harm that could be done to an agency by the disclosure of the documents. At best, the words ‘internal working documents’ disclosed a reason that could form part of the basis for a claim, but not the basis of the claim itself.[4][3] MZAFZ v MIBP [2016] FCA 1081 (Beach J, 7 September 2016).[4] MZAFZ v MIBP [2016] FCA 1081 (Beach J, 7 September 2016) at [37]. See also BXD15 v MIBP [2017] FCA 1209 (Flick J, 12 October 2017) at [46]–[48].