Revocation of existing approval and granting of an approval to hold a stake in a financial sector company of more than 20% - No. 5 of 2023
Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998
To: The Existing Approval Holders listed in Schedule 1 and the Applicants listed in Schedule 2
SINCE:
- On 2 May 2011, the Existing Approval Holders were granted approval under subsection 14(1) of the Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998 (the Act) to hold a 100% stake in numerous financial sector companies (the Existing Approval1);
B. The Existing Approval Holders requested that the Existing Approval be revoked;
C. The Applicants applied to the Treasurer under section 13 of the Act for approval to hold a 100% stake in Youi Pty Ltd ABN 79 123 074 733 (Youi) and Youi Holdings Pty Ltd ABN 41 124 972 425 (Youi Holdings), each a financial sector company under the Act;
D. I am satisfied it is in the national interest for the Applicants to hold a 100% stake in Youi and Youi Holdings.
I, Vincent Lee, a delegate of the Treasurer:
(a) under subsection 18(3) of the Act, revoke the Existing Approval; and
(b) under paragraph 14(1)(a) of the Act, approve each of the Applicants to hold a 100% stake in Youi and Youi Holdings.
1 No. GN 18, 11 May 2011, page 1019
The instrument commences on the day it is made and remains in force indefinitely. Dated: 24 May 2023
Vincent Lee
Acting General Manager Insurance Division
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority
Interpretation
In this instrument:
financial sector company has the meaning given in section 3 of the Act.
stake in relation to a company, has the meaning given in clause 10 of Schedule 1 to the Act.
Schedule 1 – Existing Approval Holders
- Discovery Holdings Limited
- Financial Securities Limited
- Firness International Pty Limited
- FirstRand Limited
- FirstRand Bank Limited
- FirstRand EMA Holdings Limited
- FirstRand Investment Holdings (Pty) Limited
- MMI Holdings Limited
- Momentum Short Term Insurance Company Limited
- OUTsurance Holdings Limited (formerly FirstRand STI Holdings Limited)
- OUTsurance Insurance Company Limited
- OUTsurance Insurance Company of Namibia Limited
- OUTsurance International Holdings Pty Ltd (formerly FirstRand STI International Holdings Limited)
- OUTsurance Life Insurance Company Limited
- OUTsurance Group Limited (formerly Rand Merchant Investment Holdings Limited and Rand Merchant Insurance Holdings Limited)
- Remgro Limited
- RMB Holdings Limited
- RMB-SI Holdings Limited
- SIAS Administration Pty Limited (formerly FirstRand STI Administration (Proprietary) Limited)
- Youi Holdings Pty Ltd (formerly FirstRand STI Australia Holdings Pty Ltd) ABN 41 124 972 425
Schedule 2 – Applicants
- Remgro Limited (South Africa)
- OUTsurance Group Limited (formerly Rand Merchant Investment Holdings Limited) (South Africa)
- OUTsurance Holdings Limited (South Africa)
- OUTsurance International Holdings (Pty) Ltd (South Africa)
- Youi Holdings Pty Ltd ABN 41 124 972 425
- Youi Pty Ltd ABN 79 123 074 733
Overview
The Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998 was enacted to regulate and maintain the stability of Australia's financial sector by controlling significant shareholdings in financial sector companies. The Act was introduced to address the problem of excessive concentration of ownership in financial institutions, which could potentially lead to systemic risks in the financial system. This legislation is overseen by the Parliament of Australia, and its policy objective is to safeguard the financial system's integrity and public confidence by ensuring that financial institutions are owned and controlled in a manner that supports the national economic stability.
In 2023, the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA), acting on behalf of the Treasurer, issued a notifiable instrument revoking the existing approval for certain entities to hold a 100% stake in various financial sector companies and granting new approval to other entities to hold a 100% stake in Youi Pty Ltd and Youi Holdings Pty Ltd. This decision was made in the national interest, reflecting a strategic shift in the regulatory approach to financial sector shareholdings under the Act. The instrument, which revokes previous approvals and grants new ones, is intended to remain in force indefinitely, underscoring the ongoing need for regulatory oversight in this area.
Scope and Application
The Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998 applies to financial sector companies and any person or entity that seeks to hold a stake of more than 20% in such a company within Australia. The Act regulates and monitors shareholdings in the financial sector to ensure the stability and integrity of Australia’s financial system. It is a Commonwealth Act, meaning it applies across the nation and not restricted by state or territory boundaries. The Act allows for the Treasurer to approve or revoke approvals for significant shareholdings based on whether it is in the national interest. The approval process under the Act can extend or restrict application through subordinate instruments. This particular instrument, F2023N00123, revokes the existing approval held by various entities listed in Schedule 1 and grants new approval to the Applicants listed in Schedule 2 to hold a 100% stake in specified financial sector companies, specifically Youi Pty Ltd and Youi Holdings Pty Ltd. The instrument is effective from its making and will remain in force indefinitely.
Key Provisions
The main sections of this legislation, F2023N00123 (Notifiable instrument), primarily involve the revocation of an existing approval under the Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998 and the granting of a new approval to certain applicants (sections 18(3) and 14(1)(a) respectively). The instrument revokes the existing approval for a list of entities (Schedule 1) to hold a 100% stake in various financial sector companies, and grants new approval for a different list of entities (Schedule 2) to hold a 100% stake in Youi Pty Ltd and Youi Holdings Pty Ltd. This legislative instrument was made based on a request from the existing approval holders and an application by the applicants, and it is deemed to be in the national interest.
The Act imposes several obligations on the parties it governs. Firstly, the existing approval holders, listed in Schedule 1, must comply with the revocation of their approval as stated in section 18(3). This revocation means they can no longer hold a 100% stake in the financial sector companies as previously permitted. Secondly, the applicants listed in Schedule 2 must adhere to the new approval granted under section 14(1)(a), which permits them to hold a 100% stake in Youi Pty Ltd and Youi Holdings Pty Ltd. These obligations are critical for maintaining compliance with the Act and ensuring that the national interest is upheld.
The legislation also outlines potential consequences for breach of its provisions. While the instrument does not explicitly state offences or penalties within its text, the Financial Sector (Shareholdings) Act 1998 itself may impose penalties for non-compliance. Generally, breaches of the Act could result in civil or criminal penalties, including fines and imprisonment, depending on the severity of the breach and the discretion of the court. It is essential for the entities involved to fully comply with the terms of the Act to avoid any legal repercussions.