1327/2007 Re MetLife Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Re MetLife Insurance Limited [2007] FCA 1327

INSURANCE – life insurance – scheme to transfer part of the life insurance business of one insurer to another – procedural requirements complied with – actuarial evidence suggested no disadvantage to policy holders – APRA did not oppose scheme confirmation – terms of insurance contracts not altered except beneficially for taxation and social security purposes – Court’s discretion to confirm not limited to supervising procedural compliance – interests of policy holders are of primary concern – objections by some transferor insurer policy holders to transfer – original scheme rejected for failing to accommodate valid concerns of objectors – modified scheme with opt out facility for objectors approved

COURTS – nature of Court’s discretion to confirm scheme for transfer of life insurance business   

Life Insurance Act 1995 (Cth), Div 3 Pt 6, Pts 2, 3, 4, 6, 9, ss 3, 9, 11, 12A, 93, 190, 191, 192, 193, 194, 195

Re MetLife Insurance Limited and Challenger Life No. 2 Limited [2007] FCA 937 related
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24 applied
Re Application of Commonwealth Life Ltd [2003] FCA 637 cited
Re Royal & Sun Alliance Life Assurance Ltd (2000) 104 FCR 37 cited
Re MLC Lifetime Co Ltd and MLC Ltd (No 2) [2006] FCA 1367 cited

METLIFE INSURANCE LIMITED ABN 75 004 274 882 and CHALLENGER LIFE NO. 2 LIMITED ABN 44 072 486 938
NSD 836 OF 2007

GYLES J
10 AUGUST 2007
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 836 OF 2007

METLIFE INSURANCE LIMITED ABN 75 004 274 882
First Applicant

CHALLENGER LIFE NO. 2 LIMITED ABN 44 072 486 938
Second Applicant

JUDGE:

GYLES J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 AUGUST 2007

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to s 194 of the Life Insurance Act 1995 (Cth), the Scheme in the form of the document annexed hereto and marked “A” (comprising the document entitled “Scheme – Life Insurance Act 1995 Part 9”) be confirmed, subject to the modifications set out in Orders 2 and 3.

2.Modifications to the Scheme

2.1 A new Section 3A is incorporated into the Scheme following Section 3:

3A.1On the Confirmation Date MetLife will issue the New MRF Policies to MTP and those policies will come into force on the Confirmation Date.

3A.2For each Relevant Policyholder and MRF Member for whom MetLife has a current address as at Confirmation Date, within 1 Business Day of the Confirmation Date, MetLife must post the Notice to that address.

3A.3Immediately after the Return Date, MetLife must debit each fixed rate option sub-account kept in relation to each Opt Out MRF Member under an Old MRF Policy with an amount equal to the current account balance shown in MetLife’s records as at the Return Date and credit an equivalent amount to a sub-account kept in relation to each Opt Out MRF Member under the corresponding New MRF Policy.

2.2The definitions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1327/2007 Re MetLife Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1327
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of MetLife Insurance Limited, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with confirming a scheme for the transfer of part of the life insurance business of one insurer to another, in accordance with Part 9 of the Life Insurance Act 1995 (Cth). The primary concern of the court was to determine whether the scheme met the statutory requirements and if the objections raised by certain policyholders should result in any modifications or refusal to confirm the scheme. The scheme in question involved the transfer of certain life insurance policies from MetLife Insurance Limited to another insurer, which was not connected to the transferor. The scheme was subject to several objections, particularly from policyholders who did not wish to have their insurance policies transferred to the new insurer.

The court was required to consider whether the scheme complied with the legislative framework established by the Life Insurance Act 1995 (Cth). This included examining whether the necessary notices were given to the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) and affected policyholders, whether an independent actuarial report was provided, and if the scheme could be confirmed with or without modifications. The court also had to determine the implications of the objections raised by the policyholders, particularly focusing on whether their objections warranted any changes to the scheme.

The court found that the scheme substantially complied with the statutory requirements. It was confirmed that the scheme, as proposed, did not require significant modifications. However, the court did make certain modifications to address the concerns raised by the policyholders. These modifications included clarifying the definition of certain policies and ensuring that specific policyholders had the option to opt-out of the transfer. The court also addressed the costs associated with the application, directing that the applicants would bear the costs of APRA. The court reserved the right for the applicants to apply for further orders after providing notice to APRA.

The court confirmed the scheme in its amended form, subject to the specific modifications made. These modifications primarily aimed to accommodate the policyholders' objections and ensure that the transfer was carried out in a manner that was fair and in compliance with the legislative requirements. The court's decision was grounded in a thorough analysis of the statutory provisions and the practical implications of the objections raised by the policyholders. The final orders ensured that the scheme could proceed while addressing the concerns of the affected parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 194 of the Life Insurance Act 1995 (Cth), the Scheme in the form of the document annexed hereto and marked “A” (comprising the document entitled “Scheme – Life Insurance Act 1995 Part 9”) be confirmed, subject to the modifications set out in Orders 2 and 3.

2. Modifications to the Scheme

2.1 A new Section 3A is incorporated into the Scheme following Section 3:

3A.1 On the Confirmation Date MetLife will issue the New MRF Policies to MTP and those policies will come into force on the Confirmation Date.

3A.2 For each Relevant Policyholder and MRF Member for whom MetLife has a current address as at Confirmation Date, within 1 Business Day of the Confirmation Date, MetLife must post the Notice to that address.

3A.3 Immediately after the Return Date, MetLife must debit each fixed rate option sub-account kept in relation to each Opt Out MRF Member under an Old MRF Policy with an amount equal to the current account balance shown in MetLife’s records as at the Return Date and credit an equivalent amount to a sub-account kept in relation to each Opt Out MRF Member under the corresponding New MRF Policy.

2.2 The definitions of ‘MetLife Policy’, ‘Pre 2004 Policy’ and ‘Transfer Deed’ in Section 10 of the Scheme are modified by inserting:

(a) as a new sentence “However a MetLife Policy does not include an Excluded Policy.” at the end of the definition of MetLife Policy;

(b) as a new sentence “However, a Life Policy does not include an Excluded Policy.” at the end of the definition of Pre 2004 Policy;

(c) “as amended by the Orders” at the end of the definition of Transfer Deed;

(d) as a new definition immediately after the definition of MRF, “MTP means MetLife Trustee Pty Limited ABN 80 115 534 453”.

2.3 The following definitions are inserted in Section 10 of the Scheme in the relevant alphabetical order:

Confirmation Date means the date this Scheme is confirmed by the Court.

Eligible Policy means:

(a) a life policy (within the meaning of the Life Insurance Act 1995); or

(b) a contract in respect of business relating to the payment of annuities that has been declared by the Insurance and Superannuation Commissioner or APRA to be treated for the purposes of the Act as if it were included in the class of ordinary business or superannuation business of life insurance business pursuant to former section 12(2)(b) or current section 12A of the Act,

of MetLife that is referable to a MetLife Fund and that is in force, or in respect of which a person has a guaranteed renewal right, as at the Return Date but that is not a policy known as a deferred annuity cash rate policy or an Old MRF Policy.

Excluded Policy means:

(a) an Eligible Policy that is held by a Relevant Policyholder who has on or before the Return Date returned to MetLife and validly signed and completed the election form attached to the Notice; and

(b) the New MRF Policies.

List means the list in Confidential Exhibit A in the proceedings.

MRF Member means a person named and identified as such in the List and who was still a member of the MRF immediately prior to the Confirmation Date.

New MRF Policies means:

(a) a policy on terms agreed between MetLife and the Transferee that is to be issued by MetLife to the MRF trustee in respect of the MRF plans that are known as the Allocated Pension Plan and the Term Allocated Pension Plan but only in respect of Opt Out MRF Members of those plans; and

(b) a policy on terms agreed between MetLife and the Transferee that is to be issued by MetLife to the MRF trustee in respect of the MRF plan that is known as the Personal Superannuation Plan but only in respect of Opt Out MRF Members of that plan.

Notice means the communication in the form or substantially in the form attached:

(a) in the case of a Relevant Policyholder, annexure “B” to the Orders; and

(b) in the case of a MRF Member, annexure “C” to the Orders.

Old MRF Policy means:

(a) the policy issued by MetLife to the former MRF trustee on 2 September 1993 in respect of the MRF plans that are now known as the Allocated Pension Plan and the Term Allocated Pension Plan; and

(b) the policy issued by MetLife to the former MRF trustee on 2 September 1993 in respect of the MRF plan that is now known as the Personal Superannuation Plan.

Opt Out MRF Member means a MRF Member who has on or before the Return Date returned to MetLife and validly signed and completed the election form attached to the Notice.

Orders means the order of the Court confirming this Scheme.

Relevant Policyholders means a person named in the List but only to the extent they are not identified as a MRF member.

Return Date means the 28 August 2007.

2.4 The interpretation provision in Section 10.2 of the Scheme is modified by adding:

(d) a document (including this Scheme) includes any variation or replacement of it.

3. Modifications to the Transfer Deed at Schedule 1 to the Scheme

3.1 Clause 8.7(b) of the Transfer Deed is deleted and replaced as follows:

(b) for that purpose has calculated the amount of the Completion Policy Liabilities and the amount of the Excluded Policies as at 31 December 2006 in accordance with Schedule 2;

3.2 Clause 31.1 of the Transfer Deed is modified by inserting a definition of ‘Excluded Policies’ and ‘Orders’ and modifying the definition of ‘Life Policy’ as follows:

Excluded Policies has the same meaning given in the Scheme.

Orders has the same meaning given in the Scheme.

Inserting the words, “However, a Life Policy does not include an Excluded Policy.” at the end of the definition of Life Policy.

3.3 The definition of ‘Policy Listing’ in schedule 2 to the Transfer Deed is modified by replacing the words “policies in the No.2 and No.3 Statutory Funds of MetLife” with the words “the Life Policies”.

3.4 Warranty 3.2 in schedule 6 to the Transfer Deed is modified by inserting the words “and the Excluded Policies” immediately after the words:

(a) “The management accounts prepared in respect of the Annuity Liabilities”; and

(b) “of the business carried on by MetLife in managing the Annuity Liabilities”.

4. The applicants pay the costs of the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) of and incidental to this application.

5. Reserve the liberty to the Applicants to apply after providing 24 hours written notice to APRA.

6. These Orders be entered forthwith.

[Annexures not attached hereto]

Background

Background to the litigation

Part 9 of the Life Insurance Act 1995 (Cth) (the Act) provides for the transfer and amalgamation of life insurance business by means of a scheme confirmed by the Court. This case concerns the transfer of part of the life insurance business of one insurer to another insurer, having no connection with the transferor. The insurers have a different history, different composition of assets backing the life business and a different credit rating, the transferee being rated lower than the transferor. The point of interest is the effect of objections by or on behalf of a number of policy holders to having a compulsory change of life insurer. BACKGROUND The principal legislative provisions relating directly to this proceeding are as follows:“190 Transfer or amalgamation of life insurance business(1) No part of the life insurance business of a life company may be:(a) transferred to another life company; or(b) amalgamated with the business of another life company;except under a scheme confirmed by the Court.…(3) A scheme must set out:(a)the terms of the agreement or deed under which the proposed transfer or amalgamation is to be carried out; and(b)particulars of any other arrangements necessary to give effect to the scheme.…191Steps to be taken before application for confirmation...(2)An application for confirmation of a scheme may not be made unless:(a)a copy of the scheme and any actuarial report on which the scheme is based have been given to APRA in accordance with the regulations; and(b)notice of intention to make the application has been published by the applicant in accordance with the regulations; and(c)an approved summary of the scheme has been given to every affected policy owner.…192Actuarial report on scheme(1)When a copy of a scheme has been given to APRA for the purpose of paragraph 191(2)(a), APRA may arrange for an independent actuary to make a written report on the scheme.(2)APRA may give a copy of the report to each company affected by the scheme.193Application to Court(1)Any of the companies affected by a scheme may apply to the Court for confirmation of the scheme.(2)An application for confirmation must be made in accordance with the regulations.(3)APRA is entitled to be heard on an application.194Confirmation of schemeThe Court may:(a)confirm a scheme without modification; or(b)confirm the scheme subject to such modifications as it thinks appropriate; or(c)refuse to confirm the scheme.195Effect of confirmation etc.When a scheme is confirmed:(a)it becomes binding on all persons; and(b)it has effect in spite of anything in the constitution of any company affected by the scheme; and(c)the company on whose application the scheme was confirmed must cause a copy of the scheme to be lodged at an office of ASIC in every State and Territory in which a company affected by the scheme carried on business.” Life insurance business is defined in s 11 of the Act, the principal provisions of which are as follows:“11 Life insurance business(1) A reference in this Act to life insurance business is a reference to:(a) business that consists of any or all of the following:(i) the issuing of life policies;(ii) the issuing of sinking fund policies;(iii) the undertaking of liability under life policies;(iv)the undertaking of liability under sinking fund policies; and(b)any business that relates to business referred to in paragraph (a).”

Decision

Reasons for decision

GYLES J
Issues
1. Whether the court should confirm the scheme as proposed, without any modifications.
2. If not, whether the court should confirm the scheme subject to certain modifications, and if so, what those modifications should be.
3. If not, whether the court should refuse to confirm the scheme altogether.

Held
1. The court confirmed the scheme as proposed, subject to certain modifications.
2. The modifications included the insertion of a new Section 3A into the scheme, modifications to definitions in Section 10 of the scheme, modifications to the Transfer Deed at Schedule 1, and the addition of certain terms to the warranty in Schedule 6.
3. The court did not refuse to confirm the scheme altogether.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GYLES J

The court considered the scheme for the transfer of part of the life insurance business of one insurer to another under the Life Insurance Act 1995 (Cth). The court examined the objections raised by policyholders to the compulsory change of insurer and considered whether the scheme should be confirmed as proposed, subject to modifications, or refused altogether. The court found that the scheme, as modified, adequately addressed the concerns of the objecting policyholders and was in the best interests of the policyholders and the public. The court confirmed the scheme subject to the modifications outlined in the orders, which included provisions for issuing new policies to policyholders who did not object to the change of insurer, mailing notices to affected policyholders, and adjustments to the Transfer Deed to reflect the modifications. The court also addressed the issue of costs, ordering the applicants to pay the costs of the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) and reserving the liberty to the applicants to apply for further orders after providing notice to APRA.