Revocation of existing approval and granting of new approval to hold a stake in a financial sector company of more than 20% No. 4 of 2023
Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998
To: Mr Matthew Lancaster (Mr Lancaster)
Farmcove Investment Holdings Pty Ltd ACN 159 553 330 as trustee for Farmcove Investment Trust III (Farmcove)
St Andrew’s Australia Services Pty Ltd ABN 75 097 464 616 (SAAS)
Latitude Insurance Holdings Pty. Ltd. ABN 37 619 174 926 (LIH) Since:
- on 19 October 2021:
- Mr Lancaster and Farmcove were granted approval under subsection 14(1) of the Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998 (the Act) to hold a 50% stake in SAAS, St Andrew’s Life Insurance Pty Ltd ABN 98 105 176 243 (SALI) and St Andrew’s Insurance (Australia) Pty Ltd ABN 89 075 044 656 (SAI), each a financial sector company under the Act; and
b. SAAS was granted approval under subsection 14(1) of the Act to hold a 100% stake in SALI and SAI,
(the Existing Approval1)
B. Mr Lancaster, Farmcove and SAAS requested that the Existing Approval be revoked;
C. Mr Lancaster and Farmcove applied to the Treasurer under section 13 of the Act for approval to hold a 100% stake in each of the financial sector companies listed in Schedule 1;
D. SAAS applied to the Treasurer under section 13 of the Act for approval to hold a 100% stake in each of the financial sector companies listed in Schedule 1, except for the financial sector company listed in item 1 of Schedule 1;
E. LIH applied to the Treasurer under section 13 of the Act for approval to hold a 100% stake in Hallmark Life Insurance Company Ltd. ABN 87 008 446 884 (Hallmark Life) and Hallmark General Insurance Company Ltd ABN 82 008 477 647 (Hallmark General);
F. I am satisfied it is in the national interest for:
- Mr Lancaster and Farmcove to hold a 100% stake in each of the financial sector companies listed in Schedule 1;
1 F2021N00268
b. SAAS to hold a 100% stake in each of the financial sector companies listed in Schedule 1, except for the financial sector company listed in item 1 of Schedule 1; and
c. LIH to hold a 100% stake in Hallmark Life and Hallmark General, I, Sean Carmody, a delegate of the Treasurer:
(a) under subsection 18(3) of the Act, revoke the Existing Approval;
(b) under subsection 14(1) of the Act, approve:
- Mr Lancaster and Farmcove to hold a 100% stake in each of the financial sector companies listed in Schedule 1;
b. SAAS to hold a 100% stake in each of the financial sector companies listed in Schedule 1, except for the financial sector company listed in item 1 of Schedule 1; and
c. LIH to hold a 100% stake in Hallmark Life and Hallmark General;
(c) under subsection 16(1), impose the condition set out in Schedule 2.
The instrument commences on the day it is made and remains in force indefinitely. Dated: 26 May 2023
Sean Carmody Executive Director Insurance Division
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority
Interpretation
Act means the Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998.
financial sector company has the meaning given in section 3 of the Act.
stake in relation to a company, has the meaning given in clause 10 of Schedule 1 to the Act.
Schedule 1 – the financial sector companies
- St Andrew’s Australia Services Pty Ltd ABN 75 097 464 616
- St Andrew’s Life Insurance Pty Ltd ABN 98 105 176 243
- St Andrew’s Insurance (Australia) Pty Ltd ABN 89 075 044 656
- Latitude Insurance Holdings Pty. Ltd. ABN 37 619 174 926
- Hallmark General Insurance Company Ltd ABN 82 008 477 647
- Hallmark Life Insurance Company Ltd. ABN 87 008 446 884
Schedule 2 – condition imposed on the Approval
Mr Lancaster and Farmcove must not hold a direct control interest of more than 40% in the financial sector companies listed in Schedule 1.
Overview
The Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998 was enacted to address the problem of significant shareholdings in financial sector companies that could potentially threaten financial stability. This legislation was introduced by the Australian Parliament to provide a framework for the regulation of shareholdings in financial sector companies, ensuring that such holdings do not pose a systemic risk to the Australian financial system. The Act enables the Treasurer to grant or revoke approvals for shareholdings in financial sector companies, particularly when these holdings exceed certain thresholds. The policy objective of the Act is to maintain the stability and integrity of Australia's financial system by overseeing and controlling significant shareholdings in financial sector entities. The instrument in question, which revokes existing approvals and grants new ones for shareholdings exceeding 20%, aligns with this overarching policy objective by providing regulatory oversight to ensure that these shareholdings do not compromise the stability of the financial sector.
Scope and Application
The Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998 applies to individuals, entities, and companies that wish to acquire or hold a stake in a financial sector company exceeding a threshold of 20%. This Act operates at the Commonwealth level and governs the shareholding of financial sector companies, aiming to maintain the stability and integrity of the financial sector. The Act stipulates that any person or entity seeking to hold more than 20% of a financial sector company must obtain approval from the Treasurer. This requirement ensures that significant shareholdings are subject to scrutiny and regulation to safeguard the financial system. The Act’s jurisdiction covers all financial sector companies as defined under section 3, encompassing entities such as insurance companies, banks, and other financial institutions. Subordinate instruments can extend or restrict the application of the Act, providing further detail or imposing additional conditions on the approvals granted under the Act. However, specific exclusions, exemptions, or thresholds are outlined in the Act itself, ensuring a clear regulatory framework for significant shareholdings in the financial sector.
Key Provisions
The key provisions of this notifiable instrument revolve around the revocation of existing approval and the granting of new approvals under the Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998 (the Act). Under subsection 18(3) of the Act, the existing approval held by Mr Matthew Lancaster, Farmcove Investment Holdings Pty Ltd, and St Andrew’s Australia Services Pty Ltd to hold a 50% stake in various financial sector companies is revoked. This revocation becomes effective upon the instrument's issuance. Following the revocation, new approvals are granted under subsection 14(1) of the Act. Mr Lancaster and Farmcove are now approved to hold a 100% stake in the financial sector companies listed in Schedule 1, with the exception of the company listed in item 1 of Schedule 1. Similarly, St Andrew’s Australia Services Pty Ltd is granted approval to hold a 100% stake in all financial sector companies listed in Schedule 1. Furthermore, Latitude Insurance Holdings Pty Ltd is approved to hold a 100% stake in Hallmark Life Insurance Company Ltd and Hallmark General Insurance Company Ltd.
The Act imposes several obligations on the parties involved. Firstly, Mr Lancaster and Farmcove, as well as St Andrew’s Australia Services Pty Ltd, must comply with the new approval conditions outlined in the instrument. Specifically, they must not hold a direct control interest of more than 40% in the financial sector companies listed in Schedule 1. This condition is set out in Schedule 2 of the instrument. Additionally, any changes to the shareholding structure or control interest must be reported to the relevant authorities as required by the Act. These obligations are essential to ensure that the financial sector remains stable and that any significant changes in shareholdings are properly monitored and managed.
Failure to comply with the provisions of the Act may result in various consequences. Firstly, any breach of the conditions imposed under Schedule 2, such as holding a direct control interest exceeding the permitted 40%, could be considered an offence under the Act. Such offences may lead to civil or criminal penalties. The maximum penalties for breaches of the Act can include substantial fines and, in some cases, imprisonment. The specific penalties depend on the nature and severity of the breach. It is crucial for the parties to adhere to the terms of the approval to avoid these potential consequences.