1511212 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

1511212 (Refugee) [2017] AATA 422 (6 March 2017)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1511212

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                  Pakistan

MEMBER:Christopher Smolicz

DATE:6 March 2017

PLACE OF DECISION:  Adelaide

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Protection visa.

Statement made on 06 March 2017 at 4:02pm

CATCHWORDS
Refugee – Protection visa – Social group – Returnee from West – Religion – Worked at Christian organisations – Western Christian wife – Threats from TPP – Credibility issues

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, ss 5(1),36, 48, 65, 499
Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2

CASES

AMA15 v MIBP [2015] FCA 1424

Bhatt v MIAC [2012] FMCA 317
DZAAS v MIAC [2012] FCA 828
SZJDS v MIAC [2013] FCCA 1383
SZJDS v MIBP [2014] FCA 51

SZGIZ v MIAC (2013) 212 FCR 235
SZNHJ v MIAC (No.2) [2012] FMCA 809

SZRLB v MIBP [2014] FCCA 2851
SZTQL v MIBP (No 2) [2015] FCA 548

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration to refuse to grant the applicant a Protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The applicant who claims to be a citizen of Pakistan, applied for the visa [in] September 2013 and the delegate refused to grant the visa [in] July 2015.

    BACKGROUND – EFFECT OF PRIOR APPLICATION FOR PROTECTION

  3. The applicant first arrived in Australia [in] September 2007 as the holder of a [student] visa.

  4. [In] June 2010 he applied for a Subclass 866 Protection visa. The Department refused the application [in] December 2010. On 20 December 2010 the applicant applied to the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) to review the Department’s decision. The application was made prior to the implementation of the complementary protection criteria on 24 March 2012.

  5. On 1 April 2011 the RRT affirmed the Department’s decision not to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa. The applicant applied to the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia (FMCA) for judicial review of the RRT decision. The FMCA dismissed the applicant’s appeal. The applicant subsequently applied to the Federal Court of Australia (FCA). [In] May 2012 the FCA dismissed the appeal.[1] [In] May 2012 and [in] February 2013 the applicant made two unsuccessful applications for Ministerial Intervention.

    [1] [Information deleted].

  6. As the applicant has never left Australia since first arriving and has previously been refused a protection visa, the provisions of s.48A of the Act apply.  There is no evidence to suggest the Minister has made any determination under s.48B that s.48A does not apply to prevent a further application for a protection visa by the applicant. 

  7. Section 48A imposes a bar on a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1511212 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 422
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, a citizen of Pakistan, sought judicial review of a decision by the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) to affirm the refusal of his application for a protection visa. The applicant had previously applied for and been refused a protection visa in 2010, and subsequent appeals to the Federal Magistrates Court and Federal Court were unsuccessful. He had also made unsuccessful applications for Ministerial Intervention. The current application was made in September 2013, and the Tribunal was required to consider his claims in the context of the complementary protection provisions, as his earlier application predated their commencement.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether there were substantial grounds for believing that the applicant would suffer significant harm as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of his removal to Pakistan. This harm was alleged to arise from his perceived status as "non-Muslim" due to studying and living in a Western country, his work for a Christian community organisation in Australia, and his marriage to a Christian woman of [Country 1] descent. The Tribunal was required to assess the credibility of these claims and determine if they engaged Australia's protection obligations under section 36(2)(aa) of the Act.

The Tribunal found that the applicant, a Sunni Muslim from Pakistan, had not established a real risk of significant harm. It found his claims of being targeted by the Tehrik-e-Taliban (TTP) due to his Western associations and Christian community work to be vague, speculative, and lacking in credibility. The Tribunal noted that thousands of Pakistanis travel to the West and that the applicant had not demonstrated any specific profile that would attract the attention of extremist groups. Furthermore, the Tribunal found no credible evidence of ongoing threats or harm to his family members remaining in Pakistan. Regarding his marriage to a Christian woman, the Tribunal concluded that this would not impute an anti-Muslim or pro-Christian profile in Pakistan, particularly as his wife did not intend to travel to Pakistan and was seeking a visa for him to [Country 1]. The Tribunal also noted that the applicant had access to social support in Pakistan through his family and possessed skills and work history that would enable him to gain employment.

Consequently, the Tribunal was not satisfied that Australia had protection obligations towards the applicant under section 36(2)(aa) of the Act, either individually or cumulatively. The Tribunal affirmed the decision not to grant the applicant a protection visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant who claims to be a citizen of Pakistan, applied for the visa [in] September 2013 and the delegate refused to grant the visa [in] July 2015. BACKGROUND – EFFECT OF PRIOR APPLICATION FOR PROTECTION The applicant first arrived in Australia [in] September 2007 as the holder of a [student] visa. [In] June 2010 he applied for a Subclass 866 Protection visa. The Department refused the application [in] December 2010. On 20 December 2010 the applicant applied to the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) to review the Department’s decision. The application was made prior to the implementation of the complementary protection criteria on 24 March 2012. On 1 April 2011 the RRT affirmed the Department’s decision not to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa. The applicant applied to the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia (FMCA) for judicial review of the RRT decision. The FMCA dismissed the applicant’s appeal. The applicant subsequently applied to the Federal Court of Australia (FCA). [In] May 2012 the FCA dismissed the appeal.[1] [In] May 2012 and [in] February 2013 the applicant made two unsuccessful applications for Ministerial Intervention.[1] [Information deleted]. As the applicant has never left Australia since first arriving and has previously been refused a protection visa, the provisions of s.48A of the Act apply. There is no evidence to suggest the Minister has made any determination under s.48B that s.48A does not apply to prevent a further application for a protection visa by the applicant. Section 48A imposes a bar on a non-citizen making a further application for a protection visa while in the migration zone in circumstances where the non-citizen has made an application for a protection visa which has been refused. However, s.48A does not prevent a person from making a further application for a protection visa on complementary protection grounds where the first application was made and refused before the commencement of the complementary protection provisions on 24 March 2012. The Full Federal Court in SZGIZ v MIAC (2013) 212 FCR 235 has held at [38] that the operation of s.48A, as it stood at the time of this visa application, is confined to the making of a further application for a protection visa which duplicates an earlier unsuccessful application for a protection visa, in the sense that both applications raise the same essential criterion for the grant of a protection visa. The Federal Court in AMA15 v MIBP [2015] FCA 1424 upheld the Tribunal’s approach of considering only claims in relation to the complementary protection criterion in s.36(2)(aa), where the applicant had previously been refused a visa on the basis of the refugee criterion in s.36(2)(a). As a result, the applicant was not prevented from making a second application for a protection visa [in] September 2013. The Tribunal must therefore consider the applicant’s claims in the context of the complementary protection provisions. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 22 February 2017 to give evidence and present arguments. The applicant provided the Tribunal with a copy of the delegate’s decision refusing the protection visa application.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal explained to the applicant that in making its decision it has had regard to the DFAT Country Information Report Pakistan dated 15 January 2016. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The issue in this case is whether there are substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicant being removed from Australia to Pakistan, there is a real risk that he will suffer significant harm in Pakistan because:· He has studied and lived in a Western country and is perceived by the Tehrik-e-Taliban (TTP) to be “non-Muslim”· He has worked for a Christian community organisation in Australia · His wife is a Christian of [Country 1] decent. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.The applicant’s factual claims and the Tribunal’s findings First, the Tribunal sets out the claims advanced by the applicant to engage Australia’s protection obligations. The Tribunal takes these claims from the applicant’s evidence at the hearing, his entry interview and statements of claim. The Tribunal has also had regard to the applicant’s most current statutory declaration dated 16 February 2017 setting out his claims for protection. The applicant is [age]. He was born in Haripur, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan. He described his religion as Sunni Muslim. He speaks, reads and writes in English and Urdu, the national language of Pakistan. In 2000 the applicant obtained a [tertiary qualification] in Pakistan. Prior to arriving in Australia he worked as a [occupation] for a private company in Pakistan. His mother was a teacher at a [school]. She resigned in 2006 after threats were made to throw acid at female students and teachers. The applicant married [(his first wife)] in 2004 and they divorced in June 2011 while he was in Australia. The applicant claims his ex-wife divorced him due to security issues and family clashes. They have one [child] together ([name]) born [date]. His first wife and [child] have never travelled to Australia. He has no contact with his first wife and last spoke to her in 2011. His father passed away in 2001 and his mother passed away from a [medical condition] [in] April 2015 while the applicant was in Australia. His brother continues to live in Pakistan in the family home. His sister has married, has [children] and lives with her husband. He has [relatives] in Haripur. The applicant said that he travelled to study in Australia in September 2007 to enhance his future career options in Pakistan. After arriving in Australia he enrolled in a [tertiary course] at [a] University at the [city] campus. He completed two semesters of study. He did not complete his studies and travelled [interstate] and enrolled in a [further course] because he thought this would enhance his employment options in Australia. As part of his [further course] he undertook [number] hours of work placement at [Christian] Community organisations. He provided a letter from [the] Coordinating Minister of [a church]. The letter confirms that the applicant came to the community centre on a student placement in early 2009 and was offered a part-time position [working]. The applicant said he was employed for about [number] months at the Community Centre.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal discussed with the applicant media reports about recent terrorist attacks in Pakistan such as the February 2017 suicide bomb blast on the Lal Shahbabaz Qalandar shrine in Sehwan which killed at least 88 people. The Tribunal noted despite the attack reports confirm that Pakistan Army, has cracked down on insurgent groups in recent years leading to a sharp drop in militant violence, vowed a swift, decisive response.[14][14] >An article published by The New York Times in March 2016 reports that a series of terrorist attacks since 2014 has galvanised fragmented public opinion in Pakistan about how to deal with jihadist militancy. The article reports:In its wake, the government lifted a six-year moratorium on executions. In a harsh crackdown, more than 300 prisoners have been hanged in the last year under a new military judicial system.But attacks – suicide bombers, planted bombs and raids by gunmen – have continued and are gathering pace. A look at major terrorist attacks in Pakistan since the assault on the Peshawar school in 2014 suggests that government officials, health workers and religious minorities continue to be frequent targets of attacks.[15]Findings[15] (The applicant provide the Tribunal with a copy of this article at the hearing).The issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether there are substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicant being removed from Australia to Pakistan, there is a real risk that he will suffer significant harm.A person may meet the criteria for the grant of a protection visa if he or she is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations because the Minister has substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicant being removed from Australia to a receiving country, there is a real risk that he or she will suffer significant harm: s.36(2)(aa) (‘the complementary protection criterion’).The Tribunal has considered the applicant’s claims be reference to the forms of serious harm exhaustively defined by the Act. The types of harm that will amount to ‘significant harm’ are exhaustively defined by s.36(2A). A person will suffer significant harm if he or she will be arbitrarily deprived of his or her life; or the death penalty will be carried out on the person; or the person will be subjected to torture; or to cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment; or to degrading treatment or punishment. There is no suggestion the applicant would be subject to the death penalty on his return to Pakistan. The Tribunal finds the applicant is a citizen of Pakistan from Haripur, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. He is a member of the majority Sunni Muslim religious group in Pakistan. The applicant first arrived in Australia in September 2007. He departed Pakistan legally on a validly issued Pakistan passport traveling to Australia on a Student visa. He is currently the holder of a valid Pakistani passport. The Tribunal has had regard to DFAT’s most recent country information report and finds that those who return voluntarily to Pakistan with their own, valid travel documents are processed like any other Pakistani citizen returning to Pakistan.(5.23)Before he travelled to Australia he had never experienced any significant harm in Pakistan. He returned to Pakistan for about one month to visit his family in March 2009. He experienced no serious harm in Pakistan.The Tribunal finds the applicant holds a [tertiary qualification] and has worked as a [occupation]. He is not a health worker or government official. His work history in Pakistan is unremarkable. He is not an activist, has had no involvement in politics and has never come to the attention of the authorities in Pakistan. He has now been living in Australia for nine years. The Tribunal found the applicant’s claim that he came to the attention of the TTP in 2009 and has since been targeted by the TTP through an ongoing campaign of threating pamphlets and letters vague, speculative and lacking in credibility. Firstly, the Tribunal has had regard to the applicant’s profile and country information referred to above and does not accept that due to his study and community work in Australia he would be imputed with a profile of being anti-Muslim and pro-Western. Country information confirms that thousands of people from Pakistan travel to work and study in the West. The Tribunal has had regard to country information and finds that the applicant would not be subject to discrimination or violence on the basis of having spent time in the West. The Tribunal finds that the applicant does not have an identifiable profile of interest in Pakistan that would bring him to the attention of extremist groups such as the TTP.The applicant said that he has never had any problems in Pakistan until he returned to Pakistan for one month in 2009. Secondly, the Tribunal found the applicant’s evidence about the circumstances in which he came to the attention of the TTP vague and lacking in credibility. The Tribunal finds the applicant or his family were not contacted, approached or threatened by the TTP when he was in Pakistan in early 2009. Thirdly, the Tribunal finds it difficult to accept that the TTP would specifically target the applicant because of a private conversation he had with friends at a restaurant discussing his life in Australia, his study and his Christian community service work in Australia. The Tribunal finds the applicant provided vague evidence about the circumstances in which he claims he came to the attention of the TTP. For example the applicant was unable to identify who was privy to the conversation, when it occurred or where it occurred or how the TTP would be able to identify him and overhear the conversation when he was dining at a public restaurant with friends. The applicant stated that he could only speculate that conversations about his work and study in Australia were the reason he was targeted by the TTP. When the Tribunal discussed its concerns with the applicant at the hearing the applicant agreed and said it was “really bad luck” but could not provide further explanation. Fourthly, given the applicant’s profile it is unclear why the TTP would instigate an ongoing campaign of threats directed towards him which commenced in 2009 and has continued for almost eight years in circumstances where the applicant has not been living in Pakistan. The Tribunal notes that despite the claims the letters continued to be sent after he departed Pakistan in 2009, his mother continued to live in the family home. His mother passed away in 2015 and his brother continues still to reside in the family home and there is no evidence that the brother has been personally targeted by the TTP. The Tribunal also finds that the applicant’s ex-wife and [child] have not been harmed by the TTP.The Tribunal found the brother’s evidence that the letters have continued to come at random points in time vague and has given this evidence little weight. The Tribunal also finds it surprising that the applicant claims the letters would continue to be sent to his family home after his mother has passed away in 2015. As stated above the applicant has never been personally threatened in Pakistan. The applicant admits that prior to 2009 he had no profile as an activist or human rights worker or someone who is opposed to Islam. The applicant has not converted to Christianity and he continues to practice Islam. The Tribunal does not accept the TTP will make an example to others not to mix with Christians or convert to Christianity.The Tribunal notes that his work experience in Australia at [a church] was part of a structured work placement in early 2009 which was part of his [further course]. He subsequently worked part-time for three to four months until early 2010 assisting with [certain work] issues. He no longer works for any Christian Community centre and works as a full time [Occupation 1] in Australia. The Tribunal notes that the applicant gave evidence at the hearing that he changed direction in his studies from [course] to [further course] because he thought it would improve his work prospects in Australia. He did not complete his [further course]. The Tribunal does not accept that his brief period community service work in Australia would impugn him to a profile of an apostolate or anti- Muslim. The Tribunal does not accept that the TTP have declared a fatwa on him and that he will been sentenced to death if he returns to Pakistan. 100. Having regard to the applicant’s profile the Tribunal does not accept his claim that the TTP have specifically targeted him with a continuous barrage of threatening letters/pamphlets and shot at his family home in circumstances where he has been absent from Pakistan since 2009. 101. The Tribunal does not accept that there are substantial grounds for believing that as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicant being removed from Australia to Pakistan, there is a real risk that the applicant will be arbitrarily deprived of his life by the TPP or subjected to torture’, ‘cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment’ and ‘degrading treatment or punishment’ because he lived in a Western country, studied [a further course] and briefly worked in a Christian Community Centre and will be perceived to be anti-Muslim and pro-Christian.Marriage to [Country 1 nationality]-Christian102. The applicant’s wife and [child] are not in Australia and have not made any claims for protection. The Tribunal has also considered if there is a real risk to significant harm to the applicant in Pakistan because he is married to a [Country 1] Christian woman. 103. The USDOS provided the following information about mixed religious marriages in Pakistan:The marriages of non-Muslim men remain legal upon conversion to Islam. If a non-Muslim woman converts to Islam and her marriage was performed according to her previous religious beliefs, the government considers the marriage dissolved. Children born to non-Muslim women who convert to Islam after marriage to a non-Muslim man are considered illegitimate, and ineligible for inheritance. The only way to legitimize the marriage, and the children, is for the husband also to convert to Islam. The children of a Muslim man and a Muslim woman who both convert to another religious group are considered illegitimate, and by law the government may take custody of the children.[16][16] 2015 Report on International Religious Freedom – Pakistan – United States Department of State - 10 August 2016: As detailed above, the applicant is a follower of Islam. He married his second wife at [a] Mosque in Australia. According to the marriage certificate the marriage was solemnised by [name]. 105. The Tribunal does not accept that his marriage to a [Country 1] Christian woman in Australia would impute him with an anti-Muslim pro Christian profile in Pakistan in the reasonably foreseeable future. The Tribunal also notes that there is no evidence that the applicant’s wife and [child] intend to travel to Pakistan. On the contrary, the applicant provided evidence at the hearing that his wife has commenced to make enquiries with the [Country 1] authorities with the aim of securing him a [Country 1] visa. 106. The Tribunal accepts the applicant feels anxious about returning to Pakistan having now lived in Australia for over nine years. The Tribunal finds however that the applicant can speak, read and write in English and Urdu. His brother and sister and extended family continue to live in Pakistan where he has access to social support. He is educated and has a history of work in Pakistan which will place him in a strong position to be able to gain work in Pakistan in the future. This was not disputed by the applicant at the hearing. 107. The Tribunal does not accept that there are substantial grounds for believing that as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicant being removed from Australia to Pakistan, there is a real risk that the applicant will be arbitrarily deprived of his life by the TPP or subjected to ‘torture’, ‘cruel or inhuman treatment or punishment’ and ‘degrading treatment or punishment’ because he is married to a [Country 1] Christian woman with whom he has a young child. 108. The Tribunal has considered the applicant’s claims both individually and cumulatively and for the reasons given above the Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant is a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under s.36(2)(aa).109. There is no suggestion that the applicant satisfies s.36(2) on the basis of being a member of the same family unit as a person who satisfies s.36(2)(a) or (aa) and who holds a protection visa. Accordingly, the applicant does not satisfy the criterion in s.36(2).DECISION110. The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Protection visa.Christopher SmoliczMember

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.