EXPLANATORY STATEMENT
SUBJECT - HEALTH INSURANCE ACT 1973
HEALTH INSURANCE REGULATIONS (AMENDMENT)
STATUTORY RULES NO. 117
ISSUED ON THE AUTHORITY OF THE MINISTER FOR COMMUNITY SERVICES AND HEALTH.
Section 133 of the Health Insurance Act 1973 (the Act) provides that the Governor-General may make Regulations, not inconsistent with the Act, prescribing all matters required or permitted by the Act to be prescribed, or necessary or convenient to be prescribed for carrying out or giving effect to the Act.
Subsection 19A(1) of the Act provides that regulations made under the Act may provide that, unless the Minister otherwise directs, medicare benefits are not payable in respect of professional services rendered in prescribed circumstances. Subsection 19A(2) provides that such regulations shall not be made other than in accordance with a recommendation to the Minister by the Medicare Benefits Advisory Committee under paragraph 67(1)(aa) of the Act (in the case of regulations relating to professional services other than pathology services) or the Pathology Services Advisory Committee under paragraph 78C(1)(b) (in the case of regulations relating to pathology services).
Subregulation 2ADB(1) of the Health Insurance Regulations accordingly provides, at present, that, unless the Minister otherwise directs, medicare benefits are not payable in respect of professional services rendered in prescribed circumstances. Subregulations 2ADB(2), (3) and (4) previously set out what these professional services and prescribed circumstances were.
The Health Insurance Regulations (Amendment) have amended regulation 2ADB to provide that medicare benefits will not be payable in respect of professional services rendered in relation to the use of computerised tomography (CT) scanning for the purpose of measuring bone mineral density for osteoporosis assessment. They have been added to the professional services and prescribed circumstances which were already listed in regulation 2ADB.
The amendment implements a recommendation made by the Medicare Benefits Advisory Committee under paragraph 67(1)(aa) of the Act which in turn was based on a 1986 report of the National Health Technology Advisory Panel. In short, it is considered by both these bodies that the effectiveness and efficacy of this procedure (CT scanning) as a means of assessing and predicting the risk of bone fracture remains unproven. It was recommended, therefore, that such publicly funded, widespread use of this procedure for the detection of developing osteoporosis should not be supported at the present time.
The National Health Technology Advisory Panel has been requested to undertake a follow-up study to its 1986 report and is expected to complete this task in late 1989. The question of whether medicare benefits should be payable for such procedures will be reconsidered once the results of this study are known.
The Regulations have also deleted current subregulations 2ADB(2), (3) and (4) and repeated the substance of them in a new subregulation (2). The professional services and prescribed circumstances to which subregulation 2ADB(1) applies - including the above CT scanning procedures - are now all included in the new subregulation 2ADB(2).
Overview
The Health Insurance Act 1973, enacted by the Parliament of Australia, was designed to provide for the administration of a health insurance scheme to help fund medical services. This legislation aims to address the gap in accessible healthcare funding for the general population. The Act allows for the creation of regulations to manage the specifics of the insurance scheme, including determining which services are covered and under what circumstances. The Health Insurance Regulations (Amendment) Statutory Rules No. 117, issued on the authority of the Minister for Community Services and Health, implement a recommendation by the Medicare Benefits Advisory Committee to restrict medicare benefits for certain professional services. Specifically, the amendment prevents the payment of medicare benefits for professional services rendered in relation to the use of computerised tomography (CT) scanning for the purpose of measuring bone mineral density for osteoporosis assessment. This amendment is based on a 1986 report by the National Health Technology Advisory Panel, which found the effectiveness and efficacy of this procedure for assessing osteoporosis risk to be unproven. The policy objective behind this regulation is to ensure that publicly funded healthcare resources are allocated towards procedures and treatments that have demonstrated effectiveness and reliability.
Scope and Application
The Health Insurance Act 1973 applies to the regulation of health insurance in Australia, affecting all individuals and entities involved in the provision of health services and the administration of health insurance funds. The Act, alongside the Health Insurance Regulations, governs the payment of Medicare benefits for professional services rendered to patients. The amendments to the Health Insurance Regulations, specifically the Health Insurance Regulations (Amendment) Statutory Rules No. 117, extend the scope of the Act by excluding Medicare benefits for professional services related to the use of computerised tomography (CT) scanning for measuring bone mineral density for osteoporosis assessment. This exclusion was recommended by the Medicare Benefits Advisory Committee based on a 1986 report from the National Health Technology Advisory Panel, which found the efficacy of CT scanning for this purpose unproven. The amendment is designed to prevent the public funding of this procedure until further evidence is available, ensuring that Medicare benefits are not paid for services deemed not effective. The changes to the regulations reflect the Act's intent to provide oversight and control over health service funding and reimbursement, ensuring that resources are allocated efficiently and effectively within the health sector.
Key Provisions
The main operative sections of the Health Insurance Regulations (Amendment) primarily amend subregulation 2ADB to exclude medicare benefits for professional services rendered in relation to the use of computerised tomography (CT) scanning for the purpose of measuring bone mineral density for osteoporosis assessment. The amendment to subregulation 2ADB(1) now includes CT scanning procedures as one of the circumstances where medicare benefits are not payable, unless the Minister otherwise directs. This amendment aligns with the recommendation made by the Medicare Benefits Advisory Committee under section 67(1)(aa) of the Health Insurance Act 1973, which was based on a 1986 report by the National Health Technology Advisory Panel. The report concluded that the effectiveness and efficacy of CT scanning for assessing and predicting the risk of bone fracture remain unproven. The amendment also consolidates the existing subregulations 2ADB(2), (3), and (4) into a new subregulation 2ADB(2), ensuring that all professional services and prescribed circumstances are included in a single subregulation.
The obligations and requirements imposed by the Act and these regulations on the parties and entities they govern include adherence to the specified circumstances where medicare benefits are not payable, as outlined in the amended subregulation 2ADB. Health service providers must ensure that professional services rendered for the purposes of CT scanning for osteoporosis assessment are not billed for medicare benefits unless expressly directed otherwise by the Minister. Additionally, these regulations mandate that the decision to exclude certain medical procedures from medicare benefits is based on recommendations from relevant advisory committees, ensuring a systematic and evidence-based approach to policy-making. This process involves recommendations from the Medicare Benefits Advisory Committee for general professional services and the Pathology Services Advisory Committee for pathology services, as stipulated in the Act.
Breaches of the Health Insurance Regulations (Amendment) may lead to civil or criminal consequences depending on the nature and intent of the violation. While the specific penalties are not detailed in the provided text, it is understood that non-compliance with the regulations regarding the payment of medicare benefits could result in penalties under the Health Insurance Act 1973. Typically, such penalties might include fines or other administrative sanctions for individuals or entities found to be in violation of the regulations. It is also important to note that the effectiveness and efficacy of CT scanning for osteoporosis assessment remain under review, and any future recommendations from the National Health Technology Advisory Panel could further impact the payment of medicare benefits for this procedure.