EXPLANATORY STATEMENT
Foreign States Immunities Regulations (Amendment)
1988 No. 36
Section 43 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 empowers the Governor-General to make regulations, not inconsistent with that Act, prescribing matters necessary or convenient to be prescribed for carrying out or giving effect to that Act.
Section 20 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 provides that a foreign State is not immune in a proceeding in so far as the proceeding concerns an obligation imposed on it by or under a provision of a law of Australia with respect to taxation, being a provision that is prescribed for the purposes of s.20 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985.
Regulations prescribing for the purposes of s.20 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 legislation of the States and Northern Territory and of the Australian Capital Territory came into force on 20 May 1987 (Foreign States Immunities Regulations: Statutory Rules No. 77 of 1987 refers).
The attached Regulations repeal and substitute Regulation 3 of the Foreign States Immunities Regulations and the Schedule thereto.
The object of these substitutions is to prescribe additional laws for the purposes of s.20 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 as requested by the Commissioner of Taxation, the ACT Administration Central Office and the Norfolk Island Government. Legislation previously prescribed for the benefit of the States and Northern Territory remains unaltered.
The prescribing of legislation for the purposes of s.20 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 does not affect the substantive liability of a foreign State to pay particular taxes. It enables a foreign State to be sued to recover a tax for which it is liable.
Overview
The Foreign States Immunities Regulations (Amendment) 1988 No. 36 amends the Foreign States Immunities Regulations under the authority granted by Section 43 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985. This legislation was enacted to address the need for more comprehensive regulation regarding the taxation obligations of foreign states, ensuring that they can be held accountable in Australian courts for certain tax liabilities. The Australian Parliament enacted this regulation to refine the scope of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985, ensuring that foreign states are not immune from proceedings related to Australian tax laws as specified in Section 20. This amendment was introduced at the request of the Commissioner of Taxation, the ACT Administration Central Office, and the Norfolk Island Government to include additional prescribed legislation, thereby facilitating the enforcement of tax obligations against foreign states in Australia.
The policy objective of these amendments is to provide a clear legal framework for pursuing tax-related claims against foreign states within Australian courts, ensuring that these states can be held accountable for their tax obligations without the hindrance of diplomatic immunity where applicable. This legislative action underscores the commitment to maintaining the integrity of Australian tax laws and ensuring that all entities, including foreign states, adhere to the taxation requirements imposed by Australian legislation.
Scope and Application
The Foreign States Immunities Regulations (Amendment) 1988 No. 36, which amends the Foreign States Immunities Regulations, are made under the authority of Section 43 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985. These regulations are designed to prescribe additional matters necessary or convenient for carrying out or giving effect to the Act, particularly concerning the taxation obligations of foreign states. The amendments focus on extending the scope of the Act to include specific tax-related laws from the Australian Capital Territory and Norfolk Island, while maintaining the existing provisions for the States and Northern Territory. This amendment does not alter the fundamental tax liabilities of foreign states but facilitates the process of suing a foreign state to recover taxes owed under the prescribed Australian laws. These regulations apply to foreign states and their assets within the jurisdiction of Australia, thereby ensuring that the substantive tax obligations of foreign states are enforceable within the Australian legal framework.
Key Provisions
The Foreign States Immunities Regulations (Amendment) 1988 No. 36, under Section 43 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985, introduces amendments to the existing regulations by repealing and substituting Regulation 3 and the Schedule of the Foreign States Immunities Regulations. This amendment allows for the prescription of additional laws for the purposes of Section 20 of the Act, which pertains to the immunity of foreign states in tax-related proceedings. The changes were prompted by requests from the Commissioner of Taxation, the ACT Administration Central Office, and the Norfolk Island Government, although the existing provisions for the states and the Northern Territory remain unaffected.
Under these regulations, the primary requirement is to specify additional laws for the purposes of Section 20 of the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985. This section ensures that a foreign state does not have immunity in a legal proceeding if it concerns an obligation imposed by Australian tax laws. The regulations thus allow for the identification and enforcement of tax obligations that a foreign state must meet, thereby enabling proceedings to recover taxes for which the foreign state is liable.
The obligations imposed by these regulations primarily concern the inclusion of additional tax-related laws that can be used to hold a foreign state accountable in Australian courts. By prescribing these laws, the regulations ensure that foreign states cannot evade their tax obligations merely by claiming immunity under international law. This ensures that the substantive liability of a foreign state to pay taxes is upheld and enforceable.
Breach of these obligations, particularly if a foreign state attempts to evade tax payments by claiming immunity, could lead to legal action. Although the regulations themselves do not specify penalties, the failure to adhere to the prescribed tax laws could result in civil or criminal consequences as per the broader tax legislation. The exact penalties would depend on the specific tax laws involved and the nature of the breach, but they could include fines or other financial penalties.
In summary, these regulations serve to clarify and extend the scope of tax-related obligations that a foreign state must meet in Australia. They ensure that foreign states cannot evade their tax responsibilities through claims of immunity, thereby upholding the integrity of Australia's tax system.