1419288 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

1419288 (Refugee) [2018] AATA 282 (24 January 2018)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1419288

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                  Pakistan

MEMBER:Paul Windsor

DATE:24 January 2018

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the following directions:

(i)that Applicant 1 satisfies s.36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act; and

(ii)that the other applicants satisfy s.36(2)(c)(i), on the basis of membership of the same family unit as the first named applicant.

Statement made on 24 January 2018 at 3:43pm

CATCHWORDS
Refugee – Protection visa – Pakistan – Criminal charges – Police corruption – Torture for confessions – Bond for bail – Appeal disposed – Death penalty – Complementary Protection

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, ss 36, 65, 424A, 499
Migration Regulations 1994 Schedule 2, r 1.05A

CASES
MIAC v SZQRB [2013] FCAFC 33

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration to refuse to grant the applicants Protection visas under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The applicants, who claim to be citizens of Pakistan, applied for the visas [in] September 2013 and the delegate refused to grant the visas [in] November 2014.  Applicants 2 and 3 applied as members of the family unit of Applicant 1 who are not making their own claims for protection. 

  3. The delegate found that Applicant 1’s claims do not have a Convention nexus and therefore considered them only against the Complementary Protection provisions.  The delegate accepted that: Applicant 1 was charged and acquitted of the murder of his [Relative A] and that his [Relative B] appealed this decision; at the time Applicant 1 departed Pakistan the appeal was ongoing and; Applicant 1 may have been harmed by the police at the time of his arrest.  The delegate did not accept, however, that: Applicant 1’s [Relative B] will harm or kill him if he returns to Pakistan; the appeal against the acquittal is ongoing; Applicant 1 would be of interest to the Pakistani authorities or; Applicant 1 would be harmed by police should he return to Pakistan.  In light of these findings, the delegate refused to grant the visas as she was not satisfied that there are substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of Applicant 1 being removed from Australia to a receiving country, there is a real risk that he will suffer significant harm.   

  4. The applicants applied to the Tribunal for review of this decision on 25 November 2014.  The applicants provided the Tribunal with a copy of the delegate’s decision record.

  5. The applicants appeared before the Tribunal on 3 November 2016 to give evidence and present arguments.  The Tribunal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1419288 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the protection visa claims of Applicant 1, his mother (Applicant 2), and his younger brother (Applicant 3), all citizens of Pakistan. Applicant 1 claimed he had been detained and tortured by police in Pakistan in 2008 in relation to a death, falsely implicated, and subsequently acquitted by a court. He alleged that despite his acquittal, an appeal was lodged, and he feared returning to Pakistan due to ongoing legal proceedings and threats to his family. He arrived in Australia in 2010 on a student visa.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Applicant 1 met the criteria for a protection visa, specifically under section 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) concerning complementary protection, and whether Applicants 2 and 3 were members of Applicant 1's family unit for the purposes of their own visa applications. The Tribunal was required to assess the risk of significant harm to Applicant 1 if returned to Pakistan, considering the availability of state protection and the possibility of internal relocation.

The Tribunal reasoned that while Applicant 1 was acquitted of the charges, the appeal remained pending, and the death penalty could apply if the acquittal were overturned. It considered country information indicating that Pakistan had lifted a moratorium on the death penalty and had become a prolific executioner. The Tribunal found that Applicant 1's experience of police corruption and torture, coupled with the ongoing legal proceedings and the potential for his profile to attract the attention of Pakistani authorities, meant that internal relocation would not remove the real risk of significant harm, including detention and return to police custody. Consequently, the Tribunal was satisfied that there were substantial grounds for believing that Applicant 1 would suffer significant harm in the form of torture if removed from Australia. The Tribunal also found that Applicants 2 and 3 were members of Applicant 1's family unit, with Applicant 2 being a dependent widow and Applicant 3 a dependent student.

The Tribunal remitted the matter for reconsideration with directions that Applicant 1 satisfies section 36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act, and that Applicants 2 and 3 satisfy section 36(2)(c)(i) on the basis of their membership in the same family unit as Applicant 1.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.56, made under s.499 of the Act, the Tribunal took account of policy guidelines prepared by the Department of Immigration – PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Complementary Protection Guidelines and PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Refugee Law Guidelines – and any country information assessment prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Applicant 1 claims to be a citizen of Pakistan who was born in Karachi in Sindh province Pakistan on [date]. Applicant 1 indicates that he is a Muslim and that he speaks, reads and writes English and Urdu. He states he has never married or been in a de facto relationship. He indicates he departed Pakistan legally [in] May 2010 and arrived in Australia [the following day], entering on a Student visa[1]. Included in the application as members of the same family unit who do not have their own claims for protection are Applicant 1’s mother (Applicant 2), born [on date] in Karachi Pakistan, and his younger brother (Applicant 3), born [on date] in Karachi Pakistan[2].[1] See folios 8-15 of Departmental file [number].[2] See folios 19-26 and 28-29 of Departmental file [number].Summary of claims from the Protection visa application Applicant 1’s claims were set out in a statement dated [in] September 2013[3] which was included with his Protection visa application. His claims are summarised as follows:·He was detained by police in Karachi [in] September 2008 in relation to the death of [his Relative A].·He was beaten by police who wanted him to confess to the [crime]. They blindfolded him and took him to another place.·[The following day] he realised he had been taken to the anti-violent crime cell. He saw a man there who later appeared in court as one of the witnesses against him.·He was hung upside down and beaten. He was tortured and beaten for an entire night. He was beaten again the next night and pushed to confess to the [killing].·On [a later date in] September 2008 he was produced before [Court 1] where he said he had been falsely implicated in the case and was innocent. He was charged and they asked that he be kept in custody. He was later shifted to [Jail 1 in] Karachi where he spent [time period]. He was physically and mentally tortured in jail and not allowed to see his parents. People tried to prevent his father talking to him when he was in court. His father [died from his medical condition].·He was found not guilty and the court ordered his release. However, the complainer appealed to [Court 1]. This is still pending.·As soon as he was released he came to Australia to make sure nothing else goes wrong. People came to his home legally and illegally treating his parents roughly and asking them to call him home so the case can continue. He has attached a picture from the [Court 1] [website] which indicates the case is pending and the dates.·His father passed away but he could not return to Pakistan to go to his father’s funeral. He is afraid that he would be returned to custody.[3] See folios 16-18 of Departmental file [number].

Decision

Reasons for decision

As noted above, both the offences with which Applicant 1 was charged carry the death penalty. While the applicant did not raise the death penalty in his initial claims, he has raised it subsequently. In this regard, the Tribunal notes that at the time of the Protection visa application, there was a moratorium on the use of the death penalty in place in Pakistan. Various reports indicate that Pakistan lifted the moratorium in December 2014, following a mass casualty terrorist attack on schoolchildren in Peshawar, firstly in relation to terror-related cases and subsequently (in March 2015) in all capital cases. Since that time it has been reported that Pakistan has become the third most prolific executioner in the world, after China and Iran[26]. [26] ‘Pakistan and the Death Penalty’, The Diplomat, 21 April 2016, >In its 2017 Country Information Report on Pakistan, DFAT comments that around 430 people have been executed since an unofficial moratorium on executions was lifted in December 2014, including more than 40 people executed since the beginning of 2017. DFAT indicates that the vast majority of these had been convicted of murder or terrorism-related charges. DFAT also commented that many of those executed were reportedly convicted in trials that did not meet international standards for fair trials[27].[27] DFAT Country Information Report, Pakistan, 1 September 2017, section 4.8.While the applicant has not been convicted of a capital offence at this stage, the Tribunal notes that if the applicant’s acquittal was to be overturned by [Court 1] and he was found guilty of the crimes he was charged with in 2008, the death penalty could apply.State ProtectionThe delegate stated in her decision record that ‘Country information indicates that state protection is available in Pakistan with an effective criminal justice system’ and commented that Applicant 1, by his own admission, had not attempted to seek the protection of the authorities. In considering this matter, the Tribunal noted that this finding by the delegate is based on consideration of the following advice contained in a 2014 UK Home Office report[28]: [28] CIS2F827D91294: UK Home Office, “Country Information and Guidance Pakistan: Background information, including actors of protection, and internal relocation”, UK Home Office, 06 October 2014.1.2.1 The reported case of AW (26 January 2011) found that there is ‘systemic sufficiency of state protection’ in Pakistan. Decision makers must, however, assess whether effectiveprotection is available in relation to the particular circumstances and profile of theperson. Any past persecution and past lack of effective protection may indicate thateffective protection would not be available in the future.1.2.2 The country information suggests that whilst there is a fully functioning criminal justice system, the effectiveness of the police varies greatly by district, ranging from reasonablygood to ineffective. Pakistan’s police system suffers severe deficiencies in a number ofareas, including equipment, technology, personnel, training, and intelligence capability.There have also been reports that the police have often failed to protect members ofreligious minorities and women.1.2.3 Decision makers must consider each case on its individual facts. The assessment ofwhether effective protection is available should be considered in relation to the particular circumstances and profile of the person. The delegate indicated that when asked if he could seek protection from the police Applicant 1 responded that the police are not supportive and it is only with the power of money that people can obtain police support. The Tribunal finds this to be a reasonable response in the circumstances of this case. The Tribunal considers that Applicant 1 was stating that he believed there was no point in seeking protection from the police because his experience was that they are corrupt and had tortured him seeking to force him to confess to a crime he did not commit because they were bribed by the applicant’s wealthy [Relative B]. The Tribunal finds that in the circumstances of this case, where the police are the agents of the significant harm feared, and where Applicant 1 has previously been tortured by the police, which his family were not able to prevent, and noting more recent DFAT advice that ‘there are credible reports of corruption in the judicial system, as well as intimidation of the judiciary, particularly in religiously sensitive cases, such as those involving blasphemy[29], the Tribunal cannot find that protection is available to Applicant 1, from an authority of Pakistan, such that there would not be a real risk that he would suffer significant harm, in the form of torture, should he return to Pakistan.[29] DFAT Country Information Report, Pakistan, 1 September 2017.S.36(2B)(a) provides that there is not taken to be a real risk that a non-citizen will suffer significant harm in a country if the Minister is satisfied that it would be reasonable for the non-citizen to relocate to an area of the country where there would not be a real risk that the non-citizen will suffer significant harm. In the circumstances of this case, where the threat of significant harm stems from an ongoing serious criminal matter, the Tribunal considers that the risk of harm extends to all areas of the applicant’s receiving country. As discussed above, the Tribunal accepts Applicant 1’s claim that his case is currently ongoing in [Court 1]. Noting measures that the Supreme Court of Pakistan recently has directed be taken to ensure that absconders appear before the courts, the Tribunal found that Applicant 1, as someone who has absconded since 2010 to avoid appearing before [Court 1], may have a profile that would bring him to the attention of the authorities of Pakistan. Consequently, the Tribunal found that there is a real risk that Applicant 1 would be detained on his return to Pakistan. The Tribunal considers that this could be at any international airport on his return to Pakistan or at any other location within Pakistan where the applicant might be detained due to his CNIC being blocked or his bank account being frozen, as directed by the Supreme Court. The Tribunal considers that there is a real risk this could result in the applicant being arrested and returned to police custody in Karachi. Accordingly, the Tribunal finds that internal relocation to another area of Pakistan would not remove the real risk of significant harm that Applicant 1 faces.After careful consideration of all the material before it, the Tribunal concludes that there are substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of Applicant 1 being removed from Australia to Pakistan, there is a real risk that he will suffer significant harm, in the form of torture. While the Migration and Refugee Division of the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction in relation to s.36(2C) matters, noting the comments of the acquitting judge in his judgement[30], it would seem that there is little basis for concerns that the ineligibility provision in s.36(2C) might apply in this case.[30] See folios 65-105 of Departmental file [number].CONCLUSIONFor the reasons given above, the Tribunal is satisfied that Applicant 1 is a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under s.36(2)(aa).The Tribunal finds that Applicant 2, who is Applicant 1’s mother, is a member of the same family unit as Applicant 1, noting that since the death of her husband (Applicant 1’s father) in 2012, Applicant 2 is a widow and, having been described by Applicant 1 as a ‘housewife all her life’ (and having not been in paid employment) has become dependent on Applicant 1, who is her eldest son. The Tribunal is satisfied that she does not have a spouse or de facto partner, is usually resident in Applicant 1’s household, and is ‘dependent’ on Applicant 1 (within the meaning of r.1.05A(2)) because she is wholly or substantially reliant on Applicant 1 for financial and psychological support. The Tribunal finds that Applicant 3, who is undertaking full time study and is the son of Applicant 2 and the younger brother of Applicant 1, is also a member of Applicant 1’s family unit, because he is a relative of Applicant 1 who does not have a spouse or de facto partner, is usually resident in Applicant 1’s household and is dependent on Applicant 1 because he is substantially reliant on Applicant 1 for financial and psychological support.The Tribunal finds, therefore, that Applicants 2 and 3 will be entitled to a protection visa provided the criterion in s.36(2)(c)(ii) and the remaining criteria for the visa are met. DECISIONThe Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the following directions:(i)that Applicant 1 satisfies s.36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act; and(ii)that Applicants 2 and 3 satisfy s.36(2)(c)(i) of the Migration Act, on the basis of membership of the same family unit as Applicant 1.Paul WindsorMember ‘What is behind Pakistan’s dramatic rise in executions’ BBC News, 16 December 2015. Sourced at

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

If a person is found not to meet the refugee criterion in s.36(2)(a), he or she may nevertheless meet the criteria for the grant of a protection visa if he or she is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations because the Minister has substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicant being removed from Australia to a receiving country, there is a real risk that he or she will suffer significant harm: s.36(2)(aa) (‘the complementary protection criterion’).Mandatory considerations In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.56, made under s.499 of the Act, the Tribunal took account of policy guidelines prepared by the Department of Immigration – PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Complementary Protection Guidelines and PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Refugee Law Guidelines – and any country information assessment prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Applicant 1 claims to be a citizen of Pakistan who was born in Karachi in Sindh province Pakistan on [date]. Applicant 1 indicates that he is a Muslim and that he speaks, reads and writes English and Urdu. He states he has never married or been in a de facto relationship. He indicates he departed Pakistan legally [in] May 2010 and arrived in Australia [the following day], entering on a Student visa[1]. Included in the application as members of the same family unit who do not have their own claims for protection are Applicant 1’s mother (Applicant 2), born [on date] in Karachi Pakistan, and his younger brother (Applicant 3), born [on date] in Karachi Pakistan[2].[1] See folios 8-15 of Departmental file [number].[2] See folios 19-26 and 28-29 of Departmental file [number].Summary of claims from the Protection visa application Applicant 1’s claims were set out in a statement dated [in] September 2013[3] which was included with his Protection visa application. His claims are summarised as follows:·He was detained by police in Karachi [in] September 2008 in relation to the death of [his Relative A].·He was beaten by police who wanted him to confess to the [crime]. They blindfolded him and took him to another place.·[The following day] he realised he had been taken to the anti-violent crime cell. He saw a man there who later appeared in court as one of the witnesses against him.·He was hung upside down and beaten. He was tortured and beaten for an entire night. He was beaten again the next night and pushed to confess to the [killing].·On [a later date in] September 2008 he was produced before [Court 1] where he said he had been falsely implicated in the case and was innocent. He was charged and they asked that he be kept in custody. He was later shifted to [Jail 1 in] Karachi where he spent [time period]. He was physically and mentally tortured in jail and not allowed to see his parents. People tried to prevent his father talking to him when he was in court. His father [died from his medical condition].·He was found not guilty and the court ordered his release. However, the complainer appealed to [Court 1]. This is still pending.·As soon as he was released he came to Australia to make sure nothing else goes wrong. People came to his home legally and illegally treating his parents roughly and asking them to call him home so the case can continue. He has attached a picture from the [Court 1] [website] which indicates the case is pending and the dates.·His father passed away but he could not return to Pakistan to go to his father’s funeral. He is afraid that he would be returned to custody.[3] See folios 16-18 of Departmental file [number].