EXPLANATORY STATEMENT
Social Security Act 1991
Social Security (Exempt Lump Sum – Rectification Action) Determination 2022
Purpose
Paragraph 8(11)(d) of the Social Security Act 1991 (the Act) allows the Secretary of the Department of Social Services (the Department), or delegate, to determine, by legislative instrument, that an amount, or class of amounts, received by a person is an exempt lump sum for the purposes of the Act.
The Social Security (Exempt Lump Sum – Rectification Action) Determination 2022 (the Determination) ensures that an amount paid by, or on behalf of, the Commonwealth as the proportion of the settlement sum representing interest notionally accrued on monies repaid by Group Members to the Commonwealth, is an exempt lump sum under paragraph 8(11)(d) of the Act.
Background
Under the social security law, an income test is used to determine a person’s entitlement to a social security payment, and if they are qualified, the rate of a social security payment that is payable. An income amount earned, derived or received for a person’s own use or benefit is generally assessable as income (see the definitions of ‘income’ and ‘income amount’ in subsection 8(1) of the Act). However, some amounts that would otherwise be income are specifically exempted.
Paragraph 8(11)(d) of the Act allows the Secretary of the Department to determine that an amount, or class of amounts, received by a person is an ‘exempt lump sum’ for the purposes of the Act. An exempt lump sum is excluded from the subsection 8(1) definition of ‘ordinary income’, meaning the exempt lump sum amount is not taken into account under social security income tests.
The exemption of an amount received by a person from the income test does not alter the fact that any ongoing income generated by the amount is not exempt from the income test, and any assessable asset produced from the lump sum is counted under the social security assets test. This is consistent with the treatment of other amounts as exempt lump sums under paragraph 8(11)(d) of the Act.
Settlement of the Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia Class Action
The class action legal proceeding Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2021] FCA 634 (Prygodicz) arose out of the Commonwealth’s use of averaged annual Australian Taxation Office (ATO) income data to review and calculate individual fortnightly social security entitlement amounts (the compliance activity) between July 2015 and November 2019. The compliance activity was designed to identify overpayments of social security payments in the period under review. If an overpayment was identified, the compliance activity would raise and seek to recover the debt.
The Commonwealth has now refunded or has undertaken to refund all amounts recovered by the Commonwealth as a result of the compliance activity where a debt was raised wholly or partially on the basis of averaged ATO income data. The refunded amounts will not be treated as income for social security purposes under subsection 8(8) of the Act, as they were refunds of amounts collected in repayment of debts…
Overview
The Social Security (Exempt Lump Sum – Rectification Action) Determination 2022 was enacted to address a specific issue arising from the settlement of the Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia Class Action. This class action, which was settled without an admission of liability by the Commonwealth, arose from the use of averaged annual Australian Taxation Office (ATO) income data by the Commonwealth to review and calculate individual fortnightly social security entitlement amounts between July 2015 and November 2019. The settlement includes a distribution sum that pays a proportion of the settlement sum based on simple interest notionally accrued on repayments made by Eligible Group Members, who were those affected by the income averaging issue. The Determination ensures that these settlement payments are exempt lump sums for the purposes of the Social Security Act 1991, meaning they are not assessed as income under the social security income tests. This ensures that the right to social security is upheld, as it prevents any reduction in social security entitlements for those receiving the settlement payments. The Determination was made under the authority of paragraph 8(11)(d) of the Act by the Secretary of the Department of Social Services and commenced on the day after it was registered on the Federal Register of Legislation.
Scope and Application
The Social Security (Exempt Lump Sum – Rectification Action) Determination 2022 applies to certain individuals affected by the Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia Class Action, specifically Category 2 Group Members and Eligible Category 3 Group Members, as defined within the Settlement Deed approved by the Federal Court in Prygodicz. These individuals, who had debts related to social security overpayments that were determined based on averaged annual Australian Taxation Office income data, are eligible to receive a proportion of the settlement sum based on interest notionally accrued on their repayments. This Determination ensures that such payments are exempt from the income test under the Social Security Act 1991, meaning they will not be assessed as income when determining a person's entitlement to, or the rate of, social security payments. The Determination operates nationwide, being a legislative instrument made under the Commonwealth's authority. It does not extend to other categories of Group Members, such as Ineligible Category 3 Group Members and Category 4 Group Members, who are not entitled to any share of the distribution sum. The Determination's provisions are effective from the day after it is registered on the Federal Register of Legislation.
Key Provisions
- The Social Security (Exempt Lump Sum – Rectification Action) Determination 2022 (the Determination) amends the Social Security Act 1991 (the Act) by exempting certain payments from the income test under subsection 8(1) of the Act. Specifically, Section 5 of the Determination provides that if an Eligible Group Member receives a Settlement Payment (as defined in Section 4), the amount of the payment is an exempt lump sum for the purposes of paragraph 8(11)(d) of the Act (Section 5). This means that the payment will not be assessed as income when determining the person's entitlement to social security benefits.
- The Determination applies to Category 2 Group Members and Eligible Category 3 Group Members, as defined in the Settlement Deed approved by the Federal Court in the Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2021] FCA 634 class action case (Prygodicz). Category 2 Group Members are those who had a debt that was wholly or partially based on income averaging from Australian Taxation Office (ATO) data, and who made a repayment towards those debts. Eligible Category 3 Group Members are those who had a debt initially determined based on income averaging from ATO data, but which was later recalculated by the Commonwealth based on other information provided by the group member. An Eligible Group Member is defined as either a Category 2 Group Member or an Eligible Category 3 Group Member (Section 4).
- The Determination imposes an obligation on the Department of Social Services to ensure that Settlement Payments made to Eligible Group Members are not assessed as income under the Act. The Determination also clarifies that any ongoing income generated by the Settlement Payment, or any assessable asset produced from the lump sum, is not exempt from the income test and is counted under the social security assets test (Section 5).
- There are no offences, penalties, or civil/criminal consequences specified for breach of the Determination. However, it is important to note that any breach of the Act or Determination could potentially result in civil or criminal penalties, depending on the nature and severity of the breach. The Act and Determination should be read in conjunction with other relevant legislation, such as the Crimes Act 1914, to determine the potential consequences of a breach.
- Area of Law
- Social Security Law
- Instrument
- Determination
- Concepts
- Definitions & Interpretation
- Exemptions & Exclusions
- Reporting & Disclosure Obligations