1504524 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

1504524 (Refugee) [2017] AATA 2212 (25 July 2017)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1504524

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                  Kenya

MEMBER:Jane Marquard

DATE:25 July 2017

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the applicant satisfies s.36(2)(a) of the Migration Act.

Statement made on 25 July 2017 at 8:43am

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. The applicant is a woman from Kenya, who was born in [year].

  2. She first arrived in Australia [in] November 2002 on [a temporary visa]. She remained in Australia on a number of [temporary visas] until 2008, when she was granted a [different type of temporary visa].

  3. She left Australia [in] 2010 and returned on the [temporary visa] [in] 2011, which expired [in] January 2012. She then applied for a [permanent visa] which was refused [in] December 2013.

  4. She applied for a Protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act) [in] December 2013.

  5. The delegate refused to grant the visa [in] March 2015.

  6. This is an application for review of that decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal).

    CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

    Evidence before the Department

  7. The applicant provided the following information in support of her claims:

    ·She was born in [a town in] Nairobi and is a Christian;

    ·Her mother and [sibling] are still living in Kenya. Her father passed away in 2011;

    ·She comes from the Kikuyu tribe of the Central Province of Kenya, and was raised in [Town 1];

    ·She acknowledged her sexual orientation as a lesbian in high school, but did not act on this discovery as she was in a Catholic school. One person she knew there who acted on her sexual orientation was shamed. She was still trying to understand her sexuality. There was no internet access then. She tried dating men after high school but it was not something she liked or desired;

    ·Her first romantic experience was in 2000, when she became attracted to a friend in college. She had a 3 month relationship with this woman;

    ·After this she had no other partners in Kenya;

    ·She had a relationship in Australia at college in 2004. She lived with this woman for a month. The relationship ended because her partner was bisexual. This was her only relationship in Australia;

    ·She had a de facto relationship in Nairobi which began in [2010]. Her partner’s name was [Ms A];

    ·She started a relationship with her partner in 2010 when she travelled back to Kenya, but they were friends prior to that;

    ·Two days after they met, they started a secret relationship. No-one in the village would have thought about a same-sex relationship taking place;

    ·After two weeks they were in love, and her partner postponed her return to her village as she had completed her studies. They spent time at her home, and her [relative]’s home as her [relatives] were travelling;

    ·They both knew that same-sex relationships were taboo in their village however…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1504524 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2212
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) which affirmed the delegate's refusal to grant her a protection visa. The applicant claimed to be a lesbian from Kenya who feared persecution due to her sexual orientation, alleging she had been subjected to violence, sexual assault by police, and ostracisation by her community and family. The core of her claim was that she could not be safely returned to Kenya because she would face serious harm, including from vigilante groups and potentially law enforcement, due to her sexual orientation and a perceived "spreading of immoral ways."

The legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal erred in its assessment of the applicant's claims and whether it correctly applied the principles of international protection law. Specifically, the court needed to determine if the applicant had established a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of membership of a particular social group, namely being a lesbian in Kenya, and whether the Tribunal adequately considered the risk of refoulement. This involved scrutinising the Tribunal's findings on the applicant's credibility, the objective country information regarding the treatment of LGBTQ+ individuals in Kenya, and the availability of protection within Kenya or third countries.

The court considered the applicant's evidence, including her account of a relationship in Kenya, the subsequent mob attack, her detention and rape by police, and the ongoing fear of reprisal from her community and family. The Tribunal had expressed doubts about the applicant's credibility, particularly concerning the lack of corroborating evidence for some of her claims, such as the absence of media reports of the alleged mob violence and the circumstances surrounding her departure from Kenya with pending charges. The court noted that while the Tribunal accepted that a person in a same-sex relationship in Kenya could face serious harm, it found the applicant's specific claims lacked sufficient credibility to warrant protection. The Tribunal's reasoning highlighted inconsistencies and a lack of detail in certain aspects of the applicant's testimony, leading it to conclude that her fear was not well-founded to the standard required for a protection visa.

The application for judicial review was dismissed. The court found that the Tribunal had not made any reviewable error in its assessment of the evidence or its application of the law. The Tribunal's findings of fact, including its adverse credibility findings, were open to it on the evidence before it, and its ultimate conclusion that the applicant had not established a well-founded fear of persecution was therefore upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This is an application for review of that decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal). CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEEvidence before the Department The applicant provided the following information in support of her claims:·She was born in [a town in] Nairobi and is a Christian;·Her mother and [sibling] are still living in Kenya. Her father passed away in 2011;·She comes from the Kikuyu tribe of the Central Province of Kenya, and was raised in [Town 1];·She acknowledged her sexual orientation as a lesbian in high school, but did not act on this discovery as she was in a Catholic school. One person she knew there who acted on her sexual orientation was shamed. She was still trying to understand her sexuality. There was no internet access then. She tried dating men after high school but it was not something she liked or desired;·Her first romantic experience was in 2000, when she became attracted to a friend in college. She had a 3 month relationship with this woman;·After this she had no other partners in Kenya;·She had a relationship in Australia at college in 2004. She lived with this woman for a month. The relationship ended because her partner was bisexual. This was her only relationship in Australia;·She had a de facto relationship in Nairobi which began in [2010]. Her partner’s name was [Ms A];·She started a relationship with her partner in 2010 when she travelled back to Kenya, but they were friends prior to that;·Two days after they met, they started a secret relationship. No-one in the village would have thought about a same-sex relationship taking place;·After two weeks they were in love, and her partner postponed her return to her village as she had completed her studies. They spent time at her home, and her [relative]’s home as her [relatives] were travelling;·They both knew that same-sex relationships were taboo in their village however they appreciated each other and spent almost every day together for the month of her visit;·A man from her village who had travelled [overseas] to find a woman to marry had expressed interest in her partner [Ms A]. This man and his friends started following them. The applicant asked them to leave her and her partner alone. This created problems for them;·[In] 2011, a group of [angry] villagers stormed the home of her partner’s [relative] in which they were living temporarily. The villagers carried [weapons]. The mob was made up of friends of the man who wanted to marry her friend, and neighbours. The door had been left open. They were caught in a compromising situation. They were [physically assaulted] by the angry mob. Her mother lived five minutes away, and heard of the disturbance, so she called the police. There were [further altercations] when the police arrived;·The police took them to [a police station] where they were locked in cells. She was kept separately from her partner in a dark room for [a number of] days. They said they were raping her to “cure” her. At night [a number of] police officers raped her repeatedly while [she was restrained]. She was also mocked and beaten by other female detainees;·She was charged with [a number of offences]. She was fined and released on police bond [a few days later] for the sum of [amount] Kenyan shillings. She did not get legal advice as she did not want to take the risk;·Her mother was shocked and disappointed to hear of her sexual orientation. The applicant’s [sibling] was also shocked and did not know what to say;·That was the last time she saw her partner. She could not return to the village as she feared the mob. There were rumours she had returned from Australia to spread sexual corruption and immoral ways. She moved to a friend’s house in [Town 2] where she could hide. She did not seek medical attention as she had no money. However after she arrived in Australia, she had a blood test and check-up and was tested for HIV;·Her mother was ex-communicated from the church;·[In] 2011 she returned to [City 1, Australia] with a fear of being arrested again;·She left from Nairobi International Airport with no trouble and she does not know how she was able to leave with a charge pending;·Even after she left her mother continued to be humiliated in public places because the people believed her involvement in same-sex relationships put a curse and misfortune on the youth in her village. The Mungiki, who are the most authoritative force in her village, attacked her home [a number of times], and forced her mother to relocate to another village;·[In] October 2013 and [November] 2013 she received letters from friends saying that her life was in danger. Some people from her village, especially her closer friends, have already been killed by the Mungiki. Their families want revenge from her;·She decided not to return to Kenya to bury her father, who died [in] 2012, as she feared for her life;·Same-sex practice in Kenya is punishable by law and is a taboo, especially in the Kikuyu tribe;·She has family members who also wish to harm her;·She is still cautious in [City 1] because her own community does not accept same sex practice. She said that “only close friends know about it”. She said that she keeps to herself and was not in a relationship at the time of the Department interview [in] July 2014;·She delayed applying for a protection visa for two years because she thought that her [other permanent visa application] would be successful.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant provided the following documents:·A handwritten letter dated [in] October 2013 from [Ms B], in which she said that the applicant’s best friends, [named], were picked up from the village by the Mungiki, [some time] prior, and their bodies were found dumped in a [location] after being tortured. She said that she was in hiding and being terrorised by the community, but especially Mungiki. She said other friends, [named] were arrested [some time] after the applicant left. The mobs beat them and they were handed to police. She said that the applicant’s mother had been ex-communicated. She said that the applicant should not return as she was “in the top list of those to be persecuted by the Mungiki for misleading all the girls who have started the life of same sex preference”;·A number of photographs of the applicant and her partner;·An original stamped Notice to Attend Court issued by the [Kenyan Police] dated [in] 2011. The notice stated that the applicant was required to attend criminal court in [location] [in] 2011 to answer a charge of “[specified offence]”. It was stated that she was released on police bond of KSH [amount];·A letter from [name] dated [in] November 2013 stating that she and her partner were in great danger and had been hiding in different places. She said that since the applicant left, they have lost a number of boys and girls who dared reveal that they were of same sex orientation. [Name] and [name] had been arrested and their whereabouts were not known. [Name] had left the [country]. The police arrested another couple. She said that she wished they had left when the applicant asked them to do so. The blame had been placed on the applicant for bringing a foreign way of life to the village. She said the police were looking for the applicant;·A copy of her passport issued [in 2011] in Nairobi;·A certificate of death for her father (date of death [a date in] 2011); and·Copies of news articles about treatment of same sex couples in Kenya.Decision by the Department to refuse the visa on 3 March 2015 The Department was not satisfied that the applicant was owed protection obligations. The Department accepted that a person in a same sex relationship in Kenya could face serious harm. However the delegate did not find the claims of this applicant to be credible.Evidence before the Tribunal The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 26 April 2017 to give evidence and present arguments. The Tribunal assured the applicant that it understood that discussion of matters concerning sexual orientation could be difficult, and it would do all it could to ensure that she felt comfortable and supported. The applicant provided the following information to the Tribunal at hearing, and in written submissions: ·She grew up in [Town 1], a village [in the region of] Nairobi, about [distance] drive from the centre. She said it was the kind of village where everyone knew everyone else. Her father worked as [occupation], but he lost his job and then went into farming. Her mother worked as [occupation]. She has one elder [sibling]. They rented a house. They had cousins in the area as well;·Her mother does not work now but does some farming. She is still living in [Town 1], but in a different house. Her [sibling] works in [industry], and is married with [number] children. [Her sibling] lives in [Kasarani]. She talks to her mother and [sibling] often, but is not really in contact with the extended family;·Her family attended church regularly, at [church name], [Town 1]. Her parents were religious. The applicant still attends church now; ·She is a Kikuyu, part of the largest ethnic group in Kenya, comprising one fifth of the population;·She attended a public school which was run by the sisters. After high school, she went on to [college] for two years. Then she did an internship with [Organisation 1] for 16 months. After that she looked for a job, but could not find one. She also tried to start a business but it did not take off. She then applied to come to Australia as a student; ·She had a lot of friends in [Town 1], from school and college. She keeps in touch with some of them;·In Australia she studied [degree major] and has worked as [a number of different occupations]; ·She has many friends in Australia from the Kenyan and Australian community;·She first realised that she was interested in women in high school. She was surrounded by girls as it was a single sex school. First she thought that it was just “being close” to people. Then she started thinking that she was attracted to one particular girl, rather than just “being friends”. She felt confused and scared. She had no-one to talk to about this. There was no access to the internet. She did not really know what a gay or lesbian was. There had been an incident where a classmate had been suspected of being a lesbian and had been shamed and humiliated and expelled from school;·She had never talked to her family about gay and lesbian people and did not know what they thought. This was “not even a conversation that would take place”;·She talked to her friends about gay and lesbians when their classmate was expelled, but rather than it being a real conversation it was gossip. The girls were glad she was expelled. Most people did not really know what it was about; ·She did not tell anyone about her feelings for girls. She did not participate when girls talked about boys, she did not really talk about it as her family was religious. There was not much dating going on between boys and girls in her high school;·After she went to college her feelings towards women continued. She was still confused and uncertain. By then a few boys had shown interest, and she remembered trying to get to know them. However there was not really any attraction;·In college she met a girl to whom she was attracted. They tried spending some time together, as their parents travelled a lot. However this girl left the country after college. They were in the same class and it was just in a joking manner that they started talking about same sex preferences. She had a few friends who had left the country who were lesbians. For the first time she spoke to someone without fear. She was also not religious. She felt that when she was with this woman, this was where she wanted to be. At the back of her mind she was worried. She thought of the teachings in the Bible, and wondered what that would mean for her as a Christian;·She remembered that someone who had gone to school with her [sibling] came back from [overseas], and she heard speculation about this girl, which was very negative. There were comments made about “people who left”. She asked her [sibling, who] was dismissive of her;·She did not have an intimate relationship with the girl at college in Kenya, but they were close. She said that she was with this girl for less than a year. They just pretended they were friends;·She was not quite sure if there were other girls who were interested in women while she was at college, because it was not really talked about. She thought that there was a gay man there, because of his tendencies and appearance. But he had to move away;·She did not date any boys while at college or while she worked at [Organisation 1]; ·She did not tell any other friends or family, and did not know any other same sex couples while at college or [Organisation 1]. There was no gay or lesbian community that she knew about;·She had no other relationships in Kenya before coming to Australia. She moved in with a family friend in [City 1]. She heard from the community that gay and lesbian relationships were accepted in Australia. The Mardi Gras took place soon after she arrived, and she was shocked to see how the gay and lesbian community was open and supported. She said that she was excited and happy that people could be who they are without having fear; ·She met a woman through friends, and they shared accommodation for one month. This was the first time that she was intimate. This woman was from [country], and had been living in [another country]. They went out and spent time together. This relationship lasted a few months, and it ended because she had a male partner who arrived. But they remained friends;·She felt good that she could have this relationship openly in Australia. However she felt worried about her own community as it was frowned upon. She was not open with the Kenyan community because she had seen their reaction; ·She did not have other relationships. After that she was worried about telling her family so did not get involved. There was always a back and forth of emotions. She has tried going out with men, but this has never eventuated into anything; ·She has met other people from the lesbian/gay community in [City 1]. She has attended events and gone out. She has attended “meet and greets” in [location], and has also visited lesbian and gay clubs, including [details of clubs]. There have been no relationship opportunities though;·She returned to Kenya in [2010] to visit her family. Her mother was living in [Town 1] still, and her father has another wife, so only visited sometimes. She stayed at her parents’ house. She spent time with her family, and a little time with extended family. She helped her mother and [sibling] with [his/her] business and children. They went to [Town 3] for a few days holiday; ·She met up with a girl called [Ms A] when she returned to [Town 1]. She had known her from school. [Ms A] was visiting her [relative] in the area. They started spending time together, and “one thing led to another”. They had a conversation in which [Ms A] asked her if she had “met anyone”. She also asked [Ms A], who hinted to her that she wanted to have a relationship. She did not know if [Ms A] was a lesbian. [Ms A] expressed to her that she really liked her, and she told her that she felt the same. [Ms A] mentioned that there was a man who wanted to marry her. However they started having a relationship about the [second week she was visiting]. She went to [Town 3] the first week. She said that she talked to [Ms A] prior to [Town 3], and then spent time with her when she returned, dividing her time between her mother’s house and spending time with [Ms A]. She was with her family for [the duration of a cultural event], and [Ms A] was with her own family; ·She said that there were friends from high school who they had kept in touch with, who knew or suspected of the relationship, although she did not tell them details. She said that about [number] friends knew of the relationship. There was talk about some of them being lesbians;·She was asked if they were together for about three weeks, considering she was away in [Town 3] for a week, and with her family for [the cultural event]. She said that even though she had to see her family she still had lots of time to see her. [Ms A] also accompanied her to places as a friend;·There was a man from the village who was interested in marrying [Ms A]. The applicant never interacted with him. She did not talk to him besides saying hello. Asked if she ever spoke to him, she said that they talked when they were walking to the main road, and they bumped into him and his friends. They had a brief conversation and he asked why [Ms A] was not responding to him, and the applicant suggested that maybe he needed to “drop it”. He just laughed this off;·Asked when she next saw this man, she said that she does not remember seeing him after that. She said that [on a date in 2011] they were at her partner’s [relative]’s house, which was empty. They had decided to spend the night together after spending the afternoon together. The Tribunal asked her how they were able to spend the night together given the taboo nature of lesbianism in Kenya. She said that it was because [Ms A]’s [relatives] were away. She told her mother that she spent the night at her friend from school. She thought that they had been discreet enough; ·There was a bang at the door, and then a group of about [number] people barged in. They [forced their way into the property]. She thinks it was locked but the dead bolt was not on. She and [Ms A] were on the sofa, not fully dressed. The group asked them what they were doing and said something along the lines of “oh this is what is happening”. They were told to stand up. There was a commotion, and they were beaten and called names. The men were armed with [weapons] and told them that they were trying to change the culture by imitating western ways. They said they had to deal with it otherwise it would cause problems. They also pulled her braids. She could hear the crowd saying things from the van;·She pled for them to leave. Then the crowd grew bigger. Someone must have run to her mother and told her. She does not remember her mother coming, but the police arrived and [dispersed the] people. The police took them and put them in the van. She heard her mother pleading with them;·Asked if this group of men broke into the house because they knew of the relationship, she said that one person said they had seen them around, and so she thought they may have suspected. She said that they may have seen them holding hands. Asked why they would do this if they were trying to be discreet, she said it was just in a friendly manner;·They were taken to [a police station]. She does not know why they did not take her to the local station. When they got to the station, they were put in separate cells. They were told someone would come and see them. [A number of] police officers came and humiliated them, and told them something must be wrong with them, and lesbianism is a disease. They took turns in raping her. This was the first night, then it happened the following night as well. She was not allowed to get a lawyer even though she asked for a call;·Asked if her mother and father arranged a lawyer she said that her mother did not, she was the only person in [Town 1] as her father was in [another location]. The applicant was helped by a friend from school and college, one of the [number] people who knew of her relationship. This friend looked for the applicant and probably went to the local police station and when she found her that was when she was released;·She was told that she was being charged on [a date in 2011]. She was brought out and they asked her if she knew why she had been locked up. She did not say anything. They told her the charges and that she should appear in court without failure. Asked what she was told she was being charged with, she said that it was [two offences]. They gave her the Notice she has provided to the Tribunal. Her mother was present when she was being charged. She had to pay a security;·When they got outside the police station, her friend asked her what she would do, and she said that she would go with a friend to [Town 2] which is far away. She told her mother not to get a lawyer because she did not want to stay. She wanted to get away. She was asked how she thought that she could leave if she was wanted in court. She thought that she could leave with her passport. She did not think it would be a problem;·There were no media reports about the incident. She did not think there was enough time. She does not think anyone contacted the media;·She was asked why the police charge sheet indicates that she was being charged with [specified offence] and she said she has no idea why they would say [there were two offences] but only charge her with [one offence];·She was in [Town 2] on [the day that she was required to appear in court]. She said that there were no repercussions for her when she did not appear in court. There was no warrant issued for her arrest. Asked if this meant that the police were not concerned about her, she said that she had never been on the wrong side of the law, and did not know what this meant. The Tribunal put to her that Kenya has procedures for issuing warrants for arrest where persons do not appear in court, pursuant to the Criminal Procedure Code Act. She said that she had no idea why there was no warrant for her arrest. Asked if she did not consider appearing on [her court date] with a lawyer, she said that she had lost faith and wanted to disappear. Her friend picked up her passport for her. Her father did not answer her calls;·Asked if [Ms A] was bailed, she said that she tried reaching her at her [relative]’s house, but her [relative] did not answer. Since then, her [relative] would not respond. She has now left the area, and her friends do not know of her whereabouts;·Her mother was disappointed and shocked to hear of her sexual orientation. The applicant’s older [sibling] was also shocked and did not know what to say. She has never spoken to her mother in detail. Her mother just says she is praying for her. She talked to her [sibling] while in [Town 2]. She did not say goodbye as [the sibling's partner] was against lesbianism. She did try reaching out to her [relative]. Her [relative] was disappointed and expressed that she had brought shame to the family;·She was asked if she received medical attention in [Town 2] and she said that she decided to wait until she got to Australia. She got blood tests for HIV, after she arrived but does not have records of this. She said she has never spoken to a counsellor or psychologist, partly because of cost, but also she finds it hard to think about it. She did not talk to any human rights organisations in Kenya about her experiences in the police station. She said that she just wanted to forget and move on;·She was asked how she could leave through the airport freely, as usually airports will have a list of people who have warrants out for their arrest so they cannot try and escape the country. She said that she has no idea how this is possible. She said that she considered herself lucky;·After she left, her mother was being asked by the community about her location. Her mother was shunned from the church, and had to move to a different church. Asked if she suffered any harm or harm to her property she said that she did not. She said that she had had some correspondence with friends, and had been mentioning going back. She said that to her shock and surprise her name was still coming up as an issue in the community; ·She was asked how she knew [Ms B], who had written the letter provided to the Tribunal. She said that she knew her from college. They had kept in touch. She was asked why she said that she had no friends from the gay and lesbian community, and she answered that she did not know they were gay or lesbian. The Tribunal put to her that the letters indicated that she knew the boys were in hiding and that the two girls were in hiding. She said that they were friends but they had never said they were gay or lesbian. Asked how she had these friends she said that she had been back before and kept in touch;·She had tried to find media reports of the events described by her friends, but could not. She has tried to find out more, but has not been able to. The Tribunal put to her that usually these kinds of serious allegations are found in Kenyan or international media, or the United States Department of State Human Rights Reports or Human Rights Watch reports, but there is no mention of them, which makes the Tribunal question whether these events occurred. She said that not everything is reported;·Her [relatives] in [Town 1] might want to harm her as they think she brought shame on the family. One of them said to her mother that he hopes that she would not think of coming back after the shame she had created. Asked what harm she thinks he will cause, she said that she is not sure, but she thinks he may harm her. She also wonders if the villagers may harm her. Some of them are Mungiki;·Since she returned to [City 1], she has not had other lesbian relationships. She has dated and met people but it has not been successful;·She has a close group of friends in the same sex community and also straight friends. They all know that she is a lesbian. She has not been out with any men. She works full time. On weekends she meets her friends, and they go hiking. They go to the beach, sport, bars (including gay bars) and barbeques;·She would like to have a girlfriend. She has used one internet site to meet people – there are predominantly gay and lesbian [sites]. One is through a website and one through [an organisation]. She does not use social media to talk to other lesbians though. She said that she would love to address some of the difficulties she has, and to be able to be in a fulfilling relationship. She would love to be in a home and travel. Some of her friends in Australia know about what happened to her in Kenya;·She delayed applying for a protection visa for two years because she thought that her [other permanent visa application] would be successful. She said that she was on a different visa. She went into a state of panic. She had put it at the back of her mind. That was when she realised she would need to seek protection. Her passport was issued [in] 2011. She has no idea why the Kenyan government would issue her with a new passport if she has charges pending;·She was asked if she had availed herself of the right to enter and reside in one of the countries of the East African community. She said that Uganda also considers same sex relationships as illegal. The fear still remains in the other countries. Rwanda and Burundi have their own problems, and she has no family and does not feel safe. She would have concerns as a single woman going to live there. She is not sure of the law in Tanzania about same sex – she does not know anyone there. She has no contacts. She does not think she could live openly as a gay person in these communities. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.